Even More Fun with Homeopath Dana Ullman, MPH(!)

According to its ICD classification, the disease in this case appears to have been a type of lymphoma called mycosis fungoides. This is not a B cell lymphoma, but a T cell lymphoma, so I wonder if the 202.1 classification in this case is correct.

Mycosis fungoides typically affects the skin, causing a plaque or lump.
It is usually very indolent if it remains confined to the skin. Survival of those treated with topical therapies is unaltered compared to those with no disease.
 
Last edited:
According to its ICD classification, the disease in this case appears to have been a type of lymphoma called mycosis fungoides. This is not a B cell lymphoma, but a T cell lymphoma, so I wonder if the 202.1 classification in this case is correct.

I wasn't sure what to make of that number. I couldn't think of or find anything that would fit well with the rest of the description (although I agree that it seems to be an ICD code, I also wondered if it were an institutional code). Maybe 202.01? There really should have been more information in the pathology report than was given, such as cell size and histology. I thought I'd get in trouble if I pointed out that the information was inadequate and inconsistent, though. :)

Linda
 
It would help if the details of the immunophenotyping were given as well as the specific histo. But it's probably asking too much for HelenSan to try and find out these details, I guess.

On the face of it, this claim might have some merit, but since we don't know the medical details noone can say for sure. There are too many unknowns.

-What exactly was the histological type of the lymphoma?
-Does this type of tumour sometimes spontaneously regress or "non-progress"?
-Was it removed completely? [I think if it were a subcutaneous lump it would have been removed in its entirety - these things are usually dealt with by performing an "excision biopsy" when the whole thing is sent for histology analysis. It makes no sense to biopsy only part of the lump when the procedure can remove the whole thing and therefore be potentially curative at the same time.]
 
It would help if the details of the immunophenotyping were given as well as the specific histo. But it's probably asking too much for HelenSan to try and find out these details, I guess.

On the face of it, this claim might have some merit, but since we don't know the medical details noone can say for sure. There are too many unknowns.

That's always the problem, isn't it. These cases could be miraculous if a number of unusual circumstances were met. But we're never given the sort of information that tells us whether this was the case. Instead we're supposed to make a bunch of assumptions that run counter to our knowledge, experience and common sense. And then suffer accusations of bias when we don't.

It's not Helen's fault. I'm feeling cynical. I was reading through a "cured-cases" database recently and the degree to which homeopaths are oblivious to reality was really brought home to me when a homeopath described what he used to cure a woman's cold (the first two remedies didn't work, by the way).

Linda
 
If only part of the node was taken, then how would you know that cancer was present in the part that was left?
Well, all sampling has limitations. But it is entirely reasonable to assume that the whole lump was cancerous, if the sample taken for biopsy was.

This is what she said to clarify, "I went to skin doc, she removed a very small amt. for biopsy. I had a lump about size of a quarter left, and over the 2 yrs, it got smaller and finally gone. I never went back to skin or cancer doc, just my regular doc, who takes blood tests."

I understand the desire for more medical records. As I said before, people who use homeopathy are not big on getting medical documentation to prove anything. They just want to get better--they don't care if you believe them or not.

I do not intend to bother her anymore. I didn't think you guys would accept this, but I did want to present the small amount of info I found. Make of it what you will.
 
Well, all sampling has limitations. But it is entirely reasonable to assume that the whole lump was cancerous, if the sample taken for biopsy was.

This is what she said to clarify, "I went to skin doc, she removed a very small amt. for biopsy. I had a lump about size of a quarter left, and over the 2 yrs, it got smaller and finally gone. I never went back to skin or cancer doc, just my regular doc, who takes blood tests."

Okay. So we can account for it by spontaneous regression of a node in NHL, the patient was mistaken about the amount taken, the sample was not representative of the node, or she forgot to mention the radiation treatment (there's a lot of missing information to this story), none of which are uncommon.

I understand the desire for more medical records. As I said before, people who use homeopathy are not big on getting medical documentation to prove anything. They just want to get better--they don't care if you believe them or not.

I do not intend to bother her anymore. I didn't think you guys would accept this, but I did want to present the small amount of info I found. Make of it what you will.

If you don't mind (and please let me know if you do), I'm going to draw conclusions based on knowledge, experience and common sense.

Linda
 
Homeopathy is 2nd largest mode of treatment in the world today.

I know you guys are mad at Homoeopaths. This is borne out of the frustation that today Homoeopathy is the second most preferred mode of treatment by the patients in the world today after allopathy. And in few decades it will surpass Allopathy to be number one. The primary reason for this would be is allopathy is anti-pathy. It suprreses the disease symptoms but does not throw them away from the body.

So keep on crying, howling at Homoeoaths, they wil at into your business and livelihood.

I can't stop you from getting more mad at Homoeopaths.
 
I know you guys are mad at Homoeopaths. This is borne out of the frustation that today Homoeopathy is the second most preferred mode of treatment by the patients in the world today after allopathy. And in few decades it will surpass Allopathy to be number one. The primary reason for this would be is allopathy is anti-pathy. It suprreses the disease symptoms but does not throw them away from the body.

So keep on crying, howling at Homoeoaths, they wil at into your business and livelihood.

I can't stop you from getting more mad at Homoeopaths.

Funny. I thought that faith healing was still #2
 
Well, at least this post isn't a cut-and-paste. This is progress.

Now, Nancy, are you going to engage in any discussion here, or simply shout your opinions at us?

Do you have a single well-documented case showing homoeopathic treatment curing any condition which is not self-limiting? That is, a condition which never goes away or resolves on its own.

When I say, well-documented, I mean sufficient test documentation to show that the patient actually did have the disease in question in the first place, then sufficiently detailed documentation of treatment to show that the cure should be attributed to homoeopathy and not to something else which was done at the same time, and then sufficient test documentation to show that the person really no longer has the disease (as opposed to just feeling a little better today).

This would be good.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
I know you guys are mad at Homoeopaths. This is borne out of the frustation that today Homoeopathy is the second most preferred mode of treatment by the patients in the world today after allopathy.

No. If there is some frustration it is because the second most preferred method (if it is that, I don't expect that can be documented) is devoid of medical effect.


And in few decades it will surpass Allopathy to be number one.

No. Homepathy is far behind and, despite current progress, all the time lacking further behind.

The primary reason for this would be is allopathy is anti-pathy.

No. Antipathy is a different modus. It is the use of medicines that couse opposite symptoms. You know, if you wanna use these terms, at least get them straight.

It suprreses the disease symptoms but does not throw them away from the body.

No. While palliative treatments are part of conventional medicine, cure is the primary aim.

So keep on crying, howling at Homoeoaths, they wil at into your business and livelihood.

No.

I can't stop you from getting more mad at Homoeopaths.

No, I don't think you can. I think you are exactly as unable to support homeopathy as all the many other homeopaths I have discussed this with.

Hans
 
I wish Nancy would decide which thread she wants to discuss in. I'm damned if I'm replying to the same post in four different threads.

Homoeoaths, they wil at into your business and livelihood.


Trying to translate that, my guess is, "Homoeopaths, they will eat..."

Really? Nancy, what do you know about the business and livelihoods of the posters in this forum, that you think homoeopathy offers any competition for them?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
I wish Nancy would decide which thread she wants to discuss in. I'm damned if I'm replying to the same post in four different threads.




Trying to translate that, my guess is, "they will eat..."

Really? Nancy, what do you know about the business and livelihoods of the posters in this forum, that you think homoeopathy offers any competition for them?

Rolfe.

I guess the homeopathic version of what I do would be one single field (not frame) to make up a fully edited feature film and <??>
to make up a dynamic webpage. :D.
 
Go back and look at her posts, they (some of them, but not the one in this thread yet) have been replaced by a mod box, and it says suspended under her name now.
 
Last edited:
Yes, she was suspended for "copy and pasting" without attribution and spamming several threads with identical posts which apparently is against the membership agreement.
 
I guess the homeopathic version of what I do would be one single field (not frame) to make up a fully edited feature film and <??>
to make up a dynamic webpage. :D.


Yeah, my guess is that a lot of the posters here work in IT. Not much threat from homoeopathy there.

MRC_Hans is about the only person I know here who is directly connected to the pharmaceutical industry in his work, and he doesn't sound bothered!

Of course, there are quite a few doctors and vets here. What Nancy fails to comprehend is that if homoeopathy actually worked, it would make precisely zero difference to our "business". We'd just be using homoeopathy either as well as or instead of what we actually use.

Indeed, in this country, people who are not vets are legally forbidden from diagnosing or treating an illness in an animal (apart from their own animals or animals owned by their employer and which they are employed to care for). And this still applies even if the person is not being paid. By law, the only people who can treat animals using homoeopathy (and so make money from it) are vets.

Maybe there's a reason why, at the last count, there were less than 100 homoeopathic vets, out of about 8,000 altogether on the Register? Oh yes, the reason is that homoeopathy doesn't actually work.

Vets, and doctors, are supreme pragmatists. If something works, they'll use it. Let somebody else worry about the mechanism of action. However, in spite of all the efforts by the small percentage of vets who have deluded themselves into believing that homoeopathic treatments have improved animals' health, it just hasn't caught on.

Because it doesn't work!

If it did, hey, wouldn't that be just great for business! Goodbye to the huge drug bill, hello to cheap sugar pills I can even make myself!

This is what was suggested to one veterinary surgeon who believed a homoeopathic colleague and bought into his practice.

One of the selling points used to entice us to purchase this practice was the fact that the profit on homoeopathic remedies was very significant. Remedies charged out at over £10 actually cost pence to produce (including materials and labour). Clearly, there was money to be made out of such a venture.


If you read the whole letter, you'll discover that the writer was horrified by what he then discovered was going on in the homoeopathic practice.

I came across increasing numbers of cases in which good-quality conventional medicine was able to improve the lot of many animals now under my care. I became more and more concerned at, what I can only term the "brain-washing" of clients into thinking that, somehow, the homoeopathic treatments were actually working when it was patently clear to an objective outsider that they were not. Many of these animals had been undergoing treatment for years without significant improvement. [....]

It is .... possible for a veterinary surgeon with "gift of the gab" to convince a client that an animal with an incurable disease is actually getting better with the help of a few sugar tablets. In my view, neither of these situations is tolerable in our profession, yet homoeopathy persists.

[....] It is my contention, [....] that cases which homoeopaths put up as examples of animals that have got better "under their care" are simply poorly-managed conventional cases originally, or they are one of the very many cases that improve spontaneously despite treatment that each of us sees every day.

I have yet to see a single case in which homoeopathy alone can be proven to have been the most likely reason for a case improvement.


And his final conclusion.

I admit now that I am vehemently opposed to homoeopathic medicines. It is my personal opinion that those who continue to contend that homoeopathic remedies work are, at best, either seri­ously misguided or, at worst, guilty of deliberate fraud.


This is why there are so few veterinary homoeopaths, even though vets have a monopoly in the treatment of animals, and homoeopathic remedies are massively cheaper than actual effective medicines.

Homoeopathy doesn't work.

If it did, far from it "eating into our business", we'd all be making pots of money out of it.

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom