Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Definitely not. The crew could rotate out guard throughout the night. Working in 1-2 hour shifts would not be hard at all. Then in the day most of the crew would be awake anyways so there would be no need for a guard.

So who is doing their actual jobs when they are on watch?
 
You were confident it would be trivial to drive them away, so why was it so hard for the rangers and delta?

Entire city of thousands of people versus a 160 men in a strange city as compared to an outnumbering crew on a ship with a significant tactical advantage verus a few pirates. Do you even think before you type things?
 
So who is doing their actual jobs when they are on watch?

Different ships require different types of work. When the majority of the crew is sleeping is really the only time a rotating guard would be needed. Other than that while the majority of the ship is awake during the day it is significantly easier to spot an approaching boat so no guard would be needed as there would almost always be someone on deck to spot it.
 
Sure thing, Quad. It's not an insult. :rolleyes:

Now, seriously, you're calling someone a sheep like you'd call someone a coward or a mindless follower and you don't expect it to be seen as rude ?

Of course not. Remember one is either a rational person who evaluates many courses of action to determine what has the best results, or one is a mindless thug.

Not quite as catchy though.
 
That's not it at all. People in the past believe that complying was your best chance of survival so they chose not to fight. Now people know that's not true, and choose not to fight.

You are failing to perpetuate the wolf/sheep dichotomy.

This is about real men who would rather be killed than taken hostage after all, everyone else are cowards. Haven't you been reading the thread?
 
Entire city of thousands of people versus a 160 men in a strange city as compared to an outnumbering crew on a ship with a significant tactical advantage verus a few pirates. Do you even think before you type things?

Yes, you claim that they were victorious, but generaly not dying is not victory, attaining your mission objectives is, but they didn't capture the warlord they set out to, and it was a humiliating defeat. We lost it, they one. Citing casualty statistics doesn't matter, because they attained their objectives and we failed at ours.

So you do have to grant that there is no reason to think that this

Even if you had just one AK47 on a ship and a person who was even remotely trained with it, they could defend an entire tanker. Its really easy to see if another little boat is approaching your ship. All you have to do is grab the AK, fire some warning shots at it. If they fail to stop, light them up.

Is anything other than bravado?
 
Thats why you don't let pirates board the damn ship.

They generally try not to. But initiating violence might not be the best way to get a preferable out come.

It is clear that you would consider Carter to be a much stronger president than Reagan. Carter at least tried to take it to the hostage takers, Reagan bought them off with weapons.
 
Nobody looks over the side during the day, there is work to do.
You would need an aditional wachman on the brigde during the day, thre is one during the night.

You have no idea how cheap the company is and I am not sure I have words for it.

The ISPS regulations require a guard at the gangway at all times, he is normally taken from the crew and is supposed to check id on anyone coming onboard.

Eccept if they look like longshoremen or coastguarders.

So if you demand id from a longshoreman they will all go home.
If you demand id from a coastguarder you will be arrested for obstructing the justice.
If you do not demand id from a coastguarder you will be arrested for not doing your job.

If you show a coastguarder around the engineroom and show him the 12 ballast pumps* lined up in the center of the engineroom. His superior will not find it amusing and work you over with the big legal rubber one.

*Cylinders of the main engine.
 
Yes, you claim that they were victorious, but generaly not dying is not victory, attaining your mission objectives is, but they didn't capture the warlord they set out to, and it was a humiliating defeat. We lost it, they one. Citing casualty statistics doesn't matter, because they attained their objectives and we failed at ours.

So you do have to grant that there is no reason to think that this



Is anything other than bravado?

You can choose to look at it that way if you like. But the fact that such a small amount of soldiers was able to hold off an entire city was a feat in itself. Just FYI, The battle of Mogadishu has NOTHING to do with what is going on right not.
 
The USS Cole was damaged by such an IED, but it was docked at the time and it required attackers willing to commit suicide. I've seen no indicaton that the pirates have suicidal members willing to take one for the team. Then there's the problem of hitting a moving target, it's not like planting a roadside bomb in Iraq. Ships don't stick to a 30 foot wide strip of water.

Shear size of modern ships renders targeting less of a problem. Suicide is not required. The K-Verband was useing remote controled explosive Linse back during WW2. Personaly I think the logistics required to get boats that can't really carry supplies near to their targets would render that method impractical.
 
You were confident it would be trivial to drive them away, so why was it so hard for the rangers and delta?
Are you really comparing a small force holding off thousands of hostile enemy deep in enemy territory to a dozen pirates attacking a cargo ship hundreds of miles out at sea?

Really?

Really?

:eek:
 
Shear size of modern ships renders targeting less of a problem. Suicide is not required. The K-Verband was useing remote controled explosive Linse back during WW2. Personaly I think the logistics required to get boats that can't really carry supplies near to their targets would render that method impractical.
Any evidence at all the Somalis have such things? You may as well stick to claiming that shooting a small boat at 100 meters with a rifle is comparable to hitting it at 10k with a 6 pound gun.
 
Nobody looks over the side during the day, there is work to do.
You would need an aditional wachman on the brigde during the day, thre is one during the night.....

Thanks for the insight. There is no substitute for actually being there. Keep the info coming please. :)

Ranb
 
I find this discussion fascinating. But I don't understand why those who are against arming crews are so convinced that these pirates would suddenly turn to outright war against the ships, sinking them when they can, etc. I think this is a bit hysterical or over-reacting. My gut tells me that the first sign of it becoming more difficult or dangerous to take these ships that most of them will get out of the business, not turn into homicidal psychopaths. They are opportunists.
 
Thanks for the insight. There is no substitute for actually being there. Keep the info coming please. :)

Ranb

I am in the western mediteranian/atlantic.
Currently between france and marcorroco.

I have been in pirate waters, but only on large container ships going 23-25 knots. The speed and freeboard made us unlikely pirate targets.

Feel free to ask for specifics, I am signing on friday evening for a more regular internet/dayrythm scedule than now.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom