Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Not following here. You take casualties in war and you don't surrender to the enemy if you have a means to fight. Whats so hard to understand?
I find this to be moving the goalposts. You clearly said and meant 'never'. Which means no surrender under any circumstance.

No where did I ever say that I would love for my men to go down in a blaze of glory. But you can bet your ass we would do everything in our power to defend the ship.
Also your solution was so impractical that I had to come to my conclusion.


Well if you actually meant to say that your short statement meant to include a specific set of circumstances I wouldn't have found it to be so careless. And we wouldn't likely have this heated discussion right now.
 
Last edited:
I find this to be moving the goalposts. You clearly said and meant 'never'. Which means no surrender under any circumstance.

Also your solution was so impractical that I had to come to my conclusion.


Well if you actually meant to say that your short statement meant to include a specific set of circumstances I wouldn't have found it to be so careless. And we wouldn't likely have this heated discussion right now.

I can't envision surrendering unless I was surrounded by hoards of pirates or something and was completely out of ammunition and no other means of defending myself. Of course we could make up circumstances, but the instances in which I would surrender would be rare.

I don't think arming crews of ships or just having an arms room is impractical whatsoever.
 
No evidence that hight helps you against small craft. And the example I was useing was the testing not the actual attack.
I have no ideas of the details of this test you keep referring to.

However, ground fire took out qute a few airplanes in WWII which I'd guess are a bit harder to hit than a speedboat.

Hell, a single shot from a Canadian soldier armed with a bolt-action rifle took out the Red Baron in WWI. And even a WWI triplane moves faster than the pirate's speedboats, and they operate in 3 dimensions.
 
I can't envision surrendering unless I was surrounded by hoards of pirates or something and was completely out of ammunition and no other means of defending myself. Of course we could make up circumstances, but the instances in which I would surrender would be rare.
You can still be surprised (commercial radar isn't that good) or even poisoned by a bribed cook. Don't expect ample time to prepare or even a 'honest' gun fight.

I don't think arming crews of ships or just having an arms room is impractical whatsoever.
We have already given multiple reasons why it is impractical way to combat this problem:
1. Its expensive to add an 24hour watch to the crew for all those ships.
2. They need to be added to all the ships or the problem will only move.
3. Gun accidents will happen.
4. Pirates/criminals can simply change tactics and might even try to simply infiltrate the ships and take over the armory.
 
I have no ideas of the details of this test you keep referring to.

You should the middle east is where a lot of the more realistic data on naval warfare comes from.

However, ground fire took out qute a few airplanes in WWII which I'd guess are a bit harder to hit than a speedboat.

Things like the QF 3.7 inch AA gun fire projectiles with a significant area of effect and they were used in batteries. And they were still not very good at shooting down planes. Sure if you are prepared to start mounting cannon on your merchant ships you can have an impact but that is seriously expensive.


Hell, a single shot from a Canadian soldier armed with a bolt-action rifle took out the Red Baron in WWI. And even a WWI triplane moves faster than the pirate's speedboats, and they operate in 3 dimensions.

The Red Baron was being fired at by multiple people whith machine guns (as well as the guy chaseing him). Out of all those shots exactly one hit him.
 
It's not questionable once you read what the pirates themselves have said about it.

And no other attacks have involved the firepower they attacked the Liberty Sun with.

And I fail to see how things could be worse if they had guns to shoot back with, instead of the water cannon they were limited to.

So we just need to keep this escalating? That is the manly thing to do I guess.

I see the US occupying three nations in the future.
 
Reading comprehension is NOT your strong suite, is it?
Quad was talking about HIS GUYS. Not Merchant Marines.
Please try to keep up, m'kay?

His sailors in the Army. He failed reading comprehension so many times, maybe he really is an officer.

Or are you now having the army operate all commercial shipping?
 
I've seen no stupidity from him, only the courage of his convictions.

Maybe you should also go on a rant about the SEALs who took out the three pirates last week?

Yep they kick the ass of those delta force guys who and to run away from the Somalis.
 
1. Its expensive to add an 24hour watch to the crew for all those ships.
You don't need a 24 hour watch. There is always someone awake on a ship. Plus the crew could work out a rest plan to where they pull guard in shifts throughout the night or whenever. On a ship with a large crew this would not be a problem.

2. They need to be added to all the ships or the problem will only move.

Even if it wasn't added to all ships, pirates will sure think twice before they board a ship and maybe if enough ships do it they would come to the conclusion that piracy is not worth their life.

3. Gun accidents will happen.
This is not true. With proper training gun accidents do not happen or are extremely minimal. Here I will give you the training right now:
Keep your finger out of the damn trigger well until you are ready to fire. Never point your weapon at something unless you intend to destroy it. Keep the weapon on safe until ready to fire. And for a ship, don't have a round in the chamber until there is imminent danger (You would not do this in a combat zone but just for kicks we can do it on the ship).
Training complete.

4. Pirates/criminals can simply change tactics and might even try to simply infiltrate the ships and take over the armory.

They would not have a chance if a proper guard is posted (They are already attempting to infiltrate the ships remember?)
 
I can't envision surrendering unless I was surrounded by hoards of pirates or something and was completely out of ammunition and no other means of defending myself. .

You realized that then there is no point in surrendering. Best save the last one for yourself.
 
You should the middle east is where a lot of the more realistic data on naval warfare comes from.



Things like the QF 3.7 inch AA gun fire projectiles with a significant area of effect and they were used in batteries. And they were still not very good at shooting down planes. Sure if you are prepared to start mounting cannon on your merchant ships you can have an impact but that is seriously expensive.
I'm talking about small arms, not AA guns.

The Red Baron was being fired at by multiple people whith machine guns (as well as the guy chaseing him). Out of all those shots exactly one hit him.
*WWI machine guns weren't well equipped to fire at targets in the sky, probably only capable of firing a few degrees above the horizon actually.

A speedboat isn't a particularly difficult target to hit. Especially since it's far easier to judge distance to a target in the water as opposed to one in the air.

*you'd need one specially mounted specifically for anti-aircraft use.
 
Last edited:
Hell, a single shot from a Canadian soldier armed with a bolt-action rifle took out the Red Baron in WWI. And even a WWI triplane moves faster than the pirate's speedboats, and they operate in 3 dimensions.

You know that there were many people firing at him at the same time, someone had to get lucky. But if you depend on getting lucky you have very very bad tactics.
 
Yep they kick the ass of those delta force guys who and to run away from the Somalis.

WTF are you talking about? Are you reffering to the "Black Hawk Down" incident where 18 Americans died and over a 1000 Somali militia were killed? Umm take a look at the numbers buddy.
 
You know that there were many people firing at him at the same time, someone had to get lucky. But if you depend on getting lucky you have very very bad tactics.
If you can't hit a speedboat from high up on a 800 foot cargo ship you have worse than bad tactics, such as being legally blind perhaps.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom