Easy solution to the pirate problem...

What you're witnessing here is a manifestly unique American solution to any problem. Piracy getting you down? Get a gun. Broken window in your apartment block? Get a gun. Cut off in traffic? Get a gun. Offended by your neighbour's dog pooping on your lawn? Get a gun. Jehovah's Witnesses bothering you on Saturday morning? Get a gun.


I don't think this is entirely fair. As was pointed out by others, England was very aggressive with pirates and it certainly was effective.

I think this thing may come down to who you see on the pirate boats.

I think some see them as poor, desperate people who are driven to do this sort of thing to survive and feed themselves, etc. And others see them as cowardly goons with weapons who hope to intimidate people into immediate submission, are not really looking for a "real fight", and are taking advantage of how easy it easy to get away with it all.

There is probably a bit of both, but I'm inclined to think it's more of the latter. The only real solution to bullies is to stand up to them. Not to placate them.
 
Last edited:
I just read that the HMCS Winnipeg chased off a pirate boat by firing a few warning shots at it. The pirates ran away, so the navy sent out a boarding crew, tracked them down, arrested them, then promptly realeased them because they had no other option. What a world.

Wait a second. They operated strictly within the parameters of their ROE in the Gulf of Aden. (You may not know that the Winnipeg has served in the Middle East continually since 1991).

They forced the pirates to discard all their weapons and unless they have gills they're lost pretty much forever.

This is actually literally yesterday's news because it happened yesterday. They launched the on-board heli that fired warning shots to "encourage" the pirates to give up.

I know it's great to kill a lot of people in "self-defence" but what the Winnipeg did was exemplary.
 
I don't think this is entirely fair. As was pointed out by others, England was very aggressive with pirates and it certainly was effective.

Huh? England was the number one pirate nation for almost two centuries until they established a regular naval force. Drake had a freakin' government licence to engage in it and keep a large share of the booty.

Or is this a metaphorical England you're all discussing?
 
Huh? England was the number one pirate nation for almost two centuries until they established a regular naval force. Drake had a freakin' government licence to engage in it and keep a large share of the booty.


I'm glad you made this point, I was waiting for someone to do it. I don't know why, but it seems Americans have an astoundingly bad grasp of history, particularly when it comes to this matter. I've often seen Drake described as a privateer, and even as a pirate - not just by random people but in authoritative sources.

Fact is he was neither.

Drake was a commissioned officer in the Royal Navy (or Navy Royal as it was then known). He was at war. He was not a privateer, and not a pirate. Funnily enough this was true of many of the so-called "Pirates" of that era.

It was full scale warfare, with unrestricted warfare against marine shipping - the same thing that happened in WW2.
 
Didn't Drake sail the Golden Hind on a privately funded expedition with letters of marque? Wouldn't this make him a privateer?

Ranb
 
Wait a second. They operated strictly within the parameters of their ROE in the Gulf of Aden. (You may not know that the Winnipeg has served in the Middle East continually since 1991).

They forced the pirates to discard all their weapons and unless they have gills they're lost pretty much forever.

This is actually literally yesterday's news because it happened yesterday. They launched the on-board heli that fired warning shots to "encourage" the pirates to give up.

I know it's great to kill a lot of people in "self-defence" but what the Winnipeg did was exemplary.



Yes, they did exactly what they were supposed to do. They did everything they were allowed to.

Are you under the impression that the pirates have now been shamed and will go find real jobs? Do you think that they will be unable to acquire new rifles and grenade launchers? Or steal a new boat?

I'm not saying that they should have been killed after surrendering, but I do wish they could have been charged under some statute, and incarcerated, or something. What good is done by letting them go? There having a good laugh about it right now, I'll wager. ("Ha! Those cowardly foreigners! They let us go! I'd have killed them if the tables were turned!")
 
There having a good laugh about it right now, I'll wager. ("Ha! Those cowardly foreigners! They let us go! I'd have killed them if the tables were turned!")

Now where did I hear something along that line? Perhaps: "They let us go. It was the only reason for the ease of our escape."
 
Didn't Drake sail the Golden Hind on a privately funded expedition with letters of marque? Wouldn't this make him a privateer?

Ranb


He was an officer of the royal navy at the time. He was given his commission in 1572 and his voyage in the Pelican (renamed Golden Hind) was in 1577.

Bear in mind that the navy didn't function at that time the same way it does now. Individuals were given royal warrants as officers, but might not necessarily be serving on a ship paid for by the crown (which would bear "HMS").

Joint ventures were also very much the norm, and remained so for a very long time; take James Cook's voyages; he irrefutably conducted them as an officer of the Royal Navy, on board Royal Navy vessels, yet his first voyage on Endeavour was on behalf of the Royal Society and initially they wanted a civilian to command the vessel, however the First Lord of the Admiralty famously said he would rather cut off his right arm than give command of a naval vessel to someone not trained in seamanship. Further, Joseph Banks - the Royal Society patron who was to go on the voyage, initially planned to fund extravagant modifications to the ship until the navy convinced him they would affect the vessel's stability.

Back to our pirates; bear in mind that many of these "pirates" were knights or lords - you have to remember the feudal system was still very much in effect and knights and lords were required to provide military forces to the crown, constituting the national army. Thus a knight might pay for a ship and a crew to wage war on Spain, on the monarch's behalf, and they're not actually a privateer at all, but the equivalent of a modern warship.

A fealty-sworn lord or knight, or a commissioned officer of the crown, was obliged to battle the monarch's enemies "wherever he may find them".
 
Last edited:
Here's a question. What happens if the pirates kill one of their hostages and then surrender? Will they still be released? They can't try them for any sort of armed robbery or kidnapping, would murder change how they're dealt with?
 
Here's a question. What happens if the pirates kill one of their hostages and then surrender? Will they still be released? They can't try them for any sort of armed robbery or kidnapping, would murder change how they're dealt with?

The "we can't try them" argument is actually garbage. Universal Jurisdiction is one of the points of extra-territorial jurisdiction - it holds that some crimes are so bad that any state can prosecute anyone, anywhere.

Piracy is included in this, and any navy in the world can capture pirates on the high seas and prosecute them for piracy, kidnapping, murder, and so forth.
 
More importantly, the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea explicitly states that any state can seize a pirate ship on the high seas, arrest the pirates, and prosecute them however it sees fit.

In fact, the convention makes it a duty for every state to help suppress piracy.
 
The "we can't try them" argument is actually garbage. Universal Jurisdiction is one of the points of extra-territorial jurisdiction - it holds that some crimes are so bad that any state can prosecute anyone, anywhere.

Piracy is included in this, and any navy in the world can capture pirates on the high seas and prosecute them for piracy, kidnapping, murder, and so forth.

You are wrong - the argument "we can't try them" is exactly the problem many of the countries helping to patrol that area face, see http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4636612#post4636612
 
You gotta be kidding me. Apparently your military training included zero military history. From the wiki, as just a start:


My emphasis.

Oh my SINCERE apologies for forgetting to mention the blackhawks. Lol.

This is from the same Wiki article though:
Repeated attempts by the Somalis to mass forces and overrun the American positions in a series of firefights near the crash sites were neutralized by aggressive small arms fire and by strafing and rocket attacks from AH-6J Little Bird helicopter gunships of the Nightstalkers, the only air support equipped to operate at night. The Somali National Alliance militia casualties were reported as 700 killed and about 1000 wounded. However, an eyewitness to the battle says the recovery parties for the SNA dead in the vicinity of the Olympic Hotel would indicate about 60.[17]

I was referring to the nighttime portion of it because that is when the majority of the battle took place and the little birds were the only ones with pilots able to fly at night. Read before you post.
 
Last edited:
WTF are you talking about? Are you reffering to the "Black Hawk Down" incident where 18 Americans died and over a 1000 Somali militia were killed? Umm take a look at the numbers buddy.

And the numbers are not about who won the battle. Just like we won vietnam because we killed more of them than they did of us.
 
Actually the ground troops quite probably did have a 100:1 kill ratio.

18 US servicemen were killed, while estimated Somali losses are about 7,000. That's a ratio of 388:1. Even if the Little Bird and Black Hawk crews killed 3/4 of the enemy, that would still give the ground forces a better than 100:1 kill ratio.

(That's a higher ratio than the Greeks at Thermopylae)

And we see again how easy it is to drive off Somali forces, just shoot a couple thousand and they all run for cover.
 
I think aircraft piracy is probably a good example to look at for a comparison.

Prior to 9/11 being a hostage of aircraft hijackers was relatively safe, if by safe you mean "unlikely to die". You had more chance of being killed by your rescucers than by your captors.

As a result people tended pretty much to comply with aircraft pirates and do what they said, offering no resistance. Crews were trained to cooperate.

All of that changed after 9/11 for some reason.

Now aircraft piracy is substantially more dangerous to the would-be pirate than it is to any of the passengers or crew, and crew are trained to actively resist pirates.

The end result is a sharp decline in aircraft piracy.

See this was a problem, eveyone in the past was pussies, they should have all had the balls to fight.
 
Ha! I guess you forgot that part about the British strategy called "pay the buy-able pirates to help kill the un-buy-able ones." Funny thing is, Ron Paul is advocating that racket: hire privateers to fight the pirates, let the military mop up. I don't agree that's a good idea.

This isn't about facts, bribary is unmanly and must have played no roll in that.
 
i just read that the hmcs winnipeg chased off a pirate boat by firing a few warning shots at it. The pirates ran away, so the navy sent out a boarding crew, tracked them down, arrested them, then promptly realeased them because they had no other option. What a world.

The rule of law sucks.
 
Yes, I think the best solution to any problem is hide under the bed and hope that the authorities will help you, and if they don't get there in time, beg for mercy from your attacker.

Here is your problem. There is no best solution to any problem, you need to evaluate the problem and look at the solutions. But you are treating guns and the solution to any problem.
 
Wait a second. They operated strictly within the parameters of their ROE in the Gulf of Aden. (You may not know that the Winnipeg has served in the Middle East continually since 1991).

They forced the pirates to discard all their weapons and unless they have gills they're lost pretty much forever.

And in somalia it is supposted to be difficult for them to get new guns?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom