Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Some may have been cowards sure. I can't comment on their level of courage.

How about something easier, the embassy in Tehran, if they had fought to the death think about how much easier the poltical situation with Iran would be. But the marines lacked courage.
That situation was much different though. The passengers were led to believe that a bomb was on the plane and if they tried anything the attackers would blow the plane up. Notice though how was the passengers on the United 93 took over the plane once they learned that there were no bombs and that it was only a suicide mission. If they had chose to be victims, that plane could have ended up hitting another heavily populated building.

So? You are ignoring that all previous hijackings the best results for the passengers were obtained by compliance on the part of the passengers.
 
How about something easier, the embassy in Tehran, if they had fought to the death think about how much easier the poltical situation with Iran would be. But the marines lacked courage.
.
You in a lot of trouble, boy!
No US Marine lacks courage!
But they do follow orders, and if they are prevented by those orders to respond properly, the problem is with the issuer of the orders, not the Marines!
See the extended fiasco with the cargo ship created by the interference by the President, seeking an nice candy-coated sugar-plumped talk down instead of letting the military people do their job, a job Obie has ZERO experience with!
We can only hope he learned something.

So? You are ignoring that all previous hijackings the best results for the passengers were obtained by compliance on the part of the passengers.
.
This event was unfolding as "death to all".
The passengers did the exact correct thing in fighting back!
It's that certainty of getting a fight that has prevented any more hijackings in this country!
 
No. It's pretty black and white to me. Arm the crews so they have a means to defend themselves. Its quite simple. Or even give the crew the option to bring their personal rifles on board to save money.

And if they get killed defending the ship, how much does the ship operator owe their families? Remember this is an economic situation so the cheapest solution will win.
 
Using guns to defend a ship from pirates. How does that not match?

Please you are kidding right?


Okey lets see


crews of ships ARM THEMSELVES

Now this may suppise you but your average crew doesn't include isreali securty personel. Actualy if you consider which trade routes somalia is on quite a few of them would preclude haveing isrealis on at all.


Even if you had just one AK47 on a ship and a person who was even remotely trained with it

There were multiple people on the ship and they were far more than remotely trained (whatever training their company has aside isreal still has fairly universal conscription for it's jewish citizens).

So it's intensely intellectually dishonest to claim a match. Do you wish to withdraw or modify large chunks of your opening post?
 
Please you are kidding right?


Okey lets see




Now this may suppise you but your average crew doesn't include isreali securty personel. Actualy if you consider which trade routes somalia is on quite a few of them would preclude haveing isrealis on at all.




There were multiple people on the ship and they were far more than remotely trained (whatever training their company has aside isreal still has fairly universal conscription for it's jewish citizens).

So it's intensely intellectually dishonest to claim a match. Do you wish to withdraw or modify large chunks of your opening post?

Arguing semantics now are we? Noted. I stand by my OP. And actually in the Israeli security guard scenario, if it would have been one member of the crew remotely trained and armed with an AK, it actually would have been more effective than the pistols. The pirates probably would not have even attempted to throw a ladder on the ship due to an AK shooting at a farther range and being much more deadly.
 
And if they get killed defending the ship, how much does the ship operator owe their families? Remember this is an economic situation so the cheapest solution will win.

Why the hell would the ship operator owe anything? Its called life insurance.
 
The average ransom paid so far is $1-$2 million, depending on where you look.

That buys a lot of thingies!

Ah but if you only know your boat will be attacked. You have to figure that the odds are very very low, so even at one percent, much higher than in reality, you would only have 10-20 thousand to spend.
 
Consider that the average ransom paid is $1-2 million and I know of at least 1 that was $3 million. How many $500 night vision goggles can $1 million buy?

eta: ships already have radar and lights.

And how much insurance can you buy with that money?
 
.
You in a lot of trouble, boy!
No US Marine lacks courage!

Not by Quads definition of courage. Remember you are either a sheep or a wolf, and because they were taken hostage the marines must be sheep. Just like all the US army units in the Philippines at the start of WWII. They should have known to fight to the death. Also John McCain.

If you missed it, this is a reducto ad absurdem.
 
Not the Achille Lauro. Ship hijacked, passenger murdered, pirates (terrorists) allowed to go free.

It seems some people here are learning nothing from history. Allow pirates and terrorists an inch and they will take a mile. Does this not make sense to anyone?

That's exactly the situation I don't want to see the current piracy problem escalate into. And exactly what you will get if you try to start a war against the pirates.
 
When you die on the job doing your job you are generally entitled to having your employer pay out a fair sum.

And the employer is the ship operator? And I can't really comment on what the companies pay out if they die on the job. What if they get shot if they surrender and negotiations go bad?
 
And if they get killed defending the ship, how much does the ship operator owe their families? Remember this is an economic situation so the cheapest solution will win.
Probably less than if someone gets killed without any sort of security. Particularly since the danger is known.

It's only dumb luck nobody has been killed thus far, it's certainly not because the pirates haven't fired on the ships. That's pretty much SOP for them.
 
Probably less than if someone gets killed without any sort of security. Particularly since the danger is known.

It's only dumb luck nobody has been killed thus far, it's certainly not because the pirates haven't fired on the ships. That's pretty much SOP for them.

Actually if a company is aware of the risk and takes no action or protective measures, I would say that is a pretty good case for negligence.
 
That's exactly the situation I don't want to see the current piracy problem escalate into. And exactly what you will get if you try to start a war against the pirates.

I do not recall seeing any proactive solutions suggested by you. You suppose that if we keep commending them as you so like to do, that they will respect the shipping companies too much to steal their ships?

If these pirates had any self respect or national allegiance, then they might form their own coast guard to prevent the waste dumping and illegal fishing. But no, they think there is more profit for them in the short term if they just steal instead.

Ranb
 
Maybe we should have an armed merchant ship to act as a combatant. We get a nice cargo ship and make it look like a nice juicy target when in reality we have a crack commando unit on board. We sail it nice and slow off the coast and as the pirate ships come out to it they blow the pirate boat out of the water and shoot any pirates that bail out. It does this all down the coast and then it's off to some Middle East port for a change of livery and ammunition reloads and then it heads back to lure more pirates out to their death.
 
here’s a good source
h-t-t-p-:-/-/-w-w-w-.-a-l-j-a-z-e-e-r-a-.-c-o-m-/-n-e-w-s-/-a-r-t-i-c-l-e-s-/-3-9-/-S-o-m-a-l-i-a-_-A-_-s-y-m-b-o-l-_-o-f-_-t-h-e-_-d-e-c-a-y-i-n-g-_-w-o-r-l-d-_-o-r-d-e-r-.-h-t-m-l
I’ll edi out the minus signs once I have fifteen posts.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom