Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Boy, arming those ships is becoming more and more expensive.
Consider that the average ransom paid is $1-2 million and I know of at least 1 that was $3 million. How many $500 night vision goggles can $1 million buy?

eta: ships already have radar and lights.
 
Last edited:
To be honest I may try to read more into it I agree to the previous person in terms of logic.
Solve the poverty problem probably would work well I hate to say it but I completly distrust the politicians quite systematically on this issue.<›— I guess it may be seen as impractical. but you know what it doesn't matter weather I’m going to ethiopia soon or not… I would prefer you solving the famine problem first I’d rather prevent what will hit me as opposed what could go wrong.—[depending on other factors probability and severity.]
Hmm Actually wild cat has a good point couldn't one just get a boat that can travel really quickly. and outrun the pirates?
A good alternative is not to go somalian.
 
Last edited:
To be honest I may try to read more into it I agree to the previous person in terms of logic.
Solve the poverty problem probably would work well I hate to say it but I completly distrust the politicians quite systematically on this issue.<›— I guess it may be seen as impractical. but you know what it doesn't matter weather I’m going to ethiopia soon or not… I would prefer you solving the famine problem first I’d rather prevent what will hit me as opposed what could go wrong.—[depending on other factors probability and severity.]
Hmm Actually wild cat has a good point couldn't one just get a boat that can travel really quickly. and outrun the pirates?
A good alternative is not to go somalian.
.
These pirates are being found 500 miles off the Somalian coast.
And large transports -can't- travel (or do anything) quickly!
Decreasing the survival percentages of the pirates will lead to less piracy.
 
One incident doesn't prove anything though I do commend the pirates for showing restraint and not firing RPGs into a cruse ship.

You commend the pirates? I think you are showing too much respect to pirates who are just scumbags preying on people. What evidence do you have that they were showing restraint? None of course, so why be so nice?

Why are you not commending the security force on the ship for showing restraint in not killing the pirates who attacked them? It seems that your sympathies lay with the pirates in this case.

Ranb
 
Last edited:
Seems that previous cruise ships did just fine without pistols:

Not the Achille Lauro. Ship hijacked, passenger murdered, pirates (terrorists) allowed to go free.

It seems some people here are learning nothing from history. Allow pirates and terrorists an inch and they will take a mile. Does this not make sense to anyone?

Ranb
 
Make the trip attractive!
It'll pay for itself. :)
 

Attachments

  • PirateCruise.jpg
    PirateCruise.jpg
    91.4 KB · Views: 11
To the one who said that fraiters wouldn't do so… well it seamed a reasonable option what the hell are fraiters doing so?⁄ also I posted latter then I thought I did several posts were added between when I meant to post and I posted:eye-poppi
Oo… If they don't get loot you also reduce their numbers…[makes it less attractive.]
You commend the pirates? I think you are showing too much respect to pirates who are just scumbags preying on people. What evidence do you have that they were showing restraint? None of course, so why be so nice?

Why are you not commending the security force on the ship for showing restraint in not killing the pirates who attacked them? It seems that your sympathies lay with the pirates in this case.

Ranb

I think your showing that you are biased.
 
They're only being shot at because they're shooting the pirates.

I think you are not being truthful. I thought the sailors were being shot at to intimidate them into giving up the ship. Have any of the Somali pirates taken a ship without shooting or without weapons? I am not a fan of the "bend over and take it" defense. You seem to be though.

If you are going to respond, then why not directly answer the question instead of being evasive?

Ranb
 
Last edited:
To the one who said that fraiters wouldn't do so… well it seamed a reasonable option what the hell are fraiters doing so?⁄ also I posted latter then I thought I did several posts were added between when I meant to post and I posted:eye-poppi
Oo… If they don't get loot you also reduce their numbers…[makes it less attractive.]


I think your showing that you are biased.

I do not understand your first two sentences. Please be more clear.

Oh yeah, I am very biased. :) It would be nice if those on the sea could carry on without SOB pirates shooting at them, holding them hostage, threatening to kill them, or stealing. Some people think this is too much to ask and that sailors need to play fair when staring down a machine gun and the person who wants their ship.

Ranb
 
I do not understand your first two sentences. Please be more clear.

Oh yeah, I am very biased. :) It would be nice if those on the sea could carry on without SOB pirates shooting at them, holding them hostage, threatening to kill them, or stealing. Some people think this is too much to ask and that sailors need to play fair when staring down a machine gun and the person who wants their ship.

Ranb

I mostly agree with this post, though I don't feel it's incredibly fair that the sailors have to stare down the barrel of a machine gun as part of their job.
 
.
These pirates are being found 500 miles off the Somalian coast.
And large transports -can't- travel (or do anything) quickly!
Decreasing the survival percentages of the pirates will lead to less piracy.


Quite a few transport ships managed to avoid being taken by out-running the pirates. I know the media presentation is that they're jetting about in high speed boats, but this clearly isn't always the case. Some of them are puttering about in crappy little wooden fishing boats.
 
They're only being shot at because they're shooting the pirates.

The pirates shoot first. In the case of the most recent cruise ship attack the pirates shot at the ship for five minutes and those on board only fired back when the pirates eventually tried to board.
 
So basically to sum up this thread, it has been proved, both through circumstantial evidence and actual accounts that arming personnel on the ship is actually a very good idea. It also seems that the only person not accepting this fact is Belz. Judging by his comments after he has been proved embarrassingly wrong, he is just trying to save face now. So moving on and ignoring his comments, what is the best course of action to get these ships armed? Would it be cheapest to hire security or just to train members of the ship to use weapons that the shipping companies purchase? What other ideas do you guys have?
 
I'd go for the mercenary idea.
More likely to be practical without any "international political ramifications" if a private company like Blackwater hires out their troops.
A round-robin situation at each end of the critical area where the boats entering pick up the guards and their firepower and experience with that firepower, and those leaving drop them off for the next boats entering.
With a multi-national group of "privateers" operating on their own, it's less likely to be embarrassing to the countries of origin for the mercs.
 
Uh-oh, lawyers are on the case now!

HOUSTON (AP) — A member of the crew on the U.S.-flagged ship hijacked by African pirates sued the owner and another company Monday, accusing them of knowingly putting sailors in danger. Richard E. Hicks alleges in the suit that owner Maersk Line Limited and Waterman Steamship Corp., which provided the crew, ignored requests to improve safety measures for vessels sailing along the Somali coast.

Hicks was chief cook on the Maersk Alabama. Pirates held the ship's captain hostage for five days until the U.S. Navy rescued him.
Hicks' lawsuit seeks at least $75,000 in damages and improved safety.

Officials for Norfolk, Va.-based Maersk Line and Mobile, Ala.-based Waterman said their companies don't comment on pending litigation.

Hicks asked that the two companies improve safety for ships by providing armed security or allowing crew members to carry weapons, sending ships through safer routes, and placing such safety measures on ships as barbed wire that would prevent pirates from being able to board vessels.
http://www.google.com/hostednews/ap/article/ALeqM5jKIexYLfRJ2nVvxrC7YEwlj5w0hQD97R28E80

Bold emphasis mine.

I guess he didn't want to take Dan O's suggestion of inviting the pirates aboard for a cup of tea instead.
 
I think Ranb overestimates the lengths the pirates are willing to go to take a ship. There's no profit in getting killed.

As the Clint Eastwood character Josey Wales once said "Dyin' ain't much of a livin' boy".

And I think it is demonstrably easy to find Somali's who are highly risk tolerant.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom