Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

I think you might be grossly misinformed on the reality of FGM in Africa.

Type 1 is the most common. And it's the WOMEN who perform and perpetuate it just as much as the men. Because it is their cultural tradition, and it's believed to have health benefits.
I'm not mis-informed, kelly. Did you consider all the factors that play into the cultural practice? It's very complex. Women in male dominated societies are raised to believe these things. It doesn't mean male domination is not at the root of the practice. Do you know of any examples of this practice where women are not under a double standard or at least didn't come from a culture with those characteristics? In other words tell me where this is practiced that women are men's equals in that society.

Well, that's what science says.
Yes, based on subjective reports. Are there studies that measured nerve impulses or anything physical? I'm not saying there is no decreased sensation. I'm wondering what the degree of change is.

Interesting sidenote...
In some areas of Africa, it is the highly educated women who are the most likely to take their daughters in for FGM procedures. I think I've read somewhere that men over there prefer "clean cut" women, as well.
Where did you read/see this? I'd like to see what the surrounding details are.

Have you ever heard of dangerous myths? Circumcision is already being referred to as an "invisible condom".
I've been in the medical field 30 years. I'm a nurse practitioner. I have a practice specialized in infectious disease. I've read a lot of the research and discussed this issue before. The researchers considered the hazard of circumcision leading to increased unprotected sex. It didn't happen.
 
Where did you get that from?
Your example.


No, you're not pointing that out because I look at different forms of sexual mutilation on the same scale that the WHO and UNICEF does. So you're not pointing out anything. There are several grades. Not all forms of sexual mutilation are created equal.

I have a feeling that kind of value judgement would be different for different individuals depending on their different personalities and circumstances....
I am weighing benefit of HIV prevented by circumcision against the loss of sexual sensation from circumcision.

I'm not looking at the loss of all sexual sensation vs the HIV prevented so why bring such hypotheticals into the discussion?

It seems like a no brainer that trading circumcision for less HIV is reasonable.

That leaves the question of will circumcision prevent enough HIV to warrant recommending it. In Sub-Saharan Africa it absolutely is a reasonable trade. In Denver, probably not.
 
If the UNAIDS/WHO decides they need, say, 96% of the male newborns being born in hospitals circumcised in order to decrease HIV transmission by whatever percent by whatever year, then the information being presented to mothers and fathers will be designed to achieve that 96% compliance rate. At least, that's how it generally goes with every other aspect of public health, and I'm not seeing any reason why circumcision would be any different. I hope I'm wrong, though. Maybe because of the controversial nature of the issue it will be treated differently.

Are you saying that health care workers systematically lie in order to accomplish public health directives from agencies they may or may not have a loose association with?

Linda
 
Except that, as demonstrated repeatedly in the previous thread on this subject, it doesn't.

It is claimed, but not fully proven, that it may decrease female to male transmission of HIV, by up to 50%.

The level of evidence in support of the claim would be considered more than sufficient if it were any other type of medical intervention. And it's not "up to". The research shows that efficacy is over 60 percent.

FtM vaginal intercourse has the lowest transmissibility rate of any form of intercourse, at .0005. It has no effect at all on Male to Female HIV transmission, .001. The study did not investigate anal intercourse, FtM .00065 and MtF .005, which is commonly practices but not as readily admitted to due to social stimgas. In both studies, circumcision was paired with substantial safe-sex education. So the chances of it substantially reducing HIV transmission on it's own is not only not proven, but it is very likely that it will be counterproductive by providing a sense of false security. It's a panacea that will do nothing to stem the steadily increasing rate of HIV infection and AIDS.

Research suggests that it decreases male to female transmission as well. And you are ignoring the fact that substantially decreasing the incidence of HIV in the male population will also decrease the incidence of HIV in the female because it will substantially decrease the exposure. The observation that HIV prevalence was lower in communities where there was a high rate of circumcision also applied to the prevalence among women.

The only way to substantially reduce the AIDS epidemic in Africa is precisely the same way it was greatly reduced in the US homosexual population during the '90s: safe-sex education and condom use.

You are ignoring good evidence in favour of wishful thinking. You are ignoring good evidence demonstrating the consistent and substantial effectiveness of circumcision. And you are ignoring the good evidence demonstrating that promoting safe-sex education and condom use has a much smaller effect in Africa. I agree that it is important to promote safe-sex education and condom use and that it is important to counteract any "invisible condom" rumours about circumcision. But I cannot sit back and say we do not need to do anything else when all the evidence from the real world says otherwise.

I would totally buy into your plan if I could - it is far more satisfying to my sensibilities to depend upon education. But if being ethical meant doing what was easy, well, then there wouldn't need to be such things as ethics and morals.

Linda
 
Except that, as demonstrated repeatedly in the previous thread on this subject, it doesn't.

It is claimed, but not fully proven, that it may decrease female to male transmission of HIV, by up to 50%. FtM vaginal intercourse has the lowest transmissibility rate of any form of intercourse, at .0005. It has no effect at all on Male to Female HIV transmission, .001. The study did not investigate anal intercourse, FtM .00065 and MtF .005, which is commonly practices but not as readily admitted to due to social stimgas. In both studies, circumcision was paired with substantial safe-sex education. So the chances of it substantially reducing HIV transmission on it's own is not only not proven, but it is very likely that it will be counterproductive by providing a sense of false security. It's a panacea that will do nothing to stem the steadily increasing rate of HIV infection and AIDS.

The only way to substantially reduce the AIDS epidemic in Africa is precisely the same way it was greatly reduced in the US homosexual population during the '90s: safe-sex education and condom use.

How did they control for the forms of sex practiced by the participants? I thought it was just a general reduction in the infection rate by 50% in men who are circumcised.
 
HIV is not 100% infectious. One case study doesn't prove the purported phenomenon. In any case, I'll bet anything you like condom use is safer, even if there is a real effect - which I concede is possible, having seen an abstract of the report. There does seem a plausible transmission mechanism in uncircumcised men, but I think it's irresponsible to offer what may be an exaggerated lifeline.

Encouraging condom use would seem to be a more responsible attutude.

So do you agree with this argument then.

Seat-belts are a more important and effective safety measure than airbags.

Some people will use seat-belts less if we install airbags

Airbags can seriously injure people

There for we should not install airbags in automobiles?
 
It's a tricky question. I tend to go with the cultural norm. Which my double standard doesn't agree with on female genital procedures. Of course in women, the sex police want to cut the clitoris completely out. Better my property hate sex than to share it with anyone else.

Good points, but also.

The two procedures are very different in effect. A more compariable prodecedure for a woman would removing part of the labia, and that is done in the US for cosmetic reasons.

There is no reason to think that the various procedures refered to as female circumcision would have an effect on HIV transmission.
 
<snip>
I would totally buy into your plan if I could - it is far more satisfying to my sensibilities to depend upon education. But if being ethical meant doing what was easy, well, then there wouldn't need to be such things as ethics and morals.

Linda

So the argument for circumcision is:

1) What works for us here fails for them there for whatever reasons.
2) Its hell over there, so implementing policies we wouldn't dream of here are ok there.

As for ethics and morals I’ve already been had up for my “childish” belief in another thread that, conceptually at least, there exist moral absolutes. How else do you “know” if something is morally/ethically better if you’ve only got the last idea you had to judge it by? Or is democracy used i.e. 51% inflict what they think is “right” on the other 49%? Kohlberg’s level 6 moral reasoning would require you to put yourself in each person’s position and come up with a reversible compromise solution i.e. one that’s acceptable to all parties.

For examples of public policies backfiring, think about the over-prescription of antibiotics and the problems we’re now having (in the UK at least) with hospital acquired infections. Antibiotic resistant TB is on the rise because people felt better and didn’t finish their course of pills. Look at the way people are using the medical evidence that a small amount of alcohol is good for your heart to justify drinking more that the recommended 14/21 units a week. There are also studies that show drivers take more risks if the speed limit is well below what they think is a safe speed. I see no reasons why circumcision will not be used in exactly the same way by people when implemented for an entire population.

To sell male circumcision to boys (or their parents) who would not usually have it done is going to require the explicit/implicit message -

‘condoms are the better choice, but if you don’t fancy wearing one, then being circumcised is good too.’

communicated to them. To me that is playing with fire.

One other problem that appears to be being overlooked is that even if circumcision was 100% effective at preventing the spread of HIV, it will make the problem of women getting pregnant worse. The last time I checked, Africa didn’t need any more mouths to feed.
 
Last edited:
So the argument for circumcision is:

1) What works for us here fails for them there for whatever reasons.
2) Its hell over there, so implementing policies we wouldn't dream of here are ok there.

The argument for circumcision is:

1) We can speculate about what may work and perform research to test our ideas. We should not assume that what works reasonably well in one situation, will work just as well in a completely different situation. Once we have tested our ideas and have evidence to guide us, we should actually use the evidence rather than ignoring it in favour of wishful thinking or fear mongering.
2) Policies that we would propose if it was hell over here are reasonable to propose when it's hell over there, especially if it is found to be an acceptable and very satisfactory proceedure by those who actually received the intervention.

As for ethics and morals I’ve already been had up for my “childish” belief in another thread that, conceptually at least, there exist moral absolutes. How else do you “know” if something is morally/ethically better if you’ve only got the last idea you had to judge it by? Or is democracy used i.e. 51% inflict what they think is “right” on the other 49%? Kohlberg’s level 6 moral reasoning would require you to put yourself in each person’s position and come up with a reversible compromise solution i.e. one that’s acceptable to all parties.

Right, which I why I don't think it is morally acceptable to let my personal distaste for the proceedure prevent me from presenting it as a solution to those that are actually affected by the situation.

For examples of public policies backfiring, think about the over-prescription of antibiotics and the problems we’re now having (in the UK at least) with hospital acquired infections. Antibiotic resistant TB is on the rise because people felt better and didn’t finish their course of pills. Look at the way people are using the medical evidence that a small amount of alcohol is good for your heart to justify drinking more that the recommended 14/21 units a week. There are also studies that show drivers take more risks if the speed limit is well below what they think is a safe speed. I see no reasons why circumcision will not be used in exactly the same way by people when implemented for an entire population.

Antibiotic prescriptions are not an example of public policy. I'm not sure why people feeling better instead of dying is an example of "backfiring". And yes, we are well-aware of the effects of "moral hazard". You make it sound like we should never act for fear of unintended consequences.

To sell male circumcision to boys (or their parents) who would not usually have it done is going to require the explicit/implicit message -

‘condoms are the better choice, but if you don’t fancy wearing one, then being circumcised is good too.’

communicated to them. To me that is playing with fire.

One other problem that appears to be being overlooked is that even if circumcision was 100% effective at preventing the spread of HIV, it will make the problem of women getting pregnant worse. The last time I checked, Africa didn’t need any more mouths to feed.

I give up. You've made your position clear. There will never exist enough evidence. It is not sufficient to demonstrate that it hasn't happened. It must be demonstrated that it won't ever happen. And any concern is sufficient to delay the possibility of saving millions of lives.

Linda
 
The argument for circumcision is:

1) We can speculate about what may work and perform research to test our ideas. We should not assume that what works reasonably well in one situation, will work just as well in a completely different situation. Once we have tested our ideas and have evidence to guide us, we should actually use the evidence rather than ignoring it in favour of wishful thinking or fear mongering.

I mostly agree. But we should also be aware of the limitations of our research. This was also a behavioural experiment. If the context is changed then so could the behaviour.

2) Policies that we would propose if it was hell over here are reasonable to propose when it's hell over there, especially if it is found to be an acceptable and very satisfactory proceedure by those who actually received the intervention.

They volunteered for the intervention. Again, if the parents or boys make an informed choice and fear mongering isn’t used to coerce them then I’m ok with it.

Right, which I why I don't think it is morally acceptable to let my personal distaste for the proceedure prevent me from presenting it as a solution to those that are actually affected by the situation.

I mostly agree. Though there are some things I would probably not present as a solution for certain problems, such as killing 6million Jews to solve my countries ills.

Antibiotic prescriptions are not an example of public policy. I'm not sure why people feeling better instead of dying is an example of "backfiring". And yes, we are well-aware of the effects of "moral hazard". You make it sound like we should never act for fear of unintended consequences.

I was merely giving a few examples of good things can have unforeseen bad consequences when implemented on a large scale. W.r.t people feeling better I think the idea was people felt better and stopped taking their pills early, allowing the disease (TB in this case) to become resistant much sooner, putting many more people at risk. This may be nonsense.

Sometimes no action is the best course to take. With more Africans alive there’s more to feed. The climate doesn’t care if you’re HIV negative and trying to grow crops.

I give up. You've made your position clear. There will never exist enough evidence. It is not sufficient to demonstrate that it hasn't happened. It must be demonstrated that it won't ever happen. And any concern is sufficient to delay the possibility of saving millions of lives.

Linda

Please don’t give up on me Linda:) I do understand your point of view and to a certain extent share it. I’m sure all I need is a few more written bashings from you and skeptigirl and I’ll be converted.
 
I mostly agree. Though there are some things I would probably not present as a solution for certain problems, such as killing 6million Jews to solve my countries ills.

It is unlikely that that idea would pass the "put yourself in each person's position" test.

Sometimes no action is the best course to take. With more Africans alive there’s more to feed. The climate doesn’t care if you’re HIV negative and trying to grow crops.

Yeah, like cost-benefit analyses come out in favour of withholding treatment from people who are ill and elderly, since you save money by letting them die so you no longer have to support them.

I don't think we want to go there.

Please don’t give up on me Linda:) I do understand your point of view and to a certain extent share it. I’m sure all I need is a few more written bashings from you and skeptigirl and I’ll be converted.

I get tired of repeating myself. Maybe the frequency with which I change my avatar is a clue. :)
 
I think it can be agreed that condom use is generally more reliable than circumcision. So I've heard arguements saying, "Why bother with circumcision, when you should hand out more condoms in Africa, and that will be more effective." There's a slight problem with that. To quote Sam Harris:

President Bush recently decided to cut off funding to any overseas family-planning group that provides information on abortion. According to the New York Times, this "has effectively stopped condom provision to 16 countries and reduced it in 13 others, including some with the world's highest rate of AIDS infection." Under the influence of Christian notions of the sinfulness of sex outside of marriage, the U.S. government has required that one-third of its AIDS prevention funds allocated to Africa be squandered on teaching abstinence rather than condom use. It is no exaggeration to say that millions could die as a direct result of this single efflorescence of religious dogmatism.
- End of Faith, p. 167-168

Unless policy has changed, and Dubya has done a 180 on this issue, foreign politics on the part of the US restricts the amount of condoms in Africa. In place of doing nothing in these areas, at least something now can be done, albeit nowhere as effective.
 
aren't there studies claiming the opposite?

i'll keep my cock intact and use a condom thanks.
 
How did they control for the forms of sex practiced by the participants? I thought it was just a general reduction in the infection rate by 50% in men who are circumcised.
I believe they collected histories from both the circumcised and the control group at various intervals then applied the differences in reported sexual encounters to the analysis of the findings.

In other words if you read the study you can see for yourself how variables between the subjects and controls were considered and controlled for.
 
Good points, but also.

The two procedures are very different in effect. A more compariable prodecedure for a woman would removing part of the labia, and that is done in the US for cosmetic reasons.

There is no reason to think that the various procedures refered to as female circumcision would have an effect on HIV transmission.
The question and my answer were to the hypothetical suggestion, "if it was your clitoris instead of my penis you wouldn't say that".

Your point is not relevant.
 
Are you saying that health care workers systematically lie in order to accomplish public health directives from agencies they may or may not have a loose association with?

Linda

No. Risk communication isn't about lying, but rather simply presenting information in a way that compels one to perform the desired health behavior.

If information about meatal stenosis (how often it happens and why it happens) isn't forthcoming, is it a lie?
I don't think presenting things in a compelling way is actually lying. It's just marketing. The people who work in public health risk communication research have degrees in marketing and advertising and things like that. But instead of selling Pepsi, they're selling behavior.
The way things are presented affect what people do. If you're familiar with the statistics in penile cancer, surely it isn't too difficult to see how information could be presented in a way that would make one feel alarmed about being intact? "Worldwide, there are X many cases of penis cancer. Lack of male circumcision has been associated with an X increase in risk of this disease". And if that doesn't get compliance high enough, then they could print out little flyers to give moms who've just delivered with horrible photos of the worst cases of penis cancer you've ever seen.
That's health risk communication. And it works really well. That's how they got a lot of people to stop smoking.


Skeptigirl...
I'll be back later with a link on the totally bizarre finding of higher education being positively associated with women bringing their daughters in for FGM in some areas. Very :confused: stuff.
I'll respond to the rest of your post then, too.
 
It is unlikely that that idea would pass the "put yourself in each person's position" test.

Very true. So we agree more than you think we do? If the facts are honestly presented to parents and boys and they are allowed to choose then I have much fewer problems with this being provided along with the other methods currently in use.

Yeah, like cost-benefit analyses come out in favour of withholding treatment from people who are ill and elderly, since you save money by letting them die so you no longer have to support them.

I don't think we want to go there.

Who said anything about withholding treatment? It was just another potential factor to take into account, given that promoting HIV reduction methods that include ones that do not involve contraception will almost certainly lead to a faster population growth than ones that don’t, and climate models predict that area of the world is going to face the brunt of higher world temperatures. Better start saving for Live Aid 2050.

I get tired of repeating myself. Maybe the frequency with which I change my avatar is a clue. :)

Sometimes you have to repeat yourself to get your point across. I believe making gestures with your hands as you speak helps to - though that’s hard to do on an internet forum. I am sorry if you feel I've been ignoring or misunderstanding what you've been saying.

Yes, you have changed your Avatar a lot. I liked the one with your(?) face on the skew and this current one. The dog one was ok. I didn't like the Andy Warholesque one. It was too bright.
 
...

Please don’t give up on me Linda:) I do understand your point of view and to a certain extent share it. I’m sure all I need is a few more written bashings from you and skeptigirl and I’ll be converted.
OK. I'll give it one more try, but you have to broaden your picture a bit. Your focus on "we wouldn't do it here" is appropriate for circumstances such as those portrayed in The Constant Gardner.

But the opposite occurs as well when we think just as erroneously as was depicted in The Rabbit Proof Fence that our values apply to the world and every situation should be judged by our own.


So with that in mind, look at the science and the facts in this case.

The research has been going on regarding the foreskin's role in HIV transmission for more than a decade (I looked back at some of my old articles on this and one was ~15 years old.)

Circumcision eliminates a particular portal of entry that HIV uses to infect males.

Education, abstinence, and monogamy are currently part of the HIV prevention programs in most countries that have any prevention.

There is scientific evidence that education, treating pregnant women with anti-retroviral drugs, condom promotion and needle exchange programs actually reduce HIV infection rates. And there is a lot of circumstantial evidence improving the economic status of women and treating HIV infected individuals with anti-retroviral drugs decreases the HIV infection rates.

Some governments have been reluctant to promote prenatal HIV drug treatments (mainly South Africa due to the ignorance of their President who declared HIV was not the cause of AIDS). Many governments including our own resist needle exchange programs, claiming it would encourage drug use despite evidence it doesn't. And the Evangelical Christians have campaigned with various degrees of success against funding or implementing condom promotion, substituting abstinence only education despite the fact that such education has been shown by scientific research to have no impact on preventing HIV transmission. And contrary to the claims of the religious police, there is no evidence promoting condoms increases sexual activity.

And now there is more than sufficient scientific evidence circumcision decreases the rate of HIV transmission. This has been demonstrated in prospective trials. IE we can show you it works.

The risks and costs (both financial and loss of some sexual sensation) of circumcision are minimal when compared to the risks and costs of HIV-AIDS.

Those of us in the skeptic community profess we support scientific evidence over preconceived beliefs, bias, prejudice, woo, and religion (maybe not every skeptic on the latter).

The evidence is clear. The need is great. Condoms aren't enough. The parent does indeed have decision making authority for children so there is an advocate for that infant. It's better for a number of reasons to circumcise younger rather than older males.

I haven't seen any scientific evidence presented in this thread arguing that the amount of HIV expected to prevented isn't going to be sufficient enough to warrant recommending circumcision in countries with high HIV prevalence rates. All the arguments against circumcision have been emotional and in my opinion, apply to the post writer, rather than being a careful evaluation of the circumstances of the people where the recommendation is being made.
 
Last edited:
aren't there studies claiming the opposite?

i'll keep my cock intact and use a condom thanks.
No

and

as you should, (in that order).

No one is telling you to get a circumcision unless perhaps you are in Sub-Saharan Africa having sex on a regular basis with multiple partners.
 
No. Risk communication isn't about lying, but rather simply presenting information in a way that compels one to perform the desired health behavior.

If information about meatal stenosis (how often it happens and why it happens) isn't forthcoming, is it a lie?
I don't think presenting things in a compelling way is actually lying. It's just marketing. The people who work in public health risk communication research have degrees in marketing and advertising and things like that. But instead of selling Pepsi, they're selling behavior.
The way things are presented affect what people do. If you're familiar with the statistics in penile cancer, surely it isn't too difficult to see how information could be presented in a way that would make one feel alarmed about being intact? "Worldwide, there are X many cases of penis cancer. Lack of male circumcision has been associated with an X increase in risk of this disease". And if that doesn't get compliance high enough, then they could print out little flyers to give moms who've just delivered with horrible photos of the worst cases of penis cancer you've ever seen.
That's health risk communication. And it works really well. That's how they got a lot of people to stop smoking.
I've been particularly interested in persuasive communication in the last few years. And the dilemma always comes up, aren't you just presenting your propaganda over their propaganda. The answer is no.

I believe we can and should educate people to recognize persuasion tactics (from marketing to politics to religion). But when we choose to use such tactics, the goal is to persuade people to recognize the evidence, not to choose the action. When the evidence supports the action, I don't need to do the persuading.

It's true if I promote risk recognition, I may indeed be doing so because I am motivated to increase smoking cessation, vaccine use or seat belt use. But in having that goal of risk reduction, presumably I have done an assessment which identified perceived risk was lower than actual risk and that was the reason risk reduction wasn't occurring.

Your perception of some goal of marketing behavior modification begs the question, why would I need to exaggerate actual risk when the problem is the perceived risk is less than the actual risk? If the perceived risk reaches par with the actual risk and still isn't persuasive, then why would I want that particular behavior modified?

There might be some other factors which need addressing but the point is, if I have to exaggerate the actual risk what is my motive for caring if someone reduces the risk?


Skeptigirl...
I'll be back later with a link on the totally bizarre finding of higher education being positively associated with women bringing their daughters in for FGM in some areas. Very :confused: stuff.
I'll respond to the rest of your post then, too.
Thanks, take your time.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom