Edge dowsing # 2

wert said:
I'm thinking you're correct Tricky. Edge has been gone quite a while now. Perhaps he has given up on us.

Come back Edge! We want to hear about your efforts to set up another test with the JREF. :)
I agree! Come on back Edge! This place was much more entertaining with you here!
 
Edge said:
I'll let you know when .
Well let's see.

You've had fifteen months since your initial abject failure to contact randi about your re-test and have been eligible to actually take the re-test for over two months now.

Why haven't you contacted Randi and the JREF yet? Randi fully expects you to come back and you do have that "Secret Weapon" and all.

What's the hold up Edge?

As far as you "letting us know", let's just say I'm not exactly holding my breath. :rolleyes:
 
I'm guessing the timing on this has slipped to "Never".

C'mon Edge. Prove us wrong and take the test again.

We're waiting.
 
Be nice to the poor fellow, now. One thing is realizing you are wrong, another is admitting it in public. Do cut him some slack.

Hans ;)
 
MRC_Hans said:
Be nice to the poor fellow, now. One thing is realizing you are wrong, another is admitting it in public. Do cut him some slack.

Hans ;)
The point is that Edge has never once admitted he was wrong.
 
Wert...

At least he tries..and tries again and again...and again...

:D

DB
 
Kopji said:

The dowsing circuits seem like an electronic version of homeopathy, at least the idea that a carefully balanced state can be influenced by tiny forces. There might be studies showing a relationship between these two concepts(?) (dowsing & homeopathy).

Well, since this one's been opened again, what can I say.

Look at this.

Yes, some homoeopaths think they can tell which is the right remedy (or even which remedy is which) by dowsing. Funny, that was one possible method of detecting a homoeopathic material Randi left out of his suggested list of ways to win that trial!

Some real homoeopaths did a proper test, and found absolutely null results. They had the decency to publish these results (above link). The last sentence of the summary is a scream. "These results, wholly negative, add to doubts whether dowsing in this context can yield objective information." ADD DOUBTS??? What will it take to make them declare it's useless?

[Off topic - why do they test the real woo-woo claims sensibly, but never the central tenet of their faith, the so-called provings?]

Rolfe.
 
Spektator said:
Sigh...I've about given up waiting for the retest. And I miss Edge. Can you dowse using a yellow bamboo staff?
Well, bamboo doesn't fork, but I would bet that using a yellow bamboo staff would be exactly as effective as using any other kind of dowsing implement.
 
Tricky said:

Well, bamboo doesn't fork, but I would bet that using a yellow bamboo staff would be exactly as effective as using any other kind of dowsing implement.

I've got dowsing impliments covered. Read my sig.:D
 
Edge said:
....I'm going to Ft. Pearce in a day or two and if I find the neutral ground down there that I'm looking for it will then be on, real soon. Du hu !


Grave marker for Randi’s Million below.

That was last spring. Are you ready for the retest yet? I'm interested in whether you succeed when you try again....
 
Tricky said:
Bumped, because Edge is in the most recent Newsweek. Thanks Claus.

That's all we get? No explanation of why he's there, what he's saying, anything at all?

Thanks. :P
 
Aw, I thought you meant that Edge had gained some recognition outside of his encounter with James Randi. Turns out it's an article about the million dollars and how people fail, he's only mentioned as one of the crowd.
 
Wow! Thought this thread likely to be one of the ones that got pruned a while back.


Hm, it's been nearly two years since Edge (Mike Guska) got tested at which point he said he'd be back for a re-test.

Hasn't happened I see.

No suprises there.

ahh.. just noticed

Guska wants to retake it: "They're going to have to come to me."

I'll take that as your cowardly way of ducking the challenge Edge.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom