Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

Yeah, my guess is that a lot of the posters here work in IT. Not much threat from homoeopathy there.


I was actually discussing this with my brother the other day. In my line of work, the homeo approach would consist of taking one single piece of data rather than the tens of gigs I usually work with and drawing conclusions from that. In his field, IC design, he'd be taking a single grain of sand and using that for noise reduction and other clever tasks. It'd make both of our jobs a whole load easier.
 
Well, if you appreciate that the guiding principle of homoeopathy is "like cures like" the analogy sort of breaks down. Nevertheless, the principle holds. If something easy and cheap and effective comes along, it doesn't "eat into" the businesses of the professionals, they simply adopt this new advance.


Go back and look at her posts, they (some of them, but not the one in this thread yet) have been replaced by a mod box, and it says suspended under her name now.


Oh, I see now. I hadn't spotted how you'd spotted it.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Let the people decide what they want: Allopathy or Homoeopathy. Who are you and me to decide?

One area where allopathy will keep on exceling over homoeopathy for all the times to come is 'Surgery'. I compliment modern medicine for this. They have become a boon for such patients. And where surgery could be avoided Homoeopathy offers a good option. So when surgery is the only option, we ask our patients to go for it surely.

I think this does not breach any rules now.
 
Let the people decide what they want: Allopathy or Homoeopathy. Who are you and me to decide?
On what basis should people decide? On the inflated and demonstrably untruthful claims of homoeopaths?

Why do you think that homoeopaths are against controlling their experiments against placebo? Why do you think that the less controls, the better the effect?
 
And if people want to go down to the Phillipines for some psychic surgery to cure their cancer......
 
One area where allopathy will keep on exceling over homoeopathy for all the times to come is 'Surgery'. I compliment modern medicine for this. They have become a boon for such patients. And where surgery could be avoided Homoeopathy offers a good option. So when surgery is the only option, we ask our patients to go for it surely.


It's amazing, isn't it, that homoeopathy is never useful for any serious illness.
 
It's amazing, isn't it, that homoeopathy is never useful for any serious illness.
With any luck we might get Dr. Nancy Malik to claim that homoeopathy can be used for AIDS, anthrax or polio myelitis. She has copied stuff from the NCH forum, and during my stint there, it was common enough for somebody to claim remedies for these illnesses. The more sensible homoeopaths did not have the guts to confront these nutters, even though they disagreed.
 
Let the people decide what they want: Allopathy or Homoeopathy. Who are you and me to decide?

One area where allopathy will keep on excelling over homoeopathy for all the times to come is 'Surgery'. I compliment modern medicine for this. They have become a boon for such patients. And where surgery could be avoided Homoeopathy offers a good option. So when surgery is the only option, we ask our patients to go for it surely.

I think this does not breach any rules now.
No it doesn't break any rules, you are entitled to your opinions, no matter how self-contradictory they are.

Why should the choice just be between homeopathy and allopathy? What's wrong with prayer healing, aromatherapy, shamanic medicine, voodoo, etc. What is in fact wrong with MRC_Hans' Little Green Miracle Pills, which will cure practically anything?

Now about surgery, which you think is great. Homeopathy invalidates the whole system of conventional medicine and all that we think we know about diseases and pathology. How do you imagine that working from this basically flawed paradigm, surgeons have still managed to reach these splendid results?

Hans
 
I see we may have a new contestant ready to take the challenge;

Nancy;


GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.


Off you go and find that case.

This is going to be really exciting. I can hardly wait.
 
BSM, I tried.

Now, Nancy, are you going to engage in any discussion here, or simply shout your opinions at us?

Do you have a single well-documented case showing homoeopathic treatment curing any condition which is not self-limiting? That is, a condition which never goes away or resolves on its own.

When I say, well-documented, I mean sufficient test documentation to show that the patient actually did have the disease in question in the first place, then sufficiently detailed documentation of treatment to show that the cure should be attributed to homoeopathy and not to something else which was done at the same time, and then sufficient test documentation to show that the person really no longer has the disease (as opposed to just feeling a little better today).

This would be good.


They never answer, and I don't expect any better from this one.

Rolfe.
 
What about the other more innocuous looking goodies:

Are homoeopathic remedies damaged by airport X-ray scanners? How do you know?
 
I see we may have a new contestant ready to take the challenge;

Nancy;


GIVE ONE, YOU ONLY NEED ONE, INCONTROVERTIBLE EXAMPLE, WITH REFERENCES, OF HOMEOPATHY CURING A NON-SELF-LIMITING CONDITION.


Off you go and find that case.

This is going to be really exciting. I can hardly wait.

Sorry, folks. Yet again that seems to be a perfect Homeopath-Repelling Charm. I insist you now call me Badly Shaved Potter.
 
Never fear, patient readers, the good Dr. Nancy, (or whatever name the MAS collective is using now), will return soon with a long, meaningless diatribe claiming everything and demonstrating nothing. The excitement continues ....
 
No it doesn't break any rules, you are entitled to your opinions, no matter how self-contradictory they are.

Why should the choice just be between homeopathy and allopathy? What's wrong with prayer healing, aromatherapy, shamanic medicine, voodoo, etc. What is in fact wrong with MRC_Hans' Little Green Miracle Pills, which will cure practically anything?

Now about surgery, which you think is great. Homeopathy invalidates the whole system of conventional medicine and all that we think we know about diseases and pathology. How do you imagine that working from this basically flawed paradigm, surgeons have still managed to reach these splendid results?

Hans
No, you are again mistaken. I said Homoeopathy offers a great alternative to sufferers. In many cases surgery could be avoided but allopaths insist on them. Let me give you a simple example of them. When I was born, i had severe inflammed tonsilitis. Allopaths offered my father to remove my tonsils. But my father thought otherwise. When I was around 3-4 years, he made me started doing gurgles. That continued for two years uninterrupted. That day onwards, with God's grace, I had never any tonsilitis problem.The point is there are many instances, where surgery could be avoided but allopaths insists otherwise because their industry has to keep running.

I don't know anything about the other modes of treatment because have not been trained in those. So I can't comment on them. But still I respect them because I beleive patient should be cured whatever the mode of treatment is , and surgery should be done only as a last resort.
 
No it doesn't break any rules, you are entitled to your opinions, no matter how self-contradictory they are.

Why should the choice just be between homeopathy and allopathy? What's wrong with prayer healing, aromatherapy, shamanic medicine, voodoo, etc. What is in fact wrong with MRC_Hans' Little Green Miracle Pills, which will cure practically anything?

Now about surgery, which you think is great. Homeopathy invalidates the whole system of conventional medicine and all that we think we know about diseases and pathology. How do you imagine that working from this basically flawed paradigm, surgeons have still managed to reach these splendid results?

Hans
Who says Homoepathy all together invalidates the allopathy system? We just say if a certain disease or condition could be cured by homoeopathy, it should be, simply because it is a safer mode of treatment compared to allopathy. And if can't be cured by Homoeopathy, one is and should refer to allopathy or any other mode of treatment for the matter of fact.
 
(snip)The point is there are many instances, where surgery could be avoided but allopaths insists otherwise because their industry has to keep running.

Ah, yes, the evil drug industry is trying to suppress this miracle cure that will put them out of business. Here's a question for you -- if it did work, why wouldn't those evil drug companies stop production of their other medicines and instead make nothing but homeopathic remedies? The costs for manufacturing drugs are huge just in getting the resources alone. That's a lot of money in overhead.

Now let's look at your 30C preparations you're so fond of. If a drug company decided to make that, they would need 1mL of substance only. Mix with 99mL of water. Shake in your very special homeopathic way. Split each of these 100mL of 1C solution into a beaker. For each, add 99mL of water. Each time you dilute, do not throw away the previous mixture, just dilute these as well. From this 1mL of original solution, the drug company will have a never ending supply of homeopathic remedy! They'd just take previous solutions and dilute further.

Water is cheap. If all drug companies needed to do was add water, their overhead will be absolutely nothing. Everything else then would be pure profit. If these drug companies are so and only interested in profit like you claim, why in the world would they NOT go to selling homeopathic remedies?
 
Thank You

Thank You Ladies and Gentleman, especially Blue.

I hope to have lovely conversation with you in this thread.

But give me just few more days to wind up (to listen to replies against my answers and to respond to other's questions bein asked) in other threads.

One thing more I need to know, earlier it was 'New Blood' under my name. Later on, I don't know who ( may be moderator) changes it to student.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom