Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Those poor uneducated fishermen are using GPS navigation.

They have the same capacity to learn as you do. So far, they haven't needed to learn new skills because the current tactic is sufficiently successful.
 
This revelation came to me in a dream many years ago...

A revelation also came to me that you are much more likely to become a hostage and taken to a remote location if you willingly let pirates board your ship and take you hostage.
 
Um... no. Are you seriously suggesting a rickety wooden dinghy (which is what most of the pirate boats amount to) is superior to a Germany navy submarine specifically engineered for firing torpedoes?

On the basis that best we can tell most of the dinghies get back home yes. List of "watercraft superior to a biber" isn't exactly short.

This isn't about "size". It's about function, sophistication, and capability. There's absolutely no comparison.

Sophistication? One of the pics was of a neger where the total navigational devices ammounted to a wrist compass. If the somalis were able to get their hands on torpedeos (which they can't) it would likely be posible to mount and launch them from drop collers.


Since we're talking about the Biber, though, you're talking about a fully submersible ship almost 9m long and weighing almost 6 tonnes. How is that comparable to the sorts of boats most commonly used by Somali pirates?

Carbon monoxide poisening doesn't appear to be a significant risk in the Somali pirates boats.

These are the sorts of boats that capsize in a spot of rough weather, as the pirates that took the Sirius Star discovered after one of their boats tipped over and drowned four of them.

While I don't know any cases of bibers capsizeing the Kriegsmarine generaly didn't send them out in rough weather.
 
Those poor uneducated fishermen are using GPS navigation.

Some of them are... on their mother ships. Don't forget there's multiple groups working here. If you think building a bomb is as simple as operating a GPS unit... well, it's not.


They have the same capacity to learn as you do. So far, they haven't needed to learn new skills because the current tactic is sufficiently successful.

The current tactic is proving highly ineffective and mostly unsuccessful, and has been for years. They don't show any signs of improving their tactics. It's not about capacity to learn, it's about resources.
 
On the basis that best we can tell most of the dinghies get back home yes. List of "watercraft superior to a biber" isn't exactly short.

We're not talking about overall rating of a water craft, but ability to correctly and effectively carry and launch a torpedo. However flawed the Bibers were, fact remains they were specifically designed to carry and launch torpedoes.


Sophistication? One of the pics was of a neger where the total navigational devices ammounted to a wrist compass. If the somalis were able to get their hands on torpedeos (which they can't) it would likely be posible to mount and launch them from drop collers.

Again, you're comparing a vehicle specifically designed for carrying a torpedo, to a wooden dingy. The displacement of the Neger was almost 3T. What do you think would happen if you tried to sling a torpedo under a wooden dinghy? The thing would sink. As it was 80% of Neger crews died, which hardly seems like a sensible plan for Somali pirates to follow.


Carbon monoxide poisening doesn't appear to be a significant risk in the Somali pirates boats.

No, but drowning is.


While I don't know any cases of bibers capsizeing the Kriegsmarine generaly didn't send them out in rough weather.


Okay, I think you're missing the fundamentals here.

You're trying to make an argument that there's a realistic potential for Somali pirates to start launching torpedoes from their boats and sinking ships with them.

As evidence that this is possible, you cite ineffective and essentially useless ships designed by the Germany Navy during WWII.

If Nazi Germany, with all of its might, technology, infrastructure, and design knowledge behind it, failed to design effective small water craft capable of launching torpedoes, what on earth makes you think Somali pirates would be capable of it?

And even presuming some sort of fantasy land where they were actually capable of this, why would they? Their sole objective is to capture ships intact. Their entire income relies on them being able to return ships and crew unharmed.

If they start sinking ships they've immediately shut off their only possible avenue of income.
 
Also, let's get practical here...

The smallest torpedoes available to groups like the Somali pirates are the Russian lightweight torpedoes which weigh about 500kg each. You're looking at about $1 million or more per unit. Now, I think most of us can imagine what would happen if you tried to attach a 500kg metal object to the side of a 100kg wooden boat.

In comparison, the AK-47 can cost as little as $15.00, up to about $150.00, and weighs less than 5kg. The RPG-7 costs around $100.00 to $500.00 per launcher and as little as $30 per round. The launcher weighs about 6kg, and a typical round weighs about 2kg.

In addition, the average person can get pretty accurate with an RPG-7 at ranges of 50-100m in very short order. Accurately launching a torpedo, on the other hand, is an art form that few can master.
 
Some of them are... on their mother ships. Don't forget there's multiple groups working here. If you think building a bomb is as simple as operating a GPS unit... well, it's not.

What's so hard about building a bomb? You take a bunch of explosives, insert a detonator, attach the battery then go find something to blow up. You should try it. :D


As for the engineering aspects, is there a quantity of explosive that will put a hole in the outer hull of a cargo vessel? Is there a quantity of explosives that will put a hole through both hulls? How many of these holes would it take to upset a ship? Could one hole through the stern flood the engine room and stop the ship? I don't need precise answers. I just need to know that you accept that there is an answer so I won't find the goal posts mysteriously disappearing later on.
 
What's so hard about building a bomb? You take a bunch of explosives, insert a detonator, attach the battery then go find something to blow up. You should try it. :D


If this is so easy, explain why terrorist bombmakers (with far more resources than Somali pirates) go to the difficult and dangerous lengths of making bombs from scratch.
 
For the terrorists, making explosives for export can be a revenue source to support the groups cause. Kind of like a bake sale.

If you have the proper resources to control the process it isn't all that difficult or dangerous.

ETA: source
"Urea nitrate is a powerful improvised explosive, frequently used by Palestinian terrorists in Israel. It was also used in the first World Trade Center bombing in New York in 1993. Non-professionals can prepare large amounts of this material in "back-yard" facilities, which have subsequently been used in improvised mines and in suicide bomber belts, the devastating results of which have killed over a hundred people in Israel alone."​
 
Last edited:
For the terrorists, making explosives for export can be a revenue source to support the groups cause. Kind of like a bake sale.

If you have the proper resources to control the process it isn't all that difficult or dangerous.


The Islamists in Somalia are opposed to the pirates. They're hardly likely to start giving them bombs. When the UIC was in control of Somalia there was a grand total of three attempted piracy attacks.

When pirates attack ships from Islamic countries quite often the Islamists go in and hit the pirates with a reprisal attack - if they are capable of doing so.
 
Oh God,

I just spent my lunch debating a colleague who claims that it is really easy to to attach an explosive to a remote controlled toy helicopter and use it accurately for terrorist attacks.

Very reminiscent of this discussion.
 
It looks like a six pack is about the limit for a typical toy helicopter:



Not exactly stealth either.

ETA: However, if you could hit the thermal exhaust port that runs directly into the reactor system, you would set off a chain reaction that would destroy the entire ship.
 
Last edited:
Oh God,

I just spent my lunch debating a colleague who claims that it is really easy to to attach an explosive to a remote controlled toy helicopter and use it accurately for terrorist attacks.

Very reminiscent of this discussion.

If they can do it in Grand Theft Auto, I don't see why the Somalis can't do it.:rolleyes:

I have to say that while I don't really agree with those advocating simply arming everyone as any kind of easy solution, the claims that pirates are going to suddenly start launching torpedoes and setting up mines on really long pieces of string really are bizzare. There are various problems associated with arming crews, hiring guards, sailing in convoys or whatever, mostly political and economic ones. The risk of being torpedoed by pirates in small wooden boats really isn't one of them.
 
It looks like a six pack is about the limit for a typical toy helicopter:




Not exactly stealth either.

That's because they're using a gas-powered heli there. The electric ones, while smaller, are much quieter and less messy (the gas spews oily residue all over). However, a six-pack isn't the limit for those things, not when properly modified. They wouldn't be able to carry enough explosives to make much of a dent in an ocean liner, though. Not to mention the range on them is questionable past 50-75 meters or so.

-----

On a separate note: it looks like some insurance companies are now offering lower piracy coverage costs for ships with guard contingents, and there is even talk of a package including the insurance, a few armed guards, and a lawyer team prepared to address inevitable (and potential) problems in the case that a guard crew has to engage with pirates.
 
Why would the range be so limited?

It's not that they couldn't travel past those distances. I just wouldn't trust the reliability of the controls past those distances. With the 72 mHz range (of controllers) you'll have pretty close to line-of-sight as far as conceivable distance, but the further away you get the more sluggish the controls are going to get (and the higher the probability of the servos switching to their default positions). With the 2.4 GHz range of controllers you'll get about the same distance and a bit better performance when further away (theoretically), but you're also dealing with a frequency that's fairly widely used, which means it's relatively simple to jam (I could do it using a modified wifi card). The normal practical range for radio controlled aircraft, using the condition of no interference and optimal conditions, is an area about the size of a football field at maximum and considering full visibility between the operator and the RC aircraft. I know some plane guys who might dispute that, but they tend to stick within line-of-sight themselves and don't usually take their craft out to test limits.

Remember: the TX (transmitter) and RX (receiver) units on these things are very small. Theoretically, boosting the power might extend the range, but it also might burn out the units. The military UAVs have TX/RX units that are an order of magnitude more sophisticated than RC toys.
 
As an RC pilot, I do have some expertise.
Commercially available units can control the things farther than you can see them. The problem is seeing them. You can't tell what it is doing out there, and that makes control iffy.
There is no "sluggishness"--it is simply difficult to determine attitude. Even if you stick a camera in the thing (which reduces payload, range, and adds a bunch to the cost), you need a visual reference (remarkably lacking at sea) to determine which way you are going. They are also remarkably easy to bring down with a 12 gauge shotgun if they get within a close enough range to attack.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom