Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Huh? England was the number one pirate nation for almost two centuries until they established a regular naval force. Drake had a freakin' government licence to engage in it and keep a large share of the booty.

Or is this a metaphorical England you're all discussing?

That is what made it so easy for them to stop the pirates. It is like the Theives guild discworld, the police need to work twice as hard to cut crime half as much, while all the theives have to do is work less.
 
Yes, I think the best solution to any problem is hide under the bed and hope that the authorities will help you, and if they don't get there in time, beg for mercy from your attacker.
And when competent authority discusses how THEY would handle the situation, deride them as "Would-be Rambo's" and defer to politicians...
 
And when competent authority discusses how THEY would handle the situation, deride them as "Would-be Rambo's" and defer to politicians...

Ok captan Rambo, you want to escalate the violence and start shooting at the pirates. Now you've caused the pirates to change their tactics. If you don't cooperate and allow the pirates to board your ship, they will simply sink your ship with an IED.
 
Ok captan Rambo, you want to escalate the violence and start shooting at the pirates. Now you've caused the pirates to change their tactics. If you don't cooperate and allow the pirates to board your ship, they will simply sink your ship with an IED.

Q.E.D.
 
And when competent authority discusses how THEY would handle the situation, deride them as "Would-be Rambo's" and defer to politicians...

Authorities? Where?

I do know that the Rangers and Delta Force are not all that good, needing rescueing from a group that can be easily driven off by a couple of random guys with a day or two training with a rifle. I am learning all kinds of new interesting things from the US Army.
 
Ok captan Rambo, you want to escalate the violence and start shooting at the pirates. Now you've caused the pirates to change their tactics. If you don't cooperate and allow the pirates to board your ship, they will simply sink your ship with an IED.

And that would further their financial cause how? And the solution to that is still the same. Any boats approaching your ship may be fired upon if they don't stop for warning shots.
 
Authorities? Where?

I do know that the Rangers and Delta Force are not all that good, needing rescueing from a group that can be easily driven off by a couple of random guys with a day or two training with a rifle. I am learning all kinds of new interesting things from the US Army.


Why are you comparing how the rangers and Delta force were able to hold off an entire city of Somalis to a few people shooting at a crappy Somali boat with rifles?
 
I have a question about Ye Olde Pirates TM:

Back in the old days, piracy seemed pretty popular. From the Vikings all the way down to Teach and Morgan, there were feared prates who sailed the seas.

My question is, what happened? Where did all the pirates go? There seems to be a gap in piracy (or maybe it just stopped being publicized) from when piracy was in its heyday until we start hearing about these Somali pirates.

What did the world do back then to drive piracy away, and could those measures be effective nowadays (factoring in more sophisticated weaponry on both sides, of course)?
 
And that would further their financial cause how? And the solution to that is still the same. Any boats approaching your ship may be fired upon if they don't stop for warning shots.

Fire away Rambo. The little speedboat is radio controlled, packed with ammonium nitrate and closing fast. Your shots prove your intention not to stop so it's to the bottom with you. Maybe the next captain will be a little brighter.
 
What you're witnessing here is a manifestly unique American solution to any problem. Piracy getting you down? Get a gun. Broken window in your apartment block? Get a gun. Cut off in traffic? Get a gun. Offended by your neighbour's dog pooping on your lawn? Get a gun. Jehovah's Witnesses bothering you on Saturday morning? Get a gun.
The Wizard of Oz called, they want their strawman back.
 
Probably because a lot of the foreign trawlers are there illegally and don't want any additional attention drawn upon themselves. Assuming you're an American, exactly how comfortable would you be with a missile and torpedo equipped foreign container ship docking at San Diego?
Can you link to the posts here advocating missiles and torpedos on merchant ships? Thanlks in advance!
 
Ok captan Rambo, you want to escalate the violence and start shooting at the pirates. Now you've caused the pirates to change their tactics. If you don't cooperate and allow the pirates to board your ship, they will simply sink your ship with an IED.
Yeah, good luck with sinking a moving 800 foot cargo ship with an IED.
 
Fire away Rambo. The little speedboat is radio controlled, packed with ammonium nitrate and closing fast. Your shots prove your intention not to stop so it's to the bottom with you. Maybe the next captain will be a little brighter.
While we're discussing fantasy weapons what if the pirates have proton torpedos? Huh? Answer that Rambo!
 
I have a question about Ye Olde Pirates TM:

Back in the old days, piracy seemed pretty popular. From the Vikings all the way down to Teach and Morgan, there were feared prates who sailed the seas.

My question is, what happened? Where did all the pirates go? There seems to be a gap in piracy (or maybe it just stopped being publicized) from when piracy was in its heyday until we start hearing about these Somali pirates.

What did the world do back then to drive piracy away, and could those measures be effective nowadays (factoring in more sophisticated weaponry on both sides, of course)?

The pirates of old were killed, became military, came to land for organized crime, repatriated themselves elsewhere, or became politicians. They didn't just go away, they found new ways to survive, thrive, or die. It wasn't as quick, clean, or easy to battle piracy then as some of the hyperbole is making it out to have been, and if it weren't for England's hiring on of privateers-- basically pirates who chose the "right" side-- then there's no guarantee that their campaigns would have been as successful as they were. The fact that Britain and France had been warring for years allowed pirates to flourish, taking advantage of both sides and attacking merchant ships while the militaries were busy fighting each other. As that fighting came to an end, the military forces turned on the pirates, which meant the pirates could either turn coat on other pirates (becoming privateers) or they'd be chased down and killed if they were caught (or stay hidden and out of 'business' if not).
 
The pirates of old were killed, became military, came to land for organized crime, repatriated themselves elsewhere, or became politicians. They didn't just go away, they found new ways to survive, thrive, or die. It wasn't as quick, clean, or easy to battle piracy then as some of the hyperbole is making it out to have been, and if it weren't for England's hiring on of privateers-- basically pirates who chose the "right" side-- then there's no guarantee that their campaigns would have been as successful as they were. The fact that Britain and France had been warring for years allowed pirates to flourish, taking advantage of both sides and attacking merchant ships while the militaries were busy fighting each other. As that fighting came to an end, the military forces turned on the pirates, which meant the pirates could either turn coat on other pirates (becoming privateers) or they'd be chased down and killed if they were caught (or stay hidden and out of 'business' if not).

So they privateered pirates, and also turned their military forces on the situation, which seemed to have worked.

Do you think that would work today? Perhaps a 2-pronged approach: 1) using military forces to patrol the waters (UN-endorsed to be able to stop and arrest), and 2) figuring out a way to stop the problem at its roots (i.e. "fix" Somalia somehow, unite the country, get a working economy there).

SIGH

Seems like blowing them out of the water is a far easier approach, even though it does nothing to cure the underlying disease. :(
 
While we're discussing fantasy weapons what if the pirates have proton torpedos? Huh? Answer that Rambo!

Yes, it is a fantasy weapon. In the 70's, the public was exposed to this weapon when Wo Fat threatened to use it to reactivate a dormant volcano and destroy one of the Hawaiian islands. Was it "Photon Torpedos" that were used to bring down the Murray Federal Building?
 
Last edited:
Fire away Rambo. The little speedboat is radio controlled, packed with ammonium nitrate and closing fast. Your shots prove your intention not to stop so it's to the bottom with you. Maybe the next captain will be a little brighter.

Lol getting ridiculous now are we? Ok. Besides force, how would you stop a boat with an IED from hitting your ship? Yell at it? Ask it to please stop because if you just simply comply everything will be alright? Have fun with that.
 
Lol getting ridiculous now are we? Ok. Besides force, how would you stop a boat with an IED from hitting your ship? Yell at it? Ask it to please stop because if you just simply comply everything will be alright? Have fun with that.

It's your ship captain. You can shoot at it and hope you get lucky or you can stop your ship and invite the pirates on board for tea while your company arranges to pay the ransom.

I suspect your never surrender attitude will dictate your action but the ships owners may want to look for a different solution.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom