Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

The other night I was listening to an episode of Great Lives on Radio 4. The life in question was Howard Flory, and the discussion was about his greater claim to the the "father of penicillin" than Alexander Fleming, also covering how it came about that Fleming got the credit, apparently almost in spite of himself.

During the lecture, details were given of the first two patients to be treated with penicillin. The first one is well known, the Oxford policeman with septicaemia who improved spectacularly on the drug, but relapsed and died because they simply didn't have enough to complete the course. The second was Fleming's sister, or sister-in-law, I think, who had meningiococcal meningitis. She was expected to die, no question. Nobody survived that one in those days. Fleming contacted Flory and asked if he had enough penicillin to give it a try. He had. The lady survived and made a full recovery.

No blinding. No control group (only the knowledge of what had happened to everyone else with these conditions in the past). Just an effect so self-evident that nobody was seriously going to argue. This is the sort of case that would be interesting in the homoeopathic challenge, if it were sufficiently well documented. Plenty diseases that were irredeemably fatal before antibiotics (and other modern discoveries). Just one such case where it was homoeopathy that done it, rather than penicillin or whatever?

Just one?

(Of course, we also have to point out that the penicillin story doesn't rest on one case. Even if the first case is ruled inconclusive because the patient died, the second stands. But then the "miracle" was repeated again and again, so that nobody could possibly have any doubt about the effect.)

This is actually a turning point for the fulfillment of the challenge. Before penicillin, septicaemia and bacterial meningitis and so on were such comprehensive killers that a cure of such a patient presented a clear opportunity to demonstrate a miracle of healing. Nowadays, so fundamental are antibiotics to the treatment of life-threatening infections, that you simply won't get an untreated patient to try homoeopathy on (expect perhaps in the third world, but then you'll have difficulty with the documentation there too).

However, it's recent. Only the 1940s. Several of the people involved are still alive. Homoeopathy has had all that time to come up with a result this spectacular, but never did.

Why not?

Rolfe.
 
<snip>

Homoeopathy has had all that time to come up with a result this spectacular, but never did.

Why not?

Rolfe.

Because it is complete and utter tripe, which allows muppets who know little about the relevant science (despite some having relevant scientific training and education:eek:) to feel good about themselves, pretending they are helping people and/or are on the cutting edge of a new theory.
 
Because it is complete and utter tripe, which allows muppets who know little about the relevant science (despite some having relevant scientific training and education:eek:) to feel good about themselves, pretending they are helping people and/or are on the cutting edge of a new theory.

Well that's the obvious answer from our point of view, but what's their excuse? Actually the usual answer seems to be to go back to the days when the stuff that non-homeopaths did was positively harmful, like the usual one about the cholera epidemics. One day I might write a blog article about all the things which have been discovered/developed in the past 200 years (germ theory, DNA, quantum mechanics, relativity, etc.) and how homeopathy has developed not at all.

Perhaps it would be interesting to read Homeopathy—quackery or a key to the future of medicine? in the latest issue of Homeopathy, especially as Rustum Roy is one of the contributors to the debate.
 
Oh thanks. I wasn't sure, and when I Googled it, most of the first half-dozen links didn't have the e.

Rolfe.
 
Perhaps it would be interesting to read Homeopathy—quackery or a key to the future of medicine? in the latest issue of Homeopathy, especially as Rustum Roy is one of the contributors to the debate.
My word, yes.
Andre Saine said:
Let us push our inquiry a bit further and look at one
of the most deadly of all infectious diseases, rabies. I have been able to document more than a dozen well-described cases with unmistakable, fully developed clinical rabies that had uneventful recoveries with homeopathic treatment, and this without any prophylaxis whatsoever to assuage the virulence of the disease.
Sadly no references to where this documentation might be found. Perhaps Dana could have a word with him, present it here and make us all eat our words?

Dana?
 
My word, yes.

Originally Posted by Andre Saine
Let us push our inquiry a bit further and look at one
of the most deadly of all infectious diseases, rabies. I have been able to document more than a dozen well-described cases with unmistakable, fully developed clinical rabies that had uneventful recoveries with homeopathic treatment, and this without any prophylaxis whatsoever to assuage the virulence of the disease.

Sadly no references to where this documentation might be found. Perhaps Dana could have a word with him, present it here and make us all eat our words?

Dana?
Interesting that hydrophobia is a symptom of rabies. Treating the patient could prove tricky.
 
Last edited:
This one is not sure:

http://www.vaccineplace.com/?fa=learn/rabies&s=student

Untreated rabies is usually fatal......Because untreated rabies is always fatal...



This one is certain:

http://www.health.state.ny.us/diseases/communicable/rabies/fact_sheet.htm

Untreated cases will invariably result in death.



And this one is a little more circumspect:

http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/ency/article/001334.htm#Expectations%20(prognosis)

Once the symptoms appear, few people survive the disease....Untreated, rabies can lead to coma and death.
 
Last edited:
I recall a report of one case where it was alleged a patient had survived rabies. It was prominent because it was apparently the only one. However, subsequently some doubts were expressed about the diagnosis. Possibly that case is the reason for some uncertainty.

Actually, treated or untreated, the patient will die. I've not heard that any antivirals have been shown to have any effect. The only possible approach is vaccination after exposure but before clinical signs develop. That has a high success rate.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
I recall a report of one case where it was alleged a patient had survived rabies. It was prominent because it was apparently the only one. However, subsequently some doubts were expressed about the diagnosis. Possibly that case is the reason for some uncertainty.


If that is the case, then we're back with misdiagnosis.
If we ever get to see the documentation, this will be the key point to look for.

Actually, treated or untreated, the patient will die. I've not heard that any antivirals have been shown to have any effect. The only possible approach is vaccination after exposure but before clinical signs develop. That has a high success rate.

I think that is actually what they call "treating rabies".

Reading those links above, I came across treatment of rabies a couple of times. Apparently the "treatment" is to get an initial dose of rabies immunoglobulin - all, or as much as you can depending on the site of the bite, directly into the wound and the rest into your deltoid muscle -followed by rabies vaccine into the other deltoid muscle at 0,3,7,14,and 28 days. You can vaccinate prophylactically with two doses of rabies vaccine and then, if you get a suspicious bite, have three further doses at 0,3,and 7 days.

Remember this, because patients have been given the wrong schedule, so it may just save your life!!!
(Homoeopaths please ignore this advice. :D )
 
Or you could just get a normal prophylactic rabies vaccination, like any other. The rabies vaccine is just a normal jag now, we're way past the days of painful repeated intra-peritoneal injections. And it's very effective. I heard one epidemiologist say that if the WHO made a concerted effort, we could wipe out rabies the same way smallpox was wiped out, because the human and animal vaccines are so successful. Certainly, anyone living in an area where rabies is enzootic ought to be vaccinated routinely, so that "treatment" is never necessary.

Rolfe.
 
This is the schedule as listed by the CDC dated 1st Dec 2006
Perhaps it's out of date after 14 months.

http://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/pubs/vis/downloads/vis-rabies.pdf

The pre-exposure schedule for rabies vaccination​

3 doses, given at the following times:

Dose 1: As appropriate​
Dose 2: 7 days after Dose 1
Dose 3: 21 days or 28 days after Dose 1

Vaccination After an Exposure


•A person who is exposed and has never been vaccinated​
against rabies should get 5 doses of rabies
vaccine - one dose right away, and additional doses
on the 3rd, 7th, 14th, and 28th days. They should also
get a shot of Rabies Immune Globulin at the same time
as the first dose. This gives immediate protection.

•A person who has been previously vaccinated​
should get 2 doses of rabies vaccine - one right
away and another on the 3rd day. Rabies Immune Globulin is not needed.



Edited to add:
Medline has the same schedule last revised 4th Jan 2007 (or is 04/01/2007 1st Apr 2007, seeing as it's a US site?)

http://www.nlm.nih.gov/medlineplus/druginfo/medmaster/a607023.html
 
Last edited:
Three doses? Well, if they say so. However, the dog and cat vaccine is a single dose with either 12 or 24-month regular boosters. We only recommend an initial 2-dose course because there is a compulsory antibody test to pass if you want a pet passport, and your chances of passing that are higher with two doses.

I'm surprised the human vaccine needs so many doses compared to the pet version.

Tell you something though. I have severe doubts about this idea of giving hyperimmune serum at the same time as vaccination. Anyone knows that passive immunity can and will interfere with vaccination by nixing the vaccine virus - that's the reason for waiting till puppies and kittens are 10 weeks old before vaccinating them, to avoid maternally-derived passive immunity. I'd like to know the rationale for that treatment regimen. (I've expressed similar doubts about a similar regimen recommended for tetanus exposure, and never received a satisfactory answer.)

Rolfe.
 
Three doses? Well, if they say so. However, the dog and cat vaccine is a single dose with either 12 or 24-month regular boosters. We only recommend an initial 2-dose course because there is a compulsory antibody test to pass if you want a pet passport, and your chances of passing that are higher with two doses.

I'm surprised the human vaccine needs so many doses compared to the pet version.

Tell you something though. I have severe doubts about this idea of giving hyperimmune serum at the same time as vaccination. Anyone knows that passive immunity can and will interfere with vaccination by nixing the vaccine virus - that's the reason for waiting till puppies and kittens are 10 weeks old before vaccinating them, to avoid maternally-derived passive immunity. I'd like to know the rationale for that treatment regimen. (I've expressed similar doubts about a similar regimen recommended for tetanus exposure, and never received a satisfactory answer.)

Rolfe.
The passive immunoglobulin only interferes with live virus vaccines where the live virus can replicate and becomes systemically distributed or at least localised to certain tissues/organs wher the passive antibody may neutralise it if the two can encounter each other. But even then the vaccine is administered into muscle or subcutaneously where it is rapidly taken up by antigen presenting cells and become internalised within the cell where antibody can't get to it. The antibody may even opsonise antigen and facilitate its recognition for uptake by APCs through Fc receptors.
 
According to Steven Novella

Far worse than Dr. Bell was Andre Saine N.D. from the Canadian Academy for Homeopathy. He presented the epidemiological evidence for homeopathy, which amounted to 150-year-old unverified anecdotes. He presented the reports of homeopaths from the mid-1800s claiming they cured cholera, pneumonia, and rabies as if it were reliable evidence. Dr. Saine would have us believe that we can verify such a cold trail of highly dubious self-serving reports. Again we see a desperate plea to lower the bar for scientific evidence so as to admit homeopathy.

http://www.theness.com/neurologicablog/index.php?p=40
 
I recall a report of one case where it was alleged a patient had survived rabies. It was prominent because it was apparently the only one. {snip}
Perhaps you are referring to this:
http://scienceblogs.com/aetiology/2007/09/world_rabies_day.php
Other good news on the rabies front comes via a recent letter in the New England Journal of Medicine. You may remember the case of a 15-year-old Wisconsin girl who was bitten by a rabid bat, and then survived rabies encephalitis after being put in a coma and treated with antivirals. (Original NEJM article here). They've now followed the girl for over 2 years, and her condition is excellent. She graduated high school and is off to college without any apparent long-term effects on learning or memory. She still has some difficulty with movement, but they note that "she had no difficulties with her instrumental activities of daily living, including driving," and "had no problems with peer relations or mood disorders."
You can search the blog for more on rabies.
 
According to wikipedia:

There are only six known cases of a person surviving symptomatic rabies, and only one known case of survival in which the patient received no rabies-specific treatment either before or after illness onset
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom