Edge dowsing # 2

Mike, Mike, Mike,
Who did you think you were conning with this crap?
Guska wants to retake it: "They're going to have to come to me."

Does an excuse that lame work on you?

Randi doesn't claim to be some sort of psychic that can divine under what conditions you can dowse. If you can't dowse in an office why did you say you could? Why did you think you could dowse when the targets were visible to you in an office and then you couldn't dowse when the targets weren't?

The truth is you can't dowse. It's that simple. You aren't a bad person because you thought you could and you can't. You are moving into the land of wackos with excuses like you just put forth though. If you could dowse there are lots of opportunities to prove it. You don't need Randi, lots of different people around the world would be willing to test you. Prove that you can really dowse in one of a multitude of ways and your fame and fortune is secure.

But you don't do it. You can't be so self-deluded not to know the answer. It is so simple that even a child would divine it instantly: You can't dowse.
 
Time keeps on slippin.

I'm forced to conclude that Edge has no dowsing abilities and will not retake the Challenge.

He's reduced to "they'll have to come to me" when he knows that isn't the way it works.

And he was so confident. Said he was, anyway.

Oh, well.
 
A few words on dowsing:

As a means to detect water, the military have employed dowsers for much of history: they're fairly serious minded people, aren't they? As for detection of other substances the record is much thinner(generally speaking).

I have dowsed successfully for water but that water was in the ground: This might make for more success.

As for a mechanism by which dowsing might successfully occur, what about being telepathically aware of the effects within the 'magnetic' field.

i.e. telepathy works by detecting waves in stuff we do not yet know about which can be caused by 'magnetic' fields.

It is true that such fields exist in the gravitational flux.
 
NNN, if you can come up with a test protocol, you can apply for the million-dollar prize. Just be sure it's a double-blinded test, then try it to make sure you can successfully detect the water, and send in the application. Edge says he is preparing to retest, so if you want the million before he gets it, you might want to hurry.
 
A few words on dowsing:

As a means to detect water, the military have employed dowsers for much of history: they're fairly serious minded people, aren't they? As for detection of other substances the record is much thinner(generally speaking).

I have dowsed successfully for water but that water was in the ground: This might make for more success.

As for a mechanism by which dowsing might successfully occur, what about being telepathically aware of the effects within the 'magnetic' field.

i.e. telepathy works by detecting waves in stuff we do not yet know about which can be caused by 'magnetic' fields.

It is true that such fields exist in the gravitational flux.

1. Welcome to the forum.

2. Evidence please.

3. If you plan on making a habit of making bold claims such as the examples in your post above, get used to #2.
 
A few words on dowsing:

As a means to detect water, the military have employed dowsers for much of history: they're fairly serious minded people, aren't they? As for detection of other substances the record is much thinner(generally speaking).

I have dowsed successfully for water but that water was in the ground: This might make for more success.

As for a mechanism by which dowsing might successfully occur, what about being telepathically aware of the effects within the 'magnetic' field.

i.e. telepathy works by detecting waves in stuff we do not yet know about which can be caused by 'magnetic' fields.

It is true that such fields exist in the gravitational flux.
The thing about dowsing for water is that if there is water in the area, it is hard to miss. The water occurs in layers underneath the earth which have some lateral variation, but not over a short space. Also, you can hit water practically anywhere on earth if you dig deeply enough.

Randi described a test for dowsing where they put pipelines underground, buried them, and then ran water through them. The dowsers would try to find the pipelines. They all failed. Would you be okay with a test like that?

Of course, a test like that is a bit expensive to set up. Maybe you would prefere something like this test.
 
Last edited:
A few words on dowsing:

As a means to detect water, the military have employed dowsers for much of history:
The words 'employed' and 'much' are used a little loosely here.

they're fairly serious minded people, aren't they?
Irrelevant appeal to authority.

As for detection of other substances the record is much thinner(generally speaking).
The 'record' may well be 'thinner', but this is irrelevant.
Any findings regarding the veracity of dowsing that might be found in those 'records' may well be of interest to some (but not to me) - Please post any references you may have.

I have dowsed successfully for water
You are mistaken.

but that water was in the ground: This might make for more success.
No it won't.

As for a mechanism by which dowsing might successfully occur, what about being telepathically aware of the effects within the 'magnetic' field
Gobbledegook.

i.e. telepathy works by detecting waves in stuff we do not yet know about which can be caused by 'magnetic' fields.
No.


It is true that such fields exist in the gravitational flux.
No.


This may appear a bit negative to you, but that would be because you are deluded.
 
Hi NNN,

Magnetic fields do not work that way. We have spent hundreds of years studying magnetic fields and their effects. I have noticed a popular woo technique is to appeal to scientific theories people know very little about - magnetic fields, gravitational waves, quantum mechanics, string theory, ect. By doing this, they effectively eliminate most of the general population from saying 'b***◊◊◊◊', simply because they don't know the theory. Well, there are a lot of smart, educated people here to help you seperate the science from the psuedo.

And what's a 'gravitational flux'?
 
I see this is already well schredded, still:
A few words on dowsing:

As a means to detect water, the military have employed dowsers for much of history: they're fairly serious minded people, aren't they? As for detection of other substances the record is much thinner(generally speaking).
Do you consider it a key competence for the military to find water? If the military believes in dowsing, why are they not using it to find land-mines?

I have dowsed successfully for water but that water was in the ground: This might make for more success.
It certainly would, since in most land areas on earth, where digging or drilling for water is relevant at all, you would have quite some difficulty finding a spot without water.

As for a mechanism by which dowsing might successfully occur, what about being telepathically aware of the effects within the 'magnetic' field.

In that case, I challenge you to do something that must be immensely easier: Find a magnet by dowsing.

i.e. telepathy works by detecting waves in stuff we do not yet know about which can be caused by 'magnetic' fields.
Waves in stuff we don't yet know about??? WHat is the differenct between 'magnetic' and magnetic?

It is true that such fields exist in the gravitational flux.
How do you know, since they are "waves in stuff we don't yet know about"?

Hans
 
If the military believes in dowsing, why are they not using it to find land-mines?

Now that would be a test and a half: simply ask the dowser to get over a densely packed minefield with a convoluted safe route :D

It may also be an exercise in natural selection.
 
Hans:

The military does have a need to find, purify, and deliver water (U.S. military anyway). It's a rather critical field, especially in current times with much of our activity being in arid areas.



However, I can say that having spent almost two years performing military operations in arid terrain and climate, I have yet to see, hear about, or otherwise be informed of the U.S. military using dowsers of any type to find water.

They use geographical clues, maps, information from locals, scouts, and similar measures. Not dowsers.

There may be individuals in the military who dowse, but dowsing is not a practice condoned or supported by the military itself.
 
Halliburton must be employing substandard dowsers, if reports that the company furnished troops in Iraq with contaminated water are accurate. Tell those guys to get on the stick!
 
Halliburton must be employing substandard dowsers, if reports that the company furnished troops in Iraq with contaminated water are accurate. Tell those guys to get on the stick!

Can't speak on that, most of my time there was before we had the contracters in and set up.

But my thought is that they simply purchased the water from someone else, rather than finding it on their own. The water the military obtained and transproted was treated and chlorinated before it got to us, and any water we recieved from Iraqi civillian sources we treated with Cholorine and/or iodine before use (even then, it was not used for drinking, only washing or other non-ingestion methods. Our simple chlorination was not a way to make potable water).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom