Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Okay, that's really getting pretty far off-topic, deserving of its own thread without the baggage that goes along with this one. Maybe it would be a good idea to start a new thread with this information, if it seems interesting enough.

I'm more interested, Quad4_72, of your assessment of the last few posts by gumboot and myself regarding the more complicated issues of the region, and why you have implied thus far that they would not come into play.
 
Okay, that's really getting pretty far off-topic, deserving of its own thread without the baggage that goes along with this one. Maybe it would be a good idea to start a new thread with this information, if it seems interesting enough.

I'm more interested, Quad4_72, of your assessment of the last few posts by gumboot and myself regarding the more complicated issues of the region, and why you have implied thus far that they would not come into play.

Obviously Somalia is a complete mess. I am not too sure what question you are asking me. Again obviously, the root of the problem of piracy comes from the societal structure of Somalia. I believe that if all ships were armed, somalis would stop attempting piracy. What logic is there in sending out boats to take ships and having none of them return? No profit comes from that so the piracy would eventually stop. So what is your question?
 
Okay, that's really getting pretty far off-topic, deserving of its own thread without the baggage that goes along with this one. Maybe it would be a good idea to start a new thread with this information, if it seems interesting enough.

I'm more interested, Quad4_72, of your assessment of the last few posts by gumboot and myself regarding the more complicated issues of the region, and why you have implied thus far that they would not come into play.
From my standpoint, there are 2 issues that must be dealt with at the same time:
1. Make piracy unprofitable
2. Stabilize the government and economy of Somalia
The first is easy to do, but will merely cause more festering of the on-ground problem.
Unfortunately, the US cannot do anything about stabilization without 3/4's of the world screaming "Imperialism", and the UN lacks the backing (and thus, the will) to do anything effective.
Catch-22 anybody?
 
Here is a great website to compare military forces:
www.globalfirepower.com

If you notice, Canada is nowhere near the top in any category whatsoever whereas the United States is in the top three for almost every single category (Comparing Canada and the United States for military is like comparing an NFL football team to a peewee team). One thing to take note of is the United States overwhelming supremacy in air power and sea power. Then on the home page if you look at the overall top list, the United States is number one.

Er... I'm not sure what this is supposed to prove. In fact, I can't glean much from the site... are we still talking man-for-man ? Because if you're talking about total manpower, then sure, a country with 300+ million people will have a stronger military than one with 30.
 
Er... I'm not sure what this is supposed to prove. In fact, I can't glean much from the site... are we still talking man-for-man ? Because if you're talking about total manpower, then sure, a country with 300+ million people will have a stronger military than one with 30.

This is very off topic. If you want to go by personal experience, my experience with Canadian soldiers is not really all that great. To me they were all very goofy and quite awkward when taking charge. Not to mention most of the time they didn't really know what they were talking about. If you want to go from combat experience, the U.S. has vast amounts of experience over Canada. I don't really see how you can compare Canada and the U.S.
 
Obviously Somalia is a complete mess. I am not too sure what question you are asking me. Again obviously, the root of the problem of piracy comes from the societal structure of Somalia. I believe that if all ships were armed, somalis would stop attempting piracy. What logic is there in sending out boats to take ships and having none of them return? No profit comes from that so the piracy would eventually stop. So what is your question?

My question is, in light of the information gumboot and I were discussing that specifically demonstrates that the piracy is not likely to stop simply because the ships are armed, for what reason do you continue to assert that the piracy will somehow stop when their success rate has already gone down considerably and yet the rate of attacks has increased in equally considerable amounts? Neither you nor anyone else has actually answered that. You've simply asserted that the piracy would eventually stop. What time frame is the "eventually" we're talking about here? 6-12 months? 3-5 years? A decade? Exactly what kind of military presence should be present during this span of time, or do you also assert that a military presence would not be necessary?
 
From my standpoint, there are 2 issues that must be dealt with at the same time:
1. Make piracy unprofitable
2. Stabilize the government and economy of Somalia
The first is easy to do, but will merely cause more festering of the on-ground problem.
Unfortunately, the US cannot do anything about stabilization without 3/4's of the world screaming "Imperialism", and the UN lacks the backing (and thus, the will) to do anything effective.
Catch-22 anybody?

I'd call it a false dichotomy instead of a catch-22. As to the two issues that must be dealt with:
1. Piracy is already unprofitable compared to ten years ago, and yet the pirate groups continue to redouble their efforts. Where do you suggest is their breaking point? You and a few others continue to assert that it's simple, but I'm still not convinced based on the answers you've been giving me. Is there something you're leaving out?
2. We're not going to be able to magically stabilize the government of Somalia, and even if we could there would be Ethiopia and Kenya to deal with directly following it. In reality, the entire AU (or, for non-US, the UA) needs to stabilize for the roots of this problem to abate. The UN isn't going to be able to bring stability in this case, even if the US were to lead the charge. The AU members bicker worse than Republicans and Democrats in the US Congress, so I'm not seeing much hope in them stepping in with much authority.
 
My question is, in light of the information gumboot and I were discussing that specifically demonstrates that the piracy is not likely to stop simply because the ships are armed, for what reason do you continue to assert that the piracy will somehow stop when their success rate has already gone down considerably and yet the rate of attacks has increased in equally considerable amounts? Neither you nor anyone else has actually answered that. You've simply asserted that the piracy would eventually stop. What time frame is the "eventually" we're talking about here? 6-12 months? 3-5 years? A decade? Exactly what kind of military presence should be present during this span of time, or do you also assert that a military presence would not be necessary?

The information provided really does not show that piracy won't stop if ships are armed. Why you ask? Because they have still had success with ships that are unarmed and will probably continue their piracy until all ships are armed. The statistics do not demonstrate what would happen if all ships are armed. If the pirates come to realize that they have NO chance at a profit because all of their boats are being destroyed every time they try to board a ship, piracy would stop. Does anyone here really deny this? Why would pirates keep attempting to board ships if all of them are armed and they fail every time? The statistics simply cannot account for this situation because it has never happened before or came even close to happening.
 
I'd call it a false dichotomy instead of a catch-22. As to the two issues that must be dealt with:
1. Piracy is already unprofitable compared to ten years ago, and yet the pirate groups continue to redouble their efforts.

I would actually dispute that premise. Again, I cite the very high ransoms paid out in 2008 and the high number of ransoms paid in 2007 as evidence that piracy has become increasingly profitable. I think that has more to do with the increase than anything else.

In 2007 over half of all attempted hijackings off Somali were successful, and at least half of these paid out a ransom - all of the public ransom amounts are in excess of $1 million.

In 2008 again the pirates saw a lot of ransoms paid, and this time some very big amounts.

What's motivating these pirates? It's money. You give them money and they'll keep trying, and they'll recruit more pirates, and attract others to start their own ventures, and piracy will increase.
 
What's motivating these pirates? It's money. You give them money and they'll keep trying, and they'll recruit more pirates, and attract others to start their own ventures, and piracy will increase.

And if you don't give them the chance to even attempt to ask for a ransom by arming the ships and not letting them even close the to the ships, piracy decreases or disappear. Start putting pirates at the bottom of the sea instead of giving them money, why would they keep trying if their main source of motivation disappears?
 
I would actually dispute that premise. Again, I cite the very high ransoms paid out in 2008 and the high number of ransoms paid in 2007 as evidence that piracy has become increasingly profitable. I think that has more to do with the increase than anything else.

In 2007 over half of all attempted hijackings off Somali were successful, and at least half of these paid out a ransom - all of the public ransom amounts are in excess of $1 million.

In 2008 again the pirates saw a lot of ransoms paid, and this time some very big amounts.

What's motivating these pirates? It's money. You give them money and they'll keep trying, and they'll recruit more pirates, and attract others to start their own ventures, and piracy will increase.

They've already gotten money. It's not like those ponies are going back into the stable.

The difference here is that one of the posited outcomes of armed ships is a decrease in piracy. However, I submit that such a premise assumes little or no strategic response on the part of the Somali pirates, who have already had a taste of the money and, I agree, want more. There's just as much chance (if not more) that in response to armed ships that they'll do their damnedest to make it less profitable to keep up the firefights than it will be to pay their ransoms.

The strategy you're suggesting is simple attrition, and there's no reason they won't respond with attrition tactics of their own. The application of it may differ from the larger, stronger resources of the ship-owning/operating nations, but it's attrition regardless and I don't see these shipping companies willing to wage long-term attrition against the pirates when it affects their bottom line. The likelihood of needing military to supplement for them is very high (and likely), and it should be fairly obvious that the application of military is only going to be workable as long as public opinion is favorable.
 
And if you don't give them the chance to even attempt to ask for a ransom by arming the ships and not letting them even close the to the ships, piracy decreases or disappear. Start putting pirates at the bottom of the sea instead of giving them money, why would they keep trying if their main source of motivation disappears?

You're missing a whole host of complicating factors or assuming that the pirates are completely stupid.
 
You're missing a whole host of complicating factors or assuming that the pirates are completely stupid.

Actually, it seems I am the one assuming they are NOT stupid. They will stop trying to take ships if everytime they attempt to they lose their lives. I wonder how exactly you think they will change their tactics though. Your IED scenario is simply implausible so please don't cite it again.
 
The difference here is that one of the posited outcomes of armed ships is a decrease in piracy. However, I submit that such a premise assumes little or no strategic response on the part of the Somali pirates, who have already had a taste of the money and, I agree, want more. There's just as much chance (if not more) that in response to armed ships that they'll do their damnedest to make it less profitable to keep up the firefights than it will be to pay their ransoms.

I see your point, but I think you're A) overestimating the pirates' ability to escalate, and B) underestimating the ease with which these attacks can be repulsed.

The pirates appear to already be operating at the limit of their capability, whereas the ships have still got a lot of head room.


The strategy you're suggesting is simple attrition, and there's no reason they won't respond with attrition tactics of their own.

You only have a shot at attrition if you can muster sufficient resources to compete with your opponent. What I've read suggests the pirates don't have a hope of doing so.


I don't see these shipping companies willing to wage long-term attrition against the pirates when it affects their bottom line.

I don't see how allowing crews to take measures to defend themselves would affect the shipping company's bottom line at all.


The likelihood of needing military to supplement for them is very high (and likely), and it should be fairly obvious that the application of military is only going to be workable as long as public opinion is favorable.

The reality is there has been an international armada of warships in that region for about two decades, and they're not going away any time soon. Piracy is only one of their many duties.

I think if we want to stop piracy, the Malaccan Straits offer a good lesson. What put a lid on the most active pirate region in the world was a combined naval effort.
 
All of the data for all five years?

All 1214 events recorded worldwide for 4 1/2 years.

There's more data in the detail records but what's on the map page is enough for making selections by location, date and type of event.
 
Actually, it seems I am the one assuming they are NOT stupid. They will stop trying to take ships if everytime they attempt to they lose their lives. I wonder how exactly you think they will change their tactics though. Your IED scenario is simply implausible so please don't cite it again.

You're falling back into creating straw men again, and it's equally unconvincing this time around. At no point did I mention any IEDs. Why you jumped to that conclusion is your own malfunction.
 
All 1214 events recorded worldwide for 4 1/2 years.

There's more data in the detail records but what's on the map page is enough for making selections by location, date and type of event.


Ah right. I was more interested in the details than the general incident data.
 
I see your point, but I think you're A) overestimating the pirates' ability to escalate, and B) underestimating the ease with which these attacks can be repulsed.

The pirates appear to already be operating at the limit of their capability, whereas the ships have still got a lot of head room.

In the long run I think this is the crux on how things are going to go.

I hope I am overestimating their potential for escalation. I hope it remains easy to brush them off. If that turns out being the case then I'd be happy to admit to being wrong.
 
You're falling back into creating straw men again, and it's equally unconvincing this time around. At no point did I mention any IEDs. Why you jumped to that conclusion is your own malfunction.

My apologies that was Dan O. who had the insane IED idea.
 
That's cool, no harm no foul. Just keep in mind that not everyone who is skeptical of the "arm the sailors" approach is so for the same reasons.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom