Edge dowsing # 2

Yes, Edge, even I would be happy to see such a new law of physics in our arsenal. However, I refuse to engage in wishful thinking untill I see some evidence.

I going to make sure that there is some evidence next time I do this.


Attempts to put off or avoid another fair test with the JREF.

We are going to make sure it's fair next time wart don't you worry and I'M NOT AFRIAD TO LOSE TWICE BECAUSE NEXT TIME I WON'T............................................................................................

Why isn't your sisters old house *which you claim is "good for dowsing", not a candidate for a retest?

See again I keep answering old questions again and again.

Your memory sucks, I told you when I went there to her house that it was for sale, and that I found her old silver trays along side of it, buried in the sand and grass. This was one of the interferences that were there at one end of the pool area. There were two rooms between where I was testing and where the trays were located.

After I did several tests there and had to go to Lauderdale the house sold.

I asked them several times to go to where I was but they couldn't, or they wouldn’t.

The next time I do this and I will.
They will have to meet me where I want them to meet me, whether here in Florida or in California.
It will never happen in an office again.
That was the first time and the last time.

I will film everything in the gold fields to show that a reliable test can be done in the field with a double check of the results so that no one can squirm out of any of the results, and again they won’t show and have the same lame excuse that you all try to put across.
Those excuses are absolutely ludicrous.
No one knows where the gold is and no one knows when it’s gone, except the dowser!

The gold in a creek or river is so far and few in-between and the job of finding it is so immense that no one can fake it or spoil the results.
Any geologist can tell if it’s been salted and if it’s coming from layered ground that hasn’t seen the light of day for hundreds of years and maybe even thousands of years so there is your back up.

I would not have gold to salt the creeks and would let them pick the areas to look for it and what ever is pulled up small or large the traps can be checked and rechecked double checked two ways of checking if it works.



When or if I find unbiased neutral ground here, or if I don't, I will call on them to meet with me Mr. wart were I want, or they will take the derision.

I will guess that they won’t meet me in gold country because there they will lose, I.M.H.O. I will have 100% hit capability.

But if possible I will do it here in Fl., but I’m not sure when, don’t you worry if I find the right place you will be the first to know but I will not be pressured into it till I find the right ground here.

ZEdge

I going to make sure that there is some evidence next time I do this.
 
Picture time.
This thin 1913-dime fell out of no were, believe it or not, straight threw the ceiling of our home.

I never owned this dime before this incident.
Strange ◊◊◊◊ happens all the time, The room was dark and it made a distinctive sound as it hit the floor and neither of us thought much of it till the next day when we woke up to find it laying on the floor where it hit.

It fell from a great height of about 7 feet and bounced more than once, at the time we figured it fell out of one of our pockets but our cloths were on the floor.
There was nothing on the ceiling but ceiling so where did it come from?
Nether one of us received it in change because when we do get a coin like that we would notice it right away, no doubt about that, it could not have slipped by.

Not to change the subject but what the ◊◊◊◊!
ZEdge
 
Edge said:
Your memory sucks, I told you when I went there to her house that it was for sale, and that I found her old silver trays along side of it, buried in the sand and grass. This was one of the interferences that were there at one end of the pool area. There were two rooms between where I was testing and where the trays were located.
That's not what you said before Edge.

Specifically, you said :

I had to go further inland to find good clean ground. One house, my sisters was excellent, but it got sold...
With your direct quote, my memory is not in question.

Nice attempt to spin it though.

The next time I do this and I will.
How about you actually contact them first to set up the time, place and conditions?

And since you're now officially eligible for the re-test, why haven't you been in contact with the JREF yet?


They will have to meet me where I want them to meet me, whether here in Florida or in California.
The test will take place under conditions mutually acceptable to you and the JREF.

If you continue to dither and place impossible conditions on the test, then by definition the test won't take place.

Then I'm wagering you'll claim victory, stating that the JREF couldn't meet your conditions.


It will never happen in an office again.
That was the first time and the last time.
Ah, but in the open test, you claimed your dowsing powers were working quite well. In fact, you scored 100% on that "open test" and then later on admitted you lied about the efficacy of your skill during that test.


I will film everything in the gold fields to show that a reliable test can be done in the field with a double check of the results so that no one can squirm out of any of the results, and again they won’t show and have the same lame excuse that you all try to put across.
Irrelevant filler noted.

Those excuses are absolutely ludicrous.
No one knows where the gold is and no one knows when it’s gone, except the dowser!
Excuses? You should know edge. You're an expert when it comes to generating excuses for failing the test the first time.

To wit:



  • Now, following the tests, Mike said that he'd found, all through the trials, that his stick was being "distracted" by the "gold" lettering on a double set of the Encyclopaedia Britannica on the shelves located near cups #1 and #2. Remember, he'd "tuned" his forked stick specifically to react to gold. We told him later that there was no gold in that location, either, since the book lettering is done with a bronze-powder ink.


    I can prove it day after day in the field does he have the stamina?
    After all he's about 80 or so.

    I don't need no open test the second time around as they now know I can dowse.

    You’re tiring to discredit me because I failed to win.

    Behind the books in that spot on the other side of the wall I believe was a good size copy machine and scanner, I'm not sure but it was about 3 or 4 feet tall or on a desk.

    From my point of view this is information not excuses.
    Call it what you like if it makes you safe in your room!

    As this happened I was trying to learn the difference in the attractions, the one holding and the ones that were not that were showing attraction. There are many reasons for it doing that. In my house here, there was more interferences, it was worse, at the foundation it was way better but interferences were there too just not as bad.

    Dowsing for gold occurs were its mined not in an office, there the success rate is 100%.

    He said he had always been successful in detecting each and all of these seventeen items, when his forked stick was specifically "tuned" to pick up gold (stated before tuning up his stick and failing miserably)


    I had three threads one was deleted by me and the other two, Well not by me.

    I'll give you a hint, behind the wall is something with electrical fields running through it., James knows what’s behind the wall.

    I don't know if the date that I can go back to the foundation for retesting is going to interfere with my plans, understand?


    I thought the conditions would be acceptable and I could over come that false readings or interferences, after going through all the trouble I was determined to try, you just don't have a clue as to what drives me but after just checking the room before the pilimanary test I all ready knew I was going to have a hard time of it.


    Some times money doesn't mean nothing compared to making an attempt at pleasing everybody, that is the best way I can put it.
    It's what you try to do for others that is worth more than money by not following my dreams for the moment I have made my own people happy that I’m here, Understand?

    You can see the target, if i said it's over there when it's obviously in 3 not 9 then I would be crazy and the test would be over because of my blindness to the real world.
    LMAO.


    James has a couple of things wrong here, now that you mention it.

    Since you don't believe me ask James about all the extra readings?

    It's the Jref office I never said he did anything to sabotage me.
    Hell my house was the same, did I sabotage my self? It’s self-evident if you dowse.
    They have many things that can interfere there.

    In the open test it's visible and I had to show that there was an attraction there, but there were still attractions were it was not.

    It wasn't total (success) it was as good as I could do in the office.

    The foundation explains it in scientific medical terms that make that knowledge a dead end.

    (Randi)Just forgetful, like any one else.

    Maybe then but now I know better, you have to fail sometimes to get it right. (When asked if he initially approved of the test conditions)

    If you want to prove something then lets go to the field where dowsing for gold occurs what your not scared are you?

    These are things that I know, most things on the list are found in pockets or cracks containing gold in the field they are dowsed together, in real life they are not together and that’s when miss readings occur do you want the list again?

    But I was talking about electrical fields that are all through their office not including other points of attraction.

    They are running a computer related business think of the amount of machinery that's there producing electrical fields one of the major attractions.


When or if I find unbiased neutral ground here, or if I don't, I will call on them to meet with me Mr. wart were I want, or they will take the derision.
Quite obviously, you're setting it up so that you can claim that "neutral ground" isn't available for the test, conveniently giving you an "out" to avoid the test.

I will guess that they won’t meet me in gold country because there they will lose, I.M.H.O. I will have 100% hit capability.
We'll see. I'm quite sure you and Randi can come to terms if you actually take the time to contact him.

But if possible I will do it here in Fl., but I’m not sure when,
I'm thinking...................Never?


don’t you worry if I find the right place you will be the first to know but I will not be pressured into it till I find the right ground here.
In other words you'll put it off as long as you can in the hopes we'll forget about it. *sigh*


We really should set up an "edge clock"

It would tick off the days inexorably until you get the courage to contact Randi, set up, take and fail the test yet again. :)

I'm saying that no matter what the conditions, you'll walk away an abject failure, just as you did the first time.

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
Remember, Edge, if you expect the testers to come to some remote location to run the test, you are responsible for their expenses. It is not as if these people have unlimited funds for traipsing all over the world to confront self-deluded people who will not accept the fact that they failed even when the evidence is right in front of their faces.
 
Edge said:

I will guess that they won’t meet me in gold country because there they will lose, I.M.H.O. I will have 100% hit capability.

Edge,

I seriously doubt they will accept a natural field test, like finding placer gold in a stream. The problem with that is that there is no baseline to determine success or failure.

Here in NC, I do a little bit of gold panning, and I know there are certain streams that are decent for finding gold, and I know how to look for high-probablilty spots for panning. Most of the time, I can find some amount of gold. If I were to haul a dowsing rod out there, and repeat my previous results, it would certainly not prove that dowsing works, only that I know how to pan for gold.

I agree that you should not attempt a test in an office environment, and that you should be 100% comfortable with the test locale. But it shouldn't need to be a highly probable gold-bearing stream. If your device can locate tiny placer gold from a distance, then can it work with a one-ounce bar of .999 fine gold, from 10 feet away?

If you cannot locate a 1-oz gold bar at 10 feet, I doubt you will ever succeed at locating a 1-dwt nugget at 100 yards.
 
TechHead said:
If I were to haul a dowsing rod out there, and repeat my previous results, it would certainly not prove that dowsing works, only that I know how to pan for gold.
Excellent point.


I agree that you should not attempt a test in an office environment, and that you should be 100% comfortable with the test locale.
He was comfortable enough dowsing in the office in his first test that he got 100% in the "open test".

(4) The performer has the opportunity of deciding for himself — in the "open" tests — whether it's his powers, or just his foreknowledge of the answer, that is actually at work. Mike was convinced of the former.


If you cannot locate a 1-oz gold bar at 10 feet, I doubt you will ever succeed at locating a 1-dwt nugget at 100 yards. [/B]

Actually, Mike(Edge) brought 17 items to the test, and he claimed this about his accuracy in finding them via dowsing.

032902-G2.jpg


He said he had always been successful in detecting each and all of these seventeen items, when his forked stick was specifically "tuned" to pick up gold — by having a small scrap of gold fastened to its tip.

Randi bent over backwards to give edge the greatest possible chance to find the items.

We decided to use the entire package of seventeen items, sealed in a plastic bag, to give Mike the maximum chance of finding his target, and he affixed his gold "guider" sample to the stick to "tune" it. The total weight of his composite target was 230 grams (8.2 ounces).

Needless to say, when the test was over and done, Mikes dowsing powers mysteriously vanished between the time of the open test and the time of the actual test.

Gory details of his failure are right here.

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
wert said:
He was comfortable enough dowsing in the office in his first test that he got 100% in the "open test".

Yup, read all about that a while back. In a slight amount of fairness to Edge, I think it was a huge mistake to administer the test indoors, and something Randi should have known better than to do.

Most treasure dowsers "do their thing" in the great outdoors, away from buildings and even cities, looking for buried caches or gold nuggets. When testing a treasure dowser, conditions should be as close to the field as possible. The #1 excuse for dowsing failure in tests, is electromagnetic radiation. Buildings are FULL of EM emmissions. Another common excuse is interfering "anomalies", such as nearby items that cause false reactions. Doing the test in a building just offers up reams of those excuses.

Yeah, I know, he did a baseline test and was 100% successful. But, in my experience, most dowsers have never attempted a true DB test, and rarely understand the concepts, especially the statistics. Passing the baseline portion, and failing the DB portion, probably doesn't register much significance. The point being, the test should replicate field conditions as closely as possible, and Randi (or whoever is sponsoring/proctoring the test) should help guide that effort, even if the dowser initially says "this office will be fine."
 
TechHead said:


The point being, the test should replicate field conditions as closely as possible, and Randi (or whoever is sponsoring/proctoring the test) should help guide that effort, even if the dowser initially says "this office will be fine."
Edge has said before that doing the same exact test in a place with "less interferences" would be fine.

However, he's now making it seem nearly impossible to find such a place in an effort to duck a fair re-test.

The items he tested for with Randi were ones he claims to have been able to find before via dowsing with a high success rate.

I've asked him before about his procedure for this sucessful "self test" that he supposedly passed.

Edge has been very silent about it.

I've suggested that he must logically have found a good place to find those objects if he claims to have found them before via dowsing.

And instead of answers, we get the sound of crickets chirping.

Also, Edge has plenty of time to post off topic images and posts here, but he so far has failed to contact the JREF even once about his fair re-test.

He claims the re-test is important and that he'll "take the million", but he doesn't even make the effort to contact the JREF to set up the details.
 
Techhead,
I use a willow because it is most flexible even when dried out.
It was what was taught to me by Tim P. who taught me how to dowse.
He said it was the best also for seeking water.

Athena,
There is only one major reason for myself to take the test.
Aside from the money, only Brother Bluto and Debunk know why I took it. I knew going in the odds were against me but I would try anything to help her and myself.
What happened to Debunk I haven't heard from him lately.

I might tell why I took the test soon but I’m not sure how to do that correctly as it involves my daughter.
This is in answer to the private messages that I have received.


Edge
 
Edge said:
Athena,
There is only one major reason for myself to take the test.
Aside from the money, only Brother Bluto and Debunk know why I took it. I knew going in the odds were against me but I would try anything to help her and myself.

I might tell why I took the test soon but I’m not sure how to do that correctly as it involves my daughter.

This is in answer to the private messages that I have received.
Edge

Edge, the last time I contacted you was many many months ago, and I sent you the Code of Ethics for the ASD. I'm not going to debate the code here with you. As you know I barely discuss dowsing here at all anymore, only to offer the fact that In *am* a dowser, specializing in water dowsing, and that if anyone would like to discuss that with me off this board I'd be happy to. I also have a few resources that I've shared with a few here who are interested, skeptics included.

Just wanted to point that out since you mentioned me specifically.
 
Edge,

Nice the way you failed to answer any of the questions again.

Now your excuse is a "private thing about your daughter'.

Please, let's keep this discussion relevant to the point at hand.

Why haven't you contacted Randi or JREF yet about your re-test?

It's now been a year. You're eligible for a fair re-test under conditions agreeable to both you and the JREF.

What happened to all the big talk about "taking the million" with your "secret weapon"?

These days we're watching you trot out old excuses and do your darndest to come up with even lamer ones.

No on cares (save perhaps Athena) your motives for taking the first test.

We're interested in why you say you'll take the re-test but have not (at this date) contacted the JREF yet to hammer out the details.

Your evasions are as transparent as ever Edge.

But I guess that's no surprise since you pretty much admitted you lied to Randi about your "open tests".

Why should we trust you now?

We've got lots of evidence that you can't dowse and not a single iota of verifiable evidence that you can.

Excuse us if we don't don't your word on it. :)

Athena said:

As you know I barely discuss dowsing here at all anymore, only to offer the fact that In *am* a dowser, specializing in water dowsing, and that if anyone would like to discuss that with me off this board I'd be happy to.
Athena,

We're all aware of the reason you don't post about dowsing much.

Simply put, you can't produce results under test conditions and would prefer to keep your self delusions intact.

At least Mike had the initial guts (nowhere in evidence these days) to initially take the test.

You don't seem to even consider taking it yourself, but it doesnt matter.

Your results would probably run along these lines.

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html :rolleyes:
 
wert said:
Athena,

We're all aware of the reason you don't post about dowsing much.

Simply put, you can't produce results under test conditions and would prefer to keep your self delusions intact.

At least Mike had the initial guts (nowhere in evidence these days) to initially take the test.

You don't seem to even consider taking it yourself, but it doesnt matter.

Your results would probably be about the same as this gentlemans.

Wart,
Those are your words, not mine. Exactly why I don't continue dialogue here. You know NOTHING about me, what I can do, or my motives, or the results I've had. Continue....
 
Athena said:


Wart,
Those are your words, not mine. Exactly why I don't continue dialogue here. You know NOTHING about me, what I can do, or my motives, or the results I've had. Continue....
"Wart" eh?

Not even smart enough to come up with your own ad-hominen I see.

As far as your dowsing "abilities" are concerned, I have a simple suggestion for you.

Put up or shut up.

Someone belonging to such an official sounding dowsing organization should be able to replicate their results under test conditions acceptable to themselves and the JREF.

We have no verifiable evidence that your dowsing skills are any less illusory than those of Edge.

Until we see said verifiable proof, what you say doesn't amount to a hill of rancid beans.

I'll tell you what I told edge concerning his dowsing "abilities".

Pardon us if we don't take your word on it. :)
 
Athena said:

Wart,
Those are your words, not mine. Exactly why I don't continue dialogue here. You know NOTHING about me, what I can do, or my motives, or the results I've had. Continue....

Yes, we know, Athena. We have been treated to an example of your righteous indignation. We remember this post of yours.
Athena said:
"Edge earnt his place to post what he likes here... "

Oh bite me. Someone asked a question and I answered. Nothing was addressed to you, or edge. The board bullies, slinging their filthy insults because they have no other resources in their tiny brains. Yes, you do much for the human race and to promote theories of skepticism and the attitude created about skeptics and this website De Bunk. At least I can write in paragraphs, am not an alcoholic, and have more respect for my fellow humans and their beliefs in my pinky then you would in your entire lifetime. Keep spewing your BS, what a waste of flesh you are. Somewhat sad too, because you seem to be somewhat creative and intelligent, however you're abrasive and rude. At least on the computer. My guess is you're a little nerd who has no job and no life, just this cyber playground where you go around shooting off your big mouth - and most of the time hitting yourself in the foot. But I don't really care.

Yes, all this mud-slinging really promotes fine dialogue. You're a loser and you know it and you're just jealous because you will never have any understanding about paranormal events. Usually the understanding comes with a personal loss and/or life-changing event, or enlightenment on the path to spiritual development.

Apologies to all those here who are not on the obnoxious end of the spectrum.

Have a nice day.:p

What we have not been treated to is your explantaion of how dowsing works. Instead, you post links to dowsing sites. Well, it's a free board. You must understand though, that most people on these boards are skeptics, and your assurance that dowsing works is simply not enough for us. Would you be willing to take part ina carefully designed test like this one? If not, show us the flaw in the test design such that suitable modifications can be made.
 
You know it's one thing to be skeptical and another to be rude especially to women.
True!

Second thing I can BE RUDE TO YOU ASS CLOWN WART.

THAT MONICURE IS WARTS FACE WHEN HES TAKING IT IN THE CABOOSE.
What’s THIS CRAP ABOUT CUSSING I CAN REMEMBER debunk BEING THE BIGGEST SKEPTIC ON HERE NEVER GITTING CHASTIZED.
WHERE are YOU? YOU OLD PUD?

SAME GOES TO YOU TesRICKY.

Now what DON'T YOU UNDERSTAND ABOUT, I’m NOT READY YET?
I'm not going to lose twice watch me son.



You know when wart and Miss Tesricky talk like this

Why should we trust you now?

These days we're watching you trot out old excuses [/QUOTE

I feel they are under a delusional trip that they are actually a part of the Jref team, wake up you are only a Part Of this forum and nothing else you haven't seen anything special or experienced anything unusual
and this is because your not special.




Excuses to you are the new knowledge of the reaction of dowsing be it positive or negative It's what is being learned about it.

Further more this is my thread and I will talk about anything that I what to at any time dig it?
I knew that you could!

Read the top of this page then read on if you like.
I wonder who had the name first?

http://www.edge.org/


What is the weight of a fully laden swallow?

Oh ya any one can pass the first open test whether you know how to dowse or not, You should have seen the look in James’s eyes when I hit the very first one correctly right off the bat and like I said no problem, then it was like a switch was thrown and I couldn’t tell my ass from a hole in the ground…I get to see them eyes in the future,
When I hit exactly what I say when the time comes and I will let you know.

There's no rush it doesn't have to be a year from the last date maybe in a month or so, at my convenience.

And wart said says this,

We have no verifiable evidence that your dowsing skills are any less illusory than those of Edge.

Until we see said verifiable proof, what you say doesn't amount to a hill of rancid beans.

I'll tell you what I told edge concerning his dowsing "abilities".

Pardon us if we don't take your word on it.

It's not about word it's about gold and action.
Proof will get gold you have no idea of its capability why would I argue about it so long? Any way if nothing else I will have some one else film the proof of a much better test that's not biased.
 
Edge said:
You know it's one thing to be skeptical and another to be rude especially to women.
True!

Second thing I can BE RUDE TO YOU ASS CLOWN WART.

THAT MONICURE IS WARTS FACE WHEN HES TAKING IT IN THE CABOOSE.
What’s THIS CRAP ABOUT CUSSING I CAN REMEMBER debunk BEING THE BIGGEST SKEPTIC ON HERE NEVER GITTING CHASTIZED.
WHERE are YOU? YOU OLD PUD?

SAME GOES TO YOU TesRICKY.
Calm yourself and turn off your caps lock, Edge. I have said nothing rude to Athena. I did challenge her to produce evidence, but that is what good skeptics do. I certainly did not rewrite her name as you have done to mine (and Wert's).

And yes, I chastised DeBunk quite frequently for his rudeness. I can show you the posts if you like.

As to Wert, he is a bit more "in your face" than is my style, but I have not known him to lie. What he does do is tenaciously hold you to what you have said. I can understand why that would be uncomfortable for you.

Edge said:
Now what DON'T YOU UNDERSTAND ABOUT, I’m NOT READY YET?
I'm not going to lose twice watch me son.
If you do not try twice, you will certainly not lose twice. However, if you do try twice, I go on record now as saying you will lose twice. Whether or not your bravado in insulting people is greater than your courage in standing behind your word, remains to be seen.

Edge said:
You know when wart and Miss Tesricky talk like this

Wert said:
Why should we trust you now?

These days we're watching you trot out old excuses


I feel they are under a delusional trip that they are actually a part of the Jref team, wake up you are only a Part Of this forum and nothing else you haven't seen anything special or experienced anything unusual and this is because your not special.
First of all, my forum name is Tricky. I do not change your name. Calling me "miss" may seem clever to you, but in actuality it shows your disdain for women. This correlates poorly with your desire to appear to be the defender of poor little opressed Athena. I do not consider being called a woman to be an insult. I like and respect women.
-----
Back to your post:

Are you suggesting that Wert and I are in collusion? I assure you, I have never so much as exchanged a Private Message with the fellow. We merely share a goal, which is getting dowsers to prove what they claim. Our ways of doing this differ.

I certainly have seen nothing special out of you, other than your ability to deny reality. I don't think that will win you the prize though. Have you looked at the tests I proposed? What modifications would you make?

Edge said:
Further more this is my thread and I will talk about anything that I what to at any time dig it?
I knew that you could!
Yes, of course you can. Of course, if you post off topic, people will think you are evading the issues that this thread is addressing. It makes more sense to post off-topic issues in other threads, wouldn't you say?

Edge said:
What is the weight of a fully laden swallow?
I believe the question is, "What is the airspeed of a fully laden swallow?", which of course begs the question, "An African swallow, or a European swallow?":D

Edge said:
Oh ya any one can pass the first open test whether you know how to dowse or not, You should have seen the look in James’s eyes when I hit the very first one correctly right off the bat and like I said no problem, then it was like a switch was thrown and I couldn’t tell my ass from a hole in the ground…I get to see them eyes in the future.
Recalling your glory days, Edge? Or glory seconds, perhaps? Did you get cocky after that first one? However, the "switch thrown" scenario is a bit different from your previous descriptions of the test. You earlier said that there was interference in the room that was present even during the open test. Now you are implying that everything was working fine until "the switch was thrown". You must realize that these constant revisions to your story do nothing for your credibility.

Edge said:
When I hit exactly what I say when the time comes and I will let you know.
I expect you will, when and if that time occurs. In all honesty, I would prefer that you simply face reality and admit you can't dowse. We could sit down and have a beer (or rum and coke) and talk about real stuff.

Edge said:
There's no rush it doesn't have to be a year from the last date maybe in a month or so, at my convenience.
Partially so. You do realize, of course, that Randi has quite a few irons in the fire and cannot be expected to adjust his schedule to fit yours. Would you be satisfied with performing for his representative? (No, not me. Unlike you, I have never had the pleasure of meeting the great man.)

Edge said:
It's not about word it's about gold and action.
Proof will get gold you have no idea of its capability why would I argue about it so long? Any way if nothing else I will have some one else film the proof of a much better test that's not biased.
I beg to differ, Edge. A person's word is more valuable than gold. If you have no honesty, then you could have more gold than anyone in the world, and still be a pauper.

I believe you are honest, but deluded. You want dowsing to be real so badly that you ignore all evidence to the contrary. Yes, I highly encourage filming the test. If you see yourself fail on film, perhaps that will encourage you to join us in the real world. Of course, I am an eternal optimist.
 
wert said:
Edge has said before that doing the same exact test in a place with "less interferences" would be fine.

However, he's now making it seem nearly impossible to find such a place in an effort to duck a fair re-test.

Well, he does need to be 100% comfortable with the locale, and 100% confident in his ability. Until he reaches that point, I wouldn't expect him to re-apply for the AR million. I know I wouldn't.

The items he tested for with Randi were ones he claims to have been able to find before via dowsing with a high success rate.

I've asked him before about his procedure for this sucessful "self test" that he supposedly passed.

As I've mentioned before, almost all dowsers have never, ever submitted to a rigorous DB test, and most don't understand the protocol. I expect that even when applying for the AR million, and developing and agreeing to the test procedure, they really don't understand the reasoning behind the procedure.

I have DB tested several dowsers myself, and found that I had to lead them through the procedural development. Otherwise, they would have been perfectly satisfied with setting targets on the ground, in full view, and walking around them with their dowsing device, not understanding the fallacies of such a "test". I'm convinced that even after a DB test, the importance of a DB protocol is lost on them, because in every case but one, they all went right back to full-view "testing". The one that did not, had a date with the undertaker 2 weeks later, ironically because he believed chelation treatments were more effective than heart bypass surgery.

I've suggested that he must logically have found a good place to find those objects if he claims to have found them before via dowsing.

Or, possibly, his self-test protocol wasn't up-to-snuff. Before going into an AR test, I would be sure that (1) I understand exactly what a DB test is, and (2) I can pass a similar DB-type test very consistently. Not doing so, would be a waste of everyone's time. Perhaps this is where Edge is at right now.

Also, Edge has plenty of time to post off topic images and posts here, but he so far has failed to contact the JREF even once about his fair re-test.


Well, I don't think there are any forum rules about off-topic images, so I'm OK with that. Read the paragraph above, as to why Edge should not contact AR about a re-test, until he is ready.

He claims the re-test is important and that he'll "take the million", but he doesn't even make the effort to contact the JREF to set up the details.

Let him figure it all out, on his own schedule. Beating him over the head with forum posts, is probably not too productive. Perhaps discussing scientific test protocols and statistics with Edge, would be more beneficial.
 
TechHead said:
Well, he does need to be 100% comfortable with the locale, and 100% confident in his ability. Until he reaches that point, I wouldn't expect him to re-apply for the AR million. I know I wouldn't.
Edge had every chance to change the test conditions or back out of the first test at any time.

Part of the terms of the test is that it's not to be done unless the applicant is comfortable with the test conditions.

Edge said that he was.

Later Edge said that he wasn't. (after he failed of course)

Conclusion.

Edge Lied.



As I've mentioned before, almost all dowsers have never, ever submitted to a rigorous DB test, and most don't understand the protocol. I expect that even when applying for the AR million, and developing and agreeing to the test procedure, they really don't understand the reasoning behind the procedure.
Ignorance is really no excuse. Do you really believe that the test protocol Randi (and Edge mind you!) came up with is intrisically unfair?

Even edge said that the test would be good if done in a place with "less interferences".


I have DB tested several dowsers myself, and found that I had to lead them through the procedural development.
And how many have been proven "real" in your estimation? If so, why not submit your testing procedure to Randi and Edge in the hopes of speeding up another fair re-test for Edge?

I know many of us here would enjoy seeing your testing protocol and seeing your testing results (if you had successes) submitted to peer reviewed scientific journals.

Otherwise, they would have been perfectly satisfied with setting targets on the ground, in full view, and walking around them with their dowsing device, not understanding the fallacies of such a "test".
Aside from the fact that you claim interferences might have played a role, please expound as to why you feel that Randis test protocol is in any way fallacious?

Or, possibly, his self-test protocol wasn't up-to-snuff. Before going into an AR test, I would be sure that (1) I understand exactly what a DB test is, and (2) I can pass a similar DB-type test very consistently.
Edge knew of the test protocal well in advance of the actual test. He could have easily "self tested" as no special equipment or conditions were really necessary.

Not doing so, would be a waste of everyone's time. Perhaps this is where Edge is at right now.
You're overthinking things I believe.

Edge is merely stalling as you'll see if you read his statements from the very start. (and there is a whole other thread filled with his plaintive excuses and ad-hominen attacks)


Well, I don't think there are any forum rules about off-topic images, so I'm OK with that. Read the paragraph above, as to why Edge should not contact AR about a re-test, until he is ready.
Edge uses off topic stuff merely as an attempt to change the topic. This very topic was created specifically so he oculd have a forum to discuss his dowsing claims.

Your rationalisations on his behalf do not convince in any logical fashion.

Let him figure it all out, on his own schedule.
Hey, he talked how he was going to "take the million" with his "secrety weapon".

If we wait for Edge, the test will frankly never occur. His continual excuses make that obvious to even the least observant of viewers.

He's questioned the honesty of Randi and now seems to think there is a conspiracy against him. :rolleyes:

Beating him over the head with forum posts, is probably not too productive.
It's one of the only things that actually got him to take the test in the first place.

Perhaps discussing scientific test protocols and statistics with Edge, would be more beneficial.
As you've noted, edge doesn't really understand science, so your suggestion is futile.

Edge will come back with non sequiturs that dowsing is real "because it is OK with god". *sigh*

You seem to think we're being too hard on edge in some fashion.

Last time I checked, we were simply asking him to back up his claims with actual evidence.

And I won't apologize for that. :)

As for you edge, you evasions become ever more obvious.

Your ad-hominen becomes ever more strident.

Whilst there are many valid questions that you can't (or won't) answer, for now, I would like an answer to the following.

Why haven't you contacted Randi or JREF yet about your re-test?

If you were serious about the re-test (and not ducking it in a cowardly fashion) it's quite apparent that you would have contacted the JREF by now. Any added excuses merely show a pathetic need to avoid losing for a second time.

And mark my words. If you test again under conditions approved by the JREF (and yourself of course) you will fail again.

And please let us know why we should should believe you are being any more truthful now than when you were when you blatantly lied during the original test?

http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 
Now for something different.


Your presence is a gift to the world,
you're unique and one of a kind.
Your life can be what you want it to be -
Take it one day at a time.

Count your blessings, not your troubles,
and you'll make it through what comes along.
Within you are so many answers,
Understand, have courage, be strong.

Don't put limits on yourself;
your dreams are waiting to be realized.
Don't leave your important decisions to chance -
Reach for your peak, your goal, and your prize.

Nothing wastes more energy than worrying -
The longer a problem is carried, the heavier it gets.
Don't take things too seriously -
Live a life of serenity, not a life of regrets.

Remember that a little love goes a long way -
Remember that a lot goes forever.
Remember that friendship is a wise investment,
Life's treasures are people... together.

Have health and hope and happiness,
take the time to wish on a star.
And don't ever forget for even a day...
How very special YOU are!
 
Hey Edge.

How typical of you to post off topic nonsense in lieu of actually answering a simply question.

Why haven't you contacted Randi or JREF yet about your re-test?


The time you spent hunting down that "cut 'n paste" poem could have been easily spent firing off an e-mail to the JREF and Randi about your fair re-test.



http://www.randi.org/jr/032902.html
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom