Easy solution to the pirate problem...

I don´t think their boats can carry more than rpg´s, ak47, and its machinegun version.

Anything heavier (.50 machinegun?) will destroy the boat with recoil.

I am not sure what damage an rpg does, but enough of them in the engineroom might hit something that will stop the engine.
That will give the pirates a problem getting the ship back to "base".
 
.....Your perception is a little off, then. That's not what I want.

What do you want then? If as you claim the sailors are only being shot at because they're shooting the pirates, then what do you expect them to do?

Ranb
 
What do you want then?

To get people to admit that it's not "easy".

If as you claim the sailors are only being shot at because they're shooting the pirates, then what do you expect them to do?

That claim was a little strong. What I meant -- and I wasn't very clear then -- is that the odds of you getting shot at are greater if you shoot at an armed person.
 
.....That claim was a little strong. What I meant -- and I wasn't very clear then -- is that the odds of you getting shot at are greater if you shoot at an armed person.

Then how does this apply to the discussion of pirates taking ships by force? When shooting occurs, it is the pirates that shoot first. Do you have any evidence that shows the pirates have not fired their weapons at any time when taking a cargo ship by force?

It still seems that you are laying blame for shooting squarely upon the sailors that are merely defending themselves.

Ranb
 
Hello? Pacifist! I wouldn't be on the ship in the first place!

How do you protect yourself? Do you live in a country that uses a standing army to defend its citizens, including pacifists such as yourself?

Ranb
 
It's not feasible.

You've shown repeatedly that you know nothing of small navel units. Firing a torpedo from a PT boat is unquestionably feasible. Indeed successful torpedo attacks have been launched from craft weighing in at 2.75 tons by crews with only a about 3 weeks training (which to some extent explains why so many failed to return from operations although that might be because the Neger was a really bad design).


The real problem with torpedo attacks is building the things (while they have been jury rigged together that was under highly artificial conditions) and the lack of speed needed to hit modern freighters.
 
You've shown repeatedly that you know nothing of small navel units. Firing a torpedo from a PT boat is unquestionably feasible. Indeed successful torpedo attacks have been launched from craft weighing in at 2.75 tons by crews with only a about 3 weeks training (which to some extent explains why so many failed to return from operations although that might be because the Neger was a really bad design).


The real problem with torpedo attacks is building the things (while they have been jury rigged together that was under highly artificial conditions) and the lack of speed needed to hit modern freighters.

I think you just answered why it is not feasible.
 
Erm... folks I think some of you are forgetting what sort of craft these pirates are using.

Here's one.

And another.

And another.

And another.

No one is going to be firing a torpedo from one of those boats any time soon.

Still looks better than this:

http://de.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Datei:Biber_axb01.jpg&filetimestamp=20050421191505

And those things carried a pair of torpedoes one on either side

http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Biber_Submarine_inIWM.jpg

Not that they were any good. Still they were larger than these:

http://img.ffffound.com/static-data/assets/6/f1b884bdd4bec1b28adca7d0b6f1aace91db93f8_m.jpg
 

What exactly is the relevance of these submarines to our discussion?
 
What exactly is the relevance of these submarines to our discussion?

Only the first pair are of a submarine.

They are a useful demonstration of how minimal a torpedo launching platform can be.
 
The fact that as little as 4kg of TNT is enough to sink a moderately large ship and that the pirates are know to have access to TNT means that it is not beyond the pirates capabilities. The link provides one delivery mechanism and I already provided another in this thread.
 
The fact that as little as 4kg of TNT is enough to sink a moderately large ship and that the pirates are know to have access to TNT means that it is not beyond the pirates capabilities. The link provides one delivery mechanism and I already provided another in this thread.

You sent me a link with to a story about a bomb pre planted on a ship. Why?
 
Then how does this apply to the discussion of pirates taking ships by force? When shooting occurs, it is the pirates that shoot first. Do you have any evidence that shows the pirates have not fired their weapons at any time when taking a cargo ship by force?

It still seems that you are laying blame for shooting squarely upon the sailors that are merely defending themselves.

Well, perhaps you should stop going with what it "seems" and rather by what I say. I said the odds of you getting shot at are greater if you shoot at an armed person.

If the armed person is shooting in the air, or a warning shot, and asking for your surrender, I think shooting back may escalate the situation. If they're shooting at you in the first place, then you might as well have a go at it.
 


Um... no. Are you seriously suggesting a rickety wooden dinghy (which is what most of the pirate boats amount to) is superior to a Germany navy submarine specifically engineered for firing torpedoes?

This isn't about "size". It's about function, sophistication, and capability. There's absolutely no comparison.

Since we're talking about the Biber, though, you're talking about a fully submersible ship almost 9m long and weighing almost 6 tonnes. How is that comparable to the sorts of boats most commonly used by Somali pirates?

These are the sorts of boats that capsize in a spot of rough weather, as the pirates that took the Sirius Star discovered after one of their boats tipped over and drowned four of them.
 
The fact that as little as 4kg of TNT is enough to sink a moderately large ship and that the pirates are know to have access to TNT means that it is not beyond the pirates capabilities. The link provides one delivery mechanism and I already provided another in this thread.


I wouldn't call a 10,000T ship "moderately large". The ferries that run between the two major islands of New Zealand are bigger than that, and they're dwarfed by even a modest size container or general cargo ship.

A large container ship is classified as one that can carry more than 7,000 standard 20ft containers. A standard 20ft container weights 2.2T empty, which means the absolute minimum payload of a large container ship alone is 15,400T. That puts into perspective your 10,000T ship.

I also think you're being a bit optimistic about Somali bomb-making capabilities. Bomb making is not as easy as you might be led to believe, and most of these pirates are poor uneducated fisherman who've turned to piracy because war and illegal shipping has destroyed their livelihood. They don't know a thing about bomb-making.

The people in Somalia who know about bomb-making are the Islamists, and they're no friend of the pirates.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom