Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Threats of escalation are only effective if you can actually carry out the threat. Blustering is expected. They have NOT escalated--only threatened to do so.
When faced with actually having to carry through, they turned tail as soon as resistance was shown.

And the quotes in the links you provided about the pirates purchasing more and more high-powered weapons (like grenade launchers)? Is this not going to come into play down the road?
 
.
"Q-ships" from WWI and WWII.. Also called "commerce raiders".
The German Navy used these quite successfully for awhile, until the Allied navies sought them out and sank them.

"Q ships" were used by the allies for ambushing submarines (principally).
"Q ships" weren't commerce raiders; their mission was attacking enemy
warships.

You may be thinking of "merchant raiders" (warships disguised as
non-combatant merchantmen whose mission was attacking enemy
merchant ships).
 
And the quotes in the links you provided about the pirates purchasing more and more high-powered weapons (like grenade launchers)? Is this not going to come into play down the road?
They had the grenade launchers before.

No evidence at all they have any more weapons now than they did before.
 
Are you really that obstinately unwilling to admit that it's not quite as simple or as black-or-white as the last umpteen pages of bickering have attempted to make it out as being?

Like I said: convince me. Do so without the hyperbole and emotional nonsense. I'm willing to be convinced, but I'm gonna need more than a "shoot em all and let dog sort em out" explanation.
 
Last edited:
Are you really that obstinately unwilling to admit that it's not quite as simple or as black-or-white as the last umpteen pages of bickering have attempted to make it out as being?

Like I said: convince me. Do so without the hyperbole and emotional nonsense. I'm willing to be convinced, but I'm gonna need more than a "shoot em all and let dog sort em out" explanation.
It actually is that simple. The pirates have a 0% success rate against ships which had armed guards on board.

They have a 100% success rate against crews which invite them aboard for a cup of tea.
 
And why don't you stop being so full of crap? Like I said already, I'm no dove. Your constant need to prejudge and talk smack at the slightest disagreement displays a lack on your part, not mine. I'm not impressed by the macho talk, and nine times out of ten the dudes who talk like that feel like they have something to prove for one reason or another, none of it having anything to do with me. So do me a favor and either keep me out of your posturing BS or put up with a convincing argument. Thus far WildCat has come closest to doing so, which gives me a great deal more intellectual respect than your responses have in this thread. If you can't put up with a reasoned argument, then shut the hell up already.



Yeah, I've gathered as much already. Now provide a convincing, reasoned explanation as to why you think it's the best solution, and if it's within your capabilities you might want to explain why you think it's actually a solution to the problem in the first place.

Oh, and "what he said" isn't going to cut it. Man up and put it in your own words if you want to be taken seriously at this point.

What more do you want? Honestly, it really doesn't matter to me which direction shipping companies take, as long as it involves arming people with weapons on the ship to keep guard. Whether it be actual security guards or members of the crew it makes no difference. We have seen from actual accounts that the pirates turn tail and run when they start taking fire. And that was just from pistols. Imagine if rifles were shooting at them. The pirates would probably lose their lives instead of just making a getaway.
 
Historic evidence. Pre 2001 would you, if you were on a hijacked air plane have put up resistance or offered complaince? The issue is escalation, and what will result in the best solution.

The orrigion of these claims is largely the idea that a rifle or two on board a ship is all you need to absolutely defend them, that was the claim at the start of this thread. Now the claims are becomeing more and more extravegent in terms of what you need to equip these ships with. The point is that this is not a simple solution, and the exact effects are hard to determine....

Well, it is no longer pre-2001, and I have what I would do or what I would have done if I was involved in a life threatening situation like that. I know what I could do, but that is one of those "wait and see" things.

Belz's claim was something he made up from thin air, then tried to pass off as hyperbole. I would not be surprized if he knew what he said was wrong from the beginning. I think he cannot stand the idea of people using deadly force to protect themselves from those who shoot at them.

Ranb
 
What more do you want? Honestly, it really doesn't matter to me which direction shipping companies take, as long as it involves arming people with weapons on the ship to keep guard. Whether it be actual security guards or members of the crew it makes no difference. We have seen from actual accounts that the pirates turn tail and run when they start taking fire. And that was just from pistols. Imagine if rifles were shooting at them. The pirates would probably lose their lives instead of just making a getaway.

See, now your responses are getting better.

Yes, from actual accounts so far it does look like having armed and trained crews is helping to chase off pirates. The main concern I've voiced is whether they're going to react with more force and more aggression as a result, and as of yet it's way too early to tell. Since you seem so positively convinced as to the outcome I'm asking you to quantify why you're so sure of how things are going to pan out. So far I've seen very little in the way of quantifying, outside of using the very short amount of time that's passed so far as your proof.

Are you prepared to change your outlook of things do change? I certainly would prefer that the trend of more armed crews out there stops the piracy altogether, but I'm not as optimistic as you seem to be and I'm asking you to quantify your optimism. My concerns are regarding six, nine, or twelve months down the road, when the flush from the first victories over the pirates has faded. Are they going to stop? If so, why? If not, then what's going to be the general situation? How does what you suggest be done play into all of this? Armaments and firearms training as a standard practice for sailors from now on?
 
Well, it is no longer pre-2001, and I have what I would do or what I would have done if I was involved in a life threatening situation like that. I know what I could do, but that is one of those "wait and see" things.

Are you serious? Maybe that's where our outlooks are different, because there isn't much different in what I know I would do now compared to what I would have done pre-9/11. Considering a life-threatening situation, in neither case does that involve simply rolling over.
 
See, now your responses are getting better.

Yes, from actual accounts so far it does look like having armed and trained crews is helping to chase off pirates. The main concern I've voiced is whether they're going to react with more force and more aggression as a result, and as of yet it's way too early to tell. Since you seem so positively convinced as to the outcome I'm asking you to quantify why you're so sure of how things are going to pan out. So far I've seen very little in the way of quantifying, outside of using the very short amount of time that's passed so far as your proof.

Are you prepared to change your outlook of things do change? I certainly would prefer that the trend of more armed crews out there stops the piracy altogether, but I'm not as optimistic as you seem to be and I'm asking you to quantify your optimism. My concerns are regarding six, nine, or twelve months down the road, when the flush from the first victories over the pirates has faded. Are they going to stop? If so, why? If not, then what's going to be the general situation? How does what you suggest be done play into all of this? Armaments and firearms training as a standard practice for sailors from now on?

As I outlined earlier in the thread, the sailors have substantial tactical advantage when it comes to defending the ship. If all the ships arm themselves, the pirates will learn very quickly that trying to hold ships for ransom is far too difficult and no longer worth the risk. Not wanting to escalate the violence by simply rolling over and letting them take the ship is by no means a solution to the problem. If for some reason down the road the pirates still feel the need to attempt the futile choice of piracy then yes, it may become a standard practice to give armaments and firearms training to all sailors. You gotta do what you have to do to defend yourself. Simple as that.
 
As I outlined earlier in the thread, the sailors have substantial tactical advantage when it comes to defending the ship. If all the ships arm themselves, the pirates will learn very quickly that trying to hold ships for ransom is far too difficult and no longer worth the risk. Not wanting to escalate the violence by simply rolling over and letting them take the ship is by no means a solution to the problem. If for some reason down the road the pirates still feel the need to attempt the futile choice of piracy then yes, it may become a standard practice to give armaments and firearms training to all sailors. You gotta do what you have to do to defend yourself. Simple as that.

How is it as simple as that? What happens when the navies are eventually shipping off or lowering their presence? The presence of nearby tactical support must come into play with the pirates' decisions, unless you're willing to believe that they're that tactically stupid. The situation simply cannot remain static. There's no realistic way that's going to happen. What is the policy and how is it going to work in a long-term, fluid political environment?

At this point I'm seeing a similar dilemma to that of those who chose to go into Iraq: a workable strategy for the short term with no clear exit strategy for the military presence. There's no denying that our military is practically second to none. What should also not be denied is that there's very little chance that our military or any other nation's military is going to commit to indefinite presence.
 
How is it as simple as that? What happens when the navies are eventually shipping off or lowering their presence? The presence of nearby tactical support must come into play with the pirates' decisions, unless you're willing to believe that they're that tactically stupid. The situation simply cannot remain static. There's no realistic way that's going to happen. What is the policy and how is it going to work in a long-term, fluid political environment?

At this point I'm seeing a similar dilemma to that of those who chose to go into Iraq: a workable strategy for the short term with no clear exit strategy for the military presence. There's no denying that our military is practically second to none. What should also not be denied is that there's very little chance that our military or any other nation's military is going to commit to indefinite presence.

If all ships are armed and ready to defend themselves, there really isn't too much of a need for a large navy presence. Like I said before, it is my prediction that IF all ships were to arm themselves and start defending their ships, the piracy will be significantly lower and eventually cease all together. If the pirates did attempt to keep taking ships, that is actually fine. That way they would all die off much quicker.
 
If all ships are armed and ready to defend themselves, there really isn't too much of a need for a large navy presence. Like I said before, it is my prediction that IF all ships were to arm themselves and start defending their ships, the piracy will be significantly lower and eventually cease all together. If the pirates did attempt to keep taking ships, that is actually fine. That way they would all die off much quicker.

Since I have very little doubt that the pirates would stop-- after all, the people running the pirate crews aren't out there taking the risks-- the only thing I get from that as an explanation is that you expect them to give up through attrition.
 
Since I have very little doubt that the pirates would stop-- after all, the people running the pirate crews aren't out there taking the risks-- the only thing I get from that as an explanation is that you expect them to give up through attrition.

Why would the people sending out the pirate crews keep sending them out when eventually they would not be coming back and they would be receiving no profit? These people would realize that they could focus their efforts on something else besides piracy when no money is flowing in and their manpower supply is fading.
 
Why would the people sending out the pirate crews keep sending them out when eventually they would not be coming back and they would be receiving no profit? These people would realize that they could focus their efforts on something else besides piracy when no money is flowing in and their manpower supply is fading.

So are you confirming that you expect them to stop because of attrition?
 
Okay, so I have been doing some more investigation of the history of attacks off the Somali coast. I have some stats:

(Note, I discounted a couple of incidents that lacked any details, and a couple of others that are believed to be vigilante attacks against illegal fishing)

Total attacks: 101
Successful: 64
Failed: 37

SUCCESSFUL ATTACKS:
Confirmed ransom: 23
Liberated by force: 9
Still held: 8
Other (released without ransom, status unknown): 24

FAILED ATTACKS:
Repelled by military presence: 20
Repelled by ships crew or onboard security (excludes military vessels): 6
Repelled by combination of crew and military: 2
Attack thwarted by maneuvering/speed: 6
Attack thwarted by passive defenses: 1
Other (pirates broke off attack for reasons unknown): 2

CASUALTIES:
Pirates killed: 15 (1 by crew resisting, rest by military liberation)
Crew killed: 6 (1 killed by pirates during hijacking, 4 killed by pirates in captivity, 1 killed during military liberation)
Other killed: 3 (Somali soldiers killed during two unrelated military liberations)

Pirates wounded: unknown
Crew wounded: 8 (3 injured while crew retaking ship, 5 injured during military liberation)
Other wounded: none

What's particularly interesting is if you map the trend over time. In 2005 and 2006 there were only two incidents each year. In each year one incident was successful, one was one. The successful incident in 2005 was ransomed, in 2006 the ship was liberated.

From then onwards, the success rate goes from 100% (2007) to 80% (2008) to 42% (2009). At the same time, successful ransom has dropped even more severely from 50% (2007) to 42% (2008) to 6% (2009) (bearing in mind five ships are still being held from 2009).

In 2007 12% of captured ships were liberated, remaining the same in 2008 but increasing to 18% in 2009.

Pirate tactics have remained constant throughout - the first attack where type of weapons was specified included heavy machine guns and RPGs. These same weapons have been the standard type utilised by pirates throughout, with no indicated that firepower has escalated. Likewise from the beginning pirates have initiated attacks by firing weapons.
 
Some more useful points and observations:

Regarding those ships that have been captured, but that have been released without ransom, or whose status is unknown:

There are quite a few ships that have probably been released after ransom, but that the payment of ransom is not confirmed.

Some ships have been captured, and then utilised by pirates as mother ships.

Some ships were attacked only to be raided for supplies, so were not kept.

Some ships have been released after threats of military intervention.

At least one ship was released by the pirates after they discovered the cargo of food was bound for Somalia.

This is further exacerbated by the fact that the data is not always clear between crew being released and ships being released. Such scenarios (only crew released or only ship released) fall into this category.

Assessing the data, I have come to the conclusion that as a crew member, if you resist you have a high probability of success. In addition, you have higher probability of harm either in the hands of pirate captors or in the event of a military liberation than you do in resisting the initial attack.

In one example a crew utilised improvised weapons in the form of molotiv cocktails, fire hoses and beer bottles to hold off a pirate force armed with heavy machine guns and RPGs. They managed to hold off the pirates for four hours before a helicopter from a Naval vessel arrived on the scene and the pirates retreated. None of the crew were injured.

ETA. Numbers appear to make little difference in the rate of success: in one incident a ship managed to chase off 29 pirate boats using high pressure hoses.
 
Last edited:
Always good to see real data. Did you include the oil tanker that was attacked yesterday? The master decided he didn't want to invite the pirates aboard for tea and used evasive maneuvers to escape.
 
Always good to see real data. Did you include the oil tanker that was attacked yesterday? The master decided he didn't want to invite the pirates aboard for tea and used evasive maneuvers to escape.

The most recent one on the database is the Qana which was hijacked on Sunday and liberated by Yemeni special forces on Monday.

I should note that the list is not a complete list of every single attack. The rates of success in my list should be regarded as much higher than reality. For example in 2008 there were a total of 111 recorded attacks, of which 42 were successful (38%) compared with the 51 in my database of which 40 were successful (78%).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom