Easy solution to the pirate problem...

I get the feeling the people here who claim the speedboats would be near impossible to hit have never fired a gun in their lives.

Geez, what about trap or skeet shooting? Impossible!
 
I get the feeling the people here who claim the speedboats would be near impossible to hit have never fired a gun in their lives.

Geez, what about trap or skeet shooting? Impossible!
Most of 'em not only haven't held on--they actively hate the fact that ANYBODY would want to own one.
 
This is what most people have come to. If your life is in danger, beg for mercy, and hope the government shows up in time to save you. By no means should you ever attempt to resist being harmed, because the safety of your attackers is paramount. You wouldn't want to hurt them would you?
 
The Rangers killed about 100 Somalis for every one they lost, the pirates would fare even worse with no place to find cover.
Nit picking here a bit, I don't think it is fair to say the Rangers killed that many. I suspect most of the Somali deaths were from air support.
 
I'm talking about small arms, not AA guns.

Wasn't common to lose planes to small arms but a lot were shot at.

*WWI machine guns weren't well equipped to fire at targets in the sky, probably only capable of firing a few degrees above the horizon actually.

That news would come as something of a shock to Cedric Popkin (generaly considered the most likely candidate to have killed the red baron) who was an AA machine gunner. Most of the other popular candidates were machine gunners.

A speedboat isn't a particularly difficult target to hit. Especially since it's far easier to judge distance to a target in the water as opposed to one in the air.

Evidences? Speedboats have been involved in various naval engaments and were never an easy target. Fortunately the K-Verband boats tended to explode after missing their targets but the italian ones managed to cause problems.

Heh this was used for 6 pounder practice by costal defence gunners in the 1940s. It generaly managed to avoid being hit (top speed 20 knotts):
 

Attachments

  • queen gull.jpg
    queen gull.jpg
    29.6 KB · Views: 6
Has anyone here ever shot at a small boat from an elevated position? I do not think it is as easy as some here are saying. It is not enough to put a small hole in the hull. The engine or the persons driving the boat need to be incapacitated. While hitting the target with a shotgun would be less difficult, there is the problem of shot size, pattern and distance. #7 shot will be easier to hit with, but hardly the choice to damage anything that is tougher than a small bird or clay pigeon. Buck shot is more lethal, but at anything other than short range, the sparse shot pattern will make a solid hit less likely.

A mounted 30 or 50 caliber machine gun, or better yet, a grenade launcher, would be very intimidating. I do not think the smaller merchant ships are going to do this unless a company executive is aboard. :)

Ranb
 
Has anyone here ever shot at a small boat from an elevated position? I do not think it is as easy as some here are saying. It is not enough to put a small hole in the hull. The engine or the persons driving the boat need to be incapacitated. While hitting the target with a shotgun would be less difficult, there is the problem of shot size, pattern and distance. #7 shot will be easier to hit with, but hardly the choice to damage anything that is tougher than a small bird or clay pigeon. Buck shot is more lethal, but at anything other than short range, the sparse shot pattern will make a solid hit less likely.

A mounted 30 or 50 caliber machine gun, or better yet, a grenade launcher, would be very intimidating. I do not think the smaller merchant ships are going to do this unless a company executive is aboard. :)

Ranb

I am not referring to taking the boat itself out, but the passengers on board. Accurate fire placed even in the direction of the boat would be VERY likely to deter the pirates seeing as how they would have absolutely no cover. Then on top of that they would have to somehow scale the side of the ship in the most vulnerable position you could possible be in.
 
Nit picking here a bit, I don't think it is fair to say the Rangers killed that many. I suspect most of the Somali deaths were from air support.

Actually the ground troops quite probably did have a 100:1 kill ratio.

18 US servicemen were killed, while estimated Somali losses are about 7,000. That's a ratio of 388:1. Even if the Little Bird and Black Hawk crews killed 3/4 of the enemy, that would still give the ground forces a better than 100:1 kill ratio.

(That's a higher ratio than the Greeks at Thermopylae)
 
I think aircraft piracy is probably a good example to look at for a comparison.

Prior to 9/11 being a hostage of aircraft hijackers was relatively safe, if by safe you mean "unlikely to die". You had more chance of being killed by your rescucers than by your captors.

As a result people tended pretty much to comply with aircraft pirates and do what they said, offering no resistance. Crews were trained to cooperate.

All of that changed after 9/11 for some reason.

Now aircraft piracy is substantially more dangerous to the would-be pirate than it is to any of the passengers or crew, and crew are trained to actively resist pirates.

The end result is a sharp decline in aircraft piracy.
 
I am not referring to taking the boat itself out, but the passengers on board. Accurate fire placed even in the direction of the boat would be VERY likely to deter the pirates seeing as how they would have absolutely no cover. Then on top of that they would have to somehow scale the side of the ship in the most vulnerable position you could possible be in.

While the ladder climbers are vulnerable, so is anyone leaning over the side of the ship to snipe at them. The other pirates in the speed boat surely will be providing some cover fire, although if they are spraying and praying from a little rocking and rolling boat, they are not likely to hit anything but hull and air either.

Ranb
 
I get the feeling the people here who claim the speedboats would be near impossible to hit have never fired a gun in their lives.

Geez, what about trap or skeet shooting? Impossible!


When I was a kid, I used to shoot discarded glass beer bottles my friends would throw out of the air with a .22 rifle.

Impossble. But I did it.
 
When I was a kid, I used to shoot discarded glass beer bottles my friends would throw out of the air with a .22 rifle.

Impossble. But I did it.


You can do that at 900 meters while dodging the incoming RPG?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom