Easy solution to the pirate problem...

My name seems to be coming up in connection with how well small arms work at repelling pirates. I have to say that while I am familiar with firearms and a decent shot, I am not a police officer, soldier or engaged in any kind of occupation that requires an expertise in their use.

While I can easily hit a target at 600 yards or less given any decent rifle, this only applies to stationary targets and a steady shooting position. While a large container ship may be rather stable, any boat riding the waves behind it and maneuvering into position is going to be a challenge for me due to the angular velocity. If the target is moving directly towards or away from the shooting position, then it is much more simple. Move the target across the field of view and it becomes something like sheet shooting, something I do poorly.

Unless the people posting have experience shooting small moving targets from an elevated/moving position, then we need to qualify our responses when we state our opinions. This is why I value the opinions of those currently in the merchant marine. Nothing beats actually being there. Thanks.

Ranb
 
There are ways to make inflatables resistant to most small arms fire nowadays. It's not even much of a big deal, and they're not limited to just military use.
.
But...
How many of these private entrepeneurs are going to get upscaled boats and weaponry when the victim is also doing it with a greater desire to not get boarded and ransomed?
 
My name seems to be coming up in connection with how well small arms work at repelling pirates. I have to say that while I am familiar with firearms and a decent shot, I am not a police officer, soldier or engaged in any kind of occupation that requires an expertise in their use.

....
Ranb
.
High rates of fire make up for lack of accuracy.
 
.
But...
How many of these private entrepeneurs are going to get upscaled boats and weaponry when the victim is also doing it with a greater desire to not get boarded and ransomed?

Ask Toke. I'm not sure that those types of rafts are exactly uncommon.
 

Sorry I missed the bottom question. No I am not going to go to the library and check out books you want me to read. Sorry. Post the quote and citation if you would like.

But as far as it being easy to arm crews, well it is. It's not hard to go purchase firearms and put them on ships. It is also not hard to give people little training on those weapons. The hard part is getting companies to decide to go this route.
 
What you are talking about here is COMPLETELY different from pirates boarding ships for a profit. Please tell me how this relates to it?

It's you that wanted to change the pirates behavior by shooting at them. I'm just showing one of the possible replacement behaviors you could get.

The pirates are still threatening the ships and crew and demanding payment to let them go but your crew armed with pea shooting AKs and assault rifles are now completely helpless to stop the attack.
 
Sorry I missed the bottom question. No I am not going to go to the library and check out books you want me to read. Sorry. Post the quote and citation if you would like.

But as far as it being easy to arm crews, well it is. It's not hard to go purchase firearms and put them on ships. It is also not hard to give people little training on those weapons. The hard part is getting companies to decide to go this route.

Not only didn't you read it the first time. You didn't understand it the second time.

I'd like to know if you agree with me that, whether or not it's a good idea, the question of arming the crews of merchants ships is not as simple or "easy" as you originally claimed.

Let me clarify, if that's not clear enough already:

I'm not asking you if it's a task that can be done with ease. I'm asking you if, after having read this thread, you agree that the problem might not be as simple as you think and that the solution might not be such a black-and-white matter.
 
But as far as it being easy to arm crews, well it is. It's not hard to go purchase firearms and put them on ships. It is also not hard to give people little training on those weapons. The hard part is getting companies to decide to go this route.



My company is too cheap to provide english courses for the polish ab´s.
The problem of arming a ship is mostly economic and legal, not practical.

It would be no problem to weld on some brackets around the ship for weapons. We can be sent on weapons training while home on vacation, and learn to fire a weapon.

The ship is pretty stable with mostly predictable movements, at least in weather that will allow a small boat to come alongside.

I take for granted that both rifle and machineguns can be fittet to a mount and benefit from it. Several mounts will be needed to move between and cover blind angles.

I have no idea at what range an ak47 can go through steel plate, but we will have better cover than someone in a small boat, and can weld up some plates where needed.
 
It's you that wanted to change the pirates behavior by shooting at them. I'm just showing one of the possible replacement behaviors you could get.

The pirates are still threatening the ships and crew and demanding payment to let them go but your crew armed with pea shooting AKs and assault rifles are now completely helpless to stop the attack.

Pea shooting AK? What in the world does that mean? The 7.62 round is quite powerful. How would that make the crew completely helpless to stop the attack?
 
Not only didn't you read it the first time. You didn't understand it the second time.

I'd like to know if you agree with me that, whether or not it's a good idea, the question of arming the crews of merchants ships is not as simple or "easy" as you originally claimed.

Let me clarify, if that's not clear enough already:

I'm not asking you if it's a task that can be done with ease. I'm asking you if, after having read this thread, you agree that the problem might not be as simple as you think and that the solution might not be such a black-and-white matter.
No. It's pretty black and white to me. Arm the crews so they have a means to defend themselves. Its quite simple. Or even give the crew the option to bring their personal rifles on board to save money.
 
Pea shooting AK? What in the world does that mean? The 7.62 round is quite powerful. How would that make the crew completely helpless to stop the attack?

I notice you again fail to address the situation at hand. Your crew is helpless because the pirates no longer need to board the ship to make their demands. Now, are you going to pay the toll or find out how well your crew can swim with those AKs.
 
No. It's pretty black and white to me. Arm the crews so they have a means to defend themselves. Its quite simple. Or even give the crew the option to bring their personal rifles on board to save money.

It is not that simple.

Yes, I would like to be trained and armed for pirate waters.
We are not sheep and do not like the idea of surrendering, we just don´t have that many options for stopping pirates.

I do not have a personal (assault) rifle and do not like the idea of bringing it through several airports, and then through customs and down to the ship.

The only clear black/white thing here is wheter pirates would go elsewhere if shot at.
 
I notice you again fail to address the situation at hand. Your crew is helpless because the pirates no longer need to board the ship to make their demands. Now, are you going to pay the toll or find out how well your crew can swim with those AKs.

So you are suggesting that somehow the pirates are going to hold the ships hostage with boats equipped with IEDs? I don't think so.
 
I notice you again fail to address the situation at hand. Your crew is helpless because the pirates no longer need to board the ship to make their demands. Now, are you going to pay the toll or find out how well your crew can swim with those AKs.
Oh right, they're going to develop drone boats capable of blowing up a moving cargo ship... :rolleyes:
 
It is not that simple.

Yes, I would like to be trained and armed for pirate waters.
We are not sheep and do not like the idea of surrendering, we just don´t have that many options for stopping pirates.

I do not have a personal (assault) rifle and do not like the idea of bringing it through several airports, and then through customs and down to the ship.

The only clear black/white thing here is wheter pirates would go elsewhere if shot at.

This is where your higher ups would need to take action. Supplying the ships with a few AKs would not be terribly expensive (AKs can be bought for less than 350 a piece. I bought mine for 345 and this is through a gun store. Buying in bulk would be significantly cheaper). Then pay money to fully train one person on each ship (Preferably a leader). Then that person could train the crew in a day or two. Honestly, I have trained people with no rifle knowledge whatsoever in a half an hour.
 
.
High rates of fire make up for lack of accuracy.

Maybe. My only experience with full auto was with a modified AR-15. I put 20 rounds in one burst towards a propane cylinder (empty with holes) at 200 yards while prone on a rest. The spotter described my group as 2 feet wide and 20 feet high. I might have had a few rounds hit the cylinder, which was about the same width as a human torso. It was not an encouraging experience for someone who wanted to hit the target.

If we are talking about proficient marksman using controlled semi-auto fire, then I think the odds of an incapacitating hit on a target improve.

Ranb
 
This is where your higher ups would need to take action. Supplying the ships with a few AKs would not be terribly expensive (AKs can be bought for less than 350 a piece. I bought mine for 345 and this is through a gun store. Buying in bulk would be significantly cheaper). Then pay money to fully train one person on each ship (Preferably a leader). Then that person could train the crew in a day or two. Honestly, I have trained people with no rifle knowledge whatsoever in a half an hour.

Lifeboat drills cost more lifes than are safed by lifeboats.

I want weapons training to take place ashore at a real range with real instructors. Ships should have some procedure to avoid accidents onboard, maybe keeping ammo and weapons seperate until pirates are spotted.

You may find that non gun owners are too worried about safe handling of weapons.
I find non electricians too worried about what they can and cannot touch in a swichtboard. (actually not:D, if they don´t know what they are doing, don´t do it.)
 
Maybe. My only experience with full auto was with a modified AR-15. I put 20 rounds in one burst towards a propane cylinder (empty with holes) at 200 yards while prone on a rest. The spotter described my group as 2 feet wide and 20 feet high. I might have had a few rounds hit the cylinder, which was about the same width as a human torso. It was not an encouraging experience for someone who wanted to hit the target.

If we are talking about proficient marksman using controlled semi-auto fire, then I think the odds of an incapacitating hit on a target improve.

Ranb

The only purpose of full auto in an assault rifle would be at close range. For our purposes, full auto would work great if a pirate boat pulled right up along beside the ship. Point the AK over the edge and spray right into the boat. But at range, semi is best.
 
Oh right, they're going to develop drone boats capable of blowing up a moving cargo ship... :rolleyes:

Toke can say if I already did. I hope the pirates have your intellect so we have time to develop a defense.
 
Lifeboat drills cost more lifes than are safed by lifeboats.

I want weapons training to take place ashore at a real range with real instructors. Ships should have some procedure to avoid accidents onboard, maybe keeping ammo and weapons seperate until pirates are spotted.

You may find that non gun owners are too worried about safe handling of weapons.
I find non electricians too worried about what they can and cannot touch in a swichtboard. (actually not:D, if they don´t know what they are doing, don´t do it.)

Of course you would not have to have the weapons training on the ship. If you want real instructors to train you that's fine, may cost a bit more but it is a one time fee. And accidents with the weapons would most likely not be an issue, as they should just sit in an arms room until needed. Keep the magazines out of the weapons until you need them as well. Remember, a weapon is not going to fire unless you chamber a round, take the weapon off safe, and pull the trigger.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom