Easy solution to the pirate problem...

You have a pretty shallow definition of "win."

I'm all for encouraging them to avoid hijacking ships, but I'd rather the goal be in deterring the Somali groups engaged in piracy from even considering it an option. I'm not convinced an overwhelming display of power is going to stop them, and will at best keep them mostly at bay until we lose interest.

What you've just said here has made me realize that this is something that requires a multi-prong approach.

People mentioned gangs and comparisons with police vs gangs and I think this is key.

Police are there to try to proect people from crime. But they are not there to analyze or fix the underlying problems which cause crime, or let such concerns stop them from doing their jobs. That's the job of government, or charities, and so forth. We don't argue that having police is bad because it causes escalation of crime. That would be ridiculous. You fight crime when you can. You don't lie down to it, and therefore, further encourage it.

I think it's the same here. The idea of some security people being on boats is, to me, akin to having police around. These are unenforced, international waters. No one else is there to protect them. And I think the idea that they shouldn't have any kind of security or protection that includes weapons, because of concerns of other pirates and the root causes and all that, is as ridiculous as saying we should not have any police for the same reasons. You don't let people get away with this sort of thing. It encourages it. You stand against it.

Taking on the bigger problems which cause the piracy should be the job of nations. Come together to work on solutions to the problems. A two pronged approach. Some kind of protection is clearly warranted for the ships. But there should also be a bigger approach taken up by the UN or someone to try to fix this problem as well.
 
Last edited:
This is where your higher ups would need to take action. Supplying the ships with a few AKs would not be terribly expensive (AKs can be bought for less than 350 a piece. I bought mine for 345 and this is through a gun store. Buying in bulk would be significantly cheaper). Then pay money to fully train one person on each ship (Preferably a leader). Then that person could train the crew in a day or two. Honestly, I have trained people with no rifle knowledge whatsoever in a half an hour.

I believe you, but I think your scenario is too optimistic. I have taught people how to safely handle a gun in an hour, but someone on a ship’s security force needs to know much more than keeping the business end pointed the right way and putting bullets into paper.

I have received very little military firearms training, but I know that a person defending the ship will need to know how to use concealment and cover and know the difference between the two. Regular training by an experienced instructor while underway is the key. Simply tossing a wooden target off the ship as it turns and having the crew shoot it while a spotter grades their performance can be valuable experience. Towing an old lifeboat 100-200 yards off the stern would make a good target also. If there is one thing good shooters all have in common is that they shoot often.

I think it is unlikely that one member of the crew can pass on all he or she learns from their lessons unless they themselves become a proficient instructor was well as a good shot. While I have been trained as a firearms safety officer, I know I have significant limitations as it is something I do not do on a regular basis.

Ranb
 
Toke can say if I already did. I hope the pirates have your intellect so we have time to develop a defense.

The idea of a floating mine with a rope to be cauth by the bulb will require that you get in front and close to the merchant ship to deploy.
The problem of detonation could be solved by having a wire along the rope and tow the mine from your speedboat.
Cut in front of the ship and detonate it when you guess it is alongside on the other side of the ship.
Depending on mine size (a 25L can?) the rope might break, the wire be rubbed raw on the bulb, the pull combined with bowwave may capzise your boat?

Radiodetonation with sea anchor and mine on each end of a rope would let you deploy and leave. There would still be problems with timing and making it strong enough to take the suddel 8-12-24 knots of the ship.

Most vessels are double hulled, they have the ballast tanks along the sides and bottom ot the ship. I don´t know how big a mine a speedboat can tow or how big it have to be to go through a side tank and into the cargo hold.
It will explode in the surface and therefore have less power than a traditional mine.

It is a clumsy risky weapon that does not generate a profit.

If you don´t board a ship but engage in a "naval" battle you are a seperate target for any real navy units showing up. Instead of having to board a vessel with hostages onboard they can simply open fire.

So no a stickup at sea is not a good idea compared to boarding.
 
It's worth pointing out that there are four major distinct groups of pirates and their expertise, equipment, tactics and motives are quite different in each case.
 
Maybe. My only experience with full auto was with a modified AR-15. I put 20 rounds in one burst towards a propane cylinder (empty with holes) at 200 yards while prone on a rest. The spotter described my group as 2 feet wide and 20 feet high. I might have had a few rounds hit the cylinder, which was about the same width as a human torso. It was not an encouraging experience for someone who wanted to hit the target.

If we are talking about proficient marksman using controlled semi-auto fire, then I think the odds of an incapacitating hit on a target improve.

Ranb
.

Blackwater should have a few murderminded thugs mercenaries for hire with lots of real weapons training.
They get on the ship(s) going south through the pirate zone, then transfer to ship(s) going north on a regular basis.
 
.

Blackwater should have a few murderminded thugs mercenaries for hire with lots of real weapons training.
They get on the ship(s) going south through the pirate zone, then transfer to ship(s) going north on a regular basis.
Hell, there's probably rich goons who would pay the shipping companies to ride along and hunt for pirates. African pirate safaris!

Oh sure it's barbaric, but who are we to judge?






;)
 
There would still be problems with timing and making it strong enough to take the sudden 8-12-24 knots of the ship.

Figuring within a mile or more where a ship is going to pass is almost trivial. The pirates are probably already using AIS to locate the ships now. Sizing for strength is just a mater of calculation. Half a mile of poly will give plenty of spring to handle the acceleration which will be minimized by the cosine factor anyway. Even if the ship doesn't sink, the damage is going to be many times the small toll being demanded.

I expect you will continue to deny the possibility. They said nobody anticipated the use of commercial airliners as weapons before 9/11 too.
 
Figuring within a mile or more where a ship is going to pass is almost trivial. The pirates are probably already using AIS to locate the ships now. Sizing for strength is just a mater of calculation. Half a mile of poly will give plenty of spring to handle the acceleration which will be minimized by the cosine factor anyway. Even if the ship doesn't sink, the damage is going to be many times the small toll being demanded.

I expect you will continue to deny the possibility. They said nobody anticipated the use of commercial airliners as weapons before 9/11 too.
And what if they use sharks with laser beams attached to their heads? :rolleyes:
 
I expect you will continue to deny the possibility. They said nobody anticipated the use of commercial airliners as weapons before 9/11 too.

I am not quite denying it, I am pointing out some of the practical problems with the weapon, as well as the problem with incentive/metod of payment.

The radiodetonation still require you to stay close enough to see when the mine is alongside.
And it must be deployed close enough for the ship to be unable to turn away. If the rope is too long or the ship hit in the anchor end the mine will come alongside behind the ship.

The idea is not as good as you think.
 
Mining ships is rather a flawed plan for the pirates; their income relies on them capturing the ships and then returning them in one piece after a ransom is paid. If they start mining ships they'll be destroying their source of income.
 
If you can't figure it out for yourself, I'm not going to tell you how to run an extortion racket.
 
If they started sinking ships, armed crew would be the least of their problems.
 
If you can't figure it out for yourself, I'm not going to tell you how to run an extortion racket.

An extortion racket doesn't work if it involves destroying something you're trying to seize control of.
 
The idea is not as good as you think.

It's only your understanding of the idea that is not so good.

If deployed as a mine, detonation can be automatic and therefore the weapon is set and forget. The sea anchor pulls the payload into position by using the bow as a pulley so it doesn't require any accuracy in placement. There is no real limitation on the length of the line and therefore the capture area except for the increased cost.
 
I know a number of merchant seamen.
Quite apart from the fact they are untrained in the use of distance weapons, some of them might be tempted to indulge in a little buccaneering themselves if presented with the appropriate armament. Or they would sell the ammunition and claim to have used it while heroically defending their employers' property.

Putting some marines on vessels in danger areas might be a wiser move for all concerned.
 
An extortion racket doesn't work if it involves destroying something you're trying to seize control of.

I wonder how payments will be arranged if they are not in controll of the ships.

Some sort of fee to traverse the area?
That requires alot of organication.

Why is nobody demanding a fee to sail the english channel?
When you answer that, you will know why this will not work.
 
An extortion racket doesn't work if it involves destroying something you're trying to seize control of.

I guess the stories of the mafia extortion rackets were exaggerated and accidents just happened.

ETA: Reference Muadib on the relationship of destruction and control.
 
Last edited:
I guess the stories of the mafia extortion rackets were exaggerated and accidents just happened.

Really? The mafia extortion rackets worked by saying "if you don't give us X we'll destroy X"?
 
Why is nobody demanding a fee to sail the english channel?
When you answer that, you will know why this will not work.

Last I looked, the english channel was not bordered by an impoverished country with a significant population that has nothing to loose by turning to piracy.

That is the ultimate solution to the problem but will still take time to implement once the world realizes that it needs to act.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom