wert said:Edge had every chance to change the test conditions or back out of the first test at any time.
Part of the terms of the test is that it's not to be done unless the applicant is comfortable with the test conditions.
Edge said that he was.
Later Edge said that he wasn't. (after he failed of course)
Conclusion.
Edge Lied.
All of the dowsers I've tested, have consistently failed to show any dowsing skills. Each one was comfortable with the protocol before the test, and very uncomfortable with the results after the test. Some argued (post hoc) that the test must not have been valid, for whatever reason they chose to believe (interference, etc.).
I don't see that, because they changed their minds after learning the results, it necessarily makes them liars. In fact, I've found that dowsers, as a whole, tend to be fairly honest folk, who truly believe they can "do it". Even after failing a DB test, they continue to dowse, and claim that they can do what they believe they can do. This is more likely denial, than dishonesty.
Ignorance is really no excuse. Do you really believe that the test protocol Randi (and Edge mind you!) came up with is intrisically unfair?
Nope... what I said, is that testing a dowser (esp a treasure dowser) in an office, was a poor choice, even though Edge agreed to it, as it helps maximize the number of post-test excuses.
And how many have been proven "real" in your estimation? If so, why not submit your testing procedure to Randi and Edge in the hopes of speeding up another fair re-test for Edge?
I use the same basic protocol that Randi uses, except in a field setting.
I know many of us here would enjoy seeing your testing protocol and seeing your testing results (if you had successes) submitted to peer reviewed scientific journals.
Again, the dowsers I've tested, have failed to demonstrate any dowsing ability, at least in those tests. For most, I agreed not to publicize the test or the results, so even if I had anything interesting to show, I would not.
Aside from the fact that you claim interferences might have played a role, please expound as to why you feel that Randis test protocol is in any way fallacious?
Once again, I never implied that Randi's protocol was fallacious, nor did I didn't claim that interferences actually played a role. What I said, was that dowsers often claim interference played a role, after they learn the results of the test, and that an office environment will maximize the likelihood of that claim.
Edge knew of the test protocal well in advance of the actual test. He could have easily "self tested" as no special equipment or conditions were really necessary.
Again, most dowsers (indeed, most people in general) don't understand the concepts of DB testing. Part of our job, should be to help them understand those concepts. Practically every dowser I've ever met, would not be able to set up any kind of DB self-test.
You're overthnking it I believe.
Could be. However, I actually have experience testing dowsers, and have otherwise worked with a few, so it's also possible that I understand some of the underlying psychology of dowsing.
If we wait for Edge, the test will frankly never occur.
Is that such a bad outcome? After all, there are plenty of other dowsers out there.
He's questioned the honesty of Randi and now seems to think there is a conspiracy against him.
I'm sure AR's used to that. I've had the exact same thing happen to me, by both treasure dowsers and treasure dowser predators (those that sell $5000 dowsing rods), who hate that I've exposed some of the outright fraud going on in their world. If you want to see some examples, read these LRL reports. They're a hoot.