Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Incorrect. You apparently are a sheep. I am an officer in the United States Army. Trust me, if someone were to try and board a ship I was on and I had a rifle, every one of those pirates would get a controlled pair right in the chest. What is it with these people that think no harm will happen to them if they just comply with the bad guys? Such cowardice. This is just inviting pirates to hi jack any ship they want knowing that they will get whatever they want from the ransom.

Yes, but you have military training.

I know at least two guys with major military experience and I wouldn't trust them to defend a ship right now.

Why? Because they're middle aged flabby dads. That's why.

Now compare this to people who never had military training in their life. Putting them in a combat situation is dangerous.

I want to like this idea of arming crews. But how much training would they need to be any good at defending a ship?

What if the pirates get on board? No more easy shots from above. What is plan B? Barricade themselves?

So you'd need some trained guys on board.
Maybe mercenaries from low wage countries would be an option? The US hires them in Iraq.
 
Here is what I said in post 245:

Take it or leave it.

That's what I was already replying to, Quad. What do you mean by sheep ?

No. It's about real men who would rather fight back then sit back and be a victim.

And there you go again with the macho stuff. Of course, people who would rather stay alive and not put their children at risk of becoming orphans are not real men.

ETA: Of course, if "real" means "like me" to you, then of course, "real" men act like you.
 
Last edited:
A good rule of thumb - if you think you have an obvious "easy" solution to something that has been going on a longtime that involves thousands of people - you haven't.
 
I tell it like it is. If you take offense to it that's your problem. The truth hurts.
I find it telling that so many people equate whatever their opinion is with "The Truth".

Of course, insults have the sole intention of hurting someone. Whether they actually do or not depends on whether the person at whom the insult is directed chooses to be hurt by it.

But insults are allowed here, as long as they relate to the discussion. If you say that all the people who disagree with your plan for dealing with the pirates are "sheep", then that is based on the discussion. It doesn't exactly do your credibility any favors though, and the result will be that you are more likely to be dismissed as a reasonable voice than you are to convince anyone. So consider your arguments well.
 
I honestly don't know what else you want from me. I have already explained in the other post what I meant.

Er, no you haven't. You just said "I say it like it is". If I call you a purse, and say "I say it like it is", am I actually saying you're made of leather and are used by women to put their credit cards ? So I doubt very well you're actually calling that person a sheep. I can only surmise you're using sheep in the way I describe, which is most certainly an insult, seeing a how calling someone spineless is seldom seen positively.
 
Now compare this to people who never had military training in their life. Putting them in a combat situation is dangerous.

I want to like this idea of arming crews. But how much training would they need to be any good at defending a ship?
They're already being put in combat situations, armed with a water cannon and a hose. I don't think it's smart to enter a gun and RPG fight with a big squirt gun.

What if the pirates get on board? No more easy shots from above. What is plan B? Barricade themselves?
That's already plan B if the water hose fails.
 
btw, the pirate wounded in the Maersk Alabama attack (the one facing charges in NYC) was wounded in the hand when a crewman hit him with an ice pick.

Now, ice picks ceased being a common household item 60 years or so ago when refrigeration became widespread. Are they still a common item to carry on board a ship, or was it taken along by the crew as a weapon just in case? It seems to me this might be an example of the crew arming themselves with whatever they could legally.
 
The crews are already doing this with water cannons.

And yet they have been successful on mor ethana few occasions.
At very close range. It isn't viable counter weapon against AKs. The presence of an active water cannon merely gives the pirates a choice. Is this cargo/etc worth the ammo and killing the crew for?

As there are plenty of other ships to surprise, so the answer is no. The less they kill the better their long term business.

Hard to damage the engine located deep inside a ship with an RPG.
The engine isn't dependent on its motor block.

This is the first link that I have ever seen that comes even close to it. Also one can read it as 'glad I didn't have to do that'.

Had the pirates succeeded in boarding the Liberty Sun they would have, at least that's what the pirates claimed.
Look at previous cases.
 
Now, ice picks ceased being a common household item 60 years or so ago when refrigeration became widespread. Are they still a common item to carry on board a ship, or was it taken along by the crew as a weapon just in case? It seems to me this might be an example of the crew arming themselves with whatever they could legally.
It is a common item on a ship, especially one that travels of has traveled through cold regions.
 
You can choose to look at it that way if you like. But the fact that such a small amount of soldiers was able to hold off an entire city was a feat in itself. Just FYI, The battle of Mogadishu has NOTHING to do with what is going on right not.

It speaks to the resolve of the Somali's.
 
Er, no you haven't. You just said "I say it like it is". If I call you a purse, and say "I say it like it is", am I actually saying you're made of leather and are used by women to put their credit cards ? So I doubt very well you're actually calling that person a sheep. I can only surmise you're using sheep in the way I describe, which is most certainly an insult, seeing a how calling someone spineless is seldom seen positively.

Alright. This is the last time I will explain it. Again, here is post 245:

The term sheep in this context is much different than how a conspiracy theorist would use it. I am not using it as an insult, its just how some people are. You are a sheep if you run from the wolf and don't do anything to defend yourself. You are always a victim and can't fight for yourself. Not an insult, just a description.
[FONT=&quot]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=4640367#post4640367[/FONT]

The term sheep refers to a person who would rather become a victim or who is unable to fight for themselves. This is clear as night and day.
 
At very close range. It isn't viable counter weapon against AKs. The presence of an active water cannon merely gives the pirates a choice. Is this cargo/etc worth the ammo and killing the crew for?
The bridge of the Liberty Sun was heavily damaged by RPG fire, so apparently it was worth the ammo and killing for.

This is the first link that I have ever seen that comes even close to it. Also one can read it as 'glad I didn't have to do that'.
Every account I have seen is that they fought the pirates all night long. Their weapon was the water cannon.

Look at previous cases.
AFAIK this was the only incident where the pirates claimed thier goal was to kill the crew. I have no reason to doubt that assertion.
 
Any evidence at all the Somalis have such things? You may as well stick to claiming that shooting a small boat at 100 meters with a rifle is comparable to hitting it at 10k with a 6 pound gun.

Technology is cheap, see all the useing of satelite phones and the like.
 
I find this discussion fascinating. But I don't understand why those who are against arming crews are so convinced that these pirates would suddenly turn to outright war against the ships, sinking them when they can, etc. I think this is a bit hysterical or over-reacting. My gut tells me that the first sign of it becoming more difficult or dangerous to take these ships that most of them will get out of the business, not turn into homicidal psychopaths. They are opportunists.

It is possible, but it is also a way to make a lot of money, and there are not many ways to make much money in somalia. So there is motivation to keep it up.
 
Numbers and terrain. By the way the Rangers and Delta did keep them at bay. You do realise they were never actually trapped in the city, right? They could have left any time they wanted.

Then why did they bother getting that vehical convoy to go rescue them?
 
You're smart enough to realise that not everyone who disagrees with some of your points holds the same identical views.

You seem to be only disagreeing with my point though, when Quad says things that you do not agree with you don't say a thing. So you agree with him in most cases, and never make a clear case against him when you do not agree with him.
 
The OP is premised on the idea that there is an "easy solution to the pirate problem". There is not. Some self-defence will probably help. But it's not a solution.

I have an easy solution to the pirate problem, stop shipping stuff.

I have an other easy solution, depopulate somalia.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom