Easy solution to the pirate problem...

I find this discussion fascinating. But I don't understand why those who are against arming crews are so convinced that these pirates would suddenly turn to outright war against the ships, sinking them when they can, etc. I think this is a bit hysterical or over-reacting. My gut tells me that the first sign of it becoming more difficult or dangerous to take these ships that most of them will get out of the business, not turn into homicidal psychopaths. They are opportunists.

It's not those pirates that would become psychopaths but the brothers of those pirates that you kill that will set out to do to you what you would want to do to pirates if they killed your brother.
 
It's not those pirates that would become psychopaths but the brothers of those pirates that you kill that will set out to do to you what you would want to do to pirates if they killed your brother.
Just like the brothers of the hostages are sailing to Somalia as we speak to capture Somalis to hold for ransom...
 
It's not those pirates that would become psychopaths but the brothers of those pirates that you kill that will set out to do to you what you would want to do to pirates if they killed your brother.
The concept of revenge is firmly established in that culture. You kill someone I love, I'll go and kill you. It's one of the reasons that region is so unstable.
 
The concept of revenge is firmly established in that culture. You kill someone I love, I'll go and kill you. It's one of the reasons that region is so unstable.


Are we then just right back to paying the pirates ransom then? Because if they're going to avenge dead pirates, then I can't imagine they're going to care if their buddies were killed by civilian mariners or soldiers.
 
Are we then just right back to paying the pirates ransom then? Because if they're going to avenge dead pirates, then I can't imagine they're going to care if their buddies were killed by civilian mariners or soldiers.
How about we try and prevent them from needing to become pirates in the first place?
 
Exchange them for my brother of course.

There you go escalating the violence again. You might just scare the pirates enough to make them want to get rid of any evidence that they were the ones that took your brother.
 
How about we try and prevent them from needing to become pirates in the first place?


That's a good idea, but it's a long term goal.

This is like saying that you don't need a gun to defend your home from crackheads, because the government is going to increase funding for education and offer treatment programs for people who have substance abuse problems. Not necessarily a bad idea, but it's something that takes time to implement and see results from.


A concerted effort to make Somalia better would solve a lot of the problems. I don't think many people here will argue that.
 
You were confident it would be trivial to drive them away, so why was it so hard for the rangers and delta?

Numbers and terrain. By the way the Rangers and Delta did keep them at bay. You do realise they were never actually trapped in the city, right? They could have left any time they wanted.
 
You just keep rolling along with the ridiculous, don't you?

Hint: was the Cole moving?


Not to mention the crew on the USS Cole knew the ship was approaching well in advance, but their ROE wouldn't let them fire at the boat, so all they could do was sit and watch while it tied alongside.

Had the crew of the Cole been actively preventing boats coming near them that boat would have been sent to the bottom before it got anywhere near the ship.
 
You are failing to perpetuate the wolf/sheep dichotomy.

This is about real men who would rather be killed than taken hostage after all, everyone else are cowards. Haven't you been reading the thread?


You're smart enough to realise that not everyone who disagrees with some of your points holds the same identical views.
 
Yes, you claim that they were victorious, but generaly not dying is not victory, attaining your mission objectives is, but they didn't capture the warlord they set out to, and it was a humiliating defeat.


Um... you realise you're wrong, right? The October 3 mission objective was to capture two of Aidid's aides: Omar Salad Elmi and Mohamed Hassan Awale. Both of these individuals were captured and extracted.

Which ever way you look at it, the mission was successful.
 
That's a good idea, but it's a long term goal.

This is like saying that you don't need a gun to defend your home from crackheads, because the government is going to increase funding for education and offer treatment programs for people who have substance abuse problems. Not necessarily a bad idea, but it's something that takes time to implement and see results from.


A concerted effort to make Somalia better would solve a lot of the problems. I don't think many people here will argue that.
The OP is premised on the idea that there is an "easy solution to the pirate problem". There is not. Some self-defence will probably help. But it's not a solution.

And for the record, there's never been a crackhead within 50km of my home. :D
 
I tell it like it is. If you take offense to it that's your problem. The truth hurts.

Evasion noted.

If you "tell it like it is", then I assume you think that the person is part of a species of sheep. Otherwise, you may want to explain what you mean by "sheep" if it isn't an insult.
 
Evasion noted.

If you "tell it like it is", then I assume you think that the person is part of a species of sheep. Otherwise, you may want to explain what you mean by "sheep" if it isn't an insult.

Here is what I said in post 245:
The term sheep in this context is much different than how a conspiracy theorist would use it. I am not using it as an insult, its just how some people are. You are a sheep if you run from the wolf and don't do anything to defend yourself. You are always a victim and can't fight for yourself. Not an insult, just a description.

Take it or leave it.
 
You are failing to perpetuate the wolf/sheep dichotomy.

This is about real men who would rather be killed than taken hostage after all, everyone else are cowards. Haven't you been reading the thread?

No. It's about real men who would rather fight back then sit back and be a victim.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom