Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Training and numbers are now to be considered semantics? Over 2000 years of militry history suggests that approach should be considered to be unreasonable.

Not sure what you are talking about. What is unreasonable?
 
Captina Phillips wants armed security on the ships. Maersk Chairman Clancey wants to use other methods. I wonder what Clancey's attitude would be if he was on the lifeboat with a rifle pointed at his back.


http://www.google.com/hostednews/afp/article/ALeqM5i6lKLPPMg7nw1jXUrbtO_x_b903g

A US cargo-ship captain saved from Somali pirates called on Thursday for toughened merchant vessels, weapons for crew members and armed detachments aboard to thwart the seaborne scourge.

At the same hearing, Maersk chairman John Clancey forcefully objected to arming the crews of merchant vessels.

"Our belief is that arming merchant sailors may result in the acquisition of ever more lethal weapons and tactics by the pirates, a race that merchant sailors cannot win. In addition, most ports of call will not permit the introduction of firearms into their national waters," he said.

Ranb
 
Last edited:
I am now putting Quad4_72 on ignore.

Don't need to do anything that drastic. After all, I wonder how many people are ignoring you after you commended the pirates for not using RPG's while machine gunning ships and people.

Ranb
 
Last edited:
Don't need to do anything that drastic. After all, I wonder how many people are ignoring you after you commended the pirates for not using RPG's while machine gunning ships and people.

Ranb

It's actually fine. Anyone who suggests that the pirates are going to result to creating remote controlled boats filled with IEDs then try to blow up all the ships probably isn't going to contribute anything relevant to a discussion.
 
Captina Phillips wants armed security on the ships. Maersk Chairman Clancey wants to use other methods. I wonder what Clancey's attitude would be if he was on the lifeboat with a rifle pointed at his back.


http://www.google.com/hostednews/afp/article/ALeqM5i6lKLPPMg7nw1jXUrbtO_x_b903g

A US cargo-ship captain saved from Somali pirates called on Thursday for toughened merchant vessels, weapons for crew members and armed detachments aboard to thwart the seaborne scourge.

At the same hearing, Maersk chairman John Clancey forcefully objected to arming the crews of merchant vessels.

"Our belief is that arming merchant sailors may result in the acquisition of ever more lethal weapons and tactics by the pirates, a race that merchant sailors cannot win. In addition, most ports of call will not permit the introduction of firearms into their national waters," he said.

Ranb

Clancey is one of those ignorant people I was talking about before. Probably thinks that guns are going to start firing by themselves the second they are put on the ship and kill the crew.
 
Clancey is one of those ignorant people I was talking about before. Probably thinks that guns are going to start firing by themselves the second they are put on the ship and kill the crew.

Or he's thinking about the insurance premiums skyrocketing. Like it or not, there are a number of sundry costs related to arming the sailors besides simply the cost of the firearms and the training. Chances are, in typical management fashion, he's considering the bottom line (as a collection of the costs versus perceived benefits) above all else.
 
Or he's thinking about the insurance premiums skyrocketing. Like it or not, there are a number of sundry costs related to arming the sailors besides simply the cost of the firearms and the training. Chances are, in typical management fashion, he's considering the bottom line (as a collection of the costs versus perceived benefits) above all else.

Its sad when money is more important that the safety of the crew.
 
Its sad when money is more important that the safety of the crew.
From all I have seen, crews have been kept safe by pirates. They're not much use as ransom when dead. I do not think that engaging in gun battles would make them safer.

This is not to say I don't think the ships should defend themselves, only that they'd be doing it for the cargo, not the crew. If you want to make it a condition of serving on one of these ships that you are expected to put your life on the line in defense of the cargo, I'm okay with that. Just be sure you state it up front.
 
From all I have seen, crews have been kept safe by pirates.
Gumboot already posted evidence this is not the case. Several have been killed by the pirates.

This is not to say I don't think the ships should defend themselves, only that they'd be doing it for the cargo, not the crew. If you want to make it a condition of serving on one of these ships that you are expected to put your life on the line in defense of the cargo, I'm okay with that. Just be sure you state it up front.
They're already fighting the pirates, only without guns. The shipping companies are sending them to a gun and RPG fight armed with water cannons and ice picks.

Another thing you'd have known if you actually read this thread is that the pirates typically fire on the ship with RPGs and AK-47s prior to boarding, despite the fact the ships are unarmed.
 
From all I have seen, crews have been kept safe by pirates. They're not much use as ransom when dead. I do not think that engaging in gun battles would make them safer.

This is not to say I don't think the ships should defend themselves, only that they'd be doing it for the cargo, not the crew. If you want to make it a condition of serving on one of these ships that you are expected to put your life on the line in defense of the cargo, I'm okay with that. Just be sure you state it up front.

Yes much of what you have said here has already been covered in this thread. Basically, it is quite silly to assume that you are going to be safe if you just comply with the pirates. What if the negotiations go wrong and the pirates decide to kill one of the hostages? Assuming you are safe with the pirates is actually quite silly. You have a damn AK pointed at your head by a man who is demanding money or you die. How safe is that really?

Instead of putting yourself in a submissive position, you could go on the offensive and defend the ship with weapons. The tactical advantage you have is so significant that the pirates really have no chance. As I said before, this has all already been covered.
 
So I am a communist for being concerned about the safety of the crew?

Feeling sadness about the natural result of a functioning free market shows clear communist tendancies. Why do you hate america?
 
From all I have seen, crews have been kept safe by pirates.

You do not really believe that do you? Take a look here. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ships_attacked_by_Somali_pirates

According to this link, Somali pirates or their supporters failed to protect several sailors. The pirates are obviously serving their own interests and not the hostages.

They killed a Chinese fisherman when the ransom demands were not met.

Three North Koreans were injured while taking back control of their ship from the pirates.

A Pakistani crewman was killed when security forces stormed the ship. The pirates could have released him, but kept the crew in the line of fire instead.

The pirates released a Dutch ship with crew members that were ill and without supplies.

A Filipino sailor was killed on a Malaysian ship by pirates.

Three sailors died on a Greek ship while in pirate custody.

Pirates tried to murder three ship's security personnel after they unsuccessfully defended a Marshall Islands ship using non-lethal methods.

Pirates beat an Indian crew after taking over their ship.

A hostage on a French yacht was killed when French forces stormed it.

Five Indian crew members were injured when Yemen soldiers stormed their ship to rescue them.

As you can see, the pirates are not really keeping their victims safe.

Ranb
 
Last edited:
You do not really believe that do you? Take a look here. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ships_attacked_by_Somali_pirates

According to this link, Somali pirates or their supporters failed to protect several sailors. The pirates are obviously serving their own interests and not the hostages.
They killed a Taiwanese hostage, no reason was given: http://www.deseretnews.com/article/1,5143,705296905,00.html

And this January they killed an Indian fisherman: http://www.hindustantimes.com/Story...rman+killed+by+pirates+off+Saudi+Arabia+coast
 
You do not really believe that do you? Take a look here. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_ships_attacked_by_Somali_pirates

According to this link, Somali pirates or their supporters failed to protect several sailors. The pirates are obviously serving their own interests and not the hostages.

They killed a Chinese fisherman when the ransom demands were not met.

Three North Koreans were injured while taking back control of their ship from the pirates.

A Pakistani crewman was killed when security forces stormed the ship. The pirates could have released him, but kept the crew in the line of fire instead.

The pirates released a Dutch ship with crew members that were ill and without supplies.

A Filipino sailor was killed on a Malaysian ship by pirates.

Three sailors died on a Greek ship while in pirate custody.

Pirates tried to murder three ship's security personnel after they unsuccessfully defended a Marshall Islands ship using non-lethal methods.

Pirates beat an Indian crew after taking over their ship.

A hostage on a French yacht was killed when French forces stormed it.

Five Indian crew members were injured when Yemen soldiers stormed their ship to rescue them.

As you can see, the pirates are not really keeping their victims safe.

Ranb
But wait! I thought if you just complied no harm would ever come to you!? My whole world is crashing down around me.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom