Rolfe
Adult human female
The other night I was listening to an episode of Great Lives on Radio 4. The life in question was Howard Flory, and the discussion was about his greater claim to the the "father of penicillin" than Alexander Fleming, also covering how it came about that Fleming got the credit, apparently almost in spite of himself.
During the lecture, details were given of the first two patients to be treated with penicillin. The first one is well known, the Oxford policeman with septicaemia who improved spectacularly on the drug, but relapsed and died because they simply didn't have enough to complete the course. The second was Fleming's sister, or sister-in-law, I think, who had meningiococcal meningitis. She was expected to die, no question. Nobody survived that one in those days. Fleming contacted Flory and asked if he had enough penicillin to give it a try. He had. The lady survived and made a full recovery.
No blinding. No control group (only the knowledge of what had happened to everyone else with these conditions in the past). Just an effect so self-evident that nobody was seriously going to argue. This is the sort of case that would be interesting in the homoeopathic challenge, if it were sufficiently well documented. Plenty diseases that were irredeemably fatal before antibiotics (and other modern discoveries). Just one such case where it was homoeopathy that done it, rather than penicillin or whatever?
Just one?
(Of course, we also have to point out that the penicillin story doesn't rest on one case. Even if the first case is ruled inconclusive because the patient died, the second stands. But then the "miracle" was repeated again and again, so that nobody could possibly have any doubt about the effect.)
This is actually a turning point for the fulfillment of the challenge. Before penicillin, septicaemia and bacterial meningitis and so on were such comprehensive killers that a cure of such a patient presented a clear opportunity to demonstrate a miracle of healing. Nowadays, so fundamental are antibiotics to the treatment of life-threatening infections, that you simply won't get an untreated patient to try homoeopathy on (expect perhaps in the third world, but then you'll have difficulty with the documentation there too).
However, it's recent. Only the 1940s. Several of the people involved are still alive. Homoeopathy has had all that time to come up with a result this spectacular, but never did.
Why not?
Rolfe.
During the lecture, details were given of the first two patients to be treated with penicillin. The first one is well known, the Oxford policeman with septicaemia who improved spectacularly on the drug, but relapsed and died because they simply didn't have enough to complete the course. The second was Fleming's sister, or sister-in-law, I think, who had meningiococcal meningitis. She was expected to die, no question. Nobody survived that one in those days. Fleming contacted Flory and asked if he had enough penicillin to give it a try. He had. The lady survived and made a full recovery.
No blinding. No control group (only the knowledge of what had happened to everyone else with these conditions in the past). Just an effect so self-evident that nobody was seriously going to argue. This is the sort of case that would be interesting in the homoeopathic challenge, if it were sufficiently well documented. Plenty diseases that were irredeemably fatal before antibiotics (and other modern discoveries). Just one such case where it was homoeopathy that done it, rather than penicillin or whatever?
Just one?
(Of course, we also have to point out that the penicillin story doesn't rest on one case. Even if the first case is ruled inconclusive because the patient died, the second stands. But then the "miracle" was repeated again and again, so that nobody could possibly have any doubt about the effect.)
This is actually a turning point for the fulfillment of the challenge. Before penicillin, septicaemia and bacterial meningitis and so on were such comprehensive killers that a cure of such a patient presented a clear opportunity to demonstrate a miracle of healing. Nowadays, so fundamental are antibiotics to the treatment of life-threatening infections, that you simply won't get an untreated patient to try homoeopathy on (expect perhaps in the third world, but then you'll have difficulty with the documentation there too).
However, it's recent. Only the 1940s. Several of the people involved are still alive. Homoeopathy has had all that time to come up with a result this spectacular, but never did.
Why not?
Rolfe.