Easy solution to the pirate problem...

I think you are not being truthful.

Simply exaggerating. I'm aware that shots are probably being fired, but killing hostages is usually not a good idea.

I am not a fan of the "bend over and take it" defense. You seem to be though.

I prefer to live. I also prefer when kids are not orphaned and wives widowed because somebody decided to play hero.

If you are going to respond, then why not directly answer the question instead of being evasive?

When have I been evasive ?
 
So basically to sum up this thread, it has been proved, both through circumstantial evidence and actual accounts that arming personnel on the ship is actually a very good idea.

Er... no. There appears to be some disagreement about that, remember ?

It also seems that the only person not accepting this fact is Belz.

Well, that's good to hear. It's a damn good thing that this isn't a poll, then.

Judging by his comments after he has been proved embarrassingly wrong, he is just trying to save face now.

Hilarious. The only thing I've been consistently saying is that the question is complicated, not "simple" as the OP claimed. So, perhaps you were thinking of someone else, because others here have been less compromising about the issue.
 
It is certainly greater than if they don't get killed.
You have shown no evidence that there is a greater risk of getting killed by resisting.

There has been evidence shown that the pirates want to kill Americans.

Not offering protection to the crews is grossly negligent, as one lawsuit already alleges..
 
There has been evidence shown that the pirates want to kill Americans.

That seems to have started immediately after Captain Philips was "rescued". It's like they learned something about what americans are.
 
There has been evidence shown that the pirates want to kill Americans.

I'm sorry, could you re-present that evidence? I know there's evidence that the pirates are willing to kill people, but I don't recall any evidence pointing to the pirates in general actually wanting to specifically kill Americans. And for what? Being American?

I'm sorry, is this going to turn into another generalize-the-brown-people nationalist meme, along similar lines to "they hate us for our freedoms" or some such?
 
That's exactly the situation I don't want to see the current piracy problem escalate into. And exactly what you will get if you try to start a war against the pirates.
.
That same mind set is promoted by the gangstas... Don't be a snitch, or else we'll do it to you... So they can continue to terrorize their 'hoods.
When the people living in the 'hoods get tired of that crap, they can and do organize and take the trash out of the 'hood.
 
Maybe we should have an armed merchant ship to act as a combatant. We get a nice cargo ship and make it look like a nice juicy target when in reality we have a crack commando unit on board. We sail it nice and slow off the coast and as the pirate ships come out to it they blow the pirate boat out of the water and shoot any pirates that bail out. It does this all down the coast and then it's off to some Middle East port for a change of livery and ammunition reloads and then it heads back to lure more pirates out to their death.
.
"Q-ships" from WWI and WWII.. Also called "commerce raiders".
The German Navy used these quite successfully for awhile, until the Allied navies sought them out and sank them.
 
I'm sorry, could you re-present that evidence? I know there's evidence that the pirates are willing to kill people, but I don't recall any evidence pointing to the pirates in general actually wanting to specifically kill Americans. And for what? Being American?

I'm sorry, is this going to turn into another generalize-the-brown-people nationalist meme, along similar lines to "they hate us for our freedoms" or some such?
How many you want. Read the thread-there are a couple up there, but here are some more
http://islaminaction08.blogspot.com/2009/04/pirates-vow-to-kill-americans-and.html
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/bloggers/2228070/posts
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,516235,00.html
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090415/ap_on_re_af/piracy
http://www.deseretnews.com/article/0,5143,705297583,00.html

shall I go on?
 
When have I been evasive ?

I asked what price are you going to put on the lives of those being shot at. You responded by claiming that “they're only being shot at because they're shooting the pirates.” It is like you are blaming the victims of pirate attack for their situation in addition to being evasive.

What makes you so trusting of pirates that you will put up no resistance to any attack?

Ranb
 
I asked what price are you going to put on the lives of those being shot at. You responded by claiming that “they're only being shot at because they're shooting the pirates.” It is like you are blaming the victims of pirate attack for their situation in addition to being evasive.

What makes you so trusting of pirates that you will put up no resistance to any attack?

Historic evidence. Pre 2001 would you, if you were on a hijacked air plane have put up resistance or offered complaince? The issue is escalation, and what will result in the best solution.

The orrigion of these claims is largely the idea that a rifle or two on board a ship is all you need to absolutely defend them, that was the claim at the start of this thread. Now the claims are becomeing more and more extravegent in terms of what you need to equip these ships with. The point is that this is not a simple solution, and the exact effects are hard to determine.

If it was cheap and it was certain that the only deaths would be pirate deaths I find it unlikely that many here who are raising protest against this would.

Just like how you sometimes when you storm in to rescue hostages get situations were no hostages are hurt and ones where all are killed.
 
How many you want.

Knock yourself out. Let's go through the list you've given first.


Posting the same article twice doesn't count as two examples.

Bolded inside the article: "The French and the Americans will regret starting this killing. We do not kill, but take only ransom. We shall do something to anyone we see as French or American from now," Hussein, a pirate, told Reuters by satellite phone.

Hmm, that sounds to me like a response to actions taken. One might even call it an "escalation" if one were so inclined. I seem to recall a few people saying that this was precisely what would happen.


This article again describes escalation. I don't think anyone you are attempting to prove 'wrong' has said otherwise regarding escalation. From the article: "We will target their ships because we know their flags. Last night, an American-flagged ship escaped us by a whisker. We have showered them with rocket-propelled grenades," boasted Ismail, who did not take part in the attack on the Liberty Sun.

The move comes after U.S. Navy sharpshooters killed three pirates Sunday to win the release of a hijacked American sea captain, Richard Phillips of the Maersk Alabama.



This seems to be a less-abbreviated portion of the same article from the foxnews.com link you gave above it, including a verbatim quote from 'Ismail' the pirate. It also describes the same thing: escalation.


Okay, this article looks like a merged copy of the previous two, complete with verbatim quotes and the same AP writers. You basically posted two links of the same thing, then three more links of another AP article. While your pointing out the very escalation that was dismissed earlier is noted, can you at least admit that you've just given two examples using five links-- all describing escalation after the military strikes (and including France and the US)-- instead of expecting me to believe that you've just given me multiple independent sources to support your claim?

shall I go on?

Oh, do please. You see, pointing out that the pirate groups are eager for revenge after our military strikes is pretty much supporting the case that those who feared escalation made a few pages back. You know, the case of escalation that has been, for several pages, summarily dismissed by a number of people as nonsense. Nowhere in any of your links are you providing any information prior to the US snipers taking out the pirates where they were targeting Americans for death, and instead you're using the fact that now the pirates want what they claim is revenge-- the very escalation that others have pointed out as a negative affect of raising the level of aggression-- as if it now supports the case for attacking the pirates more even though the two attacks from the US and French military is actually the basis for the calls of revenge in the sources you're using.

I must say, it's quite a circular claim you've got going on here if this is the best you've got for evidence. Would you accept such circular reasoning from those using it to support some conspiracy theory or woo claim? I highly doubt it.

Also, keep in mind that I'm not opposed to protecting the ships going through those waters, and I do support stopping these pirates from continually acting with what has been for years practical impunity. I do consider those SEALs who saved the Alabama captain commendable and I'm not arguing that they should have acted differently (they had no other options). So, before you fire back with hasty generalizations about what you might want to consider my motivations for challenging this claim may be, keep in mind that the reality may very well not fall neatly into some black-or-white model of rhetoric in this case. I'm much more interested in hearing about quantifiable (or at least confirmable) facts and information on the subject of solving the piracy problem, and I'm less interested in hearing some politically-vested diatribes that seek to demonize any who might disagree with the conclusion.

I'm not a dove, but I'm not much of a hawk either. Convince me using logic and reason, not emotion and hyperbole.
 
Escalation is good though IMO. When enough people have died, it will result in a Naval coalition to clear the area, which is really what should be happening now.
 
Looks like the consensus is to give in to blackmail.
That has always worked. Look at Europe in 1939, among others.

From zero to godwin in just seconds!

Seriously, though: re-read what I wrote in my last post, particularly the last few paragraphs. The post quoted here definitely does not count as convincing in any sense. Try it again without the false dichotomies.
 
So GreNME thinks any response to the piracy is "escalation".

~head asplodes~
 
I asked what price are you going to put on the lives of those being shot at. You responded by claiming that “they're only being shot at because they're shooting the pirates.” It is like you are blaming the victims of pirate attack for their situation in addition to being evasive.

Again, I don't see how that was evasive. My (admittedly simplistic) point was that shooting at the pirates only makes them shoot back. So arming them is what puts the crew in greater danger in the first place. That's one possibility, anyway. So "what price" is irrelevant if you don't shoot at them.

What makes you so trusting of pirates that you will put up no resistance to any attack?

Did I say I wouldn't put up any resistance ?
 
So GreNME thinks any response to the piracy is "escalation".

~head asplodes~

My goodness, can you for once give a response that isn't simply an opposing act of pigeon-holing?

Read the articles, they explicitly state that the pirates making the statements are out for revenge. That reaction is: A) precisely the opposite of the turn-tail-and-run response that you and some others predicted, and B) the type of escalation of aggression that was predicted by ponderingturtle and a few others in response to the US and French action. Since no evidence has been presented that shows the Somali pirates claiming a desire to target Americans for death prior to the US rescue of the Alabama captain, then calling the response from the pirates anything but predictable (given they lost that challenge) is grossly overstating the meaning of what they're saying.

So, my offer to rwguinn is equally extended to you, WildCat: Convince me using logic and reason, not emotion and hyperbole. As I also said, I'm not a dove, but I'm not much of a hawk either.
 
My goodness, can you for once give a response that isn't simply an opposing act of pigeon-holing?

Read the articles, they explicitly state that the pirates making the statements are out for revenge. That reaction is: A) precisely the opposite of the turn-tail-and-run response that you and some others predicted, and B) the type of escalation of aggression that was predicted by ponderingturtle and a few others in response to the US and French action. Since no evidence has been presented that shows the Somali pirates claiming a desire to target Americans for death prior to the US rescue of the Alabama captain, then calling the response from the pirates anything but predictable (given they lost that challenge) is grossly overstating the meaning of what they're saying.

So, my offer to rwguinn is equally extended to you, WildCat: Convince me using logic and reason, not emotion and hyperbole. As I also said, I'm not a dove, but I'm not much of a hawk either.
Threats of escalation are only effective if you can actually carry out the threat. Blustering is expected. They have NOT escalated--only threatened to do so.
When faced with actually having to carry through, they turned tail as soon as resistance was shown.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom