Easy solution to the pirate problem...

They are predictable in that they follow a trajectory at relative close range. Its not going to make 90 degree turns.
A speedboat isn't about to make a 90 degree turn either, and certainly no turn that's going to take place after the trigger is pulled but before the bullet arrives. And if they're turning they aren't getting in position to attach a ladder.

Sure some might take their time now for an easy climb. But they don't need to. If they get close enough by drifting or speeding into a blind spot, they can easily launch smoke canisters and climb on board. And their suppression fire is going to be far more effective as your almost a stationary target for them.
Oddly enough, this "suppression fire" wasn't enough to keep the water cannon aboard the Liberty Sun from thwarting the pirates, so how effective would it be for actual bullets?

This is an easy adaption to their tactics. They might become even more creative. And this one of the many reasons why we should try to fight in out at cargo ships but take out their ships and ports (or that Somalia simply gets a real government).
Oh, I have advocated taking out their ports for some time. But a lightly armed crew may well do wonders barring the more drastic solutions which are a long way from being implemented and may well be more politically difficult to accomplish.

You're over simplifying it again. Right now for the pirates its low risk (water isn't going to kill you) and lots of opportunities. So why waste the ammo? They don't need to kill anyone.
But if need to, they will, for they still have the means (ships, ports) and the rewards (salvage, cargo, hostages). We can't get rid of the latter, but the former is possible.
They attacked the Liberty Sun with the stated goal of destroying it and killing the crew. They were narrowly thwarted by a water cannon and evasive actions.
 
Can you link to the posts here advocating missiles and torpedos on merchant ships? Thanlks in advance!

Wouldn't guided-missiles be effective against enemy gunboats?

As for the strawman, I am sorry you feel that way, Wildcat. As I recall, you were the one proposing that the carnage in Mumbai would have been diminished if only everyone in the area had guns--not just the terrorists and the counter-terrorists. You were on another thread where you proposed that school officials should arm themselves just in case the janitor goes nuts or a student provides a suspicious-looking tardy slip or something like that. So the strawman is not that far from the truth in the case of your approach to virtually any problem.

You do carry a weapon at all times yourself, right? Just in case. I mean, just for self-defence.
 
Crews are already at minimum levels to save cost. And you do need a 24 hour watch, the pirates aren't going to be nice and give you a full nights rest.
The crews are already doing a 24 hour watch to look out for pirates.

And btw, no ship that I'm aware of has a policy of allowing the pirates to board and giving themselves up as hostages. They are already trained in defensive manouvers and use of the water cannon to prevent boarding, and the use of safe areas inside the ship when all else fails..
 
Last edited:
Wouldn't guided-missiles be effective against enemy gunboats?
Why not just give them tactical nukes while you're at it? :rolleyes:

As for the strawman, I am sorry you feel that way, Wildcat. As I recall, you were the one proposing that the carnage in Mumbai would have been diminished if only everyone in the area had guns--not just the terrorists and the counter-terrorists. You were on another thread where you proposed that school officials should arm themselves just in case the janitor goes nuts or a student provides a suspicious-looking tardy slip or something like that. So the strawman is not that far from the truth in the case of your approach to virtually any problem.
Funny, I don't recall saying anyone should be armed. I have only ever argued it should be an opton for those who desire it and that the bans are demonstrably ineffective.

You do carry a weapon at all times yourself, right? Just in case. I mean, just for self-defence.
I used to keep a 20 guage shotgun in the truck at work since I was often in quite dangerous neighborhoods (I have witnessed 3 shootouts in my life where I was less than 30 feet from one of the shooters), but not since it was made a felony to do so. Never had to use it in any way but it was comforting to know it was there.
 
Why not just give them tactical nukes while you're at it? :rolleyes:

I used to keep a 20 guage shotgun in the truck at work since I was often in quite dangerous neighborhoods (I have witnessed 3 shootouts in my life where I was less than 30 feet from one of the shooters), but not since it was made a felony to do so. Never had to use it in any way but it was comforting to know it was there.

Let me be clear too. I would vastly prefer a US-led international coalition invade Somalia and establish order before arming commercial vessels in any way. The latter would be a bureaucratic and administrative nightmare as well as creating a whole new class of warships that weren't there previously.

I still believe that the basic issue is an economic one and not a military one and I've put all my links and reasoning on a different thread on the same subject.
 
Let me be clear too. I would vastly prefer a US-led international coalition invade Somalia and establish order before arming commercial vessels in any way. The latter would be a bureaucratic and administrative nightmare as well as creating a whole new class of warships that weren't there previously.
I wouldn't classify civilian-type small arms on a merchant ship as a new class of military vessel.

I still believe that the basic issue is an economic one and not a military one and I've put all my links and reasoning on a different thread on the same subject.
Undoubtedly true, but I don't see any world powers lining up to sacrafice the blood and treasure necessary to solve the mess in Somalia.

So what we are left with is treating the symptom.
 
A speedboat isn't about to make a 90 degree turn either, and certainly no turn that's going to take place after the trigger is pulled but before the bullet arrives. And if they're turning they aren't getting in position to attach a ladder.
Again life isn't a pc game, if you want to kill RPG users at range on a maneuvering boat you must take speed and direction into account.

Oddly enough, this "suppression fire" wasn't enough to keep the water cannon aboard the Liberty Sun from thwarting the pirates, so how effective would it be for actual bullets?
Water cannons only prevent boarding (providing they have them at all sides). They don't stop boarding attempts or AK suppression fire.

They attacked the Liberty Sun with the stated goal of destroying it and killing the crew. They were narrowly thwarted by a water cannon and evasive actions.
The Liberty Sun was actually very lucky they didn't get any engine damage. Also they never got to use a water cannon.



The crews are already doing a 24 hour watch to look out for pirates.

And btw, no ship that I'm aware of has a policy of allowing the pirates to board and giving themselves up as hostages. They are already trained in defensive manouvers and use of the water cannon to prevent boarding, and the use of safe areas inside the ship when all else fails..
And this prevents a lot of boardings but not all of them. And during them no one dies.
 
Last edited:
Again life isn't a pc game, if you want to kill RPG users at range on a maneuvering boat you must take speed and direction into account.
The crews are already doing this with water cannons.

Water cannons only prevent boarding (providing they have them at all sides). They don't stop boarding attempts or AK suppression fire.
And yet they have been successful on mor ethana few occasions.

The Liberty Sun was actually very lucky they didn't get any engine damage.
Hard to damage the engine located deep inside a ship with an RPG.

Also they never got to use a water cannon.
Oh, but they did!
A Tennessee Valley man who was on the recently attacked cargo ship Liberty Sun says luck and the grace of God, not a show of force, saved him from Somali pirates.

“(W)e are very lucky that nobody (got killed),” 38-year-old Thomas Conry, of Tracy City, Tenn., wrote his sister, Pam Myers, in an e-mail. “Fighting pirates (with) a water hose, while they got guns (is) not a cup of tea.”
http://timesfreepress.com/news/2009/apr/17/tracy-city-man-says-fighting-pirates-not-cup-te/

And this prevents a lot of boardings but not all of them. And during them no one dies.
Had the pirates succeeded in boarding the Liberty Sun they would have, at least that's what the pirates claimed.
 
The term sheep in this context is much different than how a conspiracy theorist would use it. I am not using it as an insult, its just how some people are. You are a sheep if you run from the wolf and don't do anything to defend yourself. You are always a victim and can't fight for yourself. Not an insult, just a description.

Sure thing, Quad. It's not an insult. :rolleyes:

Now, seriously, you're calling someone a sheep like you'd call someone a coward or a mindless follower and you don't expect it to be seen as rude ?
 
No. Let's defend ourselves and never get put in a situation to become a hostage.

Now, don't misunderstand. I'm not saying that arming these people is necessarily a bad idea. But what I'm saying, and I'm sure you know this, is that starting a firefight with people who, statistically, wouldn't shoot at you under other circumstances automatically makes the situation more complicated and dangerous.

So arming merchant ship crews might be the solution (I don't claim to know), but it's far from being a simple one.
 
Sure thing, Quad. It's not an insult. :rolleyes:

Now, seriously, you're calling someone a sheep like you'd call someone a coward or a mindless follower and you don't expect it to be seen as rude ?

Probably not, since he's also called someone a coward in this thread as well.
 
I would love for the company to provide gun courses for me, and to have a rifle in my cabin, or just a few at the brigde. I wonder what the autorities in assorted countries would say to that.
Nigeria have at one point accepted a ships rifle.

Several of our polish AB´s have expressed a strong interest in learning english, the captain suggested enroling them in courses in poland. So far we got directions to a homepage where we could download a freeware language course far above their level.

At nighttime you will have a brigde officer and a AB lookout awake and on the brigde.
They can raise the alarm and wake up the rest of the crew.
The problems will be cost of weapons training, cost of weapons, accidents, and the administrative hell of having weapons onboard.
One captain told me of a time when officers carried sidearms when sailing on africa, there were some of them that were not old enough to carry weapons, and who would never be.
 
Sure thing, Quad. It's not an insult. :rolleyes:

Now, seriously, you're calling someone a sheep like you'd call someone a coward or a mindless follower and you don't expect it to be seen as rude ?

I tell it like it is. If you take offense to it that's your problem. The truth hurts.
 
See this was a problem, eveyone in the past was pussies, they should have all had the balls to fight.

That's not it at all. People in the past believe that complying was your best chance of survival so they chose not to fight. Now people know that's not true, and choose not to fight.

To be perfectly honest I don't think the rate of piracy of Somalia is actually even high enough to bother about with expensive measures.
 
You are wrong - the argument "we can't try them" is exactly the problem many of the countries helping to patrol that area face, see http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4636612#post4636612


I know that's the argument they're putting up, but it's simply not true. It's clearly stated in the UN Convention on the Laws of the Sea that they have a duty to suppress piracy and they have a legal right to capture, detain and prosecute pirates.

The issue isn't legal authority; the issue is the will. As per usual the international community is doing an impressive imitation of a spineless jellyfish.
 
Why are you comparing how the rangers and Delta force were able to hold off an entire city of Somalis to a few people shooting at a crappy Somali boat with rifles?

You were confident it would be trivial to drive them away, so why was it so hard for the rangers and delta?
 
The problems will be cost of weapons training, cost of weapons, accidents, and the administrative hell of having weapons onboard.

This was one of my contentions too.

I seriously doubt that any analysis of the maritime and open sea regions--especially around the Gulf of Aden, the Arabian Sea, and the western Indian Ocean--would come to this conclusion: "You know what the problem is? Not enough weapons around here!"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom