Ivor the Engineer
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2006
- Messages
- 11,103
OK. I'll give it one more try, but you have to broaden your picture a bit. Your focus on "we wouldn't do it here" is appropriate for circumstances such as those portrayed in The Constant Gardner.
But the opposite occurs as well when we think just as erroneously as was depicted in The Rabbit Proof Fence that our values apply to the world and every situation should be judged by our own.
So with that in mind, look at the science and the facts in this case.
The research has been going on regarding the foreskin's role in HIV transmission for more than a decade (I looked back at some of my old articles on this and one was ~15 years old.)
Circumcision eliminates a particular portal of entry that HIV uses to infect males.
Education, abstinence, and monogamy are currently part of the HIV prevention programs in most countries that have any prevention.
There is scientific evidence that education, treating pregnant women with anti-retroviral drugs, condom promotion and needle exchange programs actually reduce HIV infection rates. And there is a lot of circumstantial evidence improving the economic status of women and treating HIV infected individuals with anti-retroviral drugs decreases the HIV infection rates.
Some governments have been reluctant to promote prenatal HIV drug treatments (mainly South Africa due to the ignorance of their President who declared HIV was not the cause of AIDS). Many governments including our own resist needle exchange programs, claiming it would encourage drug use despite evidence it doesn't. And the Evangelical Christians have campaigned with various degrees of success against funding or implementing condom promotion, substituting abstinence only education despite the fact that such education has been shown by scientific research to have no impact on preventing HIV transmission. And contrary to the claims of the religious police, there is no evidence promoting condoms increases sexual activity.
And now there is more than sufficient scientific evidence circumcision decreases the rate of HIV transmission. This has been demonstrated in prospective trials. IE we can show you it works.
The risks and costs (both financial and loss of some sexual sensation) of circumcision are minimal when compared to the risks and costs of HIV-AIDS.
Those of us in the skeptic community profess we support scientific evidence over preconceived beliefs, bias, prejudice, woo, and religion (maybe not every skeptic on the latter).
The evidence is clear. The need is great. Condoms aren't enough. The parent does indeed have decision making authority for children so there is an advocate for that infant. It's better for a number of reasons to circumcise younger rather than older males.
I haven't seen any scientific evidence presented in this thread arguing that the amount of HIV expected to prevented isn't going to be sufficient enough to warrant recommending circumcision in countries with high HIV prevalence rates. All the arguments against circumcision have been emotional and in my opinion, apply to the post writer, rather than being a careful evaluation of the circumstances of the people where the recommendation is being made.
My point is that the parents or boys should be given the facts unbiased and allowed to choose for themselves. But you’ve already started the spinning of "The Facts”(TM) with your speech about “The evidence is clear…”
The facts are:
1) Male circumcision has shown ~60% efficacy at preventing males sexually contracting HIV in well run trials lasting 2 years.
2) There is likely to be limited loss of sensitivity after and a small risk of potential complications with the surgery.
3) It is still unknown by how much male circumcision reduces the likelihood of the receptive partner contracting HIV during sex.
4) Circumcision is not a condom replacement. For the best protection a condom still needs to be used during sex. Condoms alone can be >90% effective if used correctly. This effectiveness is dependent on them being available and being used correctly.
Let the parents or boys decide for themselves. Imposing your solutions to their problem smacks of colonialism.