Easy solution to the pirate problem...

In the long run I think this is the crux on how things are going to go.

I hope I am overestimating their potential for escalation. I hope it remains easy to brush them off. If that turns out being the case then I'd be happy to admit to being wrong.

Like I said, if all ships armed themselves I am convinced that the piracy would cease. While I say that is what they should do, I don't think it is what they are going to do. People are too ignorant about the use of guns and think that the second a gun gets put on their ship it is immediately going to start firing and killing all the crew.
 
If, following an unsuccessful attack, an attacking boat is followed back to the mother ship, which can't be that far away, then sink the mother ship!
Do that a time or two, and the number of attacks will drop alot, as the supply of mother ships is most likely limited!
 
Ah right. I was more interested in the details than the general incident data.

The general data provides the framework for filling in the details and insures that you aren't missing anything.

A natural bounds of the Somali pirate operations is -10º to +20º latitude and 40º to 65º East longitude. There is no way to tell for sure that these are Somali pirates without capturing them but the maps overlaid for all 5 years shows pretty clear boundaries except to the east.

Using these bounds, there are 315 events.
Code:
 Piracy	attempt	firedon	boarded	hijack	All
 2005	15	14	1	14	44
 2006	11	3		5	19
 2007	27	7		13	47
 2008	36	32	6	38	112
 2009	27	43	2	21	93
 All	116	99	9	91	315
 
What would it prove if such a device was or was not used in the past?

My point is that it does not exist and has never been used by Somalis before let alone anyone else so it is a very implausible scenario.
 
My point is that it does not exist and has never been used by Somalis before let alone anyone else so it is a very implausible scenario.

There was a day before pirates used RPGs to attack ships. Is the use of RPGs implausible?
 
There was a day before pirates used RPGs to attack ships. Is the use of RPGs implausible?

That's strange. We are talking about your mysterious IED radio controlled dinghys and you change the topic to RPGs. Why did you do that? Is it because you have no proof of the dinghys?
 
That's strange. We are talking about your mysterious IED radio controlled dinghys and you change the topic to RPGs. Why did you do that? Is it because you have no proof of the dinghys?

You don't deserve an answer.

I am now putting Quad4_72 on ignore.
 
You don't deserve an answer.

I am now putting Quad4_72 on ignore.

Hahaha. There are some REALLY sensitive people in this forum. I guess it is much easier to just put me on ignore instead of confessing that his idea was stupid.
 
If, following an unsuccessful attack, an attacking boat is followed back to the mother ship, which can't be that far away, then sink the mother ship!
Do that a time or two, and the number of attacks will drop alot, as the supply of mother ships is most likely limited!

Unless the mother "ship" is, in fact, Somalia.
 
Looks like the consensus is to give in to blackmail.
That has always worked. Look at Europe in 1939, among others.

This is why Carter was a stronger president than Reagan, he at least tried to free hostages with force, while Reagan just gave them more guns.
 
Threats of escalation are only effective if you can actually carry out the threat. Blustering is expected. They have NOT escalated--only threatened to do so.

This does seem to have been Bush's aproach to Bin Laden when he took office.
 
Well, it is no longer pre-2001, and I have what I would do or what I would have done if I was involved in a life threatening situation like that. I know what I could do, but that is one of those "wait and see" things.


And Quad is making massively stupid statements about how one always needs to use force to resist instead of complaince. This shows that the captian of the american ship who was taken hostage must be a coward by his definition.
 
Are you serious? Maybe that's where our outlooks are different, because there isn't much different in what I know I would do now compared to what I would have done pre-9/11. Considering a life-threatening situation, in neither case does that involve simply rolling over.

So you would rather kill the whole plane than submit.
 
So you would rather kill the whole plane than submit.

Well, since you already seem to know my intentions you can probably answer for me as well.

What is it with the habit here of people switching to black-or-white, this-or-that, pseudo-false-dichotomy mode any time an answer is given that doesn't completely agree with them?
 
Arguing semantics now are we?

Training and numbers are now to be considered semantics? Over 2000 years of militry history suggests that approach should be considered to be unreasonable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom