Easy solution to the pirate problem...

This "simple device" was the long rope with a mine attached that required it to be placed ahead of the ship in just the right spot so that mine would end up alongside the ship?

It's ridiculous. All the ship would have to do in the highly unlikely circumstance the device worked perfectly is reverse direction, or even stop and let the mine drift away.

I already said you don't understand it. You don't need to continue to prove the point.
 
Maybe you should read the story. It does NOT say when the pirates were first spotted. A scenario in which the pirates were first spotted as they tried to attach the ladders would be entirely consistent with the story as written.

That would also make Quad's assertion nonsense but then that would not be, in itself, a news flash.

Why can't you accept that guns were successfully used to defend a ship?
 
Was the crew armed?
Has the pirate problem been solved?

One incident doesn't prove anything though I do commend the pirates for showing restraint and not firing RPGs into a cruse ship.
 
:dl:

Some people...

Keep clinging to that straw, I'm sure it won't sink...
 
Was the crew armed?
Has the pirate problem been solved?

One incident doesn't prove anything though I do commend the pirates for showing restraint and not firing RPGs into a cruse ship.

Whether it is the crew shooting guns at the pirates or guards it really doesn't matter. Yes in that particular incident the pirate problem was solved. Now if all ships did that the pirate problem would be solved completely.
 
I'm sure the X-box and Game Boy folks will come up with another way for the pirates to elude an active defense against their raids.
If only the Somalis had Game Boy instead of having to work out the solutions in real time, while being shot at.
 
I'm sure the X-box and Game Boy folks will come up with another way for the pirates to elude an active defense against their raids.
If only the Somalis had Game Boy instead of having to work out the solutions in real time, while being shot at.
Sharks with laser beams attached to their heads?
 
The net cutters are something completely different. Though they might be useful as a defense if mounted on the bow.
 
If they were first spotted while attaching the ladders there would have been no time to run to the storage lockers and retrieve the guns and ammunition.
I read another version of the story that specifically said there was 5 minutes between the first pirate attack (their firing at the ship) and the attempt to attach ladders and board and the return fire. Seems to me that even 5 minutes is pretty darn short to get word to the captain, unlock the guns and ammo and get them in the hands of the right people, and get to the location where the pirate boat was located.

I'm agnostic on the time line.
 
Nice strawman. Do you have the manpower, ammo, training, searchlights, night vision thingies, etc. to protect it?
The average ransom paid so far is $1-$2 million, depending on where you look.

That buys a lot of thingies!
 
Media here is reporting that six pirates attacked the Cruise ship with AK-47s, and after about five minutes attempted to board, at which point they were driven off by the Israeli security team using pistols and a fire hose. They pirates continued to trail the ship for a further 20 minutes, firing sporadically at the ship, before leaving.
 
Media here is reporting that six pirates attacked the Cruise ship with AK-47s, and after about five minutes attempted to board, at which point they were driven off by the Israeli security team using pistols and a fire hose. They pirates continued to trail the ship for a further 20 minutes, firing sporadically at the ship, before leaving.

Oh dear, somebody PM TFT and inform him about yet another Israeli war crime.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom