Easy solution to the pirate problem...

You can do that at 900 meters while dodging the incoming RPG?

Well RPGs are actually pretty easy to dodge. They don't exactly travel fast. It would take an RPG-7 about 8 seconds to reach its absolute maximum range of 920m.

I feel confident I could dodge that, frankly.


ETA. According to the US Army the hit probability of an RPG-7 at 500m is only 4% for a slow-moving 7.5' x 15' target.
 
Last edited:
What air support?

There were little birds and thats about it.
You gotta be kidding me. Apparently your military training included zero military history. From the wiki, as just a start:

Early the next morning, a combined task force was sent to rescue the trapped soldiers. It contained soldiers from Pakistan, Malaysia, and the U.S. 10th Mountain Division. They assembled some 100 vehicles, including Pakistani tanks (M48s) and Malaysian Condor armored personnel carriers, and were supported by U.S. A/MH-6 Little Bird, and UH-60 Black Hawk helicopters.
My emphasis.
 
Actually the ground troops quite probably did have a 100:1 kill ratio.

18 US servicemen were killed, while estimated Somali losses are about 7,000. That's a ratio of 388:1. Even if the Little Bird and Black Hawk crews killed 3/4 of the enemy, that would still give the ground forces a better than 100:1 kill ratio.
Now that's a reasonable reply and I'll accept your conclusion at face value. That said, where did the 7,000 come from and how reliable do you think it is?
 
Last edited:
Wow. I go to sleep for one night and look what happens.

And I can't stand the coward culture who refuses to defend themselves and let the criminals win.
He who fights and runs away lives to fight another day.

Actually, I'd refine that. He who fights and runs away lives.

Hmm. Could be better.

He who runs away lives.

That's it.
 
Now that's a reasonable reply and I'll accept your conclusion at face value. That said, where did the 7,000 come from and how reliable do you think it is?

There's a variety of different estimates, ranging from 133 killed (the SNA's own estimate) up to over 10,000 killed.

I just checked again and I made a mistake however, the ~7,000 figure was a US casualty estimate, not estimate for those killed, and even that seems to have been reduced; US estimates are apparently at 1,000 to 1,500 killed and 3,000 to 4,000 wounded.

Of all the estimates, honestly I suspect the US one would be the most accurate.
 
*sigh*. Way to miss the point.

Shooting pirates does not, in any way, address the cause of piracy. Until the socioeconomic problems in Somalia are addressed, there'll just be more pirates. And as a disincentive? Like I said - it worked SO well in Iraq, didn't it? You shoot a Somali, that Somali's brother or cousin or uncle or wife now has another reason to be angry. Who do you think they'll take that anger out on?

I read things like and it makes me wonder if people really think that piracy is a problem that has never been faced before, and that international law did not, at one point in time, have methods for dealing with piracy.

England almost single handedly stopped piracy in the Atlantic a couple of centuries back, and they did so by using the cannon and the noose. When the risks became too great, people stopped trying to pirate merchant ships.

All that pap about "socioeconomic problems: is exactly that: pap. There is a reason that pirates operate out of Somalia ($600 gdp/capita) and not Eritrea ($800 gdp/capita), and it has little to do with "socioeconomic problems".
 
Well RPGs are actually pretty easy to dodge. They don't exactly travel fast. It would take an RPG-7 about 8 seconds to reach its absolute maximum range of 920m.

I feel confident I could dodge that, frankly.


ETA. According to the US Army the hit probability of an RPG-7 at 500m is only 4% for a slow-moving 7.5' x 15' target.

920m is where the RPG is designed to explode sending out anti-personnel shrapnel over a 10 meter lethal radius. You could probably still get out of the way and only get wounded (assuming you didn't run the wrong way).

You can play dodge-ball with RPG's if you want. But I personally would prefer not to get into that situation.
 
920m is where the RPG is designed to explode sending out anti-personnel shrapnel over a 10 meter lethal radius.

Um, no. 920 is the absolute maximum range of the RPG, at which it self detonates. They're designed to explode on impact, and effective range is about 50 - 100m. At 920m your odds of hitting your target would be practically nil.


You could probably still get out of the way and only get wounded (assuming you didn't run the wrong way).

I don't know about you, but I can pretty comfortably run 60m in 8 seconds. That's ample time to get behind something that will protect me from the RPG.


You can play dodge-ball with RPG's if you want. But I personally would prefer not to get into that situation.

Well piracy is a major problem in the film industry, but they don't normally have RPG-7s so I'm unlikely to ever need to worry about being in that situation.
 
Heh this was used for 6 pounder practice by costal defence gunners in the 1940s. It generaly managed to avoid being hit (top speed 20 knotts):
We're talking about a rifle at 500 meters and less, not a 6 pounder at 10k.

And as has already been pointed out to you the Liberty Sun managed to keep the pirates off using a water cannon, what's the range of that? 50 meters? And they did this while being shot at with RPGs and automatic rifles.
 
Last edited:
You can do that at 900 meters while dodging the incoming RPG?


900 meters? No.

Could I put enough rounds on target to make the pirates think twice about boarding my ship? You bet your ass I could. And that's what it's all about. One need not kill every single pirate. Just score enough hits on them and their boats to convince them there are other easier targets out there.

It's interesting to me how the anti-self-defense folks in this thread poo-poo the idea that merchant crews could possibly handle a weapon but seem convinced the pirates are some elite para-military force able and willing to withstand a hail of gunfire to achieve their mission. They're not. They're just a bunch of thugs and opportunists. I'm quite confident a couple of rounds into their approaching boat would be all that's needed to convince them they don't want to have anything to do with a ship that shoots back. Especially when there are apparently so many other ships and crews willing to roll over and put their trust in the inherent goodness of their fellow man.
 
It's interesting to me how the anti-self-defense folks in this thread poo-poo the idea that merchant crews could possibly handle a weapon but seem convinced the pirates are some elite para-military force able and willing to withstand a hail of gunfire to achieve their mission. They're not. They're just a bunch of thugs and opportunists. I'm quite confident a couple of rounds into their approaching boat would be all that's needed to convince them they don't want to have anything to do with a ship that shoots back. Especially when there are apparently so many other ships and crews willing to roll over and put their trust in the inherent goodness of their fellow man.
Exactly.
 
I'm still failing to see how self-defence is an "easy solution to the pirate problem". Sure, carry a firearm if you like, and shoot the face off someone you think looks threatening. As a solution that's temporary at best, and may even exacerbate the problem. It's certainly not an "easy solution to the pirate problem" as claimed in the OP.
 
[Why] don't the crews of ships ARM THEMSELVES???

Probably because a lot of the foreign trawlers are there illegally and don't want any additional attention drawn upon themselves. Assuming you're an American, exactly how comfortable would you be with a missile and torpedo equipped foreign container ship docking at San Diego?
 
I read things like and it makes me wonder if people really think that piracy is a problem that has never been faced before, and that international law did not, at one point in time, have methods for dealing with piracy.

England almost single handedly stopped piracy in the Atlantic a couple of centuries back, and they did so by using the cannon and the noose. When the risks became too great, people stopped trying to pirate merchant ships.

All that pap about "socioeconomic problems: is exactly that: pap. There is a reason that pirates operate out of Somalia ($600 gdp/capita) and not Eritrea ($800 gdp/capita), and it has little to do with "socioeconomic problems".

Ha! I guess you forgot that part about the British strategy called "pay the buy-able pirates to help kill the un-buy-able ones." Funny thing is, Ron Paul is advocating that racket: hire privateers to fight the pirates, let the military mop up. I don't agree that's a good idea.

But, for S&G's, let's say we use private or military guys to mop the hell out of the pirates. Considering there's a whole province in Somalia run by criminal organizations, are we going to stick around when they step in to take over the pirate rings? Or do we take it to ground?
 
I'm still failing to see how self-defence is an "easy solution to the pirate problem". Sure, carry a firearm if you like, and shoot the face off someone you think looks threatening. As a solution that's temporary at best, and may even exacerbate the problem. It's certainly not an "easy solution to the pirate problem" as claimed in the OP.

What you're witnessing here is a manifestly unique American solution to any problem. Piracy getting you down? Get a gun. Broken window in your apartment block? Get a gun. Cut off in traffic? Get a gun. Offended by your neighbour's dog pooping on your lawn? Get a gun. Jehovah's Witnesses bothering you on Saturday morning? Get a gun.

It's all in self-defence, of course, and the JREF poster who said he can drive any way he wants since buying vanity plates saying "GUN NUT" for his 4x4 is definitely *not* aggressive or irrational.

I have participated on a different thread about the escalation of piracy linking it directly to the hundreds of IUUs operating in unpatrolled Somali fishing zones. The numbers vary, but anywhere from an estimated $300 million to $450 million in revenues are stolen annually from the Somali economy.

Why not go after those pirates first?
 
I just read that the HMCS Winnipeg chased off a pirate boat by firing a few warning shots at it. The pirates ran away, so the navy sent out a boarding crew, tracked them down, arrested them, then promptly realeased them because they had no other option. What a world.
 
Yes, I think the best solution to any problem is hide under the bed and hope that the authorities will help you, and if they don't get there in time, beg for mercy from your attacker.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom