Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Are we all agreed that Somalis using torpedos, radio controlled IED boats, and RC helicopters is not feasible? We have came to that conclusion have we not?
 
Are we all agreed that Somalis using torpedos, radio controlled IED boats, and RC helicopters is not feasible? We have came to that conclusion have we not?

Yes,
I will add that an RPG round beat the RC helicopter in range and accuracy, so why bother on a windy sea.

A few boxes of RPG round may kill crewmembers and/or damage a ship enough to stop it, the pirates are unlikely to get it started again and back to their port.
No Profit

My money is on armed guards.
 
Remember: the TX (transmitter) and RX (receiver) units on these things are very small. Theoretically, boosting the power might extend the range, but it also might burn out the units. The military UAVs have TX/RX units that are an order of magnitude more sophisticated than RC toys.

The first thing you would want to do is get a better antenna. Since you would be carrying a payload on a tether, that could be used as a long wire antenna on the receiver. A 5/8th wave vertical on the transmitter would be around 2.5m for 72 MHz. A range of several km would be no problem at all. For more range, you could easily boost the transmitter power with an external amp. however, the more power you put out the easier it is to triangulate your position.

2.4 GHz systems could use a high gain yagi or parabolic dish on the ground end for longer range and less chance of interception.

Military systems don't worry about range. They have active antenna systems that electronically track orbiting satellites and will therefore be less susceptible to ground based interference signals.
 
Seriously people... pirates using highly sophisticated remote aircraft to bomb ships?

C'mon. We're trying to discuss reality here. There are pirates who more often than not call off a chase because they're running out of fuel.

Why hold back on the fantasy?

"What happens if you escalate the situation and pirates start attacking ships with lightsabres?"
 
Who's proposing that the pirates would use remote controlled aircraft?

I was just passing the time correcting some misinformation while waiting for you to provide a reference to why the Somali pirates can't make their own explosives.



As for an arial attack, they might do better by using a tether behind the speed boats to lift a couple of pirates on a hang gliders who can then spot the prey at a great distance and then in the attack, glide in with the sun at their back and land on the upper deck of the ship to gain the advantage of hight.
 
Who's proposing that the pirates would use remote controlled aircraft?

I was just passing the time correcting some misinformation while waiting for you to provide a reference to why the Somali pirates can't make their own explosives.



As for an arial attack, they might do better by using a tether behind the speed boats to lift a couple of pirates on a hang gliders who can then spot the prey at a great distance and then in the attack, glide in with the sun at their back and land on the upper deck of the ship to gain the advantage of hight.

Ok. I think that's quite enough Dan o. The other posters can handle it from here. Thanks though.
 
I was just passing the time correcting some misinformation while waiting for you to provide a reference to why the Somali pirates can't make their own explosives.

I don't want to get into the specifics of making explosives, but suffice to say that even something as simple as urea nitrate poses some problems for Somali pirates.

No doubt, if they really needed to, they could learn how to make explosives, and get hold of the appropriate chemicals to do so. With luck they wouldn't kill too many of their own in the process.

Then what?

Point remains, that explosives wouldn't actually help them in any way whatsoever.


As for an arial attack, they might do better by using a tether behind the speed boats to lift a couple of pirates on a hang gliders who can then spot the prey at a great distance and then in the attack, glide in with the sun at their back and land on the upper deck of the ship to gain the advantage of hight.

I'm sure the pirates have hang gliders on their "to buy" list, right beneath "speed boat", "torpedo" and "large RC helicopter".

How many times do I have to repeat the obvious? Most of these guys are poor half-starved fishermen using crappy wooden dinghies. I mean, they're regularly being outrun by container ships. They have to raid small boats to steal petrol just to keep their pathetic little outboard motors going.
 
Dan,
You have to slow down a bit and consider all the practical problems your ideas would run into.
As in "get real"

Example: Land on top of the the containers, run towards the brigde, jump, realice that the horizontal distance is a few meters longer than it looked like from afar, splatter on the deck below.
 
You prove I'm right when your only defense is to change the scenario.

I clearly said: "land on the upper deck" not on the containers.

You can find a picture of a container ship without containers here for reference: link

(Please excuse the smoke. I presume it won't be there at the initiation of an attack)
 
You prove I'm right when your only defense is to change the scenario.

I clearly said: "land on the upper deck" not on the containers.

You can find a picture of a container ship without containers here for reference: link

(Please excuse the smoke. I presume it won't be there at the initiation of an attack)
If there are no containers on deck, it's not going to be a target, particularly.

You obviously really enjoy the Star Wars movies, especiall the ones involving Ewoks, don't cha?
 
Deck
A deck is a permanent covering over a compartment or a hull[1] of a ship. On a boat or ship, the primary deck is the horizontal structure which forms the 'roof' for the hull, which both strengthens the hull and serves as the primary working surface. Vessels often have more than one level both within the hull and in the superstructure above the primary deck which are similar to the floors of a multi-story building, and which are also referred to as decks, as are specific compartments and decks built over specific areas of the superstructure.​
 
Last edited:
You prove I'm right when your only defense is to change the scenario.

I clearly said: "land on the upper deck" not on the containers.

You can find a picture of a container ship without containers here for reference: link

(Please excuse the smoke. I presume it won't be there at the initiation of an attack)


I hate to spoil your fantasy but the MSC Napoli was fully loaded with containers up to about five layers high on its deck when it was damaged in a storm. It was towed off the coast of the UK where it was intentionally beached so its cargo could be unloaded before it was blown apart.

Here's a photo of it beached as its cargo is being unloaded.

After delays due to weather they had to bring in a special platform called "Big Foot" with a heavy lifting crane on it so they could remove the 2,300 containers.

Unfortunately they weren't able to prevent 110 of the containers being washed overboard, many of them being washed up broken on nearby beaches where scavengers had a field day.

It's very, very rare for container ships to move about without containers on their deck. In fact I'd go so far as to say it virtually never happens. Even when they are unloaded, they're not a big spacious empty deck as you might imagine.

If you look closely at pictures of the ship after it was unloaded, you'll see red steel "racks" running across the width of the deck - brackets which the containers are stacked against. Landing anything on the deck would be virtually impossible.
 
The first thing you would want to do is get a better antenna. Since you would be carrying a payload on a tether, that could be used as a long wire antenna on the receiver. A 5/8th wave vertical on the transmitter would be around 2.5m for 72 MHz. A range of several km would be no problem at all. For more range, you could easily boost the transmitter power with an external amp. however, the more power you put out the easier it is to triangulate your position.

2.4 GHz systems could use a high gain yagi or parabolic dish on the ground end for longer range and less chance of interception.

Military systems don't worry about range. They have active antenna systems that electronically track orbiting satellites and will therefore be less susceptible to ground based interference signals.

The R/C equipment out there is not likely to be modified in a manner that would work the way you propose. Further than that, however, you still run into the problems described by rwguinn with regard to point of reference flight with a remote controlled aircraft. The chances these guys would be able to get hold of military systems that could do it are nil.
 
If you are going to rain on anything, I think eastern Australia still needs the water. The image was only for illustrative purposes since a number of responders here didn't appear to actually know what a container ship looked like.

Only an idiot would waist the tactical advantage of hight and surprise by landing on the main deck right in front of where the pilot is expected to be watching the most. Where you want to land is on the top deck above the bridge. With the ship under way there will be a steady 15-20 knot head wind so your final decent would be almost vertical with a soft landing. Not something a beginner would be doing but an experienced hang glider or perhaps a para-sailer could pull it off. Another advantage is that this location gives them access to the radio antenna so if they aren't seen coming in, there won't be any call for help (if they are smart, they would only cut the transmit side of the satellite feed so the off-duty crew won't have their television show interrupted).
 
As for an arial attack, they might do better by using a tether behind the speed boats to lift a couple of pirates on a hang gliders who can then spot the prey at a great distance and then in the attack, glide in with the sun at their back and land on the upper deck of the ship to gain the advantage of hight.
Is anyone else havng a Poe's Law moment here?
 
If you are going to rain on anything, I think eastern Australia still needs the water. The image was only for illustrative purposes since a number of responders here didn't appear to actually know what a container ship looked like.

Only an idiot would waist the tactical advantage of hight and surprise by landing on the main deck right in front of where the pilot is expected to be watching the most. Where you want to land is on the top deck above the bridge. With the ship under way there will be a steady 15-20 knot head wind so your final decent would be almost vertical with a soft landing. Not something a beginner would be doing but an experienced hang glider or perhaps a para-sailer could pull it off. Another advantage is that this location gives them access to the radio antenna so if they aren't seen coming in, there won't be any call for help (if they are smart, they would only cut the transmit side of the satellite feed so the off-duty crew won't have their television show interrupted).
If the pirate ships have trouble overtaking cargo ships now, how will they do it while towing a hang glider? Do you have any idea how much drag that would put on the boat?
 
The R/C equipment out there is not likely to be modified in a manner that would work the way you propose. Further than that, however, you still run into the problems described by rwguinn with regard to point of reference flight with a remote controlled aircraft. The chances these guys would be able to get hold of military systems that could do it are nil.

For the typical R/C hobbyist, there is no need to modify the equipment. But someone would have to be totally ignorant about RF systems to not know how to add proper antennas to increase the range. For instance, when the controls are acting sluggish do you make sure that the transmitter antenna is pointing directly at the aircraft to maximize the signal?

Hobbyist helicopters that almost fly themselves are already available. It's just a matter of having an inertial reference and smart controls for the routine station keeping. The operator needs only give it a course and speed. Two trackers with binoculars could position it over a target several km away as long as they had sufficient elevation to see the target.

The helicopter is still an inefficient delivery vehicle. The limits on payload and range, the noise, the transmitted control signal that could be tracked all make it unsuitable. An autonomous radar invisible balloon born smart bomb would be a much better choice.
 
Is anyone else havng a Poe's Law moment here?

For the typical R/C hobbyist, there is no need to modify the equipment. But someone would have to be totally ignorant about RF systems to not know how to add proper antennas to increase the range. For instance, when the controls are acting sluggish do you make sure that the transmitter antenna is pointing directly at the aircraft to maximize the signal?

Hobbyist helicopters that almost fly themselves are already available. It's just a matter of having an inertial reference and smart controls for the routine station keeping. The operator needs only give it a course and speed. Two trackers with binoculars could position it over a target several km away as long as they had sufficient elevation to see the target.

The helicopter is still an inefficient delivery vehicle. The limits on payload and range, the noise, the transmitted control signal that could be tracked all make it unsuitable. An autonomous radar invisible balloon born smart bomb would be a much better choice.
Dan, are you really serious about this?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom