Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Nor is there any evidence that the pirates couldn't fit sharks with lasers on their heads and train them to attack shipping.

WildCat thinks about training sharks...



ETA: Here is an earlier discussion on the merits of underwater lasers used to sink merchant ships: http://www.kbismarck.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=1570&st=0&sk=t&sd=a

The attenuation of the laser light in water is a considerable drawback. If the laser is powerful enough to cut through steel, it's going to be boiling the water in the path and therefore causing more scatter. For close up cutting, underwater lasers have proven to be successful (link) but the 4kW power source seems to be a bit excessive for a shark to carry.

Maybe you are thinking of some other use for the lasers besides as directed energy weapons.
 
Last edited:
That is a really good beginning Dan, now try apply your attention to gritty details to the other ideas.
Like how powerfull is the speedboats used for tourist paragliding along the beach?
etc..
 
That is a really good beginning Dan, now try apply your attention to gritty details to the other ideas.
Like how powerfull is the speedboats used for tourist paragliding along the beach?
etc..

That isn't the question that needs to be answered. Although paraglider would have some advantages such as being lighter weight and no radar signature, they are not as maneuverable, have a lower top speed and a higher drop rate than the hang glider.

What speed and power are required to lift a hang glider?

The greatest power requirement would be during takeoff with the glider in the water. This can be minimized by carrying the glider and pilot in a second boat until liftoff which would eliminate the need for pontoons on the glider. Takeoff with a hang glider occurs at a slow running speed so this shouldn't be a problem. Since the gliders have a high glide ratio, it isn't going to take much power to keep them airborne. I'll need to gather the figures to work out an exact number. Here is an article on tow lifting using a motor scooter as a winch. (link)
 
WildCat thinks about training sharks...



ETA: Here is an earlier discussion on the merits of underwater lasers used to sink merchant ships: http://www.kbismarck.org/forum/viewtopic.php?f=10&t=1570&st=0&sk=t&sd=a

The attenuation of the laser light in water is a considerable drawback. If the laser is powerful enough to cut through steel, it's going to be boiling the water in the path and therefore causing more scatter. For close up cutting, underwater lasers have proven to be successful (link) but the 4kW power source seems to be a bit excessive for a shark to carry.

Maybe you are thinking of some other use for the lasers besides as directed energy weapons.


The laser would be above the shark's head so it could be deployed out of the water and fired through the air at the ship's waterline.

This is another argument for why dolphins might be better as they naturally break the surface regularly anyway. In addition, dolphins are known to leap bodily out of the water. Perhaps they could be trained to launch some sort of anti-shipping missile from their backs.
 
The laser would be above the shark's head so it could be deployed out of the water and fired through the air at the ship's waterline.

This is another argument for why dolphins might be better as they naturally break the surface regularly anyway. In addition, dolphins are known to leap bodily out of the water. Perhaps they could be trained to launch some sort of anti-shipping missile from their backs.

This thread has gotten WAY out of hand lol.
 
Dan,
You have to slow down a bit and consider all the practical problems your ideas would run into.
As in "get real"
Example: Land on top of the the containers, run towards the brigde, jump, realice that the horizontal distance is a few meters longer than it looked like from afar, splatter on the deck below.

I am not so much trying atack you personally or change your scenario, more trying to fit it with reality and give an example of a practical problem.
I hoped to encurage you to do the same.
 
I am not so much trying atack you personally or change your scenario, more trying to fit it with reality and give an example of a practical problem.
I hoped to encurage you to do the same.

My comment to Blez was that I didn't want to attack you personally.

I hadn't even considered landing in the cargo deck because the whole concept of a stealth attack with a small force is to avoid being seen. Before posting, I did the basic research to verify that hang gliders had the necessary speed to keep up with the ship. The popular gliding hill I pass on the way to work has a landing site that is probably smaller than the top of the ships super structure surrounded by power lines roads river and cliff. The unknown factor is landing with a substantial headwind without drifting too far fore or aft out of the blind zone. If this were navy seals retaking the ship they would do it at night and take out any guards with silenced sniper rifles with infrared vision and nobody would think twice about it because they had already seen it in the movies.
 
And how many of those are there in Somalia? If you don't know exactly, just round it to the nearest thousand hundred one zero.


If you had a telescope and an RC transmitter with an amplifier and high gain antenna you could literally pick planes out of the sky.

(http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1999191/posts)
On a side note, I remember when my ship was cruising off of the coast of Somalia. Someone had a RC plane and was doing circles around the flight deck. Well all of the sudden, the plane turned west, and went towards Somalia​
.
 
If you had a telescope and an RC transmitter with an amplifier and high gain antenna you could literally pick planes out of the sky.

(http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/1999191/posts)
On a side note, I remember when my ship was cruising off of the coast of Somalia. Someone had a RC plane and was doing circles around the flight deck. Well all of the sudden, the plane turned west, and went towards Somalia​
.

Wow. In response to a question of how many RC hobbyists there are in Somalia, you reply with an anonymous post telling a story about how someone on a cruise ship once had an RC plane that turned west at some point.

I have to disagree with Wildcat here on Poe's law. That would require you to at least pretend to make sense.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom