Easy solution to the pirate problem...

For instance, when the controls are acting sluggish do you make sure that the transmitter antenna is pointing directly at the aircraft to maximize the signal?

The RC transmitters I have used will transmit farther than I can see. I can see a model airplane much father away than I can control one by sight. The model has to be much more than visible to control; it has to be close enough to orientate to keep it in control. I suppose head mounted binoculars would help, but I not see this happening.

The controls do not get sluggish when near the limit of the transmitter's range, they get erratic. This means the airplane is going to most likely fall out of the sky rather quickly unless the plane happens to start flying closer to the transmitter.

Ranb
 
Dan, are you really serious about this?

Serious in that I am providing truthful information: yes. Do I have any intention of acting like a pirate and actually using any of this stuff: no.

I'm just showing a few ways that the situation could escalate if the pirates are forced to become terrorists by shutting off their last avenue of making a living.
 
Serious in that I am providing truthful information: yes. Do I have any intention of acting like a pirate and actually using any of this stuff: no.

I'm just showing a few ways that the situation could escalate if the pirates are forced to become terrorists by shutting off their last avenue of making a living.
It's just as likely to escalate via the pirates using trained sharks with lasers on their heads.

Seriously, your ideas are beyond ridiculous.
 
You are still ignoring all the little practical details.

Like landing on top of the brigde among twentysomething antennas, without getting hurt, and then cutting the wires for the right ones?

I read of something called TOW3, a remote controlled fast moving explosive. It comes with a really good sight system to let you see what is happening downrange.

I doubt it will work from an unstable dingy, you would not be able to keep the sight focused on target. So helicopter and binoculars, not likely.
 
I'm just showing a few ways that the situation could escalate if the pirates are forced to become terrorists by shutting off their last avenue of making a living.


If you've just shut off their last avenue of making money where exactly are they going to get the funds for the torpedoes, hang gliders, RC helicopters, and gallons of nitric acid?

The pirates aren't pirates because it's their only way of making money. They're pirates because until now it has been a relatively safe way of potentially making lots of money.

I predict they'd join up with the various militia fighting for control of Somalia before they'd turn international shipping terrorist.

Aside from which, as I think I already mentioned, the pirates are clearly already operating near their maximum capability but the forces opposing them have barely even started to fight back.

Believe me, the west would crush the pirate bases long before they started launching squadrons of bomb-laden hang glider commandos.
 
If you've just shut off their last avenue of making money where exactly are they going to get the funds for the torpedoes, hang gliders, RC helicopters, and gallons of nitric acid?

The pirates aren't pirates because it's their only way of making money. They're pirates because until now it has been a relatively safe way of potentially making lots of money.

I predict they'd join up with the various militia fighting for control of Somalia before they'd turn international shipping terrorist.

Aside from which, as I think I already mentioned, the pirates are clearly already operating near their maximum capability but the forces opposing them have barely even started to fight back.

Believe me, the west would crush the pirate bases long before they started launching squadrons of bomb-laden hang glider commandos.

:dl:

That was great! :)

I know I've been deploring using derision as a means of making a point, but that was just too clever and funny.
 
Last edited:
Again, you're comparing a vehicle specifically designed for carrying a torpedo, to a wooden dingy. The displacement of the Neger was almost 3T. What do you think would happen if you tried to sling a torpedo under a wooden dinghy? The thing would sink. As it was 80% of Neger crews died, which hardly seems like a sensible plan for Somali pirates to follow.

Torpedoes with neutral buoyancy are possible to construct. No the reason you don't put one under a boat is that it would totaly destory your speed and manoverability.

Okay, I think you're missing the fundamentals here.

You're trying to make an argument that there's a realistic potential for Somali pirates to start launching torpedoes from their boats and sinking ships with them.

No I'm trying to argue that the reason they can't do that is torpedeo availiblity and not the limts of their craft.

As evidence that this is possible, you cite ineffective and essentially useless ships designed by the Germany Navy during WWII.

If Nazi Germany, with all of its might, technology, infrastructure, and design knowledge behind it, failed to design effective small water craft capable of launching torpedoes, what on earth makes you think Somali pirates would be capable of it?

Because they can use surface ships. The forces deployed by the allies in that area during WW2 make the anti-pirate force look rather small.

The reason the german boats are of interest is that they are far closer to the minium size for a torpedeo platform than MBTs were.
 
Torpedoes with neutral buoyancy are possible to construct. No the reason you don't put one under a boat is that it would totaly destory your speed and manoverability.

I don't imagine Somali pirates would be able to be too picky about which torpedoes they used, nor would they be able to construct their own.


No I'm trying to argue that the reason they can't do that is torpedeo availiblity and not the limts of their craft.

I think it's an issue of both. Primarily the first, but the second also counts. How do you attach the torpedo? How do you arm it? How do you launch it. These aren't trivial issues when you're talking about Somali pirates.


Because they can use surface ships. The forces deployed by the allies in that area during WW2 make the anti-pirate force look rather small.

I'd be skeptical of that, actually. In terms of firepower comparable size modern warships pack a substantially greater punch than WW2 era ones, have better speed, maneuverability, and visibility.


The reason the german boats are of interest is that they are far closer to the minium size for a torpedeo platform than MBTs were.

Just because it's possible to build a ship capable of using torpedoes that's about the size of the pirate vessels doesn't mean that the pirate vessels are capable of using torpedoes.

(In addition, as I think I pointed out, even those midget German vessels are substantially larger than many of the Somali pirate vessels).
 
Actualy the towed glider craft aproach does have something of a history with the Focke Achgelis Fa 330.
Oh dear FSM geni, that is not even remotely what Dan was suggesting. He actually suggested towing the hang gliders ahead of the ship so they could then be cut loose and land on the "deck" of a loaded container ship, whereupon the sooper-733T pirate commandos would take over the ship.

Your example was designed to warn of other ships nearby so the U-boat could escape. And I doubt the gyro glider affected the surface speed of the U-boat at all, whereas towing a hang glider behind a small boat would certainly reduce the top speed of the boat drastically. And these boats already have a tough time catching up to container ships without towing a hang glider..
 
Just because you can't figure it out doesn't mean that the pirates won't be able to.

The hang gliders store energy in the form of elevation. Before the attack, the speedboats would be ahead of the ship. The gliders would be cut free and the boats stopped to minimize their visibility. The gliders can sail over the ship then descend vertically onto the top deck of the superstructure. The speedboats would then commence their attack as a diversion while the elite pirate commandos take over the bridge.
 
Just because you can't figure it out doesn't mean that the pirates won't be able to.

The hang gliders store energy in the form of elevation. Before the attack, the speedboats would be ahead of the ship. The gliders would be cut free and the boats stopped to minimize their visibility. The gliders can sail over the ship then descend vertically onto the top deck of the superstructure. The speedboats would then commence their attack as a diversion while the elite pirate commandos take over the bridge.
Once again, Poe's Law is in full force.

I honestly can't tell if you're serious or just trolling.
 
Once again, Poe's Law is in full force.

I honestly can't tell if you're serious or just trolling.

Poe's law
...One might as well argue that genuine works of art are indistinguishable from cheap knockoffs, because some people are unable to distinguish between the two.​

If what I suggest really can't work then someone would be able to point out the fundamental flaws that cannot be circumvented. So far, you've only invented flaws that don't exist.
 
Shame on everyone for engaging in discourse about pirates hang gliding onto cargo ships. Now apologize to Randi please.
 
Dan is clearly just having fun now, no way can he possibly be serious...
 
Nobody pays me to post here. So if I'm not having fun I wouldn't be doing it.

My enjoyment however doesn't create evidence that it can't work.
 
Nobody pays me to post here. So if I'm not having fun I wouldn't be doing it.

My enjoyment however doesn't create evidence that it can't work.
Nor is there any evidence that the pirates couldn't fit sharks with lasers on their heads and train them to attack shipping.
 
Dolphins would be better, well known for their intelligence and proven abilities when trained , and probably could be deployed by parachute too, as they are mammalian air breathers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom