Easy solution to the pirate problem...

It's your ship captain. You can shoot at it and hope you get lucky or you can stop your ship and invite the pirates on board for tea while your company arranges to pay the ransom.

I suspect your never surrender attitude will dictate your action but the ships owners may want to look for a different solution.

Wow. That is wrong in so many ways I cannot even begin to describe. I can't believe I just read that statement.
Edited by Gaspode: 
Edited for civility
Glad you aren't defending anything.

Keep it civil please.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Its not about defending material goods. Its about defending yourself. If you really think that no harm would come to you if you just comply with pirates (remember these guys come from a society where killing is an everyday thing to them and means nothing) then you are gravely naive. What if the negotiations go bad and they don't get what they want and they start killing hostages? There goes your little philosophy right out the window.

And since it MAY happen, let's just shoot and MAKE it happen. Great idea.
 
So they privateered pirates, and also turned their military forces on the situation, which seemed to have worked.

Do you think that would work today? Perhaps a 2-pronged approach: 1) using military forces to patrol the waters (UN-endorsed to be able to stop and arrest), and 2) figuring out a way to stop the problem at its roots (i.e. "fix" Somalia somehow, unite the country, get a working economy there).

SIGH

Seems like blowing them out of the water is a far easier approach, even though it does nothing to cure the underlying disease. :(

I think a two-pronged approach-- taking out pirates as well as attempting to address the underlying problems on the mainland in Somalia-- will eventually be the preferred approach, and will likely work out best. Blowing the pirates out of the water would be fairly easy for most of the military ships out there from different countries right now, but it probably won't slow down the aggression coming from the mainland since there are a lot of groups whose primary operations revolve around criminal activity in spite of the local government. They behave with impunity because they have guns and sufficient numbers to ignore the government, which is weak and fractured (and barely recognized by some neighbors).

It's a difficult climate over there right now, and just as surely as we could blow pirates away we could also send Somalia into all-out civil war (again) as a result.
 
What is it with people and calling other folk sheep ?

Both sides have good arguments in this thread, so far. I see no reason to resort to insults, at this point.

The term sheep in this context is much different than how a conspiracy theorist would use it. I am not using it as an insult, its just how some people are. You are a sheep if you run from the wolf and don't do anything to defend yourself. You are always a victim and can't fight for yourself. Not an insult, just a description.
 
So would a complete massacre of all hostages by pirates who did not get there way be enough to convince you that people need to defend themselves? Why even let it get to that point?

What part of "hasn't happened" did you not understand ?

I take back what I said two posts ago. This thread has already gone to insult mode by the time I got through page 1 :p

Like i said, they are trained. You obviously have no idea what we do in the Army do you?

Are you going to put a platoon of soldiers on EVERY cargo vessel ?

You take casualties in war, but you sure as HELL never surrender.

You never surrender in a war ? That's odd, because that's usually what they do when they lose. That or retreat.

Yes as of right now there have not been very many civilian casualties. But does that mean we should just let pirates keep hijacking vessels and give into their demands every time so nobody gets hurt?

Yes. Ensuring the safety of people is of prime importance.

Great, the pirates win.

You're going to have to agree to lose, sometimes.
 
You're going to have to agree to lose, sometimes.

Not in my vocab pal. I abide by my warrior ethos.

I will always place the mission first.
I will never accept defeat.
I will never quit.
I will never leave a fallen comrade.


[FONT=Verdana, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif]I will always place the mission first.
I will never accept defeat.
I will never quit.
I will never leave a fallen comrade.
[/FONT]
 
You don't need a 24 hour watch. There is always someone awake on a ship. Plus the crew could work out a rest plan to where they pull guard in shifts throughout the night or whenever. On a ship with a large crew this would not be a problem.
Crews are already at minimum levels to save cost. And you do need a 24 hour watch, the pirates aren't going to be nice and give you a full nights rest.


Even if it wasn't added to all ships, pirates will sure think twice before they board a ship and maybe if enough ships do it they would come to the conclusion that piracy is not worth their life.
Then they will simply find other ways. Also its stupid to engage pirates on their battlefield (cargoships). To be truly effective their bases have to be neutralized and their boats intercepted. To take the fight to them and not play defensive.


This is not true. With proper training gun accidents do not happen or are extremely minimal. Here I will give you the training right now:
Keep your finger out of the damn trigger well until you are ready to fire. Never point your weapon at something unless you intend to destroy it. Keep the weapon on safe until ready to fire. And for a ship, don't have a round in the chamber until there is imminent danger (You would not do this in a combat zone but just for kicks we can do it on the ship). Training complete.
You obviously never dealt with humans before in your life. What you presented is taught in every army and still humans will find a way to make room for gun accidents.


They would not have a chance if a proper guard is posted (They are already attempting to infiltrate the ships remember?)
Let me guess a proper guards would be 3 guards working in 8 hour shifts, who can never be surprised, tricked or bribed?
 
Obviously you are not an officer. Those bad guys have got guns. They have no training. They might hurt you if you use your guns. You are merely in charge of a bunch of disciplined, well-armed-and-trained, fit soldiers who occupy the high ground.
Obviously, you must throw down the guns and give up [/french accent]

Got something against the French ?
 
Yeah, good luck with sinking a moving 800 foot cargo ship with an IED.

Do able with modifed limpet mines at a pinch. Not aware of any cases because it is not something there is normaly any millitry need for.
 
If you can't hit a speedboat from high up on a 800 foot cargo ship you have worse than bad tactics, such as being legally blind perhaps.
WildCat, life isn't a PC game.

Speedboats are small, fast and unpredictable targets. While your shooting from an unstable platform. Lets compare:

Geez, what about trap or skeet shooting? Impossible!
Predictable, cluster ammo, and you have a stable platform.


To have an all around good chance of stopping pirates dead in their tracks you would need spray machine gun fire at them and also need good surface radar to detect them no matter what. But chances are that no nation would want such ships in their ports.
 
Do able with modifed limpet mines at a pinch. Not aware of any cases because it is not something there is normaly any millitry need for.
The USS Cole was damaged by such an IED, but it was docked at the time and it required attackers willing to commit suicide. I've seen no indicaton that the pirates have suicidal members willing to take one for the team. Then there's the problem of hitting a moving target, it's not like planting a roadside bomb in Iraq. Ships don't stick to a 30 foot wide strip of water.

WildCat, life isn't a PC game.

Speedboats are small, fast and unpredictable targets. While your shooting from an unstable platform. Lets compare:

Predictable, cluster ammo, and you have a stable platform.
You've obviouslky never done it. The only thing predictable is the clay pigeon will be flung, the direction and angle are unknown. And you have only a few seconds at most to hit the target.

A pirate boat often stays in range for hours on end while they try to manouver into position to attach their ladders/grappling hooks. And their boats are a much bigget target. The stern of a large ship is actually not a bad platform to shoot from, particularly since your opponents have a much less stable platform.

To have an all around good chance of stopping pirates dead in their tracks you would need spray machine gun fire at them and also need good surface radar to detect them no matter what. But chances are that no nation would want such ships in their ports.
I'm pretty certain I'd have the upper hand armed with nothing more than a bolt action rifle with a scope, or even no scope if shooting at night. The pirates would have difficulty hitting the side of a ship even in relatively calm seas, let alone a small target high overhead with only a small portion not behind cover.

This is why many pirates have been foiled by nothing more than a water cannon, even though they had automatic rifles and RPGs.
 
Fire away Rambo. The little speedboat is radio controlled, packed with ammonium nitrate and closing fast. Your shots prove your intention not to stop so it's to the bottom with you. Maybe the next captain will be a little brighter.

Maybe you should wait to see what actually happens before engaging in hyperbole. These pirates as a whole seem to be much more motivated by profit than revenge. There is no profit in sinking a ship before removing the cargo, unless another group is paying the pirates to do so.

If a ship does not have any external security, then they need to defend themselves in some manner. These sailors are all alone on the sea. They can call for help, but it may be hours away. Whether they surrender, out run, or attack (water hoses or guns) the pirates is something the captain and crew have to decide for themselves. While the ship's owners may try to limit the crew's options, I am not going to criticize the crew's decisions. They are not the ones sitting behind a computer in the comfort of home awaiting the cargo that is shipped through pirate infested seas.

Have any merchant seamen currently sailing commented on this forum? It would be interesting to hear their views.

Ranb
 
Let me guess a proper guards would be 3 guards working in 8 hour shifts, who can never be surprised, tricked or bribed?

Definitely not. The crew could rotate out guard throughout the night. Working in 1-2 hour shifts would not be hard at all. Then in the day most of the crew would be awake anyways so there would be no need for a guard.
 
You've obviouslky never done it. The only thing predictable is the clay pigeon will be flung, the direction and angle are unknown. And you have only a few seconds at most to hit the target.
They are predictable in that they follow a trajectory at relative close range. Its not going to make 90 degree turns.

A pirate boat often stays in range for hours on end while they try to manouver into position to attach their ladders/grappling hooks. And their boats are a much bigget target. The stern of a large ship is actually not a bad platform to shoot from, particularly since your opponents have a much less stable platform.
Sure some might take their time now for an easy climb. But they don't need to. If they get close enough by drifting or speeding into a blind spot, they can easily launch smoke canisters and climb on board. And their suppression fire is going to be far more effective as your almost a stationary target for them.

This is an easy adaption to their tactics. They might become even more creative. And this one of the many reasons why we should try to fight in out at cargo ships but take out their ships and ports (or that Somalia simply gets a real government).

I'm pretty certain I'd have the upper hand armed with nothing more than a bolt action rifle with a scope, or even no scope if shooting at night. The pirates would have difficulty hitting the side of a ship even in relatively calm seas, let alone a small target high overhead with only a small portion not behind cover.
As I have said before life isn't a PC game.

This is why many pirates have been foiled by nothing more than a water cannon, even though they had automatic rifles and RPGs.
You're over simplifying it again. Right now for the pirates its low risk (water isn't going to kill you) and lots of opportunities. So why waste the ammo? They don't need to kill anyone.
But if need to, they will, for they still have the means (ships, ports) and the rewards (salvage, cargo, hostages). We can't get rid of the latter, but the former is possible.
 
Definitely not. The crew could rotate out guard throughout the night. Working in 1-2 hour shifts would not be hard at all. Then in the day most of the crew would be awake anyways so there would be no need for a guard.
Taking any definition of proper guard, I see. In such a situation even a cook could take over the armory.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom