Edge dowsing # 2

Tricky said:
This is absolutely ludicrous. Gold, silver and platinum are non-magnetic and have no affect on the earth's magnetic field.

Ooops... actually, they can. While non-magnetic metals and ores don't concentrate magnetic fields, they can displace ferromagnetic soils that normally do concentrate the Earth's magnetic field. Therefore, ore bodies that displace magnetic soils, can affect the magnetic field, in a sorta reverse way. Aerial magnetometers are sometimes used to search for this effect.

But, we're talking big honkin' bodies of ore here, not nuggets. :)
 
Edge said:
Oh but it can and that ain't all. A lot of bell south guys do it down here on new houses but they use the L wires. I think I have seen the cable guys do it too when there little machines fail them in locating the wires they are looking for, and they are able to compleat there job.
Yes, but you have already indicated that you can't tell one source from another (like you found the "silver" trays when dowsing for gold). Likewise, you should not be able to tell power lines or any other EM field from gold. If you were standing under power lines, your dowsing rod ought to jerk upward very strongly.

Edge said:
How would you know?
I'm just going by what you say, Edge. I don't believe any of it. You were the one that was saying it had to do with the "heaviness" of the metal (by which I assume you mean density). I am merely showing you where this theory falls down.
Edge said:
Lead in the pockets where gold is found is found with gold but I never separated the two to see. More experiments are needed.
Yes, but you should find lead by itself too. It is more dense than silver. If you ever douse where there has been hunting, there will be a lot of lead shot lying around.

Edge said:
I have given you a distance before, The Kelly mine can be picked up any where up to at least 7 miles in the valley of Hay fork I can get a direction from anywhere.

I have checked.
Depth is as far as I can tell 12 feet after that I don't know but I suspect even deeper. That's the deepest overburden that I have uncovered with success.

Thank you, Edge. So if you have a 12 foot depth range, then you must dig every hole, including the ones where you have no dowsing response, a minimum of 12 feet deep, and carefully examine the diggings in order to "prove" that the gold is gone. If you do not do this, then you can understand why we cannot simply accept your contention that there is no gold left?

Seven miles, eh? Does your dowsing rod also point out the location of the nearest jewelry store?

Edge said:
You are wrong it has to be stable or the reaction does not occur.
Not according to other dowsers. In fact I believe you told me about a fellow you dowsed with who held his dowsing rod loosely on the top of his hands.

Edge said:
It's a balance and that makes it sensitive and if I can stop the reaction then there is little if I can'tthen I start to mine with the big dredge.
And how has that worked out so far? You shouldn't even need Randi's million.

Edge said:
The reason for gold or platinum is that the reaction is stronger for silver it's slightly weaker, lead is I think 11 times lighter than gold so it would be weaker, a weaker distortion in the field.
Never tried Iron either. Heaviest metals on the atomic scale are what tipped me off, time is a factor in what a person can do and I seem to be busy all the time.
LOL! Hardly. Gold is not even twice as dense as lead. Silver is much less dense than lead. Platinum varies widely depending on it's purity , but when pure, it is denser than gold. It is almost never found in a pure state in nature, the way gold is.

If you are going by atomic weight, lead(207.2) is higher than gold(197.0) , platinum (195.1) or silver (107.9). The atomic number of lead is also higher than any of the other three.
http://www.webelements.com/webelements/elements/text/Ag/key.html

So, all in all, your explanation of how dowsing works is completely at odds with all the evidence. However, I do appreciate the attempt. It is only by examining your assumptions that you find out when they are faulty.

************
TechHead said
Ooops... actually, they can. While non-magnetic metals and ores don't concentrate magnetic fields, they can displace ferromagnetic soils that normally do concentrate the Earth's magnetic field. Therefore, ore bodies that displace magnetic soils, can affect the magnetic field, in a sorta reverse way. Aerial magnetometers are sometimes used to search for this effect.

But, we're talking big honkin' bodies of ore here, not nuggets.
D'oh! You're right of course. Sort of the same way we discover black holes; by their lack of radiation. But as you note, not noticable on a small scale.
 
Edge said:
What ever, Istill say it's a distortion that's picked up.
I must say I am amazed by your brilliant defense of your theories.

"Whatever".

It is a shame you were not on the prosecution team in the O. J. Simpson case. That murderer would surely be in the slammer now.

Yes, it's a distortion all right. Reality is distorted within a 12 foot radius of you.
 
TRICKSY SAID

It is a shame you were not on the prosecution team in the O. J. Simpson case. That murderer would surely be in the slammer now.

Yes, it's a distortion all right. Reality is distorted within a 12 foot radius of you.


__________________

HE WOULD BE AND WHAT'S WRONG WITH YOU JUST HAVE TO TURN NASTY UH?
 
Edge said:
TRICKSY SAID

It is a shame you were not on the prosecution team in the O. J. Simpson case. That murderer would surely be in the slammer now.

Yes, it's a distortion all right. Reality is distorted within a 12 foot radius of you.


__________________

HE WOULD BE AND WHAT'S WRONG WITH YOU JUST HAVE TO TURN NASTY UH?
I'm sorry, Edge, but when I present evidence that refutes your theories and all you can do is say "whatever", it is a tad frustrating. You say it is distortion. Distortion of what? I've already shown why it can't be the earth's magnetic field (or you would pick up ferromagnetic metals like iron better than gold). It is certainly not gravity, since lead is more dense than silver. It is not electromagnetic, or you would be drawn to every nearby power source. What is it then, Edge? How does it work? Every thing you have proposed so far has been shown to be illogical. You have failed every real dowsing test you have ever taken. You have shown that you don't know the difference between real gold and gold colored coins. You have demonstrated that you do not know basic chemistry, geology or physics. How the heck do you manage to hold on to your delusions?

No, I'm not being nasty to you. I'm being tough on you. You are a nice guy who refuses to deal with reality. I'm trying to force you to learn how to reason. I know you don't believe this, but it will do you good in the long run.

And in all my "nastiness" I have never made fun of or changed the spelling of your forum name.
 
Tricky said:

I'm sorry, Edge, but when I present evidence that refutes your theories and all you can do is say "whatever", it is a tad frustrating. You say it is distortion. Distortion of what? I've already shown why it can't be the earth's magnetic field (or you would pick up ferromagnetic metals like iron better than gold). It is certainly not gravity, since lead is more dense than silver. It is not electromagnetic, or you would be drawn to every nearby power source. What is it then, Edge? How does it work? Every thing you have proposed so far has been shown to be illogical. You have failed every real dowsing test you have ever taken. You have shown that you don't know the difference between real gold and gold colored coins. You have demonstrated that you do not know basic chemistry, geology or physics. How the heck do you manage to hold on to your delusions?

No, I'm not being nasty to you. I'm being tough on you. You are a nice guy who refuses to deal with reality. I'm trying to force you to learn how to reason. I know you don't believe this, but it will do you good in the long run.

And in all my "nastiness" I have never made fun of or changed the spelling of your forum name.


I come back after 3 months and your still debating Edge in the same thread Tricky this might even out last the The "Carlos Swett affair" thread.
 
Sorry Tricky, but I think you're wrong to be asking Edge how dowsing works. The question surely must be if Edge can dowse or not. He doesn't have to know how it works.

My girlfriend has no idea what goes on inside an internal combustion engine. For all she knows it might just as well have a load of little pixies on a treadmill inside it. Even if this is what she believed, she would still be able to move the car using the engine.

Just because Edge isn't a scientist / doesn't understand the theories you've asked him to explain / is just making this explaination up, it doesn't effect his ability to dowse either way.

The million dollar challenge ask that the applicant proves his or her ability. It doesn't ask for an explaination of how they've done it.
 
robbersdog said:
Sorry Tricky, but I think you're wrong to be asking Edge how dowsing works. The question surely must be if Edge can dowse or not. He doesn't have to know how it works.

I agree, the average dowsing practitioner probably doesn't understand what is going on. Most dowsers believe in "theories" that have simply been passed along to them, and can't adequately explain or defend those theories, much like your example of the internal combustion engine. And it's really not valid to ask them to do so.

As long as a dowser believes he can dowse, then the theory of how it works is of little importance to him anyways. You'll never convince a dowser that he cannot dowse, by trying to convince him that his theory of dowsing is bogus. Ain't gonna happen.

On the other hand, there are people out there who build and market super-duper-electronic-locating-devices, and claim all sorts of ridiculous theories, who should be pressed on those theories. DKL, Quadro, Electroscope, LectraSearch, VectorTrek, OmniRange, Vernell, TreasureScope, Ranger-Tell, Anderson, just to name a few. IMO, these are the predators of the dowsing world, and the ones that skeptics should be targeting.
 
Your wrong I do understand if it was a medical thing described in the human body I would not find any thing or my percentage of hits would be small, and what I think is the reason why it works and why I hit gold every time is my theory, it is because it works and has worked for me. The fact that my hits were on the order of lets say 99% makes me the way I am about this, my knowledge of these facts makes me persistent at this forum.


I might be on to something greater than everybody thinks, that is my opinion and the fact that I have mined for a living and dowsed for it and feel it doing it's thing makes me persistent I wouldn’t be this way about it except that I with my own eyes have looked at the movement of the stick and I wouldn’t say these things about it unless I was real certain, I think that it is with out a doubt attracting to the distortions in the field, now what in space distorts a field what makes a pocket or a well and what is the biggest distortions?

I’ll be your daisy, if it gets you to think, we have to look, we have nothing else, or else we wouldn’t be using 2000-year-old technology, or older.
I know there are many competent scientists that are looking into these things but were are their discovery’s ?

Do you get where I’m going with this.
Maybe more should be done to look into it as something that can be proven through many more different experiments, makes it very interesting in the fact that it can be much greater than first thought.
Maybe you guys are locked into one way of thinking and I’m wasting my time oh well.

These guys that build these fake machines maybe ◊◊◊◊ heads but what if one could build a machine that could be attracted to magnetic fields and replicated the movement of a simple dowsers stick?
What could you use that application for? That is the question that keeps running through my head, and what would that information be worth? A million?

Just thoughts.

Here’s a thought when I asked why do they come here? We discussed this on my U.F.O. thread. What if the people that told me that the aliens were in that part of the country to mine for heavy metals were right? Why do they need them?
Why are there so many space-based applications for gold and those metals? You don’t have to answer I know, but think if they needed them for a grater application that we don’t understand yet.

One more thing I will or would like to do the tests for Jref in Trinity County that is now my goal. The reason why is that I can clear a piece of ground completely of all distortions when I mine it and they can do their cup thing there, my secret is not to dowse too long because it is something different than what you think and why tell you why?
On the river I only am accurate if I do it quickly, figure it out, your playing with a form of electricity.
Not good for your body. After about an hour it gets confusing.
I have explaned how it feels in a post on this thread.

Knock yourselves out.
And now for the picture of the day on this post.

Things that have been clamed to be found in pre-diluvium {sp.} layers of the Earth in Russia, I know never trust the Russkys.
What if they are not lying?
 
Nice thoughts. You want to test again, but have left yourself a convenient out. You say you want to clear an area first, by dowsing for any gold or distortions there. You then say that after about an hour, dowsing gets confusing. I'll bet it takes about an hour to clear the area right?

I'm also betting you'll have an excuse not to clear the area one day and come back the next.

I'm sure you know you can do it, but can't you see that saying things like 'scientists are locked into one way of thinking' is just plain stupid. It's like me saying your locked into one way of using gravity, why can't you fly. Just like it there is no other way to use gravity, scientists aren't thinking the wrong way, they're thinking the only way that works. Although you like to think your mind is liberated in some way, it's not. You're just conveniently ignoring facts, and creating 'outs' for yourself.

If dowsing really worked, there would be huge companies doing it and making a LOT of money. 2000 years is plenty of time to refine an art like dowsing. If it really works it would be very easy to test, just like a metal detector is easy to test.

Come and test again. If you can do it like you know you can, prove it and make us all look like idiots and get some much needed cash to help your daughter. If you can dowse it is the most logical thing you could do! :)
 
I'm sure you know you can do it, but can't you see that saying things like 'scientists are locked into one way of thinking'

I was talking about you, not scientists. But theories are rewritten all the time.


If dowsing really worked, there would be huge companies doing it and making a LOT of money. 2000 years is plenty of time to refine an art like dowsing. If it really works it would be very easy to test, just like a metal detector is easy to test.

I was talking about solid rockets.

I told you before that the guy that taught me did it for the government when the army engineers couldn’t find what they were looking for specifically uranium, that's how he first got rich; the government is a pretty big company.

You like to twist peoples’ words too.

You want to test again, but have left yourself a convenient out.

No I believe I have left a way to win and I'm going to be patient and make sure next time and I really don't want to rub it in your face.

What I want is a way out of the violence and greed if we could tap the recourses just in this solar system there would maybe be harmony on Earth and peace but we need something that really works as far as traveling space.

It I believe will have to be electrical in nature and we will have to attract and repel against fields, I.M.H.O.....
 
Edge said:
I believe will have to be electrical in nature and we will have to attract and repel against fields, I.M.H.O.....

Did you watch "Powder" too much or something?
 
robbersdog said:
Sorry Tricky, but I think you're wrong to be asking Edge how dowsing works. The question surely must be if Edge can dowse or not. He doesn't have to know how it works.

My girlfriend has no idea what goes on inside an internal combustion engine. For all she knows it might just as well have a load of little pixies on a treadmill inside it. Even if this is what she believed, she would still be able to move the car using the engine.

Just because Edge isn't a scientist / doesn't understand the theories you've asked him to explain / is just making this explaination up, it doesn't effect his ability to dowse either way.

The million dollar challenge ask that the applicant proves his or her ability. It doesn't ask for an explaination of how they've done it.
What you say is true, robdog, but Edge has claimed time and time again that he does know how it works. In fact, he goes on in great detail about EMFs and such.

However the main difference between Edges dowsing and your girlfriend's car is that the care does work. You could take it in front of a lot of skeptical observers and it would still work. You could try to start it ten times and be successful ten times.

Edge was only able to dowse "successfully" one out of ten times, exactly what would be predicted by the law of averages, when asked to do so in the presence of observers, even though he claims (without evidence) to be successfull 99% of the time.

However, I agree to your point that it doesn't matter whether or not he can explain it, as long as he can do it. But he can't do that either.
 
You could try to start it ten times and be successful ten times.

You wanna bet! :D

I know where you're coming from Tricky. You'll see from my earlier posts in this thread how I feel about Edge and his claims. Personally I think Edge is dumb as toast, his theories are obviously based on the same evidence his belief in dowsing arises from.

Unfortunately we're not here to dicide how intelligent Edge is, since I suspect that would be a lot easier than trying to convince him that dowsing doesn't work!
 
robbersdog said:

You wanna bet! :D
Okay, maybe not your girlfriend's car, but most cars.
robbersdog said:
I know where you're coming from Tricky. You'll see from my earlier posts in this thread how I feel about Edge and his claims. Personally I think Edge is dumb as toast, his theories are obviously based on the same evidence his belief in dowsing arises from.
I should have read more carefully. I've mostly been concerned with confronting Edge on this thread. If I confronted you, it was not intentional.

This may surprise you, but I disagree with you. Edge is not dumb, in my opinion. I think that long ago, Edge made some assumptions that may have been questionable. Rather than change those assumptions, he has sought out evidence to support them, without regard to it's veracity. He has shown an abilility to learn and an admirable desire to be taken seriously. Perhaps this is the reason I have spent so much effort trying to show him that his beliefs are not supportable. I think he could be reasonable if he were not humiliated. He is basically a nice guy with unsubstantiated beliefs. I hope he will be cured of his fantasies without being cured of being a nice guy.
 
robbersdog said:

Personally I think Edge is dumb as toast...

Insulting people who believe in the paranormal, makes skeptics look mean-spirited. Since skeptics generally represent the scientific viewpoint, this perception carries over to science as well, which already has a perception of being cold and uncaring.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom