Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

Very true. So we agree more than you think we do? If the facts are honestly presented to parents and boys and they are allowed to choose then I have much fewer problems with this being provided along with the other methods currently in use.

I never said otherwise.

Who said anything about withholding treatment? It was just another potential factor to take into account, given that promoting HIV reduction methods that include ones that do not involve contraception will almost certainly lead to a faster population growth than ones that don’t, and climate models predict that area of the world is going to face the brunt of higher world temperatures. Better start saving for Live Aid 2050.

I didn't make it clear what I was referring to. When doing cost-benefit analyses for certain treatments in North America, it is beneficial to not treat the heart attack in the 65-year-old and let them die, since then we save money by not paying for future support. You have to be careful how you place a value on intangibles.

However, I don't understand why promoting HIV reduction methods that do not involve contraception precludes the ability to make family planning choices.

Yes, you have changed your Avatar a lot. I liked the one with your(?) face on the skew and this current one. The dog one was ok. I didn't like the Andy Warholesque one. It was too bright.

It turns out (and yeah, I didn't realize this beforehand) that it matters a lot more whether or not I can stand to look at my avatar, than whether or not someone else likes it. :)

Linda
 
so now of course paranoid parents and maybe even doctors will have kids circumcised because of one study showing a correlation. whoopy! i suppose it can't hurt to be safe, not in the long run anyway.

suppose it could be torn skin and bodily fluids going into the torn skin. i have no idea, lol. still crap evidence though.

I don't think you understand what evidence is available. There is not one study showing a correlation. There are many observational studies showing a correlation. There are numerous studies of the pathophysiology. And there are now three very well-done experimental studies showing effectiveness from which conclusions about causation can be drawn. For any other issue the quality of the research would be considered very good, not crap.

Linda
 
I understand that they studied it, but real life works differently from clinical trials. People form their "beliefs" in their teen years, and they look to peers to share information with. How can this study say what Christian school teachers are going to tell 9th graders about condoms and circumcision?
Many of the "educators" over there are teaching kids that the HIV virus is smaller than the pores in latex, so condoms can't work at all, ever, to prevent HIV.
Believing that this study controlled for those kinds of factors requires a tremendous suspension of disbelief.

Medical research involves numerous factors which cannot be controlled (and often aren't even recognized). This is dealt with by randomization; by making it likely that these uncontrolled factors will be distributed equally amongst the control and intervention group. So that while they are present and influencing the outcome, the influence on both groups will be equivalent and can effectively be cancelled out.

Of course we don't know for sure what will happen in the future. But in order to advance, we make educated guesses. What the study shows is that people who are in the process or who have already formed their beliefs exhibit this particular behaviour. Regardless of whether they were exposed to Christian school-teachers or other educators feeding them misinformation, this was the result.

Can we assume that the prevailing culture will remain unchanged? I don't think that would be wise. Can we think of ways that it would change to make the situation worse? Yes. Can we think of ways that it would change to make the situation better? Yes. Should we never act because we never know for sure?

These studies were about as real life as we get, unless for some reason you think that real life involves knowledge of the future.

Linda
 
And if you're a child forget about having any absolute rights. Like the right not to have your body altered for a risk that can be reduced by many different ways, if you so choose.



That’s the problem the supporters of this have got. If a man has not chosen circumcision then you will need to provide a really big incentive for him to elect to have it done, or lie to him, in the nicest possible way of course, by presenting half-truths as the whole. You can start a war that way.

Alternatively you can have already done it to him before he could protest, i.e. when he was a child. The parents will be easier to convince. Just show them pictures of children dying of AIDS soon after their child is born. Keep up the propaganda until it’s time for the little one to be taken away for processing – sorry, I mean have the procedure – and you’ll obtain the desired 96% compliance.



If parallel universes exist then I’m sure there are all kinds of bizarre stuff being done because authority figures e.g. God, Tribal Elders and Experts decree it to be the right thing to do. There might even be one where some fundamental rights of the individual have been agreed and are not ignored when the going gets tough.



Didn’t someone post last time about being taught in medical school that on average, circumcised men take longer to reach orgasm? If true that would be a clear indication that the sensation is significantly different after circumcision. But if you’re circumcised as an infant you won’t know any different, so that makes it ok for Skeptigirl. I mean, it’s only a little bit of skin, isn’t it?



I’ve tried this argument and they’re not listening kellyb. Probably because they will be exploiting the same psychological techniques that all groups use who wish to change people’s behaviour.



No, no, no. What you don’t understand is that the real world and real people’s human rights are not important. What counts is how many people’s lives the model predict they will save. All the uncontrolled factors in the experiment or that not included in the model are unimportant and anyone who brings them up is accused of not wanting or being able to do anything to help anybody, ever, for not being certain of the outcome.

This is turning into the public health version of Bush’s “War on Terror”, where basic human rights that our society has supposedly agreed to support and champion are being forgotten about when they get in the way of what some what to do.

I wonder if occasionally beating children has any long term behavioural health benefits? Along the lines of “spare the rod and ruin the child.” I’m sure there’s a culture out there that does it that could be studied.

I just read this post.

I'm done with you.

Linda
 
To sell male circumcision to boys (or their parents) who would not usually have it done is going to require the explicit/implicit message -

‘condoms are the better choice, but if you don’t fancy wearing one, then being circumcised is good too.’

communicated to them. To me that is playing with fire.

So do airbags comunicate the message

'seatbelts are a better choice, but if you don't fancy wearing one, then having an airbag is good too.'?
 
At exactly what point do fundamental human rights cease to matter?

Considering that grown men elected to have this proceedure performed, what fundamental human right am I proposing that we violate?

Linda
 
I never said otherwise.

Then I shall look forward to any of your replies to my other posts. I think.

I didn't make it clear what I was referring to. When doing cost-benefit analyses for certain treatments in North America, it is beneficial to not treat the heart attack in the 65-year-old and let them die, since then we save money by not paying for future support. You have to be careful how you place a value on intangibles.

Given that my farther had £10000 of drugs (Temozolomide) + radiotherapy + 8 weeks in a 2 nurse to a bed hospice before he died and that it was clear from the outset of this treatment that he was not going to live for very long I shall not be arguing for withholding treatment from chronically or terminally ill patients unless they request it.

However, I don't understand why promoting HIV reduction methods that do not involve contraception precludes the ability to make family planning choices.

It doesn’t preclude it; it will just increase the number of ‘accidents’.

It turns out (and yeah, I didn't realize this beforehand) that it matters a lot more whether or not I can stand to look at my avatar, than whether or not someone else likes it. :)

Linda

That’s interesting. I’m reading about self-concept at the moment.
 
The question and my answer were to the hypothetical suggestion, "if it was your clitoris instead of my penis you wouldn't say that".

Your point is not relevant.

Um, what? I see pointing out how incomparable the procedures are and generally agreeing with you is not relevant then.
 
There is clear evidence that some do specificaly the catholic church

I recognize that this is a problem. When I talk about health care workers, I am referring more to a group of professionals who follow a medical code of ethics in line with the Declaration of Helsinki. I realize that non-professionals also provide health education and do not follow these ethics, and that there is individual variation in interpretation. I do not want to give the appearance that I am promoting the "no true Scotsman" fallacy. I just want to make it clear, when discussing these issues, that identifying exactly where we fall away from the ideal enables us to more accurately discuss problems/solutions.

Linda
 
So do airbags comunicate the message

'seatbelts are a better choice, but if you don't fancy wearing one, then having an airbag is good too.'?

I have not done any research into this. But I am aware of research that shows if a driver feels they are traveling below a certain speed they are more likely to engage in risky behaviours, e.g., finding a CD that dropped under the passenger seat. Other research (or maybe part of the same study) showed that if a road junction is designed so it is perceived as more dangerous, less accidents happen there.

I also think trying to equate air bags to male circumcision and condoms to seatbelts is not totally applicable, since an airbag gives you significant extra protection even when you use your seatbelt correctly.

A better analogy would be a second seatbelt in the car made to a lower spec. that might not work but automatically wraps around you.
 
Last edited:
I have not done any research into this. But I am aware of research that shows if a driver feels they are traveling below a certain speed they are more likely to engage in risky behaviours, e.g., finding a CD that dropped under the passenger seat. Other research (or maybe part of the same study) showed that if a road junction is designed so it is perceived as more dangerous, less accidents happen there.

I also think trying to equate air bags to male circumcision and condoms to seatbelts is not totally applicable, since an airbag gives you significant extra protection even when you used your seatbelt correctly.

A better analogy would be a second seatbelt in the car made to a lower spec. that might not work.

The studies have free condoms and education and still show the effectiveness of circumcision.

You want a real solution, teach abstinence only. That is an assured way not to get it. The problem is that teaching this does not work as it does in theory in the real world.
 
The studies have free condoms and education and still show the effectiveness of circumcision.

You want a real solution, teach abstinence only. That is an assured way not to get it. The problem is that teaching this does not work as it does in theory in the real world.

Here we go again. This is a really common tactic here. Someone’s point of view is not in total agreement with you own and so they misrepresent what your point of view. I shall summarize my position for you so you can cherry pick a phrase or sentence and misrepresent me again.

I have read the Kenyan study in detail and quickly looked at the Ugandan study. They have convinced me that male circumcision has ~60% efficacy for the trials. I believe there is a significant potential risk that implementing this at the population level will hinder the success that has been had with the current HIV prevention measures in the future.

Given the report kellyb found it is also a significant risk that these studies will be used to justify infant circumcision. The only way I can see that being done in practice is to scare parents into giving consent for their child to be circumcised. I outlined how I thought that could be achieved. In the Kenyan study it mentions models that assume 100% uptake. That doesn’t sound to me like they assumed it was going to be implemented on a voluntary basis.

You came up with a flawed analogy that I corrected for you. I have never, ever suggested that abstinence only would be effective at all and am not doing so now or ever will.

I would expect the ethical way to promote male circumcision is to give all the facts in a way that the person considering having it done can understand, without your agenda or appeals to emotion skewing the balance. I do not believe given the information in that format anywhere near 100% of men would opt for it. I could be totally wrong.

There is an advert on UK TV at the moment that uses this kind of tactic for a cereal that might help lower cholesterol. I don’t know how effective it has been but it’s a refreshing change just to be given a piece of information rather than be dictated to, which is the norm in the UK anyway. By the way, is the US planning mass stomach stapling operations to tackle the obesity epidemic?

I think it could be argued that the policy on smoking has not worked as well as it could because the warnings have been intensified gradually, leading to the population becoming somewhat inoculated against the message. Perhaps they should get Tarantino on the job?

Finally, Linda is pissed at me because she has taken my comments about how I presume people who would justify infant circumcision for HIV prevention think personally. Given that she has convinced me she would not do this herself it is unfortunate.
 
Last edited:
Here we go again. This is a really common tactic here. Someone’s point of view is not in total agreement with you own and so they misrepresent what you’re point of view. I shall summarize my position for you so you can cherry pick a phrase or sentence and misrepresent me again.

I have read the Kenyan study in detail and quickly looked at the Ugandan study. They have convinced me that male circumcision has ~60% efficacy for the trials. I believe there is a significant potential risk that implementing this at the population level will hinder the success that has been had with the current HIV prevention measures in the future.

Given the report kellyb found it is also a significant risk that these studies will be used to justify infant circumcision. The only way I can see that being done in practice is to scare parents into giving consent for their child to be circumcised. I outlined how I thought that could be achieved. In the Kenyan study it mentions models that assume 100% uptake. That doesn’t sound to me like they assumed it was going to be implemented on a voluntary basis.

You came up with a flawed analogy that I corrected for you. I have never, ever suggested that abstinence only would be effective at all and am not doing so now or ever will.

Why? What is so different from not wanting a demonstrated improvement to the current educational system to be used? Abstinence seems the most likely comparison becuase while in theory it is the most effective, as a public health policy it totaly fails.

So here we see that in the real world that circumcision is of significant benifit in addition to educational programs. But you agrue against it from pinciple. That is just what abstinence only advocates do.

So while in detail you might be distinct from abstinence only advocates, but you seem to have the same rational and making some of the same failures that they make.
 
fls said:
These studies were about as real life as we get, unless for some reason you think that real life involves knowledge of the future.
Linda


Considering that grown men elected to have this proceedure performed, what fundamental human right am I proposing that we violate?
Linda

The behavior results do apply and are relevant to men who would choose this themselves in the near future. At least to some extent it is.

Does it tell us anything, though, about what the babies who will be circumcised in the year 2007/2008 will end up doing in 15 years?
Or is that still largely unknown?


It is large scale circumcision of infants that I'm seeing having the human rights problem, as well.
 
Except that, as demonstrated repeatedly in the previous thread on this subject, it doesn't.

It is claimed, but not fully proven, that it may decrease female to male transmission of HIV, by up to 50%. FtM vaginal intercourse has the lowest transmissibility rate of any form of intercourse, at .0005. It has no effect at all on Male to Female HIV transmission, .001. The study did not investigate anal intercourse, FtM .00065 and MtF .005, which is commonly practices but not as readily admitted to due to social stimgas. In both studies, circumcision was paired with substantial safe-sex education. So the chances of it substantially reducing HIV transmission on it's own is not only not proven, but it is very likely that it will be counterproductive by providing a sense of false security. It's a panacea that will do nothing to stem the steadily increasing rate of HIV infection and AIDS.

The only way to substantially reduce the AIDS epidemic in Africa is precisely the same way it was greatly reduced in the US homosexual population during the '90s: safe-sex education and condom use.

... and don't run with a scalpel in your hand.

M.
 
Yes, that would be considered a lie. Withholding information necessary for informed consent violates the Declaration of Helsinki.

Linda

So why is the CDC fact sheet saying this about it?

http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/resources/factsheets/circumcision.htm

Risks Associated with Male Circumcision
Reported complication rates depend on the type of study (e.g., chart review vs. prospective study), setting (medical vs. nonmedical facility), person operating (traditional vs. medical practitioner), patient age (infant vs. adult), and surgical technique or instrument used. The most common complications are minor bleeding and local infection. In large studies of infant circumcision in the U.S., complications rates range from 0.2 to 2.0% [2]. In the recently completed South African study of adult circumcision by general medical practitioners in their surgical offices, the overall complication rate was 3.8%. The most commonly reported complications were pain (0.8%), followed by swelling or hematoma, bleeding, and problems with appearance (each 0.6%). Damage to the penis (0.3%), infection (0.2%), and delayed wound healing (0.1%) were uncommon. There were no reported deaths or problems with urination [10].

Meatal stenosis happens 10% of the time, so they're obviously not counting it as a complication of circumcision..
And I know the CDC and the WHO cooperate with each other a lot and do a lot of information sharing...so this very well might be the story in Africa, as well.

Or am I missing something?
 
Why? What is so different from not wanting a demonstrated improvement to the current educational system to be used? Abstinence seems the most likely comparison becuase while in theory it is the most effective, as a public health policy it totaly fails.

The current efforts are not just based on abstinence only. You do know that don’t you?

So here we see that in the real world that circumcision is of significant benifit in addition to educational programs. But you agrue against it from pinciple. That is just what abstinence only advocates do.

The trials have shown circumcision to be of benefit. The implementation of circumcision will not be a trial situation. I believe there are numerous things that can go wrong, some of which I know the Kenyan report discusses.

So while in detail you might be distinct from abstinence only advocates, but you seem to have the same rational and making some of the same failures that they make.

My bias or principle is that I definitely don’t want this being used for evidence to circumcise children. Feel free to disagree with me on this.

I have no problem with circumcision being presented fairly to men, not spun to make it look like a better option than it is. If this is done I do not believe it will be taken up by many men. I admit I could be wrong, in which case I hope it all goes well and hundreds of thousands of lives are saved.

What failures am I making?
 
So why is the CDC fact sheet saying this about it?

http://www.cdc.gov/hiv/resources/factsheets/circumcision.htm

Meatal stenosis happens 10% of the time, so they're obviously not counting it as a complication of circumcision..
And I know the CDC and the WHO cooperate with each other a lot and do a lot of information sharing...so this very well might be the story in Africa, as well.

Or am I missing something?

How do you know meatal stenosis happens 10% of the time?

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom