Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Perhaps you need to read the thread closer. Several pages were spent discussing one's ability to hit a small boat with small arms fire. At night, the discussion is virtually moot.

Yeah. You definitely have not read the thread. THATS WHAT THE NIGHT GUARDS ARE FOR. Shine a light on their boat and start firing.
 
Yeah. You definitely have not read the thread. THATS WHAT THE NIGHT GUARDS ARE FOR. Shine a light on their boat and start firing.
What is this thing you call a "light"? Some kind of witchcraft?
 
Yeah. You definitely have not read the thread. THATS WHAT THE NIGHT GUARDS ARE FOR. Shine a light on their boat and start firing.
Jesus what a stupid remark. How are you going to shine a light on a boat you don't know is there. Ok, ok, you know it's there and shine a light on it. What about the other two boats on the other side of the ship that are boarding while you are shooting at the decoy they left off the fantail?

You really haven't thought this through have you?
 
Jesus what a stupid remark. How are you going to shine a light on a boat you don't know is there. Ok, ok, you know it's there and shine a light on it. What about the other two boats on the other side of the ship that are boarding while you are shooting at the decoy they left off the fantail?

You really haven't thought this through have you?

Alright lets try this again. Nice and slow just for you. You ready? NIGHT GUARDS. They keep watch on all sides of the ship to see if any boats are approaching. So if they see a boat, they alert everyone and shine a spotlight on it. This isn't Pirates of the Caribbean here. There is no such thing as a "ghost ship". I know it's a pretty crazy concept to comprehend. Perhaps you should spend less time at Disney World.
 
Apparently the pirates don't attack in the middle of the night. Most successful attacks occurred at last light in the evening or first light in the morning. I suspect that this gives the pirates a visibility advantage with the ship silhouetted in the skyglow and the pirates hidden in the dark sea.
 
Alright lets try this again. Nice and slow just for you. You ready? NIGHT GUARDS. They keep watch on all sides of the ship to see if any boats are approaching. So if they see a boat, they alert everyone and shine a spotlight on it. This isn't Pirates of the Caribbean here. There is no such thing as a "ghost ship". I know it's a pretty crazy concept to comprehend. Perhaps you should spend less time at Disney World.
Thanks for slowing down. Now that you've reduced yourself to a hunt-and-pecker I can keep up.

So they keep watch at night. Presumably using large searchlights. Or are you assuming that some guy and his buddy, the Energizer Bunny, can spot small boats at night on a tossing sea with a flashlight?

And how many guards are you posting? It'll take more than four but with your military expertise I assume you can give us the parameters.

Oh and fog. Or rain. Or dust storms blown out to sea. Yeah, the pirates will never take advantage of the weather.

As I said, you really haven't thought this through.
 
So they keep watch at night. Presumably using large searchlights. Or are you assuming that some guy and his buddy, the Energizer Bunny, can spot small boats at night on a tossing sea with a flashlight?
There are searchlights, there are night vision goggles, there is radar.

And how many guards are you posting? It'll take more than four but with your military expertise I assume you can give us the parameters.
I'd imagine it's the same amount already being posted at night to look out for pirates. You do realize that the whole crew doesn't go to bed at night while sailing past the Gulf of Aden, don't you?

Oh and fog. Or rain. Or dust storms blown out to sea. Yeah, the pirates will never take advantage of the weather.
The pirates are limited to operating in calm seas. Small craft don't work very well in storms. 6-8 foot waves pretty much rules out piracy until things calm down.

As I said, you really haven't thought this through.
Clearly, you haven't. Because all those things you mention are already factors now. You're not introducing anything new to the equation.
 
The goggles are image intensifiers, not thermal imagers.

I noticed that after posting. Those are way too cheap for IR.

Still, it remains to be seen how effective these are at spotting small boats in the surf while looking in the direction of the setting sun.
 
I noticed that after posting. Those are way too cheap for IR.

Still, it remains to be seen how effective these are at spotting small boats in the surf while looking in the direction of the setting sun.

Night vision goggles are fairly inexpensive. I have used them many a times and they could definitely spot a boat at night.
 
The history of the last thirty years in merchant shipping is one of steadily reducing manpower, automating navigation and other systems, replacing highly qualified bridge crews with the cheapest labour available and of generally cutting payroll costs to the bone.
Modern freighters have plenty of power and are much tougher than modern warships, which are built lightly for manoeuvrability. They can easily be equipped with all manner of high tech weaponry.
However- That comes at cost, as does the additional manpower and the training to use it. Believe me, giving a bunch of poorly paid Phillipino sailors RPGs or Stinger missiles is not a smart move. These guys have agendas at home.
Then there's the small problem that a lot of said weaponry is going to accidentally fall overboard when the ship is being attacked at night by something that turns out to be a whale- and will subsequently float to the surface in interesting markets all over the world.

There are still mutineers at sea as well as pirates. What stops an armed crew taking over their own ship and selling the cargo in some backwater port?

Much, much safer for the shippers to levy a tax on goods and use it to pay actual soldiers to stay on board in danger areas. Hire some Gurkhas and form a marine security outfit. Would you try to hijack a tanker with a bunch of grinning Nepalis polishing their kukris on the handrail?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom