Easy solution to the pirate problem...

At what stage are the pirates usually noticed by the crew?
Upon approach? Or when in the process of boarding?

Gumboots info on failed attacks seem encouraging. If most attacks can be repelled with water hoses and barbed wire, then two or three AK's would really throw the balance in the crews favour.

eta: and by what means are the pirates noticed? Visual contact? Radar? Other sensors?

Given the size of the cargo ships and how small the crews are it's a question I'd like answered as well.



It's a good question. Reading through the accounts, it seems to me a lot of the attacks happen at night, so I am guessing that visual detection plays a big part. A lot of the ships seem to escape the pirates by turning off their lights and performing evasive maneuvers. This strongly suggests the pirates are detected before they reach the ships.

In other cases it appears ships don't have a watch set - one ship was boarded and all of the Indian crew members taken without the Korean crew realising it (that was a pretty odd incident).
 
I think detection is the key here.

If the crew can get a warning when the pirates are still in a very bad strategic position, then defence seems feasible. Even with an untrained crew.

So, electronic detection systems would be an excellent investment for shipping companies. I suspect that I'm not the first one to come up with this idea, so there must be a reason why merchant ships are not equipped with such systems. High maintenance? Expensive? Complicated to operate? I don't know.

Oh and if the attacks happen mostly at night:
Detection, floodlights, automatic fire.

Problem solved. In an ideal world.

The weapons might not even be necessary.
 
Brainwave!

Just get a bunch of Supersoakers and fill them with battery acid.:D

I'll go back to work now.
 
Here you go wildcat. Your search ability and memory need more work.
I think Ranb overestimates the lengths the pirates are willing to go to take a ship. There's no profit in getting killed.

As the Clint Eastwood character Josey Wales once said "Dyin' ain't much of a livin' boy".
 
I think Ranb overestimates the lengths the pirates are willing to go to take a ship. There's no profit in getting killed.

As the Clint Eastwood character Josey Wales once said "Dyin' ain't much of a livin' boy".

Of course, it must also be considered what value the pirates place on their own lives, the likelihood that their hoarded resources can sustain them through an aborted raiding attempt, and what other career opportunities they have available.
 
Of course, it must also be considered what value the pirates place on their own lives, the likelihood that their hoarded resources can sustain them through an aborted raiding attempt, and what other career opportunities they have available.
Not even the most desperate mugger decides to rob a uniformed policeman.

They will pick the weak target. If they receive fire from one ship they will move on to another one, even if it is also armed they think maybe they can take it by surprise. No reason at all to press an attack on a ship when surprise is lost and you are taking fire.
 
I think Ranb overestimates the lengths the pirates are willing to go to take a ship. There's no profit in getting killed.

As the Clint Eastwood character Josey Wales once said "Dyin' ain't much of a livin' boy".

And I think you underestimate the mode of thinking of these criminals, who have already proven to be less risk-averse. Urban gangs don't get less violent when they're met with overwhelming force from law enforcement or some other group, and no one has provided any explanation as to why these groups of pirates wouldn't likely follow the same pattern as gangs since they're practically operating like gangs already. I agree that overwhelming military force is likely to send them running-- people are rarely that stupid to charge at a force like that-- but if the fire is coming from their targets, barring clearly and loudly projecting that the ships are being protected by military, what is the reasoning for expecting the pirates to fold?
 
In your opinion, how much training would an average civilian need to defend a merchant ship?

I'd say with a AK, as it seems the most powerful weapon that is also reasonably user friendly. (going on widespread use by child soldiers)

Why did you answer my question with a question that was unrelated to mine?
 
Why did you answer my question with a question that was unrelated to mine?

Because I wanted to ask this question to you specifically, you have military training.

Must have tagged my question the wrong post. My bad. Sorry.
 
Sure and it was because everyone on the plane was a coward that the twin towers were brought down right?

Some may have been cowards sure. I can't comment on their level of courage. That situation was much different though. The passengers were led to believe that a bomb was on the plane and if they tried anything the attackers would blow the plane up. Notice though how was the passengers on the United 93 took over the plane once they learned that there were no bombs and that it was only a suicide mission. If they had chose to be victims, that plane could have ended up hitting another heavily populated building.
 
Because I wanted to ask this question to you specifically, you have military training.

Must have tagged my question the wrong post. My bad. Sorry.

Well to answer your question, training on an AK or any rifle for that matter is pretty straight forward. The basics of marksmanship can be taught in a day. I know this because I have taught them to new soldiers before in that time period.
 
And I think you underestimate the mode of thinking of these criminals, who have already proven to be less risk-averse. Urban gangs don't get less violent when they're met with overwhelming force from law enforcement or some other group, and no one has provided any explanation as to why these groups of pirates wouldn't likely follow the same pattern as gangs since they're practically operating like gangs already. I agree that overwhelming military force is likely to send them running-- people are rarely that stupid to charge at a force like that-- but if the fire is coming from their targets, barring clearly and loudly projecting that the ships are being protected by military, what is the reasoning for expecting the pirates to fold?

You must not be reading ANY of the posts. Did you see any of the stuff gumboot posted about how the pirates were deterred simply by hoses and barbed wire? And with gangs, are you kidding? Gangs usually SCATTER when a police force show up as do most criminals.
 
You must not be reading ANY of the posts. Did you see any of the stuff gumboot posted about how the pirates were deterred simply by hoses and barbed wire? And with gangs, are you kidding? Gangs usually SCATTER when a police force show up as do most criminals.

They scatter, but they don't leave or stop doing what they were doing. You're mistaking avoidance of getting caught with deterrence.
 
BTW, Where's Captain Rambo now?

Lol. Sorry but some of us can't stay up all night posting on a forum when they wake up at 5 in the morning or earlier everyday.

I told you before that I could put an explosive packed speedboat on the hull of your ship. The only response was to deny the existence of radio control technology.

Somalia being a poor backwards country may in fact not have a hobby store with radio control systems so I'll do it without the tech. And I don't need a suicide volunteer either. (And don't bother asking how it's done because if you can't figure it out there is a slim possibility that the pirates and jihadists won't figure it out and I'm not about to tell them by posting instruction in an open forum)

The only detail left is how to inform the captain that he should stop. Perhaps integrating a thumper into the payload will get his attention. ( ETA: If it doesn't attract the worms first :) )

What you are talking about here is COMPLETELY different from pirates boarding ships for a profit. Please tell me how this relates to it?
 
They scatter, but they don't leave or stop doing what they were doing. You're mistaking avoidance of getting caught with deterrence.

I still don't see what you are getting at here. If you can ward off your attackers, you win.
 
They scatter, but they don't leave or stop doing what they were doing. You're mistaking avoidance of getting caught with deterrence.
And deterrence is the issue. Some gangs may be heavily armed, but even then they don't engage in pitched battles with the police or even other gangs. Far more likely to do a drive-by.

And in the pirate's case there's no profit in doing a drive-by. That's basically what they do in the half of the attacks they carry out which are unsuccessful.

These are crimes of opportunity, not warriors fighting for an ideology greater than themselves. Unless you believe all the crap about them just defending their territory from foreign fishermen and toxic waste dumpers...
 
Last edited:
And deterrence is the issue. Some gangs may be heavily armed, but even then they don't engage in pitched battles with the police or even other gangs. Far more likely to do a drive-by.

And in the pirate's case there's no profit in doing a drive-by. That's basically what they do in the half of the attacks they carry out which are unsuccessful.

These are crimes of opportunity, not warriors fighting for an ideology greater than themselves. Unless you believe all the crap about them just defending their territory from foreign fishermen and toxic waste dumpers...

Oh, I don't believe that claptrap at all. That doesn't mean I'm convinced that some of them don't believe it, or something close to it. The guys running the pirating operations are quite likely in it for the profit, but when their resources include expendable people, then much like gangs I don't see them worrying too much about the losses that might occur except for how to use them as methods for getting the rest of their people all fired up to hurt back at those who hurt their guys.

-----

I still don't see what you are getting at here. If you can ward off your attackers, you win.

You have a pretty shallow definition of "win."

I'm all for encouraging them to avoid hijacking ships, but I'd rather the goal be in deterring the Somali groups engaged in piracy from even considering it an option. I'm not convinced an overwhelming display of power is going to stop them, and will at best keep them mostly at bay until we lose interest.
 
I see the word "inflatable" being used as a descriptor for the attack vessels.
Seems to me, the natural enemy of the inflatable is something that would -deflate- it... like say, BULLETS!
The simple cow-herders who've graduated from riding around Mogadishu in their technicals, which when a tire goes flat can steal another tire easily, might think twice, or even once, when 50 miles out in the ocean and their "inflatable" becomes an anchor, and no one offers to give them a ride.
 
There are ways to make inflatables resistant to most small arms fire nowadays. It's not even much of a big deal, and they're not limited to just military use.
 
In that case why not try to find the book and read it, yourself ?

In any case, I'd like to know if you agree with me that, whether or not it's a good idea, the question of arming the crews of merchants ships is not as simple or "easy" as you originally claimed.

There's much to consider.

Quad ?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom