[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

This is specifically incorrect -- the legal definition of "income" has already been cited (I.R.C. section 61) and quoted, and it includes money derived from ALL sources, including salaries and wages.




Wrong..... You left a little out


How can you define income by saying all income? And I sure don't see wages or labor in there.



61(a) [SIZE=-1] GENERAL DEFINITION[/SIZE]. --Except as otherwise provided in this subtitle, gross income means all income from whatever source derived, including (but not limited to) the following items:
61(a)(1) Compensation for services, including fees, commissions, fringe benefits, and similar items;
61(a)(2) Gross income derived from business;
61(a)(3) Gains derived from dealings in property;
61(a)(4) Interest;
61(a)(5) Rents;
61(a)(6) Royalties;
61(a)(7) Dividends;
61(a)(8) Alimony and separate maintenance payments;
61(a)(9) Annuities;
61(a)(10) Income from life insurance and endowment contracts;
61(a)(11) Pensions;
61(a)(12) Income from discharge of indebtedness;
61(a)(13) Distributive share of partnership gross income;
61(a)(14) Income in respect of a decedent; and
61(a)(15) Income from an interest in an estate or trust.




Where is your reference to wages and labor in this section?
 




Wrong..... You left a little out


How can you define income by saying all income? And I sure don't see wages or labor in there.



61(a) [SIZE=-1] GENERAL DEFINITION[/SIZE]. --Except as otherwise provided in this subtitle, gross income means all income from whatever source derived, including (but not limited to) the following items:
61(a)(1) Compensation for services, including fees, commissions, fringe benefits, and similar items;
61(a)(2) Gross income derived from business;
61(a)(3) Gains derived from dealings in property;
61(a)(4) Interest;
61(a)(5) Rents;
61(a)(6) Royalties;
61(a)(7) Dividends;
61(a)(8) Alimony and separate maintenance payments;
61(a)(9) Annuities;
61(a)(10) Income from life insurance and endowment contracts;
61(a)(11) Pensions;
61(a)(12) Income from discharge of indebtedness;
61(a)(13) Distributive share of partnership gross income;
61(a)(14) Income in respect of a decedent; and
61(a)(15) Income from an interest in an estate or trust.




Where is your reference to wages and labor in this section?



"From whatever source derived"
 
Well good luck with that, dude.

Before you get kicked out for flunking, ask them to tell you what "taxable income" means. Or you could read U.S.C. Title 26 §63 and U.S.C. Title 26 §1.


Where in these chapters does it define income as wages or labor? These are just about deductions from people who are required to pay income tax, these are not laws stating you have to pay income tax. Where are these chapters and sections?
 
Where in these chapters does it define income as wages or labor? These are just about deductions from people who are required to pay income tax, these are not laws stating you have to pay income tax. Where are these chapters and sections?

So what, exactly, is your point in debating here? (I'm assuming you and the OP are one and the same). What are you hoping to accomplish here?

You are playing semantical games.


1. Join an activist group and push reforms.
2. Live on a commune here or abroad, and don't worry about it. Then you will be trading your labor for your livelihood.
3. Stop paying taxes and go to jail.
 
- Yes, congress CAN tax all gains, but my salary and wage is not a gain

Wrong. It is a gain. Go outside, labor to dig a hole for 8 hours. Does anyone give you money for your labor? No. You haven't lost money, either. You have failed to gain money, which is not a loss.
 
"From whatever source derived"

It says income from whatever source derived. That does not define income. It does however define it right under the intro you quote.

Also the supreme court ruled:
1916: Brushaber vs. Union Pacific Railroad, 240 U.S. 1. Established
that the 16th Amendment had no affect on the constitution, and that
income taxes could only be sustained as excise taxes and not as
direct taxes.

1916: Stanton v. Baltic Mining, 240 U.S. 103. Declared that the 16th
Amendment conferred no new powers of taxation to the U.S. government,
but simply prevented income taxes from being taken out of the
category of indirect (excise) taxes to which they inherently
belonged.

1930: Lucas v. Earl, 281 U.S. 111. The Supreme Court ruled that
wages and compensation for personal services were not to be taxed in
their entirety, but instead, the gain or profit derived indirectly
from them.

1938: Hassett v. Welch, 303 U.S. 303. Ruled that disputes over
uncertainties in the tax code should be resolved in favor of the
taxpayer.
"In view of other settled rules of statutory construction, which
teach that... if doubt exists as to the construction of a taxing
statute, the doubt should be resolved in favor of the taxpayer..."

1959: Flora v. United, 362 US 145. Ruled that our tax system is
based on voluntary assessment and payment, not on force or coercion.
"Our system of taxation is based upon voluntary assessment and
payment, not upon distraint."

1978: Central Illinois Public Service Co. v. United States, 435 U.S.
21. Established that wages and income are NOT equivalent as far as
taxes on income are concerned.

Long v. Rasmussen, 281 F. 236, at 238

"The revenue laws are a code or a system in regulation of tax
assessment and collection. They relate to taxpayers, and not to non-
taxpayers. The latter are without their scope. No procedures are
prescribed for non-taxpayers, and no attempt is made to annul any of
their rights and remedies in due course of law. With them Congress
does not assume to deal, and they are neither the subject nor the
object of the revenue laws."

Redfield v. Fisher, 292 P. 813, 135 Or. 180, 294 P.461, 73 A.L.R. 721
(1931)

"The individual, unlike the corporation, cannot be taxed for the mere
privilege of existing. The corporation is an artificial entity which
owes its existence and charter powers to the state; but the
individuals' rights to live and own property are natural rights for
the enjoyment of which an excise cannot be imposed."

U.S. v. Ballard, 535 F2d 400, cert denied, 429 U.S. 918, 50 L.Ed.2d
283, 97 S.Ct. 310 (1976)

"income" is not defined in the Internal Revenue Code
 
Wrong. It is a gain. Go outside, labor to dig a hole for 8 hours. Does anyone give you money for your labor? No. You haven't lost money, either. You have failed to gain money, which is not a loss.

This only validates his point. Labor belongs to the person doing the labor, if he wants to waste it digging a hole for nothing that is his desision. If he wants to sell his labor to survive this is not income, it is one commodity being traded for another.

And if you spend 8 hrs digging a hole for no reason you did lose money, you could be digging a hole for someone who needs a hole dug instead of digging for no reason.
 
I think my IQ just dropped about 40 points after wading through this thread. Tax protestors in the US are some of the worst CT nuts alive.

CPAs, tax lawyers, and tax court judges, administrative and judicial, have all heard these arguments many times before. Yawn.

What's sad is that there has been in recent years quite a cottage industry built around convincing people of some wealth that they can get around their legal obligation to pay income taxes by engaging in a series of twisted transactions in a misguided attempt to assign their income to some other entity they control. Not only does it not work as a legitimate means of escaping tax liability, but it can lead to criminal charges of tax fraud and land one in prison. Typical come ons for these scams promise seminars in the Bahamas or other Caribbean resort destination. Slick hucksters go to work on their marks there, and usually sign up a healthy percentage of attendees. Unfortunately, I have seen the results of their hucksterism. It ain't pretty.

As always, if it sounds too good to be true (live a life of luxury without ever paying another penny of income taxes!), it almost certainly is.

AS
 
It says income from whatever source derived. That does not define income. It does however define it right under the intro you quote.

Wrong. It specifically enumerates some examples, but it also explicitly states that those are examples, but not an exhaustive list.

"All income from whatever source derived including (but not limited to) the following items"

And you are greatly mistaken in how you interpret your court cases....
 
This only validates his point. Labor belongs to the person doing the labor, if he wants to waste it digging a hole for nothing that is his desision. If he wants to sell his labor to survive this is not income, it is one commodity being traded for another.

And if you spend 8 hrs digging a hole for no reason you did lose money, you could be digging a hole for someone who needs a hole dug instead of digging for no reason.

This splitting of hairs is simply philosophy. If you feel this way philosophically, fine. It's still not the legal definition. It sounds like you should be living on a Kibbutz.
 
So what, exactly, is your point in debating here? (I'm assuming you and the OP are one and the same). What are you hoping to accomplish here?
Don't know what your reference to OP is but whatever. The point to my argument is that if there is no law requiring tax on labor then we have a giant issue in America that needs discussion in major media.


You are playing semantical games.
reiterate. I fail to see semantics. This is a issue of law, the IRS has to follow the law, if there is no law then the IRS is breaking the law. That's pretty cut and dry and hardly semantical.


1. Join an activist group and push reforms.
I am a member of the Tax Honesty Movement but the IRS refuses to address our redress for grevences assured to us in the Constitution. At one time they agreed to answer questions but required that we send them the questions 2 weeks in advance. When they recieved the questions they cancelled the meeting. How is that for Government accountability and assurances for redress of grevences?
2. Live on a commune here or abroad, and don't worry about it. Then you will be trading your labor for your livelihood.
Because I am an American with a voice that I am going to use. It is such ignorance for people to say that if you don't like America then leave it when the ideals we were founded on were based on dessent and governence by the people. If Americans don't like America they shouldn't leave they should fight here for what they believe in. You are talking like a communist.

3. Stop paying taxes and go to jail.
I am afraid my taxes that I pay are completely legal since I own my own business. My profits from business activity is clearly defined in law, what is not is my employees wages being taxed under no law. If it existed someone would have posted by now, so where is it? What is the law? You don't know and the IRS isn't telling us.
 
Wrong. It specifically enumerates some examples, but it also explicitly states that those are examples, but not an exhaustive list.
Right, list the examples that are constitutional but leave out the ones that are not. Are you aware of the Constitution and how it states that taxes must be apportioned or indirect? Which is the income tax?

"All income from whatever source derived including (but not limited to) the following items"
Still does not define income, as the Supreme Court did in the example above.
And you are greatly mistaken in how you interpret your court cases....
enlighten me, because I can get into the actual wording if you want. What have you got?
 
This splitting of hairs is simply philosophy. If you feel this way philosophically, fine. It's still not the legal definition. It sounds like you should be living on a Kibbutz.

Nothing to do with philosophy everything to do with law. My argument is not philosophical in the least. For the last time shom me the law that requires laborers to pay taxes. You can't do it and that is the problem.

Once again I am an American with the right to have my grievences redressed. Just because I dessent does not mean that I should leave the country. That is what people say when they don't have a real argument.
 
Without Rights,

As noted above by Anti-sophist, while your interpretation of the legal issues may be interesting -- in a snap-shot into the mind of a CTist sort of way -- it is ultimately without basis in the legal system as the institution charged with interpreting the Constitution and federal law have ruled again and again.

In fact, also posted above was a FAQ on tax "protesters" which specifically addresses the claim you seem to be making here that wages are not income:

http://evans-legal.com/dan/tpfaq.html#wagesincome

I especially enjoyed this judicial quotation from that link:

Although not raised in his brief on appeal, the defendant's entire case at trial rested on his claim that he in good faith believed that wages are not income for taxation purposes. Whatever his mental state, he, of course, was wrong, as all of us are already aware. Nontheless, the defendant still insists that no case holds that wages are income. Let us now put that to rest: WAGES ARE INCOME. Any reading of tax cases by would-be tax protesters now should preclude a claim of good-faith belief that wages--or salaries--are not taxable." United States v. Koliboski, 732 F.2d 1328, 1329 n.1 (7th Cir. 1984), (emphasis in original; convictions for criminal failures to file affirmed).

ETA: Here is the reponse to the argument that "nothing requires individuals to pay taxes" as you've requested:

http://evans-legal.com/dan/tpfaq.html#liable
 
Last edited:
Don't know what your reference to OP is but whatever. The point to my argument is that if there is no law requiring tax on labor then we have a giant issue in America that needs discussion in major media.



reiterate. I fail to see semantics. This is a issue of law, the IRS has to follow the law, if there is no law then the IRS is breaking the law. That's pretty cut and dry and hardly semantical.



I am a member of the Tax Honesty Movement but the IRS refuses to address our redress for grevences assured to us in the Constitution. At one time they agreed to answer questions but required that we send them the questions 2 weeks in advance. When they recieved the questions they cancelled the meeting. How is that for Government accountability and assurances for redress of grevences?

Because I am an American with a voice that I am going to use. It is such ignorance for people to say that if you don't like America then leave it when the ideals we were founded on were based on dessent and governence by the people. If Americans don't like America they shouldn't leave they should fight here for what they believe in. You are talking like a communist.


I am afraid my taxes that I pay are completely legal since I own my own business. My profits from business activity is clearly defined in law, what is not is my employees wages being taxed under no law. If it existed someone would have posted by now, so where is it? What is the law? You don't know and the IRS isn't telling us.

BWHAHAHAHAHA. I'm talking like a communist. I'm quite a libertarian (philosophically, not a member of the party), actually, and I not only symathize with tax reform groups, I occasionally volunteer for them.

Your CT stripes are showing.
 
Without Rights,

As noted above by Anti-sophist, while your interpretation of the legal issues may be interesting -- in a snap-shot into the mind of a CTist sort of way -- it is ultimately without basis in the legal system as the institution charged with interpreting the Constitution and federal law have ruled again and again.

In fact, also posted above was a FAQ on tax "protesters" which specifically addresses the claim you seem to be making here that wages are not income:

http://evans-legal.com/dan/tpfaq.html#wagesincome

I especially enjoyed this judicial quotation from that link:

That pretty much puts the issue to bed.
 
I think my IQ just dropped about 40 points after wading through this thread. Tax protestors in the US are some of the worst CT nuts alive.

CPAs, tax lawyers, and tax court judges, administrative and judicial, have all heard these arguments many times before. Yawn.

What's sad is that there has been in recent years quite a cottage industry built around convincing people of some wealth that they can get around their legal obligation to pay income taxes by engaging in a series of twisted transactions in a misguided attempt to assign their income to some other entity they control. Not only does it not work as a legitimate means of escaping tax liability, but it can lead to criminal charges of tax fraud and land one in prison. Typical come ons for these scams promise seminars in the Bahamas or other Caribbean resort destination. Slick hucksters go to work on their marks there, and usually sign up a healthy percentage of attendees. Unfortunately, I have seen the results of their hucksterism. It ain't pretty.

As always, if it sounds too good to be true (live a life of luxury without ever paying another penny of income taxes!), it almost certainly is.

AS

So does that leave you with an IQ of 0?

Show me the law genius, where is the law? It is easy to call people CT's and nuts without one shred of proof, it shows intelligence when you can actually back up your ad hominem retoric with facts. So where is it. Site the law. What chapter? What section? Are we not a nation of law or can the IRS do what they want without a law? Why wont the IRS debate this openly? Why are ex-IRS agents saying it is a fraud? Do you have any talking points to add to the debater or are you here just to give an opinion based on nothing but hot air?
 
Nothing to do with philosophy everything to do with law. My argument is not philosophical in the least. For the last time shom me the law that requires laborers to pay taxes. You can't do it and that is the problem.

Once again I am an American with the right to have my grievences redressed. Just because I dessent does not mean that I should leave the country. That is what people say when they don't have a real argument.

I wasn't telling you to leave if you don't like it. I should have been more clear by saying "commune" not kibbutz.

If your argument isn't based in fact or truth, then the most polite conclusion is that it's very much a philosophical argument.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom