Edge said:
Oh but it can and that ain't all. A lot of bell south guys do it down here on new houses but they use the L wires. I think I have seen the cable guys do it too when there little machines fail them in locating the wires they are looking for, and they are able to compleat there job.
Yes, but you have already indicated that you can't tell one source from another (like you found the "silver" trays when dowsing for gold). Likewise, you should not be able to tell power lines or any other EM field from gold. If you were standing under power lines, your dowsing rod ought to jerk
upward very strongly.
Edge said:
I'm just going by what you say, Edge. I don't believe any of it. You were the one that was saying it had to do with the "heaviness" of the metal (by which I assume you mean density). I am merely showing you where this theory falls down.
Edge said:
Lead in the pockets where gold is found is found with gold but I never separated the two to see. More experiments are needed.
Yes, but you should find lead by itself too. It is more dense than silver. If you ever douse where there has been hunting, there will be a lot of lead shot lying around.
Edge said:
I have given you a distance before, The Kelly mine can be picked up any where up to at least 7 miles in the valley of Hay fork I can get a direction from anywhere.
I have checked.
Depth is as far as I can tell 12 feet after that I don't know but I suspect even deeper. That's the deepest overburden that I have uncovered with success.
Thank you, Edge. So if you have a 12 foot depth range, then you must dig every hole, including the ones where you have no dowsing response, a minimum of 12 feet deep, and carefully examine the diggings in order to "prove" that the gold is gone. If you do not do this, then you can understand why we cannot simply accept your contention that there is no gold left?
Seven miles, eh? Does your dowsing rod also point out the location of the nearest jewelry store?
Edge said:
You are wrong it has to be stable or the reaction does not occur.
Not according to other dowsers. In fact I believe you told me about a fellow you dowsed with who held his dowsing rod loosely on the top of his hands.
Edge said:
It's a balance and that makes it sensitive and if I can stop the reaction then there is little if I can'tthen I start to mine with the big dredge.
And how has that worked out so far? You shouldn't even
need Randi's million.
Edge said:
The reason for gold or platinum is that the reaction is stronger for silver it's slightly weaker, lead is I think 11 times lighter than gold so it would be weaker, a weaker distortion in the field.
Never tried Iron either. Heaviest metals on the atomic scale are what tipped me off, time is a factor in what a person can do and I seem to be busy all the time.
LOL!
Hardly. Gold is not even twice as dense as lead. Silver is much less dense than lead. Platinum varies widely depending on it's purity , but when pure, it is denser than gold. It is almost never found in a pure state in nature, the way gold is.
If you are going by atomic weight, lead(207.2) is higher than gold(197.0) , platinum (195.1) or silver (107.9). The atomic number of lead is also higher than any of the other three.
http://www.webelements.com/webelements/elements/text/Ag/key.html
So, all in all, your explanation of how dowsing works is completely at odds with all the evidence. However, I do appreciate the attempt. It is only by examining your assumptions that you find out when they are faulty.
************
TechHead said
Ooops... actually, they can. While non-magnetic metals and ores don't concentrate magnetic fields, they can displace ferromagnetic soils that normally do concentrate the Earth's magnetic field. Therefore, ore bodies that displace magnetic soils, can affect the magnetic field, in a sorta reverse way. Aerial magnetometers are sometimes used to search for this effect.
But, we're talking big honkin' bodies of ore here, not nuggets.
D'oh! You're right of course. Sort of the same way we discover black holes; by their
lack of radiation. But as you note, not noticable on a small scale.