Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Really? The mafia extortion rackets worked by saying "if you don't give us X we'll destroy X"?

As depicted by Hollywood, the mafia would send a collector to the business which would pay the pre-arranged protection money to prevent the business from accidentally burning down. The pirates could do the same thing by having a single collector sail up the the merchant ship (jolly roger flying overhead and parrot on shoulder) to collect the pre-arranged transit fee. Any interference from Rambo or the military and an unfortunate accident could befall one of the companies ships.
 
Last I looked, the english channel was not bordered by an impoverished country with a significant population that has nothing to loose by turning to piracy.

That is the ultimate solution to the problem but will still take time to implement once the world realizes that it needs to act.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound_Dues

A country strong and organiced enough to implement such a scheme is also vulnerable to the political consequenses.

England and France does not consider it worth the trouble it would bring them.
 
I know a number of merchant seamen.
Quite apart from the fact they are untrained in the use of distance weapons, some of them might be tempted to indulge in a little buccaneering themselves if presented with the appropriate armament. Or they would sell the ammunition and claim to have used it while heroically defending their employers' property.

Putting some marines on vessels in danger areas might be a wiser move for all concerned.
.
Looking at a book on piracy at B&N this afternoon, it mentions the Chinese Navy's anti-pirate organization isn't above a little piracy themselves!
 
As depicted by Hollywood, the mafia would send a collector to the business which would pay the pre-arranged protection money to prevent the business from accidentally burning down. The pirates could do the same thing by having a single collector sail up the the merchant ship (jolly roger flying overhead and parrot on shoulder) to collect the pre-arranged transit fee. Any interference from Rambo or the military and an unfortunate accident could befall one of the companies ships.


That's a nice fantasy, but it's very clear that the pirates only ever manage to capture ships when they surprise them, and even then they aren't very successful. If they were to announce themselves first their odds of success would plummet.

Your mafia example works for several reasons:

1) The mafia are almost certain to successfully burn down the business
2) Loss of the business would render the owner destitute
3) The owner has no viable way of avoiding the situation

None of these apply in the case of the Somali pirates

1) The pirates' odds of actually sinking a ship is very very low
2) Loss of a ship would not cause severe harm to most shipping companies
3) The ship crews can easily avoid the situation by resisting or evading the pirates all together
 
As depicted by Hollywood, the mafia would send a collector to the business which would pay the pre-arranged protection money to prevent the business from accidentally burning down. The pirates could do the same thing by having a single collector sail up the the merchant ship (jolly roger flying overhead and parrot on shoulder) to collect the pre-arranged transit fee. Any interference from Rambo or the military and an unfortunate accident could befall one of the companies ships.
Ah yes, I saw that documentary...

 
On a more serious note, General Petraeus says shippers should consider armed guards:
The global shipping industry should consider placing armed guards on its boats to ward off pirates who have become increasingly violent, the U.S. military commander who oversees the African coastline said Friday. Gen. David Petraeus told a House committee Friday that just trying to outrun or block pirates from boarding cargo ships isn't enough to deter sea bandits off the Somali coast who are becoming more aggressive.

...
Joe Cox, president of the Chamber of Shipping of America, cautioned that deploying armed guards aboard cargo ships could escalate violence if pirates expect a gunfight.

"If you asked us two weeks ago, we would say, 'No guns on ships,'" Cox said Friday. "Now the reaction is, 'Let's talk.' That's not a ringing endorsement of going in that direction. But we know, under the current circumstances, something has to be done."
 
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound_Dues

A country strong and organiced enough to implement such a scheme is also vulnerable to the political consequences.

That's a good point. But the Somali pirates are not a country and so are not subject to political pressures. Since they are individuals that can disappear and blend in with the population, it will take a significant police action to track down enough of the pirate organization to prevent them from operating.
 
Not even the most desperate mugger decides to rob a uniformed policeman.

They will pick the weak target. If they receive fire from one ship they will move on to another one, even if it is also armed they think maybe they can take it by surprise. No reason at all to press an attack on a ship when surprise is lost and you are taking fire.

Some of them may be able to run and come back another day. Some of them are starving and out of gas and have few options but to attack.
 
Reading through the accounts, it seems to me a lot of the attacks happen at night, so I am guessing that visual detection plays a big part.
If many of the attacks happen at night, aren't the endless pages of posts here about the ease of hitting a pirate boat moot? And if the ships are armed, won't even more of the attacks happen at night in order to counter the shooting defense?
 
If many of the attacks happen at night, aren't the endless pages of posts here about the ease of hitting a pirate boat moot? And if the ships are armed, won't even more of the attacks happen at night in order to counter the shooting defense?

Shhhh... did you see that lightning?
 
If many of the attacks happen at night, aren't the endless pages of posts here about the ease of hitting a pirate boat moot? And if the ships are armed, won't even more of the attacks happen at night in order to counter the shooting defense?

Yes.
 
One effective defense has been for the crew to go into a safe room and wait for the cavalry to come clean out the pirates with overwhelming force. Without a crew of hostages to hide behind, the pirates are exposed and quickly surrender.

The pirate strategy is therefore to try and take control of the ship and hostages before they are spotted. This is probably not possible in the daylight where anyone on deck could see them coming a mile away.
 
The book on piracy I looked at mentioned the low-level piracy in the South Pacific.. Thai and Phillipine pirates go after fishermen, extorting what little these people have.
A strong government in the area where there are pirates seems to clean up the problem.
Those working the Carolinas in the 1700s were accomodated by some of the colonies governments, until the regime was changed through appointments in London.
Were it possible for Somalia to get a strong government, then the pirate problem would be workable at both ends.
Cutting out the sources and havens.
 
If many of the attacks happen at night, aren't the endless pages of posts here about the ease of hitting a pirate boat moot? And if the ships are armed, won't even more of the attacks happen at night in order to counter the shooting defense?

Perhaps you need to read the thread closer. It was discussed about posting guards at night or cycling the crew out in hour shifts to keep watch.
 
That's a good point. But the Somali pirates are not a country and so are not subject to political pressures. Since they are individuals that can disappear and blend in with the population, it will take a significant police action to track down enough of the pirate organization to prevent them from operating.

The point is that to implement such a scheme they will have to get organised and equiped to a point where they represent a target.

Small loose organisations are not that vulnerable but can not acomplich that much either.
 
Small loose organisations are not that vulnerable but can not acomplich that much either.

It doesn't take a large organization to gather explosives, a few boats and some rope. The cost would probably be similar to equipping 20 pirates with AKs and RPGs.
 
Perhaps you need to read the thread closer. It was discussed about posting guards at night or cycling the crew out in hour shifts to keep watch.
Perhaps you need to read the thread closer. Several pages were spent discussing one's ability to hit a small boat with small arms fire. At night, the discussion is virtually moot.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom