Easy solution to the pirate problem...

I doubt they are able to escalate much further.

But arming crews will create its own problems*, a solution would be armed guards onboard.
And it will probably happen soon after the cost of hijacked vessels exceed the cost of guards.

*Remember you will have to arm all vessels, not just the ones that get attacked, and not all sailers can be trusted with a firearm.

If you can't trust random people from the third world with fire arms who can you trust.
 
Wait I thought this was not about safety, but about not being sheep. Could you present a consistent argument.

Not being sheep IS about safety. If all the crew were willing to step up and defend themselves with weapons, the pirates would never even be able to board the ship. If they were to let the pirates board the ship, they put themselves in much more danger. You aren't really thinking this through are you?
 
Not being sheep IS about safety.

No you made it clear, it is about being men, not about looking for the outcome were you are alive at the end. You made it clear that dieing bravely is better than being a hostage even if you live at the end of it.

If all the crew were willing to step up and defend themselves with weapons, the pirates would never even be able to board the ship.

Is this true? It you do not present an evidence that it will be so absolutely effective. For example first you would have to show that ships always see the pirates before the board.
 
No you made it clear, it is about being men, not about looking for the outcome were you are alive at the end. You made it clear that dieing bravely is better than being a hostage even if you live at the end of it.



Is this true? It you do not present an evidence that it will be so absolutely effective. For example first you would have to show that ships always see the pirates before the board.

So we can predict the future now huh? Your premise assumes that you know the outcome of your choices. If pirates try to board the ship, you have no idea if they are going to take you hostage and eventually kill you or not. That is why you defend yourself. You don't give them the chance.

Apparently you have not read a single post in the thread. You can see if pirates are approaching the ship by posting guards. Please try and keep up.
 
Is this true? It you do not present an evidence that it will be so absolutely effective. For example first you would have to show that ships always see the pirates before the board.
So unless it's guaranteed 100% effective nothing should be done? :rolleyes:
 
Apparently you have not read a single post in the thread. You can see if pirates are approaching the ship by posting guards. Please try and keep up.

So how many guards do you need to be sure to see the pirates at a useful distance?
 
So unless it's guaranteed 100% effective nothing should be done? :rolleyes:

But the claims here have been for easy 100% effective solutions. It is so easy anyone can do it, and it will always be effective. That is all it seems to need, a couple of rifles will solve the problem every time according to many of the posts here.
 
But the claims here have been for easy 100% effective solutions. It is so easy anyone can do it, and it will always be effective. That is all it seems to need, a couple of rifles will solve the problem every time according to many of the posts here.
Who claimed 100% effectiveness? 100% isn't an animal that exists much in the real world.
 
But the claims here have been for easy 100% effective solutions. It is so easy anyone can do it, and it will always be effective. That is all it seems to need, a couple of rifles will solve the problem every time according to many of the posts here.

No one claimed 100% effectiveness. But to be honest, as I have already outlined it would not be difficult to repel pirates if they are attempting to board the ship and you have a rifle.
 
From all I have seen, crews have been kept safe by pirates. They're not much use as ransom when dead. I do not think that engaging in gun battles would make them safer.


Others have already pointed out this isn't entirely true, but here's some hard data:

In 2008 2 ships were boarded and 42 hijacked by Somali pirates. 815 crew members were taken hostage, 2 were reported injured, 4 were killed, and 14 are missing.

In Q1, 2009 a total of 9 ships were hijacked by Somali pirates, and 1 boarded. 157 crew members were taken hostage, and 4 injured.

As of 31st March 2009 Somali pirates still held 160 crew members hostage.
 
For what it's work, after the IMB stressed that Masters should do everything they could to resist hijacking, the rate of successful pirate attacks in the first quarter of 2009 dropped dramatically compared with the previous year.
 
So "easy solution" requires 100% effectiveness in your world?

Well if we take gumboot's figures for 2008 and assume all the missing are dead (I assume that was the bunch who were probably on that boat india blew apart) that gives you a 2.2% death rate. Crews are not being paid to die (security personel change that part of the equation but they are expensive) so any action taken by the crew needs to have at least a 97% sucess rate where sucess is defined as no crew memeber dies..
 
Apparently you have not read a single post in the thread. You can see if pirates are approaching the ship by posting guards. Please try and keep up.

You've just claimed that cutting out opperations should be pretty much imposible. Centuries of militry history suggest otherwise.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom