The behavior results do apply and are relevant to men who would choose this themselves in the near future. At least to some extent it is.
Does it tell us anything, though, about what the babies who will be circumcised in the year 2007/2008 will end up doing in 15 years?
Or is that still largely unknown?
Is that a serious question?
It is large scale circumcision of infants that I'm seeing having the human rights problem, as well.
This is how I would look at it. Given that neonatal circumcision is easier, would a 20-year-old man who is willing to be circumcized look back and say, "I would have preferred to have been circumcized as an infant, rather than now"? The answer may be yes most of the time. And given that the parents are speaking for someone that cannot speak for themselves (as though they are the adult male their son will become), it is not unreasonable to think that neonatal circumcision represents an informed choice. I.e. it is not necessarily a violation of human rights; it may actually better represent individual preferences than withholding circumcision until adult-hood would.
ETA: I should add that that reasoning works well in a stable situation (i.e. the reasons that a man may choose to be circumcized 20 years from now are similar to the reasons a 20-year-old chooses now). It should be taken into consideration that this is not necessarily a stable situation (trying to be optimistic
Linda
Last edited: