Edge dowsing # 2

OK, appologies for my last post, if it offended Edge or others. I have to agree with Tricky about Edge, but I'm afraid only to an extent. Edge is obviously not a complete idiot, but he is stubborn. He's clever enough to be a half decent gold miner. He obviously has a natural ability to be able to tell where the gold is in a rock formation. This, along with the human brains natural tendency to ignore misses, has lead him to believe in dowsing. Superficial evidence, but which could be (and obviously has been) very persuasive to the right person.

The reason I only half agree with Tricky is that I don't think Edge is really that bright due to all the evidence he has seen and produced himself which shows dowsing doesn't work.

But it's worse than that. I don't actually believe the above. I think Edge is clever enough to see that dowsing doesn't work. He's just too proud/stubborn to admit it.

He has REPEATEDLY ignored direct questions. An honest person would have tried to answer those questions. Edge didn't, because he knows he will get caught out. Edge knows the score, he's just winding you up.
 
Edge
The fact that my hits were on the order of lets say 99% makes me the way I am about this, my knowledge of these facts makes me persistent at this forum.
So you are claiming that every single time you got a 'hit' you dug down and found gold and that every time you did not get a 'hit' you dug down and did not find gold. As for being correct 99% of the time, did you record every mining expedition and every dig?

… the fact that I have mined for a living and…
Bold mine.
Don't you think your field experience taught you anything? Are you claiming that dowsing is the only thing you rely upon to determine a location to dig?

Ossai
 
Ossai said,

So you are claiming that every single time you got a 'hit' you dug down and found gold and that every time you did not get a 'hit' you dug down and did not find gold. As for being correct 99% of the time, did you record every mining expedition and every dig?

I had to know for sure, was it a good thing or a waste of time?
I checked over and over as I mined it's just like I described, there I will be able to clean the ground and it will be neutral.

The documentation is burnt into my memories.
Next will be a recording of my every move.
 
Edge said:
I had to know for sure, was it a good thing or a waste of time?
I checked over and over as I mined it's just like I described, there I will be able to clean the ground and it will be neutral.
Remember you said:

Edge said:
Depth is as far as I can tell 12 feet after that I don't know but I suspect even deeper. That's the deepest overburden that I have uncovered with success.
Thus, the only way to determine if your "neutral" ground is truly neutral is to dig down twelve feet everywhere you get a negative response. If you do not do this, then you have not properly checked your accuracy. I may be wrong, but I suspect you are not thouroughly checking areas with no response. Doing one or two is not enough. We all know that there are a lot more areas without gold than with it.

Edge said:
The documentation is burnt into my memories.
Next will be a recording of my every move.
No offense, Edge, but I'm afraid the boundary between your memories and you imagination is a bit fuzzy. If you have a video recorder (or can borrow or rent one), I highly recommend recording everything. . Heck, you might be able to make some money by selling "How-to" tapes on dowsing.
 
Edge

What of my other questions?

Don't you think your field experience taught you anything? Are you claiming that dowsing is the only thing you rely upon to determine a location to dig?
 
Well Ossai, you can use book knowledge and that's very good for things like areas and what side of the river the gold lines should be on, for example the inside of a curve or the shortest distance.
Boulder packs and cracks.

I remember reading on how to work the gold pan to get rid of everything but the heavy metals.
I couldn't do it to save my life till some one actually showed me in the creek.

Book knowledge is good but it doesn't mean the gold is there, it gets expensive moving ground when you do not make a profit, I know how that feels.

The river is a dynamo when the rains and snow comes you can hear and see the bottom literally moving like a conveyor belt it can actually shake the ground around you and it’s one of the dangers any time of year, flash floods and such.
Trees can take you out if your not real careful and read the weather also.
 
Edge
Book knowledge is good but it doesn't mean the gold is there, it gets expensive moving ground when you do not make a profit, I know how that feels.
You are deliberately avoiding the question. I never claimed that you learned solely from books.
I ask if your field experience had taught you anything?

Are you claiming that dowsing is the only thing you rely upon to determine a location to dig?

To me it appears that you have learned some prospecting techniques and instincts, but are afraid to rely on them. Instead you dowse in order to confirm your instincts.

Ossai
 
Are you claiming that dowsing is the only thing you rely upon to determine a location to dig?

To me it appears that you have learned some prospecting techniques and instincts, but are afraid to rely on them. Instead you dowse in order to confirm your instincts.

Yes except locations or general areas.....
 
There are also those who believe that if you stick your fingers up your nose and blow, it will increase your intelligence.


No it seems to plug your ears!
 
I should feel guilty for being skeptical about Edge's gift. Edge is an honest dowser who only took Randi's test to pay for his sick daughter's medicine. LO! CHEATED out of his just reward by cold and uncaring skeptics.

Nothing like the REAL criminals out there, who prey upon the gullible with useless and expensive devices.

That about sum up the arguments so far?...

I don't see the basis for complaining about the $5000 devices though. A religion needs its trappings and priests need the cool special robes and stuff. If dowser believers find comfort and meaning in the $5000 gizmos, and if they "work", who are we to criticize?

Edge just plays the role of poor country preacher instead of the rich televangelist.

I criticize useless $5000 gizmos because the world is a better place when we face things honestly, even when it is uncomfortable. The benefit may not always be immediate, but if dowsing has no truth in it, we are better off knowing.
 
Kopji said:
I don't see the basis for complaining about the $5000 devices though.

"Professional" devices (i.e., expensive) play a major role in getting people to believe in dowsing, at least in the field of treasure hunting. Why would a company sell such an expensive piece of equipment, and why would people buy it, if it didn't work?

And, the expensive devices reach beyond treasure dowsing. Quadro sold one to government agencies for locating drugs, and taxpayers picked up a substantial bill on that one. DKL continues to sell the "Lifeguard" to search-and-rescue organizations, claiming it can locate a human heartbeat from 100's of feet away. Is there any basis for complaining about these devices, or should we just let the buyer beware?

Edge just plays the role of poor country preacher instead of the rich televangelist.

In the religion of dowsing, the poor country preacher is not the one buying a $5000 LRL, but the one who makes his dowsing device by breaking a branch off a willow tree. Those who buy the expensive devices, are the gullible flock who follow the slick-talking "televangelist" LRL salesmen.
 
Edge has now been eligible for his re-test with the JREF for nearly two months.

AFAIK, he hasn't even bothered to contact them yet.

He'll whine that he "isn't ready", yet he's had over 14 months to prepare since his first abject failure to prove his abilities under test condtions approved by himself.

My guess is that he'll likely never re-test for the million with the JREF....


Tell us Edge. When do you plan on "being ready"?
 
Techhead
I enjoyed your site on the long range finders. I worked as a engineering tech for several years, designing & building control circuits for manufacturing machines. The model based around the 555 timer brought back fond memories...

I built a simple roulette wheel with one once: The 555's are sensitive to changes to a resistor/capacitor combination that serve as a simple analog program. Removing a battery and allowing the timing capacitor to discharge caused the timer to sweep through a range of frequencies before halting. Using low quality components gave a delightfully random frequency output sensitive to all kinds of things. (Remember the movie Poltergeist when the TV received ghosts on dead channels?).

I missed my calling and should have gotten to work making these things. :)

A comment was made somewhere in the thread that people who believed in these tended to believe other 'out there' things also.

The dowsing circuits seem like an electronic version of homeopathy, at least the idea that a carefully balanced state can be influenced by tiny forces. There might be studies showing a relationship between these two concepts(?) (dowsing & homeopathy).
 
Edge said:
.....Ok Tell you what You talk the talk you set it up, before I can redo the test according to the rules, my choice
At ft-Lauderdale
With Jref.

Because I believe I can't take the test over till what is it March, say in a month or two instead.
If you can do that I will do it over again in a spot out side, down there, that I pick.....

Isn't it time for the retest?
 
Re: Re: Edge dowsing # 2

Spektator said:


Isn't it time for the retest?
He has been eligible to set up a re-test for since March '03.

And of course, he had a whole year before that to contact Randi about setting up a re-test.

Not suprisingly, all we get are plaintive excuses of "I'm not ready".


So tell us Edge, when will you be ready?
 
It is never going to happen. Edge has realized (perhaps only subconsciously) that he cannot succeed in a fair test, though many have been suggested here. He wants to propose some scenario where he drags the investigators out into the field, dowses untill he stumbles across some gold, then claims that this "proves" dowsing. Of course, no investigator is going to agree to this protocol, so Edge gets to walk away from the challenge claiming that the JREF is "afraid" to test him.

This is SOP for paranormal claimants (see S&S). Of course, he will aslo walk away without the million.
 
I'm thinking you're correct Tricky. Edge has been gone quite a while now. Perhaps he has given up on us.

Come back Edge! We want to hear about your efforts to set up another test with the JREF. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom