Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

The other night I was listening to an episode of Great Lives on Radio 4. The life in question was Howard Flory, and the discussion was about his greater claim to the the "father of penicillin" than Alexander Fleming, also covering how it came about that Fleming got the credit, apparently almost in spite of himself.

Slight nitpick, but technically neither of them should really have had credit. Penicillin was actually discovered in 1897 by Ernest Duchesne. Unfortunately his dissertation was pretty much ignored, mainly due to intelecutal snobbery, and he ended up dying of TB after catching it while in the army. Possibly the worst part is that the strain he discovered was actually more effective than the one Fleming discovered later, and could also cure typhoid, which Fleming's strain couldn't.
 
Slight nitpick, but technically neither of them should really have had credit. Penicillin was actually discovered in 1897 by Ernest Duchesne. Unfortunately his dissertation was pretty much ignored, mainly due to intelecutal snobbery, and he ended up dying of TB after catching it while in the army. Possibly the worst part is that the strain he discovered was actually more effective than the one Fleming discovered later, and could also cure typhoid, which Fleming's strain couldn't.

Is there anything that was actually invented or dicovered by the person who it is popularly attributed too? I seem to be getting the impression lately that everything that invented by someone else first.

Or maybe I have just been waching too much QI...
 
Is there anything that was actually invented or dicovered by the person who it is popularly attributed too? I seem to be getting the impression lately that everything that invented by someone else first.

This is what Pratchett, Iain Stewart and Jack Cohen call "steam engine time" in the Science of Discworld 3. The idea is that things rarely catch on when first invented, but once the time comes for them, everyone will do it at the same time. In their example, steam engines have existed for thousands of years, but it was only when the combination of better materials, an application that really needed it and the money to put it into practice came along that it really took off, and when it did, so many different people came up with different inventions and improvements that it's practically impossible to really say who should get the credit.

The same seems to apply to most human inventions. For antibiotitcs, Fleming tends to get the credit, but they've actually been used for thousands of years. However, it took modern science and medicine to make anything more than folk remedies out of it, and when science did come along, suddenly everyone was doing it. Duchense, Fleming, Florey and so on. And that always ignores the fact that penicillin wasn't even the first mass produced antibiotic, Salvarsan was.

I always find it interesting to really look properly at the history of discoveries, rather than just reading the popular story. It almost always turns out that the person who gets credit wasn't first, and often didn't even have the idea themselves. Some, like the steam engine, deserve credit for finally refining an idea to the point it became properly useful. Others, calculus for example, just go to the person who had the best PR.
 
Tell you something though. I have severe doubts about this idea of giving hyperimmune serum at the same time as vaccination. Anyone knows that passive immunity can and will interfere with vaccination by nixing the vaccine virus - that's the reason for waiting till puppies and kittens are 10 weeks old before vaccinating them, to avoid maternally-derived passive immunity. I'd like to know the rationale for that treatment regimen.

Experience must have shown that this is the way to do it.
They must have found that too many patients died whilst waiting for the vaccine to take affect, and that giving an initial dose of immunoglobulin bought a bit of time. Maybe it does interfere a little - though Capsid seems to have some ideas how it may not interfere and that it may even assist - which might be why they have to give 5 doses of the vaccine over a period of a month. It's almost impossible to verify this from online sources, though, so who knows.
The complex schedule, though, suggests they must have taken some time to get it right

The difference with cats and dogs is interesting: My brother is a vet and he used to try diagnosing and treating himself for minor ailments and his GP had to keep reminding him that he was not a cat. :D
 
I think its more of a case of belt and braces when you're in a tight spot, and if indeed the belt doesn't interfere with the action of the braces, then that's good enough!

Rolfe.
 
Hmmm...maybe. Still, why 5 injections over 4 weeks? Why not 2 or 3? Why not 8 or 10 over 8 to 12 weeks. Why those particular intervals? Surely there is some rhyme or reason? I did get my ipod to work one time by dropping it, so who knows.
 
Slight nitpick, but technically neither of them should really have had credit. Penicillin was actually discovered in 1897 by Ernest Duchesne. Unfortunately his dissertation was pretty much ignored, mainly due to intelecutal snobbery, and he ended up dying of TB after catching it while in the army. Possibly the worst part is that the strain he discovered was actually more effective than the one Fleming discovered later, and could also cure typhoid, which Fleming's strain couldn't.
Never knew that.
Now, thanks to Cuddles (and Wikipedia), I do.

PS Cuddles - you're my favourite intelecutal ;)

One point - whoever wrote the Wiki article confuses Typhoid and Typhus, presumably thinking they are the same condition.
They are completely different. Typhoid is due to a bacterium (Salmonella typhi), the initial features of which resembled those of the epidemics of typhus (hence "typhoid" - ie typhus-like). Typhus is caused by a Rickettsia organism which is not quite a proper bacterium.
Can someone drop wikipedia a line or edit this? (I can't because of firewalls covering my institution)
 
Last edited:
Hmmm...maybe. Still, why 5 injections over 4 weeks? Why not 2 or 3? Why not 8 or 10 over 8 to 12 weeks. Why those particular intervals? Surely there is some rhyme or reason? I did get my ipod to work one time by dropping it, so who knows.
Its been nearly 50 years since the post exposure vaccination schedule for rabies used intraperitoneal (ie intra-abdominal) shots.
There are 2 vaccines in use - commonly used is the human diploid vaccine (and there is also one derived from duck egg embryos). If you are unfortunate enough to be in an area where these may not be available you might still get a vaccine derived from suckling mouse brains, which I think may still be available someplaces.

The idea of immunising after exposure to prevent illness only works with infections with a prolonged incubation period of weeks - months like hepatitis B or rabies. Giving passive antibody/immunoglobulin helps to immediately start protection. Then the immune system kicks in. Rabies immunoglobulin is injected directly in and around the bite wound.

Dosage schedules for hep B and rabies seem to have been worked out partly by trial and error but mainly by a knowledge of how rapidly antibody levels can be boosted and sustained in the vaccinated person. Studies have looked at levels of neutralising antibody vs rabies using many different dosing schedules. Also there have been schedules using low dose intradermal vaccine rather than intramuscular vaccine - this seems equally effective and since it uses less vaccine is much more cost effective in endemic areas where you may use it frequently.
 
Deetee,

You have restored my faith in medicine which Rolfe so casually destroyed with a flick of her wrist. :D
 
Slight nitpick, but technically neither of them should really have had credit. Penicillin was actually discovered in 1897 by Ernest Duchesne. Unfortunately his dissertation was pretty much ignored, mainly due to intelecutal snobbery, and he ended up dying of TB after catching it while in the army. Possibly the worst part is that the strain he discovered was actually more effective than the one Fleming discovered later, and could also cure typhoid, which Fleming's strain couldn't.

Slight education needed: in the 60s and 70s I was looking at the production of antibodies to penicillin in guinea pigs injected with different penicilloylated proteins. Two guinea pigs injected with one particular preparation died. I then had to show that no penicillin remained in the protein prep because it was well known that penicillin is toxic in guinea pigs. Was I misinformed? There doesn't seem to be much in terms of references in the Duchesne wiki article and yet it reports that part of his research into penicillin was in guinea pigs.
 
Merely out of a sense of duty, I repeat;

"GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION."
 
Yes, we must stick to the topic.

Alternatively, the homeopaths could still:

"Provide one, single example of a controlled trial of homeopathy where the independent Data Safety Monitoring Board has halted the study because homeopathy has been shown to be more effective than placebo or conventional therapy."
 
http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/denis_maceoin/2007/11/your_ignorance_is_showing.html

Unfortunately the time-gate has closed on that thread. I wonder whether JamesGully or his extremely close friend Dana Ullman will dare to show up here to keep it going.

It was getting to be fun.

I think we can assume he reads these forums, so I'll ask the question that he seems determined to overlook in his paranoid fantasies of " Big Pharma reps who are hired guns". Though, I should also like to know, if Big Pharma is hiring "guns" does anyone know what the pay is like and whether it can compete with the living that Mr Ullman is making for himself?

"GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION."

Bump!

Well, it's been almost 2 months since our eminent homeopath was presented with this simple challenge and he has come up with nothing at all.

So, the time has come to say to Dana/JamesGully: we win, you lose.
 
The host of that call LOVES Dullman.

That link is quite funny though, well it would be if people weren't taking this in as true and evidence of homeopathic success.

Can I point out that just because the Royal family are advocates of homeopathy it isn't any kind of proof you idiot! Royalty can be (and very regularly is) wrong or will make stupid decisions.
 
Last edited:
Whilst we await Dana’s acknowledgement of the above, for those interested - and with an hour or so to spare - you can listen to a recent teleconference recording of him discussing homeopathy/promoting his book via this link:
http://www.wholehealthnow.com/teleconferences.html
I tried to listen to Paul Herscue's piece on animal homeopathy, but was forced to stop. His voice is identical to those voice synthesisers that people like Steven Hawking use (only slower)
 
It's now 2 months and 1 day since Dana Ullman was first presented with the easy question of the opening post. He has still not answered it.

GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.
 
Looks like Wikipedia have mostly had enough of Ullman.

Dana, the agreement with your unblock was that you not edit the article space until consensus had been reached on the talk page. You've not upheld this part of the deal. For that reason, your editing of the article space is now revoked for an undetermined period of time.
 
That talk page is really priceless. Where does Dana get the stamina? You'd think that with a good half-dozen people belting him with the same clue bat, he might begin to get a glimmer, but no....

I'm interested to read that Rustum Roy's wife is a homoeopath. That must be the connection we were looking for. I suppose he can still go on saying that he has no vested interest in homoeopathy etc., but really!!!

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom