Easy solution to the pirate problem...

OMG, somebody go claim the $1 million from Randi, the impossible (according to some here) just happened - security guards drove off a boat of Somali pirates by firing actual guns at them, and this happened at night!
Cmdr. Ciro Pinto told Italian state radio that six men in a small white boat approached the Msc Melody and opened fire Saturday night, but retreated after the Israeli security officers aboard the cruise ship returned fire.
http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1239710790320&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull

And they didn't even require machine guns, or even a rifle - they did it with pistols!

Truly, if some here are to be believed, this was a paranormal event... how could they see them at night?! And why didn't the pirates sink the ship with an improvised mine?
 
Last edited:
There are still mutineers at sea as well as pirates. What stops an armed crew taking over their own ship and selling the cargo in some backwater port?
What stops an unarmed crew from taking over a ship? Are sea captains expert martial artists capable of fighting off a dozen crew mebers with their bare hands?
 
So if you already know that they can be purchased for around $350 why do you want me to provide evidence of this?

http://www.atncorp.com/units/nightvision/nightvisionmonoculars/atnnightstorm1black

Or you could just type night vision goggles into google.


Miss much don't you.

The limiting factor for image intensifiers in this application is intra-scene dynamic range. You'll be looking for a small boat in the dark swells right below the bright evening horizon. The blooming is likely to wash out the entire image.


However, for the pirates, these may indeed be useful for determining if there is a watch on the ship.
 
Miss much don't you.

The limiting factor for image intensifiers in this application is intra-scene dynamic range. You'll be looking for a small boat in the dark swells right below the bright evening horizon. The blooming is likely to wash out the entire image.


However, for the pirates, these may indeed be useful for determining if there is a watch on the ship.

You ever used NODs?
 
OMG, somebody go claim the $1 million from Randi, the impossible (according to some here) just happened - security guards drove off a boat of Somali pirates by firing actual guns at them, and this happened at night!

http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1239710790320&pagename=JPost/JPArticle/ShowFull

And they didn't even require machine guns, or even a rifle - they did it with pistols!

Truly, if some here are to be believed, this was a paranormal event... how could they see them at night?! And why didn't the pirates sink the ship with an improivised mine?

Haha. Reading that story is almost exactly the way I have described it would go down in this thread.
 
Haha. Reading that story is almost exactly the way I have described it would go down in this thread.

Note remotely. Forgotten your opening post?:

I’m not sure if this has been discussed in other threads, but if pirates are such a big problem, why don't the crews of ships ARM THEMSELVES??? I really have trouble seeing why they don't do this. Even if you had just one AK47 on a ship and a person who was even remotely trained with it, they could defend an entire tanker.

1)Israeli security people do not normaly feature as part of the crew.
2)there was more than one of them
3)They were a bit more than "remotely trained"

You've also got to remember that every attack on a cruise ship so far has failed even without resorting to guns.
 
Note remotely. Forgotten your opening post?:



1)Israeli security people do not normaly feature as part of the crew.
No they don't. But the use of weapons worked did it not?
2)there was more than one of them
Your point?
3)They were a bit more than "remotely trained"
Sure they had more training. But do you really think the training was what saved that ship or the fact that pirates turned tail and ran when they started taking fire?
You've also got to remember that every attack on a cruise ship so far has failed even without resorting to guns.

The guns worked.
 
3)They were a bit more than "remotely trained"
These weren't guys who were from some highly trained elite commando unit. Just regular ex-military. The pool of such people is deep, and I'd guess your typical ship's crew has one or 2 ex-military.
 
OMG, somebody go claim the $1 million from Randi, the impossible (according to some here) just happened - security guards drove off a boat of Somali pirates by firing actual guns at them, and this happened at night!


Considering that cruse ships can outrun the pirate skiffs, it's unclear why they needed to fire at the pirates at all. Did they not see the pirates in time (even with the added watch) to simply speed away?


And why didn't the pirates sink the ship with an improvised mine?


What makes you so sure that they won't. The pirates have plenty of time.

Besides, they already captured one ship this weekend. It doesn't mater if a few get away.
 
The history of the last thirty years in merchant shipping is one of steadily reducing manpower, automating navigation and other systems, replacing highly qualified bridge crews with the cheapest labour available and of generally cutting payroll costs to the bone.
Modern freighters have plenty of power and are much tougher than modern warships, which are built lightly for manoeuvrability. They can easily be equipped with all manner of high tech weaponry.
However- That comes at cost, as does the additional manpower and the training to use it. Believe me, giving a bunch of poorly paid Phillipino sailors RPGs or Stinger missiles is not a smart move. These guys have agendas at home.
Then there's the small problem that a lot of said weaponry is going to accidentally fall overboard when the ship is being attacked at night by something that turns out to be a whale- and will subsequently float to the surface in interesting markets all over the world.

There are still mutineers at sea as well as pirates. What stops an armed crew taking over their own ship and selling the cargo in some backwater port?

Much, much safer for the shippers to levy a tax on goods and use it to pay actual soldiers to stay on board in danger areas. Hire some Gurkhas and form a marine security outfit. Would you try to hijack a tanker with a bunch of grinning Nepalis polishing their kukris on the handrail?

I don't know what it would cost to put four guards on a merchant ship. And have them patrol in shifts. But I proposed earlier in this thread to use security people from developing nations. I still think that might make it affordable.

As an importer I'd be willing to pay extra for the certainty that my goods don't get held up for an extra month. I know the chance of it happening is small. But I have all sort of insurance for things that are statistically unikely to happen.
 
Considering that cruse ships can outrun the pirate skiffs, it's unclear why they needed to fire at the pirates at all.
Obviously they couldn't outrun these particular pirates.

Did they not see the pirates in time (even with the added watch) to simply speed away?
Maybe you should have read the story? If you did you'd find that the pirates were spotted in time to retrieve the pistols from a storage locker. And pistols have a very limited range, it wasn't until the pirates got close enough to try to attach ladders that they were fired on.


What makes you so sure that they won't. The pirates have plenty of time.
Because frankly it's a stupid idea. No reason at all to do such thing which rivals a Rube Goldberg machine in its complexity that has no payoff in the end.

Besides, they already captured one ship this weekend. It doesn't mater if a few get away.
A ship which didn't contain an armed guard who fired on them. Thank you for proving the point in the OP.
 
OMG, somebody go claim the $1 million from Randi, the impossible (according to some here) just happened - security guards drove off a boat of Somali pirates by firing actual guns at them, and this happened at night!

http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1239710790320&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull

And they didn't even require machine guns, or even a rifle - they did it with pistols!

Truly, if some here are to be believed, this was a paranormal event... how could they see them at night?! And why didn't the pirates sink the ship with an improvised mine?
Let's nominate them for the badasses of the month! Sorry, wrong forum...

But seriously, the pirates are so used to non-resistance that even pistols scares them away. I wouldn't be suprised if the next pirate attack will be repelled with clogs and gym weights. Compare with marine commandos that are trained not only to avoid and return gunfire, but also to show a healthy indifference to it.
 
No they don't. But the use of weapons worked did it not?

Your point?

Sure they had more training. But do you really think the training was what saved that ship or the fact that pirates turned tail and ran when they started taking fire?

So you admit that the senario in no way matches the criteria of your opening post?
 
Maybe you should have read the story? If you did you'd find that the pirates were spotted in time to retrieve the pistols from a storage locker. And pistols have a very limited range, it wasn't until the pirates got close enough to try to attach ladders that they were fired on.
Maybe you should read the story. It does NOT say when the pirates were first spotted. A scenario in which the pirates were first spotted as they tried to attach the ladders would be entirely consistent with the story as written.

That would also make Quad's assertion nonsense but then that would not be, in itself, a news flash.
 
Because frankly it's a stupid idea. No reason at all to do such thing which rivals a Rube Goldberg machine in its complexity that has no payoff in the end.


I described a simple device that the pirates could produce themselves as an alternative if their current operations are shut out by arming the merchant ships. That you can't understand it doesn't have any barring on the intellect of the pirates.
 
Maybe you should read the story. It does NOT say when the pirates were first spotted. A scenario in which the pirates were first spotted as they tried to attach the ladders would be entirely consistent with the story as written.
If they were first spotted while attaching the ladders there would have been no time to run to the storage lockers and retrieve the guns and ammunition.
 
I described a simple device that the pirates could produce themselves as an alternative if their current operations are shut out by arming the merchant ships. That you can't understand it doesn't have any barring on the intellect of the pirates.
This "simple device" was the long rope with a mine attached that required it to be placed ahead of the ship in just the right spot so that mine would end up alongside the ship?

It's ridiculous. All the ship would have to do in the highly unlikely circumstance the device worked perfectly is reverse direction, or even stop and let the mine drift away.


Or were you referring to your equally ridiculous drone boat packed with explosives?
 
This "simple device" was the long rope with a mine attached that required it to be placed ahead of the ship in just the right spot so that mine would end up alongside the ship?

It's ridiculous. All the ship would have to do in the highly unlikely circumstance the device worked perfectly is reverse direction, or even stop and let the mine drift away.

Questionable. Back during the cod wars the icelandic people came up with a device like that to target nets. It was to an extent effective.



Or were you referring to your equally ridiculous drone boat packed with explosives?

That one isn't too hard to build. Never worked mind. Tended to sink, explode or run aground.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom