You have a pretty shallow definition of "win."
I'm all for encouraging them to avoid hijacking ships, but I'd rather the goal be in deterring the Somali groups engaged in piracy from even considering it an option. I'm not convinced an overwhelming display of power is going to stop them, and will at best keep them mostly at bay until we lose interest.
What you've just said here has made me realize that this is something that requires a multi-prong approach.
People mentioned gangs and comparisons with police vs gangs and I think this is key.
Police are there to try to proect people from crime. But they are not there to analyze or fix the underlying problems which cause crime, or let such concerns stop them from doing their jobs. That's the job of government, or charities, and so forth. We don't argue that having police is bad because it causes escalation of crime. That would be ridiculous. You fight crime when you can. You don't lie down to it, and therefore, further encourage it.
I think it's the same here. The idea of some security people being on boats is, to me, akin to having police around. These are unenforced, international waters. No one else is there to protect them. And I think the idea that they shouldn't have any kind of security or protection that includes weapons, because of concerns of other pirates and the root causes and all that, is as ridiculous as saying we should not have any police for the same reasons. You don't let people get away with this sort of thing. It encourages it. You stand against it.
Taking on the bigger problems which cause the piracy should be the job of nations. Come together to work on solutions to the problems. A two pronged approach. Some kind of protection is clearly warranted for the ships. But there should also be a bigger approach taken up by the UN or someone to try to fix this problem as well.
Last edited: