Easy solution to the pirate problem...

But wait! I thought if you just complied no harm would ever come to you!? My whole world is crashing down around me.
Someone said they would invite the pirates on the ship for tea...

Okay, I've complained once about this already, but it really isn't helpful to keep shifting over to extremes one way or the other or assuming the worst about the reasons for disagreement. I've already complained to ponderingturtle (who appears to disagree with your solution) for doing this, and now I'm letting you know the same thing. I'm fairly certain that you have more sense than to lump any resistance to your idea as advocating complete submission and acquiescence. What the sailors who have been taken so far have been doing is certainly not simple compliance, and to suggest as much isn't very respectful to those who have been taken.

I agree with your earlier statement that it would be a shame to have the heads of these companies more concerned about money than the lives of the sailors. The bottom line is something that gets in the way of a lot of ideas that could make lives safer.
 
Which has everything to do with blowing open the door of a safe room and nothing to do with your contention that they seek to sink a ship with drone boats loaded with explosives or IEDs in shipping lanes.

Have a few armed guards on the ship and they never board in the first place, and no one needs to cower inside a safe room hoping the pirates don't blow the door open.

And for some reason no crew seems to want to invite the pirates aboard for a cup of tea...
 
Which has everything to do with blowing open the door of a safe room and nothing to do with your contention that they seek to sink a ship with drone boats loaded with explosives or IEDs in shipping lanes.

It has everything to do with the pirates adjusting their strategies to meet the changing defenses.

If arming the crews prevented the pirates from seizing ships with their current tactics, the pirates will be forced to either give up piracy and stay home where they face a life of slow starvation or find an alternative to counter the small arms of the crew.

I'm not saying that the pirates will resort to using IEDs. Only that the IED scenario I presented is a possibility if the use of force is escalated and that nobody here has offered any counter-measures against it.
 
It has everything to do with the pirates adjusting their strategies to meet the changing defenses.

If arming the crews prevented the pirates from seizing ships with their current tactics, the pirates will be forced to either give up piracy and stay home where they face a life of slow starvation or find an alternative to counter the small arms of the crew.

I'm not saying that the pirates will resort to using IEDs. Only that the IED scenario I presented is a possibility if the use of force is escalated and that nobody here has offered any counter-measures against it.

The pirates can get explosives to open doors all they want. If they can't board the ship due to the crew being armed it really makes no difference. And you should probably drop the IED thing. It's quite silly.
 
It has everything to do with the pirates adjusting their strategies to meet the changing defenses.

If arming the crews prevented the pirates from seizing ships with their current tactics, the pirates will be forced to either give up piracy and stay home where they face a life of slow starvation or find an alternative to counter the small arms of the crew.

I'm not saying that the pirates will resort to using IEDs. Only that the IED scenario I presented is a possibility if the use of force is escalated and that nobody here has offered any counter-measures against it.


Just out of curiosity, is there any actual limit to how far you can envision pirates continuing to escalate and adapt? Is there a line, somewhere, where they could be stopped, via defense and lethal force? Or do you envision them continually ramping up forever and ever? Do you feel that there is not any way to stop this problem with force? Is that your position?

Not trying to put words in your mouth, or state your position for you in a negative way. I'm geniunely curious. You seem to keep on going back to them escalating and escalating. I wonder how far you think they would actually go? Or how far you believe they are willing or able to go?
 
Last edited:
Just out of curiosity, is there any actual limit to how far you can envision pirates continuing to escalate and adapt? Is there a line, somewhere, where they could be stopped, via defense and lethal force? Or do you envision them continually ramping up forever and ever? Do you feel that there is not any way to stop this problem with force? Is that your position?

Not trying to put words in your mouth, or state your position for you in a negative way. I'm geniunely curious. You seem to keep on going back to them escalating and escalating. I wonder how far you think they would actually go? Or how far you believe they are willing or able to go?

That's a good question. I believe they would escalate as far as they could. For me, the main question is how far they are actually capable of escalating, not whether they will or not. I think the conversation between gumboot, Quad4_72, and myself pretty much reached that point and from there it becomes conjecture. On that question I'm definitely hoping that their assessments of their upper limit are more accurate than mine, though I will state that even my own projected limit is lower than what Dan O. seems to be suggesting.
 
I doubt they are able to escalate much further.

But arming crews will create its own problems*, a solution would be armed guards onboard.
And it will probably happen soon after the cost of hijacked vessels exceed the cost of guards.

*Remember you will have to arm all vessels, not just the ones that get attacked, and not all sailers can be trusted with a firearm.
 
There is the limit of how far the pirates are willing to escalate and how far they are capable of escalating. Their will is a mater of necessity. When the alternative to escalation is to go back to their homes where there are no jobs and insufficient food, the risk of being a pirate doesn't look that bad.

The capability to escalate is limited by money. In the current operations, a war lord or other financier supplies the pirates with what they need for the mission and in return gets the majority of the take.

Most of the financiers are either already out of the country or looking to leave to start a better life once they've accumulated a sufficient nest egg.

In the current conditions, the financiers will want to limit violence that causes damage to the ships and injuries or deaths of the crews. They don't want to escalate to the level that will trigger operations to capture or kill the financiers. However, if we start indiscriminately killing the pirates, some financiers will shift from being motivated only by money to being jihadist with no bounds on what they will support.
 
Whether it is the crew shooting guns at the pirates or guards it really doesn't matter. Yes in that particular incident the pirate problem was solved. Now if all ships did that the pirate problem would be solved completely.
You don't think that if all ships did this the pirates would just go and get more guns?

Isn't that what you would do?
 
The pirates use of guns and RPGs so far has been a show of force. They aren't there to fight a gun battle. When the merchant ships are armed and start shooting back, the pirates will find some other way to make a living. There is no work in Somalia and nobody is going to hire Somalian pirates for legitimate work so they will continue piracy but find another way that doesn't involve a high risk gun fight.

Demanding "protection" money is one way to avoid the gun battle. Teaming up with Lloyds and demanding increases in "insurance" money is another. Both still require a "show of force" to backup the demand but don't require getting into a gun battle.
 
You don't think that if all ships did this the pirates would just go and get more guns?

Isn't that what you would do?

You don't know too much about the pirate situation do you? Each one of them is armed with at least on AK47 and they also bring RPGs on occasion. They use small boats to board large ships. What other firepower do you suppose they are going to start bringing along? Additionally, what difference do you think that will make if the ships they are trying to board are sufficiently armed? Remember, we have already established that it is basically impossible to board a ship while taking fire.
 
The pirates use of guns and RPGs so far has been a show of force. They aren't there to fight a gun battle. When the merchant ships are armed and start shooting back, the pirates will find some other way to make a living. There is no work in Somalia and nobody is going to hire Somalian pirates for legitimate work so they will continue piracy but find another way that doesn't involve a high risk gun fight.

Demanding "protection" money is one way to avoid the gun battle. Teaming up with Lloyds and demanding increases in "insurance" money is another. Both still require a "show of force" to backup the demand but don't require getting into a gun battle.

So you are agreeing then that if merchant ships were to arm themselves and defend their boats piracy would cease?
 
I doubt they are able to escalate much further.

But arming crews will create its own problems*, a solution would be armed guards onboard.
And it will probably happen soon after the cost of hijacked vessels exceed the cost of guards.

*Remember you will have to arm all vessels, not just the ones that get attacked, and not all sailers can be trusted with a firearm.
.
Back in the old days, when the pirates and society were just about equally armed, the pirates tended to lose in determined conflicts intended to stamp them out.
AKs and RPGs are no defense against what the civilized world could bring to combat them today,
 
.
Back in the old days, when the pirates and society were just about equally armed, the pirates tended to lose in determined conflicts intended to stamp them out.
AKs and RPGs are no defense against what the civilized world could bring to combat them today,

The pirates are currently a diffuse target.
If they get bigger well armed boats, they will make themselfes a obvius target.

So no, they cannot escalate much further than what they can bring in a small boat. And if they make too much of a nuiance of themselfes there will be "punitive expeditions" against their bases/home ports.
 
However, if we start indiscriminately killing the pirates, some financiers will shift from being motivated only by money to being jihadist with no bounds on what they will support.

Wait, what?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom