[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

Fine I will explain.

Theres income. Income is the gains derived from business; revenues minus costs is income as defined by the constitution.

The 16th amendment allowed the government to levy taxes on all forms of income, which it already had the power to do.

Wages and Salaries are not income, because when you trade labor for money you're trading 100 dollars of labor (1 hour) for 100 dollars of currency. When your labor becomes more valuable you get a raise, or maybe you have an easy job and your labor is less valuable.

If I make 100 dollars an hour and I work 8 hours I have 0 dollars of income, because my labor has value. So I spent 800 dollars of labor (cost) to gain 800 dollars of currency.

800 - 800 = 0

0 income.

But the tax is on the currency you are making in the process.
You are selling a product; your labor, You are recieving currency for that labor. The currency you are making in exchange for your labor is income. You are not exchanging labor for goods, you are exchanging it for currency.
The currency you are making in exchange for your labor is being taxed.
 
Last edited:
Indeed.

However there are none so deaf as those that stick their fingers in their ears and shout "la, la, la. I'm not listening"

Yea I know. I just comes down to not wanting to pay taxes. It's about the money not some lofty idealistic goal.
 
My labor is worthless? I guess I am a slave.

Even though the founding fathers talked about the "sacred agreement" between employer and employee where labor is TRADED for wage and/or salary

The employees input their labor and get their payout, there is no income. Assume a employee is paid 50 dollars for 50 dollars of labor.

50 - 50 = 0 dollars of income, for the employee

The business pays the employees 800 dollars for their labor, and that labor produces 2000 dollars of proffits for the company.

2000 - 800 = 1200 dollars of income, for the business

so the business must pay its income tax, on 1200 dollars of taxable income

but the employee has 0 dollars of taxable income

another 2 examples of how a business can produce income is a business buying items and selling them or using them.

Items original cost 2000 dollars, sold for 5000.

5000 - 2000 = 3000 dollars of income.

Or items original cost 2000 dollars, produced 7000 dollars of productivity.

7000 - 2000 = 5000 dollars of income.


I have taken college level accounting classes and there are many forms of cost proffit revenue expense analysis that you use to put together an income statement for a business to find its total taxable income. this is the easy to explain nutshell version.
How much money did you pay for your labor so that you could then resell it?
 
i didnt know there was a federal law, applying to all citizens in all 50 states, saying "all us citizens are required to pay the federal income tax"

if there is yeah i need to find that one too

Not hard to find. It's section ONE of the Internal Revenue Code.

"There is hereby imposed on the taxable income of [various categories] a tax determined in accordance with the following table: "

Implicit in the verb "imposed" is the idea that people in the named category are required to pay. There's no such thing as an optional tax.
 
i bolded it simply to imply that that was the major argument....

so... is it?

I trade 800 dollars of labor for 800 dollars.

800 - 800 = 0

income is defined as gains, and there is no gain here, so my wage is not a form of gain derived from compensation for services, meaning my wage is not a form of income derived from compensation for services,

This seems to be the crux or your argument. It's a very weak postion. As it relies on a very specific definition of income. All the courts have to do define income differently than you do and your argument evaporates.
Good luck in court using this argument.

Oh and salaries and wages are compensation for services. You are providing a service; labor. You are being compensated for those services with currency.
You have made an income of currency which was compensation for labor.
 
in·come (nkm)
n.
1. The amount of money or its equivalent received during a period of time in exchange for labor or services, from the sale of goods or property, or as profit from financial investments.

income n. money, goods or other economic benefit received. Under income tax laws, income can be "active" through one's efforts or work (including management), or "passive" from rentals, stock dividends, investments and interest on deposits in which there is neither physical effort nor management. For tax purposes, income does not include gifts and inheritances received. Taxes are collected based on income by the federal government and most state governments.

wage (wj)
n.
1. Payment for labor or services to a worker, especially remuneration on an hourly, daily, or weekly basis or by the piece.
2. wages Economics The portion of the national product that represents the aggregate paid for all contributing labor and services as distinguished from the portion retained by management or reinvested in capital goods.
3. (used with a sing. or pl. verb) A fitting return; a recompense. Often used in the plural with a singular or plural verb. the wages of sin.

sal·a·ry (sl-r, slr)
n. pl. sal·a·ries
Fixed compensation for services, paid to a person on a regular basis.

It's well established under Common Law rules that words that are not explicitly defined in the laws or contracts are to be read with their commonly understood meanings.

Just because you choose to use an idiosyncratic definition of income and wages doesn't mean the rest of us have to. So shut up and pay your taxes!
 
Not to be too pedantic but don't you mean tax on your INCOME?

Income is defined as profits gained from business activity. Labor is owned by the individual who performs the labor so it is a trade, labor for wages. There is no law requiring Americans to pay taxes on wages earned from labor.
 
Income is defined as profits gained from business activity. Labor is owned by the individual who performs the labor so it is a trade, labor for wages. There is no law requiring Americans to pay taxes on wages earned from labor.

What is the source for your definition?
 
Income is defined as profits gained from business activity.

This is specifically incorrect -- the legal definition of "income" has already been cited (I.R.C. section 61) and quoted, and it includes money derived from ALL sources, including salaries and wages.
 
Income is defined as profits gained from business activity. Labor is owned by the individual who performs the labor so it is a trade, labor for wages. There is no law requiring Americans to pay taxes on wages earned from labor.

That particular definition is applied to companies and corporations.
An individual is not a corporation or business firm. That leaves the interpretation of income to be applied differently to an individual.
 
if i had asked you guys "please debunk Freedom to Facism for me, uhh and be logical" you would have laughed and linked me to some debunk site that probably doesnt even include the REAL counter arguement that i have received from this thread and it probably just contains a bunch of little stupid ones.

NO. I wanted to use what i determined to be the best arguement from that film, and I wanted THAT to be countered. So I presented it over and over again untill anti-sophist understood what i was saying and he was able to explain to me and counter the arguement that i wanted to be countered and he explained how that arguement doesnt mean the tax is illegal.

Thats why this was effective, in my opinion. what i actually wanted to get countered, got countered in a way i could understand...

i guess i doesnt matter. OK I RLY NEED 2go SLEEP NOW COMPUTER SHUT DOWN

So you are a lying troll? Wow! I sure never saw that coming!! :rolleyes:

How are your stocks looking today troll? You may actually be closer to not paying any income taxes than you ever thought you'd be. What's Daddy Alex have to say 'bout this turn of events?? Conspiracy I'll bet....

-z
 
That particular definition is applied to companies and corporations.

Not even there. As a simple example, I believe that Microsoft has something like $40 billion dollars in cash reserves, and gets "income" from the interest. Even if it never sold another program, it would still derive "income" from its reserve portfolio.
 
This seems to be the crux or your argument. It's a very weak postion. As it relies on a very specific definition of income. All the courts have to do define income differently than you do and your argument evaporates.
Good luck in court using this argument.

Oh and salaries and wages are compensation for services. You are providing a service; labor. You are being compensated for those services with currency.
You have made an income of currency which was compensation for labor.

Well the argument is good enough for some jurys. Consider:
U.S. District Court, Western District of Tennessee (Memphis) # 03-CR-20111, USA v. Kuglin.
The argument is enough to exonerate
Vernice Kuglin of 6 counts of tax evasion based on the fact the prosecutors could not show a law that demanded taxation on wages earned through labor.

Or Joseph Banister, a former officer of the IRS who quit when he learned that the IRS was fraudulently charging taxes that were not backed by law.
Banister was taken into custody Nov. 19 by IRS agents and released on $25,000 bond after pleading not guilty.

A jury in the U.S. District Court in Sacramento found him not guilty on a charge of conspiracy and on all three counts of aiding and assisting the filing of false tax returns for a client. Banister is a CPA and member of the tax honesty movement and was telling clients they did not have to legally file. They let him off because they could not site a law that required tax on labor.

There is also a Million dollar challenge for anyone who can find a law requiring tax obn labor. Many have tried of course but no one has won, simply because there is no law.
 
The IRS says the tax on wages and salaries is absorbed into the national debt. Translation: it goes to the private banks of the federal reserve that we owe the national debt to.

Maybe you forget about the tax on income from business operation. That tax goes into our military mostly. The tax on wages and salaries goes into the national dept. IRS says this.
You're an accounting student and believe this crap? My accountancy profs always used to drill into our heads that a dollar is a dollar is a dollar - you can't allocate them in this way. It all goes into the same pot, so to speak, you can't take dollars out and say "this one came from a corporation, and this one came from an individual".

I shudder to think of what they're teraching you about allocated overhead expenses.
 
Well the argument is good enough for some jurys. Consider: U.S. District Court, Western District of Tennessee (Memphis) # 03-CR-20111, USA v. Kuglin.
The argument is enough to exonerate Vernice Kuglin of 6 counts of tax evasion based on the fact the prosecutors could not show a law that demanded taxation on wages earned through labor.
That is an interesting case, but the acquittal (which isn't the same as exoneration) was not for the nonsense you state. Also, the decision did not address whether Ms. Kuglin still owed taxes.

The jury found that "[t]he government failed to prove that Ms. Kuglin was wrong in her assumption that the tax didn't apply to her or that she had reason to know that her position was wrong." (reference)
 
oahuoahu,

How goes the reading of the US Constitution? Many of us still anxiously await you showing us where, exactly, it defines 'income.'
 
What is the source for your definition?

The income tax does not meet either criteria of Constitutionally legal taxation in America, that is direct apportioned tax or indirect uniform tax. The IRS claims that the 16th Amendment allowed for a third form of taxation, however, the supreme court ruling on the amendment states that it allows for no new forms of taxation. More supreme court cases in the same period confirm the same conclusion. The 16th Amendment did not allow the Federal Government to levy a new tax. The Supreme Court said before the 16th amendment was ratified that there was no law requiring tax on labor and they also said the 16th amendment doesn't allow for new forms of taxation. So if it is not apportioned or indirect uniform then it is unconstitutional, the income tax does not meet any of those standards as it is unapportioned direct which is unconstitutional and the supreme court sais so.
 
The income tax does not meet either criteria of Constitutionally legal taxation in America, that is direct apportioned tax or indirect uniform tax. The IRS claims that the 16th Amendment allowed for a third form of taxation, however, the supreme court ruling on the amendment states that it allows for no new forms of taxation. More supreme court cases in the same period confirm the same conclusion. The 16th Amendment did not allow the Federal Government to levy a new tax. The Supreme Court said before the 16th amendment was ratified that there was no law requiring tax on labor and they also said the 16th amendment doesn't allow for new forms of taxation. So if it is not apportioned or indirect uniform then it is unconstitutional, the income tax does not meet any of those standards as it is unapportioned direct which is unconstitutional and the supreme court sais so.
Which Supreme Court decision would that be? And can you cite the specific language in the decision that supports your analysis?
 
Not even there. As a simple example, I believe that Microsoft has something like $40 billion dollars in cash reserves, and gets "income" from the interest. Even if it never sold another program, it would still derive "income" from its reserve portfolio.
They had $6.7 billion in cash and equivalents, and an additional $27.5 billion in short-term investments for 2006.

Source.

Had to look that up because you made it sound like they just had $40 billion sitting in a bank somewhere. :p
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom