Edge dowsing # 2

wert said:
Edge had every chance to change the test conditions or back out of the first test at any time.

Part of the terms of the test is that it's not to be done unless the applicant is comfortable with the test conditions.

Edge said that he was.

Later Edge said that he wasn't. (after he failed of course)

Conclusion.

Edge Lied.

All of the dowsers I've tested, have consistently failed to show any dowsing skills. Each one was comfortable with the protocol before the test, and very uncomfortable with the results after the test. Some argued (post hoc) that the test must not have been valid, for whatever reason they chose to believe (interference, etc.).

I don't see that, because they changed their minds after learning the results, it necessarily makes them liars. In fact, I've found that dowsers, as a whole, tend to be fairly honest folk, who truly believe they can "do it". Even after failing a DB test, they continue to dowse, and claim that they can do what they believe they can do. This is more likely denial, than dishonesty.

Ignorance is really no excuse. Do you really believe that the test protocol Randi (and Edge mind you!) came up with is intrisically unfair?

Nope... what I said, is that testing a dowser (esp a treasure dowser) in an office, was a poor choice, even though Edge agreed to it, as it helps maximize the number of post-test excuses.

And how many have been proven "real" in your estimation? If so, why not submit your testing procedure to Randi and Edge in the hopes of speeding up another fair re-test for Edge?

I use the same basic protocol that Randi uses, except in a field setting.

I know many of us here would enjoy seeing your testing protocol and seeing your testing results (if you had successes) submitted to peer reviewed scientific journals.

Again, the dowsers I've tested, have failed to demonstrate any dowsing ability, at least in those tests. For most, I agreed not to publicize the test or the results, so even if I had anything interesting to show, I would not.

Aside from the fact that you claim interferences might have played a role, please expound as to why you feel that Randis test protocol is in any way fallacious?

Once again, I never implied that Randi's protocol was fallacious, nor did I didn't claim that interferences actually played a role. What I said, was that dowsers often claim interference played a role, after they learn the results of the test, and that an office environment will maximize the likelihood of that claim.

Edge knew of the test protocal well in advance of the actual test. He could have easily "self tested" as no special equipment or conditions were really necessary.

Again, most dowsers (indeed, most people in general) don't understand the concepts of DB testing. Part of our job, should be to help them understand those concepts. Practically every dowser I've ever met, would not be able to set up any kind of DB self-test.

You're overthnking it I believe.

Could be. However, I actually have experience testing dowsers, and have otherwise worked with a few, so it's also possible that I understand some of the underlying psychology of dowsing.

If we wait for Edge, the test will frankly never occur.

Is that such a bad outcome? After all, there are plenty of other dowsers out there.

He's questioned the honesty of Randi and now seems to think there is a conspiracy against him.

I'm sure AR's used to that. I've had the exact same thing happen to me, by both treasure dowsers and treasure dowser predators (those that sell $5000 dowsing rods), who hate that I've exposed some of the outright fraud going on in their world. If you want to see some examples, read these LRL reports. They're a hoot.
 
Edge
Very sweet, Edge. Did you write that yourself? Have you gotten over your anger? I hope so. Then we can get back to the topic at hand.

TechHead makes some very good points about establishing procedure. He would seem to be a very good person to contact as to preparing for your test, since he appears to have some experience with these tests.

TechHead
This is very interesting. In what capacity have you had the opportunity to test dowsers? The things you say jive very closely with what Randi has said of dowsers, namely that as a general rule they are not cheats or scam artists, but people who sincerely believe in their power. They also tend to believe in other "non-scientific" things. For your deceased dowser, it was new age cures. For Edge, it is UFOs and free energy devices.

I'd be very interested in hearing more about your tests of dowsers; how they came about, how they were done, how you got them to agree to being tested...
Fascinating stuff.

Wert
Maybe as TechHead suggests we are taking the wrong tack with Edge. Obviously, if he feels he is in a non-hostile environment, he is more likely to agree to testing. Also I agree that any way to reduce the availability of excuses is a good thing.

Personally, I still like my idea of using a piece of gold that was "dowsed' from a field location and using the same piece of gold in the same field for the double blind tests. That would seem to minimize the "environmental difference" possibilities.
 
Green eyes up there says your insane.
Wart tell me exactly what you don't understand about,
{I'm not ready yet}jeezzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz?
 
Edge said:
Green eyes up there says your insane.
Wart tell me exactly what you don't understand about,
{I'm not ready yet}jeezzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz?
Ok Edge.

Why do you have to "be ready" to simply contact the JREF about the test?

All it takes is a simple e-mail, letter or call.

Randi and the JREF will help you to "get ready".

The time you spend here coming up with excuse after excuse could be better spent actually talking to Randi about setting up terms for a fair re-test.

I guess the fear of failure is even greater this time. :)
 
Tricky said:
TechHead

This is very interesting. In what capacity have you had the opportunity to test dowsers? The things you say jive very closely with what Randi has said of dowsers, namely that as a general rule they are not cheats or scam artists, but people who sincerely believe in their power. They also tend to believe in other "non-scientific" things. For your deceased dowser, it was new age cures. For Edge, it is UFOs and free energy devices.

I'd be very interested in hearing more about your tests of dowsers; how they came about, how they were done, how you got them to agree to being tested...
Fascinating stuff.

My interest is solely in "treasure" dowsing. I don't mess with water dowsing, because I don't have the funds to investigate it, or properly test it. Also, I tinker a lot with metal detector designs, and other types of treasure hunting instruments (of the real variety).

Treasure dowsers call their devices "long range locators", or LRL for short. There have been various "LRL" forums over the years, the longest running is on TreasureNet. Over the past few years, I've hung out on these forums, and learned quite a bit about LRLers, discussed (& debated!) "theories", and heard about successes & failures.

I managed to talk a few of them into running through a simple almost-DB test. The test I typically use, is based on standard DB tests, using discrete locations and a single target. I ran the protocol by Randi years ago, to get his feedback on it. I call it almost-DB because, most often, there is just the dowser and me, and it cannot be run truly DB. So, I take extra precautions for that.

So far, 4 dowsers are 0-for-4. They all scored right at what is predicted for chance guessing. One dowser claimed to be a bit skeptical of what he was doing, and asked to be tested. After he failed the test, he went right on dowsing. On thing Randi told me way back then, is you will never, ever convince a dowser that they cannot do what they think are doing. So far, he's been right.

A bit of a funny story... on the LRL forum, there were a few dowsers that get together once a year in Quartzite, AZ, to compare notes and try out equipment. They don't like my views on LRLs (esp pointing out the fraud involved, see my last post), and knowing that I live in NC, they "invited" me to join them in Quartzite. There was a collective jaw-dropping when I walked into the local restaurant the morning they met, and introduced myself. We got along quite well, had a nice get-together, and I learned even more about their beliefs than I ever could reading a danged ol' forum. It was truly fascinating.

Honestly, I think folks should ease up on Edge. He ain't the enemy. If you want someone to growl at, take a look at the fraud involved in dowsing. Some of the treasure dowsing devices that I've gotten ahold of, are purely criminal. I'm currently posting full reports on the ones I've dissected, and intend to loan them to JREF for further scrutiny. People who make these things, have literally raked in millions of dollars (no exaggeration), not by finding buried treasure, but by wallet mining. IMO, these frauds should really be the target of JREF and the skeptical community, not the individual Edge's out there.
 
What I can't understand is why wart takes this whole concept so personally?
It’s not paranormal and it’s defiantly not tiny muscles under the skin because they would have to be stronger than the major muscles in your arms to get the stick to arch, hell I cant get it to do that on purpose.

Tech head I knew about the fake machines long ago you are a very logical and rational person, and a nice guy.

But I did understand the tests, but I had to try and there was a chance to make my daughter’s life and her sons a whole lot easier.

Her medicines cost between 500 & 800 dollars a month and she is only 23.


I would take ridicule any time to at least have a chance at tring to make her life and mine esaier, any time.


Now what I can’t figure is why in the field it’s 100% accurate, not only in detection but non-detection.

When you mine for a living you do not want to labor for nothing because you can starve.

Don’t give me it’s because of your knowledge of where to look that doesn’t cut it.
It can help to at least get you in the area and you maybe lucky or not but if your not and then you dowse and you hit every time, well then, there it is.
I will never mine blind again.

I will in the future make a film about its accuracy.
I am itching to mine soon though.

I know I will do excellent and I’m not worried about the million.
But I haven’t ruled out trying for it again.

I have used the same book knowledge before I knew how to dowse with very little success.

The oddest thing about it, and every miner has these thoughts, did I move enough ground? Did I leave any behind?
Once you make a hole you want to clean it totally.

Like I said before and I checked, because you could be a foot shy of hitting the big one, is there anything left?

It will tell if there’s anything left in your spot till you get every piece down to microns.
When I go to mine in Trinity Co; it will have been at least eight years since I was there last and the ground will be almost totally changed, what a challenge it will be and to see how much new stuff has been deposited in the traps.

There will be many new traps and boulder packs to look into.
I would rather be there to take a chance at that than to have to go back to Ft. Lauderdale, the farther south you go in Florida the crapper it gets I.M.H.O.
:cool:
 
TechHead,
I read your links and I definately agree that the "high tech" companies that take advantage of dowsers are truly evil, whereas dowsers themselves are pretty much nice guys. I am not an electronics whiz, but even a layman like myself could see that those high-priced dowsing "tools" were nothing but a scam. Sadly, they will trap enough people with their mumbo jumbo to make a comfortable living.

Are you yourself a treasure hunter? you seem to know quite a bit about the business. I find it fascinating and while rather risky, smart people have made a lot of money, although it is telling that none of them have been dowsers.

Edge said:
What I can't understand is why wart takes this whole concept so personally?
It’s not paranormal and it’s defiantly not tiny muscles under the skin because they would have to be stronger than the major muscles in your arms to get the stick to arch, hell I cant get it to do that on purpose.
Wert (his name is not Wart) is annoyed by your self assured belief which flies in the face of evidence. He wants you to admit you lied (which is pretty much a matter of record by your own words). I only want you to realize, for your own good, that dowsing does not work. I hate to see you waste your life on this. If I seem rude, it is only because you ignore the good points many of us have made.

For example, if this force is so strong, then why can it not move a tiny pendulem of gold? Have you come up with a logical explanation for that, Edge? If not, then consider reexamining your axioms.


Edge said:
Tech head I knew about the fake machines long ago you are a very logical and rational person, and a nice guy.
Glad you realize that, Edge. Not all skeptics are jerks. If he is a logical and rational person, then do you think his tests of dowsers which have shown 100% failure of dowsing are also logical and rational? If not, what happened?


Edge said:
But I did understand the tests, but I had to try and there was a chance to make my daughter’s life and her sons a whole lot easier.

Her medicines cost between 500 & 800 dollars a month and she is only 23.

I would take ridicule any time to at least have a chance at tring to make her life and mine esaier, any time.
Your motives are quite noble, Edge. Who wouldn't want to make life better for their loved ones. But I think you have chosen a bad way to go about it. You would have a better chance at winning the lottery than to prove dowsing. This is the real world, Edge. Don't expect the dowsing fairy to save you. You have to do it with hard work and the help of others.

Believe me, I am very sorry for your families woes. I am supporting a mother and a sister who have very expensive medical bills, so really I am very sympathetic. I wish you the best of luck, but people make their own luck. Wishing that dowsing were real won't help your daughter.

Edge said:
Now what I can’t figure is why in the field it’s 100% accurate, not only in detection but non-detection.
Because you cannot completely test them in the field, especially non-detection. You probably don't spend much time looking in a place where your dowsing says there is no gold, yet this is what you must do to provide fairness. You must look every bit as hard in "no response" areas as in those where you get a response, otherwise, your experiment is prejudiced in favor of the area in which you looked harder. But even if you looked equally hard, you could never be 100% sure you hadn't missed something.

Edge said:
When you mine for a living you do not want to labor for nothing because you can starve.

Don’t give me it’s because of your knowledge of where to look that doesn’t cut it.
It can help to at least get you in the area and you maybe lucky or not but if your not and then you dowse and you hit every time, well then, there it is.
If you could prove your abilities to a mining company, Edge, you could make many times worth the value of gold you discover yourself. You would not starve, you would be rich. Have you considered trying to show your talents to a mining company? They own most of the land where mineral reserves are likely. If you could provide them with a reliable, relatively inexpensive way to find precious metals and ores, your fortune would be made. Have you ever heard of a dowser being employed by a mining company? If not, ask yourself why.


Edge said:
Don’t give me it’s because of your knowledge of where to look that doesn’t cut it.
It can help to at least get you in the area and you maybe lucky or not but if your not and then you dowse and you hit every time, well then, there it is.
I will never mine blind again.
There are none so blind as those who will not see. Why aren't there any people who became rich dowsing?

Edge said:
I will in the future make a film about its accuracy.
I am itching to mine soon though.
I hope you will do so, and show it to mining experts.

Edge said:
I know I will do excellent and I’m not worried about the million.
But I haven’t ruled out trying for it again.
It sounds as if you are leaning against it. Why? It is easy money if you really can dowse. Much easier than digging in the dirt. Why haven't you commented on my test of using autocthonous (found in the field) gold to run a test? If it finally proves to you that dowsing does not work, then it would be a blessing to you, because you would no longer waste your time on a fruitless pursuit.

Edge said:
The oddest thing about it, and every miner has these thoughts, did I move enough ground? Did I leave any behind?
Once you make a hole you want to clean it totally.
But you use your dowsing to tell you when to abandon a hole, do you not? If you do, then you are not using your dowsing ability. If you do not, then your do not trust your dowsing ability. The only fair way is to dig every hole the same, regardless of the dowsing response. Do you do this?

Edge said:
Like I said before and I checked, because you could be a foot shy of hitting the big one, is there anything left?
You never answered this question for me before, Edge. How deep can your dowsing ability pierce? Have you tested it?

Edge said:
It will tell if there’s anything left in your spot till you get every piece down to microns.
When I go to mine in Trinity Co; it will have been at least eight years since I was there last and the ground will be almost totally changed, what a challenge it will be and to see how much new stuff has been deposited in the traps.
Eight years? Do you have any idea of the slowness of geological processes? Please tell me this is a joke.

Edge said:
There will be many new traps and boulder packs to look into.
I would rather be there to take a chance at that than to have to go back to Ft. Lauderdale, the farther south you go in Florida the crappier it gets I.M.H.O.
:cool:
Yes, you are right, because there are no metamorphic rocks in the area from which gold deposits might originate. South Florida rocks are exclusively sedimentary and deposited almost wholly by the actions of the ocean. Any third-year geology student could tell you this, Edge. There are no "serious" gold miners in South Florida, other than the ones looking for sunken treasure.

Edge, please snap out of it. Your daughter needs help, not fantasies. You are doing her no favors by this mad quest.
 
I see that you have misinterpreted my whole post or at least most of it.

For instance.
In 1982 I left to go to Florida, then in 1995 I went back on vacation.
In that time the terrain of the creek were I mined had changed so much that I couldn't even recognize the area were I had left off at, the very spot were I had done so good.
You have no Idea tricky how quick the geological process work.
It is no joke.

In January of 1995 I was on salt creek and it was low it started to rain we seen the water level raise 4 feet in a half an hour and we then could hear boulders on the bottom start to move and make rumbling sounds, crashing into other boulders. I’m talking about 2 to 4 foot size boulders.


If you could prove your abilities to a mining company, Edge, you could make many times worth the value of gold you discover yourself. You would not starve, you would be rich. Have you considered trying to show your talents to a mining company? They own most of the land where mineral reserves are likely. If you could provide them with a reliable, relatively inexpensive way to find precious metals and ores, your fortune would be made. Have you ever heard of a dowser being employed by a mining company? If not, ask yourself why.


Most of those companies are strip mining with heavy equipment they don't care.

But the the guy "Tim P." that taught me how to dowse did exactly that and was rich but he did it in the 30s or 40s.


The last things I found from dowsing was five silver trays.
 
Three, I havent took pictures of the other two, they are all differnt,and all were in a stack.
 
Edge said:
I see that you have misinterpreted my whole post or at least most of it.

For instance.
In 1982 I left to go to Florida, then in 1995 I went back on vacation.
In that time the terrain of the creek were I mined had changed so much that I couldn't even recognize the area were I had left off at, the very spot were I had done so good.
You have no Idea tricky how quick the geological process work.
It is no joke.

In January of 1995 I was on salt creek and it was low it started to rain we seen the water level raise 4 feet in a half an hour and we then could hear boulders on the bottom start to move and make rumbling sounds, crashing into other boulders. I’m talking about 2 to 4 foot size boulders.
So you are talking about uncovering more gold, not about refilling old traps, as you suggested earlier. But this is damaging to your case. You should have been able to find the gold earlier, even if it was covered, right? This is why I cannot accept your story that you are "certain that there is no gold remaining", when it is clear that you cannot be sure of that.

Of course, you have never answered the question about the range of your dowsing ability. It is obviously more than a few feet, since you were thrown off in your test with Randi by objects many feet away (and behind walls).

Edge said:
Most of those companies are strip mining with heavy equipment they don't care.
On the contrary, they care very much. Strip mining is very expensive work. If you can direct them so that they don't have to do as much stripping to find their targets, then you would be amply rewarded. Their payout is bigger, so their pockets are deeper.

Edge said:
But the the guy "Tim P." that taught me how to dowse did exactly that and was rich but he did it in the 30s or 40s.
Then why aren't you rich? If he was able to do so well, and he taught you, then logically, you should have done just as well. Did all of his money come from dowsing?

Edge said:
The last things I found from dowsing was five silver trays.
Were you dowsing for silver at the time? If not, then one could only assume you stumbled on them by sheer luck. By the way, have you had those trays appraised yet? Maybe they could pay for some of your daughter's medicine.
 
tricky said,
So you are talking about uncovering more gold, not about refilling old traps, as you suggested earlier. But this is damaging to your case. You should have been able to find the gold earlier, even if it was covered, right? This is why I cannot accept your story that you are "certain that there is no gold remaining", when it is clear that you cannot be sure of that.

What the hell are you talking about?

It's obvious you know nothing about how gold moves down and into a river or creek.

I'll have to figure out how to educate you on this issue.


Then why aren't you rich? If he was able to do so well, and he taught you, then logically, you should have done just as well. Did all of his money come from dowsing?



Were you dowsing for silver at the time? If not, then one could only assume you stumbled on them by sheer luck. By the way, have you had those trays appraised yet? Maybe they could pay for some of your daughter's medicine.

See there you go agian being a smart asss.

I gave you all a list of things a long time ago about what can be a target when dowsing 4 gold, duhu.
Gold, silver, platinum, and the major one, feilds of energy,{E.M.E.}.

When doing the D.B. test at my sisiters house those trays were picked up as a majore interferance and there was one other spot under the slab next to the pool, that was pretty good here in Florida.
The reason those trays were there she threw them out there for her X husband to pick up.
He didn't and they stayed there for months till she moved then right before she sold the house I did my testing there on the other side of the house.
Did you understand that?
They were buried and grown over by grass.

Out in the fields there are no E.M.E.

When I said it gets crappier the farther south you go in Florida it had nothing to do with minig here in Florida, it had to do with wall to wall city,heat and people.

It's tricky just talking to you, I thought I was clear.

I'll be back to break it down to you later about placer mining in the mountains God, I think {sigh}
 
Edge said:

What the hell are you talking about?

It's obvious you know nothing about how gold moves down and into a river or creek.

I'll have to figure out how to educate you on this issue.
I admit I am a soft-rock geologist, however, I have seen no evidence from you that you know anything about geology. Maybe you have learned a few good places to look for gold, and I am happy for you.

As for educating me, why don't you explain in simple terms how gold moves down and into a stream. Truly, I am curious.

Edge said:
See there you go agian being a smart ass.
I was not being a smart ass. I was genuinely concerned for your daughter. If dowsing is not paying enough to cover her expenses, perhaps you should investigate a more stable source of income.

Edge said:
I gave you all a list of things a long time ago about what can be a target when dowsing 4 gold, duhu.
Gold, silver, platinum, and the major one, feilds of energy,{E.M.E.}.

Fields of energy? What sort of energy fields are you talking about? Your dowsing rod should go nuts when it gets near electrical lines. But this is a good and easy way to test yourself. You should be able to tell whether or not there is current running through a wire or not, since electricity sets up a powerful EM field. You should also be able to detect underground cables. But if you are talking about the "energy" in quartz, you should know that quartz is the most common mineral on the earth's surface. Oh, and you are aware that the Earth itself has a magnetic field, no?

You should also get a strong response from copper and nickel, since copper is in line with gold and silver, and nickel with platinum on the periodic table. It has always been amazing to me that dowsers zero in on valuable elements, but not on similar but common elements. Can you explain how this works?

Edge said:
When doing the D.B. test at my sisiters house those trays were picked up as a majore interferance and there was one other spot under the slab next to the pool, that was pretty good here in Florida.
The reason those trays were there she threw them out there for her X husband to pick up.
He didn't and they stayed there for months till she moved then right before she sold the house I did my testing there on the other side of the house.
Did you understand that?
They were buried and grown over by grass.
Funny, sounded like they were antique things that nobody could have known were there, only to find out you know who put them there. Are you even certain they are silver? Lots of things look like silver, but aren't. Sacagawea dollers look gold, but aren't. Does dowsing pick up steel as well? How about chromium?

Also I am curious about this "double blind" test you were doing. Could you describe how you set up this test? What were the results?

Edge said:
Out in the fields there are no E.M.E.
You'd be surprised. How far away from civilization were you? Any cars nearby? Did you have a flashlight on you? A battery powered watch? Do you have any dental work?
It is extremely rare when humans are able to completely escape their civilization.
Edge said:
When I said it gets crappier the farther south you go in Florida it had nothing to do with minig here in Florida, it had to do with wall to wall city,heat and people.
Too bad. I thought maybe you realized that it had to do with the fact that you are so far away from a source of gold.

How does heat affect dowsing?

Edge said:
It's tricky just talking to you, I thought I was clear.

I'll be back to break it down to you later about placer mining in the mountains God, I think {sigh}.
No, Edge, I am afraid you are not clear at all. Perhaps this is because you are not skilled at writing, but I suspect it is because you cannot make this hodge-podge of beliefs which defies the laws of physics, fit into any logical framework.
 
Tricky said:
TechHead,
I read your links and I definately agree that the "high tech" companies that take advantage of dowsers are truly evil, whereas dowsers themselves are pretty much nice guys. I am not an electronics whiz, but even a layman like myself could see that those high-priced dowsing "tools" were nothing but a scam. Sadly, they will trap enough people with their mumbo jumbo to make a comfortable living.

Are you yourself a treasure hunter? you seem to know quite a bit about the business. I find it fascinating and while rather risky, smart people have made a lot of money, although it is telling that none of them have been dowsers.

Treasure hunter? S'pose you could say that, as I do hunt. But it's mostly with a metal detector, and mostly for Civil War relics. Also, a little gold panning here & there. But, my profession is electronics engineering, and my interests are mostly in the design of devices such as metal detectors, magnetometers, etc.

Highly successful treasure finders, such as Mel Fisher, Tommy Thompson, Carl Fismer, Bob Marx, and others, have made some very nice discoveries, but not with dowsing equipment. However, don't think for a minute that people who use dowsing devices never find anything -- they do, although not because the dowsing device played the role they'd like to believe it played. Thus, some stories of successful dowsing, coupled with a bit of fraudulent advertising, keep unsuspecting folks buying into the LRL scams.
 
Edge said:
It’s not paranormal and it’s defiantly not tiny muscles under the skin because they would have to be stronger than the major muscles in your arms to get the stick to arch, hell I cant get it to do that on purpose.

Most dowsing proponents who seriously study dowsing, now admit that dowsing devices are reacting to minute muscular movements (ideomotor action). I believe even the ASD agrees with this. In the case of a y-rod, it is held with a lot of applied torsion, such that it takes very little to get it to unwind. Where dowsers & skeptics usually disagree, is what triggers the ideomotor action.

Now what I can’t figure is why in the field it’s 100% accurate, not only in detection but non-detection.

When I go to mine in Trinity Co...

You may have answered your own question. Trinity County is one of the best gold panning areas in the entire lower 48. Despite having been heavily worked, they never get it all, and anyone who pans, is likely to find some gold. Especially anyone who has the slightest idea as to where to look, which I'm sure you do. So, your y-rod may be responding to your own intuition.
 
Hi Edge,
I'm the guy that asked you a while back if you had any theories as to what might make dowsing work. I'm still curious about that.

Does dowsing work if it is done with a mechanical fixture holding the dowsing rods or is the human interaction with the rods a critical element? If the human element is required maybe the dowsing effect can be interfered with.

Have you considered the possibility that just as you were to be tested last time Tricky, Techhead or Wert went into a big psychic meditation and loused up your results Tricky and Techhead seem like they might be a little too nice for this, but Wert, doesn't seem to have their limitations in this area.

Lastly, some people have brought up the issue of metal detectors. It seems like for some of the dowsing you do a metal detector might work pretty well. Do you have any thoughts about where it's better to use dowsing instead of metal detecters?
 
Q
Does dowsing work if it is done with a mechanical fixture holding the dowsing rods or is the human interaction with the rods a critical element? If the human element is required maybe the dowsing effect can be interfered with.
A
I don’t know but it would be interesting to have time do many experiments Dave.

Q
Have you considered the possibility that just as you were to be tested last time Tricky, Techhead or Wert went into a big psychic meditation and loused up your results Tricky and Techhead seem like they might be a little too nice for this, but Wert, doesn't seem to have their limitations in this area

A
LOL, I doubt that anyone could have an effect that way.
But if wart looked anything like his little clown picture then that could throw a person into some kind of a nervous fit.

Q
Lastly, some people have brought up the issue of metal detectors. It seems like for some of the dowsing you do a metal detector might work pretty well. Do you have any thoughts about where it's better to use dowsing instead of metal detecters?
A
Metal detectors are a very good tool, however they are limited in depth and distance.
Now a days I’m not sure what that is that would be a good way to check a dowser on most spots and then to bring it up and recheck the spot over, first the dowser then the metal detector to see which is better, did I lose you Tricky.
Tech head can probably answer the depth question.



Tech head said,
“Most dowsing proponents who seriously study dowsing, now admit that dowsing devices are reacting to minute muscular movements (ideomotor action). I believe even the ASD agrees with this. In the case of a y-rod, it is held with a lot of applied torsion, such that it takes very little to get it to unwind. Where dowsers & skeptics usually disagree, is what triggers the ideomotor action.”

I disagree I don’t need any side ways tension to get it to move and there is no way to wind up a branch.
First off you’re talking about a circle of wood, or copper.
If you wind it up then there would be immediate movement.

I can get the same thing with a copper wire bent in a Y configuration with a loop in the end and then you have the two copper wires in a L shape held separately with out completing a circuit.

You cannot use side ways tension in those.

I think there is something more to this accuracy or not.

The pendulum method is strange and I have no Idea except maybe the movement of the earth might be involved don’t know about that one.

What I think is this, that most of the heavier metals are laying on the earth’s magnetic field and there is a distortion in the spot where they are laying and that’s what is changed and being picked up not the metal it self whether in the ground or above or higher. That would explain the experiment that Tricky proposed to see if movement could be induced in a suspended piece of gold as another piece was used to dowse it, like a magnet does, it doesn’t work that way.

Metal detectors are actually reading the metal that’s if I’m correct, that might be the difference.
Z edge
 
Edge said:
Q
Have you considered the possibility that just as you were to be tested last time Tricky, Techhead or Wert went into a big psychic meditation and loused up your results Tricky and Techhead seem like they might be a little too nice for this, but Wert, doesn't seem to have their limitations in this area

A
LOL, I doubt that anyone could have an effect that way.
But if wart looked anything like his little clown picture then that could throw a person into some kind of a nervous fit.
That's interesting. Lots of people who claim paranormal abilities (including my wife) believe that skeptics cast out "vibes" that nullify their powers. As always, these vibes are undetectable except by their results.:rolleyes:

Edge said:
Q
Lastly, some people have brought up the issue of metal detectors. It seems like for some of the dowsing you do a metal detector might work pretty well. Do you have any thoughts about where it's better to use dowsing instead of metal detecters?
A
Metal detectors are a very good tool, however they are limited in depth and distance.
Now a days I’m not sure what that is that would be a good way to check a dowser on most spots and then to bring it up and recheck the spot over, first the dowser then the metal detector to see which is better, did I lose you Tricky.
Tech head can probably answer the depth question.
No, I am right with you, Edge. In fact I have asked you many times (and you have answered me zero) about the range of your dowsing powers. Obviously you feel that it is greater than that of a metal detector. How deep then? What affects the range?

Edge said:
I disagree I don’t need any side ways tension to get it to move and there is no way to wind up a branch.
First off you’re talking about a circle of wood, or copper.
If you wind it up then there would be immediate movement.

I can get the same thing with a copper wire bent in a Y configuration with a loop in the end and then you have the two copper wires in a L shape held separately with out completing a circuit.

You cannot use side ways tension in those.
Most dowsing devices are held in an unstable equilibrium. You are the only one I have ever heard that said he held it firmly and a powerful attractive force yanked it down even when you tried to act against the force. You might want to talk to some other dowsers about this phenomenon, which is unusual even for dowsers.


Edge said:
The pendulum method is strange and I have no idea except maybe the movement of the earth might be involved don’t know about that one.
You don't have any idea how the stick method works either. See below.


Edge said:
What I think is this, that most of the heavier metals are laying on the earth’s magnetic field and there is a distortion in the spot where they are laying and that’s what is changed and being picked up not the metal it self whether in the ground or above or higher. That would explain the experiment that Tricky proposed to see if movement could be induced in a suspended piece of gold as another piece was used to dowse it, like a magnet does, it doesn’t work that way.
This is absolutely ludicrous. Gold, silver and platinum are non-magnetic and have no affect on the earth's magnetic field. Iron, on the other hand, should send your dowsing rod crazy, yet you never seem to detect this very common metal. Also, if it is the heaviness of the metal that causes the reaction, then you should be finding a great deal of lead.

As to your excuse for why you can't attract a gold pendulum, it is equally farcical. For one thing, the magnetic field of the earth extends far above the earth's surface (and in fact holds the Van Allen radiation belts in place). But if you are worried about it, lower the pendulem untill it just touches the ground, then try to attract it with your dowsing rod. Of course, if you are dowsing for gold dust lying on the ground, the attractive force of the rod should make it leap up off of the ground and stick to the rod.


Edge said:
Metal detectors are actually reading the metal that’s if I’m correct, that might be the difference.
And what is dowsing reading? Don't tell me the energy field. I already asked why you couldn't dowse current in a wire. As I recall, that question went unanswered too.
 
And what is dowsing reading? Don't tell me the energy field. I already asked why you couldn't dowse current in a wire. As I recall, that question went unanswered too.

Oh but it can and that ain't all. A lot of bell south guys do it down here on new houses but they use the L wires. I think I have seen the cable guys do it too when there little machines fail them in locating the wires they are looking for, and they are able to compleat there job.

This is absolutely ludicrous. Gold, silver and platinum are non-magnetic and have no affect on the earth's magnetic field. Iron, on the other hand, should send your dowsing rod crazy, yet you never seem to detect this very common metal. Also, if it is the heaviness of the metal that causes the reaction, then you should be finding a great deal of lead.

How would you know?

Lead in the pockets where gold is found is found with gold but I never separated the two to see. More experiments are needed.


I have given you a distance before, The Kelly mine can be picked up any where up to at least 7 miles in the valley of Hay fork I can get a direction from anywhere.

I have checked.
Depth is as far as I can tell 12 feet after that I don't know but I suspect even deeper. That's the deepest overburden that I have uncovered with success.

Most dowsing devices are held in an unstable equilibrium.

You are wrong it has to be stable or the reaction does not occur.

If it is unstable it will fall or shoot up or down.

It's a balance and that makes it sensitive and if I can stop the reaction then there is little if I can'tthen I start to mine with the big dredge.
The copper wire one is most important, you really should try it. You need something thick like the copper wire they use to ground the meter box where the service for a house comes in from your electric company, don’t know the gauge right at the moment. Thick enough to grasp and hold its shape.

Another thing I notice when doing this is some form of jucie going through my hands and arms It will wear you out slowly like a good long jolt of 110, if you get enough of a jolt of electricity you'll feel sleepy and tired.

The reason for gold or platinum is that the reaction is stronger for silver it's slightly weaker, lead is I think 11 times lighter than gold so it would be weaker, a weaker distortion in the field.
Never tried Iron either. Heaviest metals on the atomic scale are what tipped me off, time is a factor in what a person can do and I seem to be busy all the time.

I'll have to try some of your thoughts one day soon.

I have seen some of the other dowsers hold it like you said and I find it quite amusing.

I don't know if this means any thing or not but the other day at the d.m.v. I was out side and was waiting I happened to notice a Y stick on the ground I think it was oak so I decided to look for water and I dowse under hand.

I have a hard time over hand with all most no reaction any way the stick went in reverse or pointed up and back around in one spot it was hard and strong for water, no Idea what it was seeking so I decided to see since it was so strong could I get it to work the same way over handed wouldn't the tiny muscles in my skin make it go the opposite direction? It didn’t it went to the source in the same direction up and over. Just a thought.


I don't mean to not answer it is just hard to type all this stuff.
 
Edge said:
Q
Does dowsing work if it is done with a mechanical fixture holding the dowsing rods or is the human interaction with the rods a critical element? If the human element is required maybe the dowsing effect can be interfered with.
A
I don’t know but it would be interesting to have time do many experiments Dave.

Myself, and several others, have tried this with a variety of LRL-type gadgets. All fail to do anything.

The most interesting experiment I've come up with, is to take an L-rod type device, and add a counterweight such that it is 100% balanced about the pivot point (the handle), then hold it in the normal fashion. You would think that, if there is a true physical attraction between the rod and, say, gold, the rod would still function. But it does not. In both this case, and in the case where the device is fixture-mounted, ideomotor has been removed, and the device ceases to function.

Compare this to the common magnetic compass, where ideomotor has also been removed, yet the compass still points north. This is an example of a real physical attraction, and a case where ideomotor would muss up the results.

Metal detectors are a very good tool, however they are limited in depth and distance.
Now a days I’m not sure what that is that would be a good way to check a dowser on most spots and then to bring it up and recheck the spot over, first the dowser then the metal detector to see which is better, did I lose you Tricky.
Tech head can probably answer the depth question.

Detectors are VERY limited in depth. A single coin at maybe 8-10 inches, a matchhead nugget at 4 or 5 inches. Yet, most "commercial" LRLs claim depths up to 100 feet, and distances on the order of a mile.

Most treasure dowsers I'm familiar with, all use metal detectors for "ground truthing" their dowse. That is, if the detector ain't beepin', don't bother diggin'. So anyone who ground truths with a metal detector is (a) limiting their LRL to a few inches depth, and (b) basically metal detecting. Also, I don't know of any LRL'ers who keep a journal of "hits" and "misses", so they have no idea if the LRL is making any difference or not.

Tech head said,
“Most dowsing proponents who seriously study dowsing, now admit that dowsing devices are reacting to minute muscular movements (ideomotor action). I believe even the ASD agrees with this. In the case of a y-rod, it is held with a lot of applied torsion, such that it takes very little to get it to unwind. Where dowsers & skeptics usually disagree, is what triggers the ideomotor action.”

I disagree I don’t need any side ways tension to get it to move and there is no way to wind up a branch.

I've used a y-rod -- to "properly" use one, you have to apply torsion to it, by twisting the handles either inward or outward, when holding it. This creates an unstable situation, and if you just stand there with your eyes closed, the y-rod will pop out due to slight movements in the hands.

I haven't used circular dowsing devices, so I can't comment on their use.

The pendulum method is strange and I have no Idea except maybe the movement of the earth might be involved don’t know about that one.

Nope, strictly hand movement and, of course, gravity. (Gravity plays a key role in L-rods, but not necessarily Y-rods.) Pendulums have been placed in fixtures, and they just don't move, without a hand to make them move.

Metal detectors are actually reading the metal that’s if I’m correct, that might be the difference.

Metal detectors operate on the principle of induction, same as a transformer. They require an AC-type signal to work.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom