Normal Dude
Space Shuttle Door Gunner
- Joined
- Jul 22, 2007
- Messages
- 3,966
You don't think that if all ships did this the pirates would just go and get more guns?
Isn't that what you would do?
So they would have two AKs per pirate?
You don't think that if all ships did this the pirates would just go and get more guns?
Isn't that what you would do?
So I am a communist for being concerned about the safety of the crew?
I doubt they are able to escalate much further.
But arming crews will create its own problems*, a solution would be armed guards onboard.
And it will probably happen soon after the cost of hijacked vessels exceed the cost of guards.
*Remember you will have to arm all vessels, not just the ones that get attacked, and not all sailers can be trusted with a firearm.
Wait I thought this was not about safety, but about not being sheep. Could you present a consistent argument.
Not being sheep IS about safety.
If all the crew were willing to step up and defend themselves with weapons, the pirates would never even be able to board the ship.
No you made it clear, it is about being men, not about looking for the outcome were you are alive at the end. You made it clear that dieing bravely is better than being a hostage even if you live at the end of it.
Is this true? It you do not present an evidence that it will be so absolutely effective. For example first you would have to show that ships always see the pirates before the board.
So unless it's guaranteed 100% effective nothing should be done?Is this true? It you do not present an evidence that it will be so absolutely effective. For example first you would have to show that ships always see the pirates before the board.
Apparently you have not read a single post in the thread. You can see if pirates are approaching the ship by posting guards. Please try and keep up.
So unless it's guaranteed 100% effective nothing should be done?![]()
Who claimed 100% effectiveness? 100% isn't an animal that exists much in the real world.But the claims here have been for easy 100% effective solutions. It is so easy anyone can do it, and it will always be effective. That is all it seems to need, a couple of rifles will solve the problem every time according to many of the posts here.
So how many guards do you need to be sure to see the pirates at a useful distance?
But the claims here have been for easy 100% effective solutions. It is so easy anyone can do it, and it will always be effective. That is all it seems to need, a couple of rifles will solve the problem every time according to many of the posts here.
Or two pirates. Or two pirates with .50cals rather than AKs. Or two pirates with RPGs.So they would have two AKs per pirate?
From all I have seen, crews have been kept safe by pirates. They're not much use as ransom when dead. I do not think that engaging in gun battles would make them safer.
Who claimed 100% effectiveness?
So "easy solution" requires 100% effectiveness in your world?Nobody. But it was labeled an "easy" solution.
So "easy solution" requires 100% effectiveness in your world?
Apparently you have not read a single post in the thread. You can see if pirates are approaching the ship by posting guards. Please try and keep up.
So "easy solution" requires 100% effectiveness in your world?