Easy solution to the pirate problem...

I will disregard it until I can read the actual account that he is talking about.

In that case why not try to find the book and read it, yourself ?

In any case, I'd like to know if you agree with me that, whether or not it's a good idea, the question of arming the crews of merchants ships is not as simple or "easy" as you originally claimed.

There's much to consider.
 
So you agree that self defense is justified. Glad to hear it.

My take on it is that arming the crews (for "self-defense") can deter the pirates, but it also automatically creates a situation where shots WILL be fired, as opposed to MAY. It's like arming yourself to go to the bank just in case there's a robbery. You may scare the robbers away, or you might get yourself and a lot of people killed that wouldn't have been, otherwise.
 
My god. Are the profit margins really this abysmal in the shipping industry?

Getting a couple of ex-SEALs would probably be a bit steep. But India for instance has a huge and underpaid army. They have reasonable professional standards.

But you have to higher hundreds for every one who does the job. Remember you need to compare to the cost to the ransom costs, not the costs of losing a ship.
 
Apparently if you want to fight instead of being hostage or just simply defend yourself you are Rambo. Don't ask me how they come up with this stuff.

Sure and it was because everyone on the plane was a coward that the twin towers were brought down right?
 
Perhaps I'm misreading, but seems to me those who poo-poo the notion of self defense and label it "escalation" are saying fighting back is worse than the original act of piracy.

You're misreading. I suspect intentionally so.
 
Their commanders chose to send in the QRF. The force stayed in the city because they were having difficult extracting one of the bodies from the wreckage of Super 6-1, and they refused to leave anyone behind. Once the body was extracted they blew the wreck and left.

It's about the only point regarding the book and film that the members of Task Force Ranger are unhappy with, and something they often reiterate. They could have left the city, but it would have meant leaving dead and wounded behind. They chose to remain, because they "Leave no man behind".

How do you know who to believe?
 
Perhaps I'm misreading, but seems to me those who poo-poo the notion of self defense and label it "escalation" are saying fighting back is worse than the original act of piracy.

Trying to evaluate a situation to see if self defense or complaince is the best in that situation is poo-pooing the notion of self defense?
 
I have zero experince with firearms, but lots of experince stopping on the brigde for a cup of coffe and some seawiev.

I am simply assuming that rifles are less impressive to pirates than a stream of tracer from a high point with a good view around the ship. And 100 round belts and some sort of bracket/pintel makes for better chances of hitting/scaring pirates. Particulary as crews are unlikely to be very good shots.

There might be a legal difference between an ak47 and a light machinegun, but I would want every advantage I can get, and I don´t see a practical problem in carring a machinegun from a locker on the brigde to the window.

One of our 2.engineers are in the home army and mentioned the idea to me.


That doesn't address the root problem. The passing ships are still a potential source of income for the pirates who have few if any other options. Their current tactic is a stealth approach and attempting to board without being seen. When every ship has posted 24 hr sentries and carries a sufficient armory to repel the boarders the pirates will shift tactics. The new tactic may involve a single boat approaching the ship and demanding a cash toll be paid to insure safe passage.

Will it actually be necessary for the pirates to back their threat with proof that they can sink a merchant ship before the tolls are paid?
 
Support this claim.
.
Most criminals are in the business for its ease of performance.
They look for defenseless prey.
Fight back, they will look elsewhere.
When the criminals are in boats way out in the ocean, with nowhere to hide, or escape to when fired at, even the dumbest should be able to finger out that not attacking -that- boat is better for survival.
I believe it was a lot of enforcement in the days of the glamorous pirates that got rid of them.
Make the task too difficult/dangerous for these people, they'll yearn for the good old days of cattle herding instead of drowning.
 
That doesn't address the root problem. The passing ships are still a potential source of income for the pirates who have few if any other options. Their current tactic is a stealth approach and attempting to board without being seen. When every ship has posted 24 hr sentries and carries a sufficient armory to repel the boarders the pirates will shift tactics. The new tactic may involve a single boat approaching the ship and demanding a cash toll be paid to insure safe passage.

Will it actually be necessary for the pirates to back their threat with proof that they can sink a merchant ship before the tolls are paid?

We do not carry cash.
The pirates will need an upgrade in armory to sink vessels.
If they start looking like a real navy they will be bombed like one.
 
BTW, Where's Captain Rambo now?
If you were referring to me you may want to take note of the time of your post where I live. Unlike some here, I don't keep my location a secret.

I told you before that I could put an explosive packed speedboat on the hull of your ship. The only response was to deny the existence of radio control technology.
Oh look, a complete lie! I guess you must know your position is in trouble to resort to such a tactic.

Somalia being a poor backwards country may in fact not have a hobby store with radio control systems so I'll do it without the tech. And I don't need a suicide volunteer either. (And don't bother asking how it's done because if you can't figure it out there is a slim possibility that the pirates and jihadists won't figure it out and I'm not about to tell them by posting instruction in an open forum)

The only detail left is how to inform the captain that he should stop. Perhaps integrating a thumper into the payload will get his attention. ( ETA: If it doesn't attract the worms first :) )
Go ahead Dan O.

Devise a remote controlled boat that can hit a moving target with enough accuracy to sink it. Remember, you have to be able to control this from a distance.


And the motivation for this is revenge? :rolleyes:

eta: take your remote-controlled car and hit a moving full-sized car with it from several blocks away. That is the problem you are facing.
 
Last edited:
You haven't seemed to convince Ranb of the ease of the shot and he is a shooter.

:confused:

Maybe you should wait to see what actually happens before engaging in hyperbole. These pirates as a whole seem to be much more motivated by profit than revenge. There is no profit in sinking a ship before removing the cargo, unless another group is paying the pirates to do so.

If a ship does not have any external security, then they need to defend themselves in some manner. These sailors are all alone on the sea. They can call for help, but it may be hours away. Whether they surrender, out run, or attack (water hoses or guns) the pirates is something the captain and crew have to decide for themselves. While the ship's owners may try to limit the crew's options, I am not going to criticize the crew's decisions. They are not the ones sitting behind a computer in the comfort of home awaiting the cargo that is shipped through pirate infested seas.

Have any merchant seamen currently sailing commented on this forum? It would be interesting to hear their views.

Ranb
 
We do not carry cash.

It's a good idea to remove the low hanging fruit. But apparently not universally followed as evidenced by this statement seen earlier:
After the other pirates boarded the boat, three of them accompanied the captain to a safe where he took out about $30000 in cash

And even if you don't have the cash on hand that trip, they could just tell you to have it ready on your next trip.


The pirates will need an upgrade in armory to sink vessels.
If they start looking like a real navy they will be bombed like one.

What would it take to sink or at least heavily damage a merchant ship? We saw what one little boat did to the heavily armored navy vessel in Yemen.

I could send you a PM of one possibility of an invisible pirate navy if you want to start planning a defense.
 
Here you go wildcat. Your search ability and memory need more work.


Has anyone here ever shot at a small boat from an elevated position? I do not think it is as easy as some here are saying. It is not enough to put a small hole in the hull. The engine or the persons driving the boat need to be incapacitated. While hitting the target with a shotgun would be less difficult, there is the problem of shot size, pattern and distance. #7 shot will be easier to hit with, but hardly the choice to damage anything that is tougher than a small bird or clay pigeon. Buck shot is more lethal, but at anything other than short range, the sparse shot pattern will make a solid hit less likely.
 
It's a good idea to remove the low hanging fruit. But apparently not universally followed as evidenced by this statement seen earlier:
​

And even if you don't have the cash on hand that trip, they could just tell you to have it ready on your next trip.

What would it take to sink or at least heavily damage a merchant ship? We saw what one little boat did to the heavily armored navy vessel in Yemen.

I could send you a PM of one possibility of an invisible pirate navy if you want to start planning a defense.

Small ships from small companies have to cary cash to pay their expenses, the larger ones have an agent in port to handle it. I have only sailed large vessels and are a bit biased there.

If pirates want to make an actual sea blocade of the bay of aden they will need something bigger than speedboats, with radars. And that is what navies are designed to take on.
GPS have narroved the sea lanes considerably, everyone follow the same shortest route, a radar outside that area and not fitting a AIS signal would attract navy interrest.

A speedboat with a rpg could make holes into the engineroom and eventually stop a ship. They may even be able to carry something bigger and make enough holes in the ship to sink it.
The problem is the profit, where is it?

I am quite quirius about pirate options, do PM me.
 
So you don't have any evidence for this specific case.
.
Actually, the 4 children involved in this particular case were seeking to supplement the shortfall in public assistance the orphanage sponsoring their pirate activities was experiencing due to the gangstas --oops, warlords.. oops, public administrators in Mogadishu in charge of distributing the tons of welfare who were dragging their feet and selling the internationally gathered and freely given goods instead of giving them to all those in need, therefore the nautical moonlighting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom