Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

The behavior results do apply and are relevant to men who would choose this themselves in the near future. At least to some extent it is.

Does it tell us anything, though, about what the babies who will be circumcised in the year 2007/2008 will end up doing in 15 years?
Or is that still largely unknown?

Is that a serious question?

It is large scale circumcision of infants that I'm seeing having the human rights problem, as well.

This is how I would look at it. Given that neonatal circumcision is easier, would a 20-year-old man who is willing to be circumcized look back and say, "I would have preferred to have been circumcized as an infant, rather than now"? The answer may be yes most of the time. And given that the parents are speaking for someone that cannot speak for themselves (as though they are the adult male their son will become), it is not unreasonable to think that neonatal circumcision represents an informed choice. I.e. it is not necessarily a violation of human rights; it may actually better represent individual preferences than withholding circumcision until adult-hood would.

ETA: I should add that that reasoning works well in a stable situation (i.e. the reasons that a man may choose to be circumcized 20 years from now are similar to the reasons a 20-year-old chooses now). It should be taken into consideration that this is not necessarily a stable situation (trying to be optimistic :)).

Linda
 
Last edited:

The references used in that article illustrate what is mentioned in the CDC fact sheet. The incidence of complications varies greatly depending upon where and how you look. The 10 percent rate comes from a selected population. If you look at a general population sample (a much more representative sample) the rate is much lower and is less common than the other complications that were mentioned.

Linda
 
fls said:
Is that a serious question?
Yes.
Perhaps I'm misunderstanding the argument, but it seems that when the point is made "This could eventually increase risky behavior" the answer is "They looked for that, and it didn't happen".

So, yes...it's a serious question. Even though it become rhetorical when phrased that way.

This is how I would look at it. Given that neonatal circumcision is easier, would a 20-year-old man who is willing to be circumcized look back and say, "I would have preferred to have been circumcized as an infant, rather than now"? The answer may be yes most of the time.

Is there evidence saying that's the case? Don't the acceptibility studies say it's "only" about 60%? So that leaves 40% of the guys without a sex organ who otherwise would have wanted it.

And then among the 60% who are cool with the idea...surely some of them would think being able to choose as an adult is better? What percentage I don't know...but surely some of them at least...

And given that the parents are speaking for someone that cannot speak for themselves (as though they are the adult male their son will become), it is not unreasonable to think that neonatal circumcision represents an informed choice. I.e. it is not necessarily a violation of human rights; it may actually better represent individual preferences than withholding circumcision until adult-hood would.

To some extent, yes. Maybe. It's subjective opinion, I suppose.

But if a goal is set for compliance...that's messed up, right?
Do you agree with me there?
 
The references used in that article illustrate what is mentioned in the CDC fact sheet. The incidence of complications varies greatly depending upon where and how you look. The 10 percent rate comes from a selected population. If you look at a general population sample (a much more representative sample) the rate is much lower and is less common than the other complications that were mentioned.

Linda

So they're just wrong here?

Background: Genital disorders are commonly encountered in the office of the primary care physician. Meatal stenosis is a relatively common acquired condition occurring in 9-10% of males who are circumcised. This disorder is characterized by an upward deflected, difficult-to-aim urinary stream and, occasionally, dysuria and urgent, frequent, and prolonged urination. Surgical meatotomy is curative.


Pathophysiology: After circumcision, a child who is not toilet trained persistently exposes the meatus to urine, resulting in inflammation (ammoniacal dermatitis) and mechanical trauma as the meatus rubs against a wet diaper. This causes the loss of the delicate epithelial lining of the distal urethra. This loss may result in adherence of the epithelial lining at the ventral side, leaving a pinpoint orifice at the tip of the glans. Because this condition is exceedingly rare in children who are not circumcised, circumcision is believed to be the most important causative factor of meatal stenosis.

Another hypothetical cause of this condition is ischemia due to damage to the frenular artery during circumcision, resulting in poor blood supply to the meatus and subsequent stenosis. In a prospective study of circumcised boys, Van Howe (2006) found meatal stenosis in 24 of 239 (7.29%) children older than 3 years, making meatal stenosis the most common complication of circumcision.

Frequency:


Internationally: Incidence is 9-10% of males who are circumcised.

Are you 100% sure, Linda?

My own anecdotal experience here in the US talking to guys is that one in 10 is about right. Although I'm the one to tell them it was circumcision that did it. Most guys just think they were born with deformed pee holes or something that required a small corrective surgery in early childhood. (that freaked them out really badly.)

Not that anecdote counts for much of anything...but it seems to be the US experience from my perspective.
 
<snip>
This is how I would look at it. Given that neonatal circumcision is easier, would a 20-year-old man who is willing to be circumcized look back and say, "I would have preferred to have been circumcized as an infant, rather than now"?

That thinking is so back-to-front I don’t now how someone as smart as you could come out with it. I used to find myself thinking I wish I could have done things I’ve only just done twenty years ago. But I’ve realised that the only reason I’m doing whatever I’m doing now is because of my past experiences up to now. Twenty years ago I was a different person and so wanted different things.

The answer may be yes most of the time.

Only if they buy into the twisted logic you’ve just come out with.

And given that the parents are speaking for someone that cannot speak for themselves (as though they are the adult male their son will become), it is not unreasonable to think that neonatal circumcision represents an informed choice. I.e. it is not necessarily a violation of human rights; it may actually better represent individual preferences than withholding circumcision until adult-hood would.

And she goes for the goal but it was offside. What a shame.

ETA: I should add that that reasoning works well in a stable situation (i.e. the reasons that a man may choose to be circumcized 20 years from now are similar to the reasons a 20-year-old chooses now). It should be taken into consideration that this is not necessarily a stable situation (trying to be optimistic :)).

Linda

That reasoning works well on people significantly less smart than you, probably with young kids who they want to impose something on like say, RELIGION. Richard Dawkins would not be impressed.

Please feel free to keep on ignoring me.
 
Yes.
Perhaps I'm misunderstanding the argument, but it seems that when the point is made "This could eventually increase risky behavior" the answer is "They looked for that, and it didn't happen".

So, yes...it's a serious question. Even though it become rhetorical when phrased that way.

The answer is that we cannot predict what will happen in the future. All we can do is say this is what happened, and take the possibility into consideration when planning educational programs.

Is there evidence saying that's the case? Don't the acceptibility studies say it's "only" about 60%? So that leaves 40% of the guys without a sex organ who otherwise would have wanted it.

I think you are talking about surveys done in the US for circumcision, where they were probably mostly done for non-medical reasons, or for fairly minor preventative measures, not for prevention of a disease that has led to the death of many of your friends and family.

And then among the 60% who are cool with the idea...surely some of them would think being able to choose as an adult is better? What percentage I don't know...but surely some of them at least...

I would think so, too. My point was simply that it was unreasonable to assume that it always represents a case of trampling on someone's human rights. For all we know, that may apply only to a small minority.

But if a goal is set for compliance...that's messed up, right?
Do you agree with me there?

I don't think it should be involuntary, if that's what you are getting at.

Linda
 
So they're just wrong here?

The research that is quoted is from a select population. We already know that prevalence can easily vary 100-fold once you start looking at unrepresentative populations.

Are you 100% sure, Linda?

My own anecdotal experience here in the US talking to guys is that one in 10 is about right. Although I'm the one to tell them it was circumcision that did it. Most guys just think they were born with deformed pee holes or something that required a small corrective surgery in early childhood. (that freaked them out really badly.)

Not that anecdote counts for much of anything...but it seems to be the US experience from my perspective.

I'm pretty sure that I trust information where the contribution of confirmation and attribution bias has been reduced or eliminated over information where it has been allowed free rein.

Linda
 
fls said:
The answer is that we cannot predict what will happen in the future. All we can do is say this is what happened, and take the possibility into consideration when planning educational programs.

I guess that's fair enough. :)


I think you are talking about surveys done in the US for circumcision, where they were probably mostly done for non-medical reasons, or for fairly minor preventative measures, not for prevention of a disease that has led to the death of many of your friends and family.

No, I'm thinking about the African acceptability studies. But I'm not 100% on what the rates were on average or in different areas. I'll try to re-find a link on that.

I would think so, too. My point was simply that it was unreasonable to assume that it always represents a case of trampling on someone's human rights. For all we know, that may apply only to a small minority.

I see your point.

I don't think it should be involuntary, if that's what you are getting at.

Linda

No, that's not what I was getting at. Persuasion is a spectrum kind of thing, it seems.

The research that is quoted is from a select population. We already know that prevalence can easily vary 100-fold once you start looking at unrepresentative populations.

I'm pretty sure that I trust information where the contribution of confirmation and attribution bias has been reduced or eliminated over information where it has been allowed free rein.

Linda

I just checked, and I don't have access to the CDC's source. So I dunno.
I'll see if I can get it somehow.
I'm not really seeing how confirmation bias would play into a diagnosis like meatal stenosis, though.
But I do see a lot of room for under-reporting.

Can you give me a rundown on what's wrong, exactly, with the studies that find it happening one out of ten times?
Like, how did they mess up to produce an inflated figure?
 
<snip>
Can you give me a rundown on what's wrong, exactly, with the studies that find it happening one out of ten times?
Like, how did they mess up to produce an inflated figure?

As I think Linda has me on ignore you may also want to ask her how the complication rate is likely to change given less time for each patient w.r.t the studies and what will happen to it if loads of men really do want to be circumcised and the third world infrastructure is overloaded?
 
As I think Linda has me on ignore you may also want to ask her how the complication rate is likely to change given less time for each patient w.r.t the studies and what will happen to it if loads of men really do want to be circumcised and the third world infrastructure is overloaded?

I've already read about where they're making plans for all of that. They're going to train the nurses and midwifes on the proper way to do it. They're probably allocating funding for the education as we speak.
 
I just checked, and I don't have access to the CDC's source. So I dunno.
I'll see if I can get it somehow.
I'm not really seeing how confirmation bias would play into a diagnosis like meatal stenosis, though.
But I do see a lot of room for under-reporting.

Aren't you more likely to remember when your idea was confirmed than when it wasn't?

Can you give me a rundown on what's wrong, exactly, with the studies that find it happening one out of ten times?
Like, how did they mess up to produce an inflated figure?

It's not that the studies themselves are necessarily messed up. It's that the ability to generalize from a small sample to a broader population is messed up. First of all, they selected from a population that was different from the general population (selection bias), meaning that generalizing to a general population would be invalid. And then the sample was not chosen randomly, allowing for systematic bias to influence the results.

Linda
 
I've already read about where they're making plans for all of that. They're going to train the nurses and midwifes on the proper way to do it. They're probably allocating funding for the education as we speak.

Midwifes! Why might they need to train midwifes?

Hopefully just for extra hands to perform the operations on boys/men old enough to decide for themselves.

Could you send me a link to that info. please. Thanks.

Did you buy Linda's argument for choosing things for your kids’ 20-years in advance? Am I totally alone in thinking that was the worst argument for parental choice ever?

Which was along the lines of:

I'm a 24 year old Catholic. I love being a Catholic. I'm so glad my parents sent me to the nuns from the age of 4!

Does that really make sense to you?
 
fls said:
Aren't you more likely to remember when your idea was confirmed than when it wasn't?

What do you mean?
Are you referring to my anecdotal experience with the rate? If so, then, yeah. I know. That's why I'm looking for raw data.

It's not that the studies themselves are necessarily messed up. It's that the ability to generalize from a small sample to a broader population is messed up. First of all, they selected from a population that was different from the general population (selection bias), meaning that generalizing to a general population would be invalid. And then the sample was not chosen randomly, allowing for systematic bias to influence the results.

Linda

I'm having a horrible time of finding raw data either way. I must not be using the right keywords or something. I did stumble across the Van Howe 2006 study mentioned in the emedicine article, and that's the best study I've been able to locate thus far.
Have you looked at that one? Is there a structural flaw I'm not seeing in the abstract? Do you want me to find a link on it?

Where is the conflicting evidence that says that complication rate in newborns is lower?

It has to look strictly at neonatal circumcision, though, since the complication doesn't happen when circumcision takes place after the foreskin separates from the glans.
 
There’s some evidence that the virus survives better in the moist environment and there are more of the target cells available on an uncircumcised penis. Also, I think that circumcised penis’s are “tougher” and less likely to have small cuts on them. (That’s CUTS you dirty boy).

details? i'd rather hear about that than this piece of inconclusive junk.

CUTS?! shhhh
 
details? i'd rather hear about that than this piece of inconclusive junk.

CUTS?! shhhh

Sorry Alan, I didn't find the info. on this last time, just looked at it. Perhaps someone else reading/taking part could point him in the right direction for the info. he wants?

Could you or anyone else reading / taking part (even you Linda:) ) provide me with a sanity check please? Do you think Linda's argument for parental choice is valid? Have I missed something subtle in it? Skeptics are supposed to use logic just a little bit, aren't they?
 
Midwifes! Why might they need to train midwifes?

Hopefully just for extra hands to perform the operations on boys/men old enough to decide for themselves.

Could you send me a link to that info. please. Thanks.

Did you buy Linda's argument for choosing things for your kids’ 20-years in advance? Am I totally alone in thinking that was the worst argument for parental choice ever?

Which was along the lines of:

I'm a 24 year old Catholic. I love being a Catholic. I'm so glad my parents sent me to the nuns from the age of 4!

Does that really make sense to you?

I'll try to refind the links on the midwifes thing.

As far as choosing things for your kids 20 years in advance...I sort of get it.
These things do have a way of becoming self-fulfilling prophesies.

But I found the acceptability studies in question:
http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140673607603237/fulltext

Westercamp and colleagues reviewed25 13 acceptability studies done in sub-Saharan Africa among non-circumcising communities. The median acceptability was 65% among men, whereas 69% of women favoured their partners being circumcised, and 81% of both men and women were willing to circumcise their male children.
So that's about one in three men who would not have wanted to have been circumcised as an infant, I guess.
 
Last edited:
I don't think you understand what evidence is available. There is not one study showing a correlation. There are many observational studies showing a correlation. There are numerous studies of the pathophysiology. And there are now three very well-done experimental studies showing effectiveness from which conclusions about causation can be drawn. For any other issue the quality of the research would be considered very good, not crap.

Linda

i don't give a **** how many correlation experiments there have been. show the virus transmitting, add some controls(!), do some trials on monkeys, rats, mice or whatever. the research should be moving along, instead wallowing over the same type of study that provides no reasons to why circumcision helps in an uncontrolled environment. did circumcision alone prevent aids? there might be other methods without circumcision to prevent aids. some people have vague ideas why it might help, but they're vague and ideas, not evidence. etc etc etc
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom