Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

OK. I'll give it one more try, but you have to broaden your picture a bit. Your focus on "we wouldn't do it here" is appropriate for circumstances such as those portrayed in The Constant Gardner.

But the opposite occurs as well when we think just as erroneously as was depicted in The Rabbit Proof Fence that our values apply to the world and every situation should be judged by our own.


So with that in mind, look at the science and the facts in this case.

The research has been going on regarding the foreskin's role in HIV transmission for more than a decade (I looked back at some of my old articles on this and one was ~15 years old.)

Circumcision eliminates a particular portal of entry that HIV uses to infect males.

Education, abstinence, and monogamy are currently part of the HIV prevention programs in most countries that have any prevention.

There is scientific evidence that education, treating pregnant women with anti-retroviral drugs, condom promotion and needle exchange programs actually reduce HIV infection rates. And there is a lot of circumstantial evidence improving the economic status of women and treating HIV infected individuals with anti-retroviral drugs decreases the HIV infection rates.

Some governments have been reluctant to promote prenatal HIV drug treatments (mainly South Africa due to the ignorance of their President who declared HIV was not the cause of AIDS). Many governments including our own resist needle exchange programs, claiming it would encourage drug use despite evidence it doesn't. And the Evangelical Christians have campaigned with various degrees of success against funding or implementing condom promotion, substituting abstinence only education despite the fact that such education has been shown by scientific research to have no impact on preventing HIV transmission. And contrary to the claims of the religious police, there is no evidence promoting condoms increases sexual activity.

And now there is more than sufficient scientific evidence circumcision decreases the rate of HIV transmission. This has been demonstrated in prospective trials. IE we can show you it works.

The risks and costs (both financial and loss of some sexual sensation) of circumcision are minimal when compared to the risks and costs of HIV-AIDS.

Those of us in the skeptic community profess we support scientific evidence over preconceived beliefs, bias, prejudice, woo, and religion (maybe not every skeptic on the latter).

The evidence is clear. The need is great. Condoms aren't enough. The parent does indeed have decision making authority for children so there is an advocate for that infant. It's better for a number of reasons to circumcise younger rather than older males.

I haven't seen any scientific evidence presented in this thread arguing that the amount of HIV expected to prevented isn't going to be sufficient enough to warrant recommending circumcision in countries with high HIV prevalence rates. All the arguments against circumcision have been emotional and in my opinion, apply to the post writer, rather than being a careful evaluation of the circumstances of the people where the recommendation is being made.

My point is that the parents or boys should be given the facts unbiased and allowed to choose for themselves. But you’ve already started the spinning of "The Facts”(TM) with your speech about “The evidence is clear…”

The facts are:

1) Male circumcision has shown ~60% efficacy at preventing males sexually contracting HIV in well run trials lasting 2 years.

2) There is likely to be limited loss of sensitivity after and a small risk of potential complications with the surgery.

3) It is still unknown by how much male circumcision reduces the likelihood of the receptive partner contracting HIV during sex.

4) Circumcision is not a condom replacement. For the best protection a condom still needs to be used during sex. Condoms alone can be >90% effective if used correctly. This effectiveness is dependent on them being available and being used correctly.

Let the parents or boys decide for themselves. Imposing your solutions to their problem smacks of colonialism.
 
No

and

as you should, (in that order).

No one is telling you to get a circumcision unless perhaps you are in Sub-Saharan Africa having sex on a regular basis with multiple partners.

thought penn and teller bs mentioned some, guess not.

aids doesn't just affect africa. if this research is true, it could obviously help in slowing the spread. all children for example could be circumcised at birth.

i'm still dubious though, this study indicates it's the skin aids spreads by, which doesn't seem right, especially when i think about what i've been told about how it spreads(bodily fluids). why is aids less likely to be caught when circumcised? there's no explanation at all. so now of course paranoid parents and maybe even doctors will have kids circumcised because of one study showing a correlation. whoopy! i suppose it can't hurt to be safe, not in the long run anyway.

suppose it could be torn skin and bodily fluids going into the torn skin. i have no idea, lol. still crap evidence though.

oh and religious motives *sigh*. zzzz
 
Last edited:
I'm not mis-informed, kelly. Did you consider all the factors that play into the cultural practice? It's very complex. Women in male dominated societies are raised to believe these things. It doesn't mean male domination is not at the root of the practice. Do you know of any examples of this practice where women are not under a double standard or at least didn't come from a culture with those characteristics? In other words tell me where this is practiced that women are men's equals in that society.

I'm not sure there's any culture in the world where women are men's equals. We still don't get paid the same to do the same job here in the West. (the root of sexism is an interesting topic in and of itself.)

They firmly believe FGM has health benefits. And now that they've finally found health benefits for MGM I'm honestly thinking...who knows? Maybe they're right. Maybe removing the labia and scarifying the vagina makes it hard for the herpes virus to replicate or something there.

Not that it matters, because I'll do pretty much anything to keep my vagina exactly the way it is.

But I wonder if in some parallel universe where God told Abraham to circumcise all the girls on the 8th day, if they're now doing these studies in women. The Judeo-Christian influence has undeniably set the stage for this in a multitude of ways.


Yes, based on subjective reports. Are there studies that measured nerve impulses or anything physical? I'm not saying there is no decreased sensation. I'm wondering what the degree of change is.

The nerve impulse type research is conflicting from what I remember. The "survey" type research says it's fairly significant.

Where did you read/see this? I'd like to see what the surrounding details are.
I found it. (thanks to Eos for posting this link in the other thread from a few months ago.)

http://www.unicef.org/publications/files/FGM-C_final_10_October.pdf

It is generally observed that women with
higher education are less likely to have circumcised
daughters than women with lower or no
formal education. Of the 15 countries with available
survey data, 8 present a positive relationship,
with ratios of 1.5 or greater; 6 show no difference
by levels of education; and in 1, Nigeria, the likelihood
of having at least one daughter circumcised
is greater among women with some education.

While for most countries the impact of mothers’
education on the FGM/C status of daughters is
significant, it is less evident in Eritrea, Guinea,
Mali, Mauritania, northern Sudan and Yemen.
These individual cases require special analysis to
account for the differences observed. In the case
of Nigeria, for example, one explanation could be
that this difference is “due to the confounding
factor of ethnicity, because FGC is practiced by
Yoruba groups, who are also more likely to be educated.
The lack of association in Mali…could be
related to the overall low level of education in the
country – 81 per cent of respondents have never
been to school, and only 7 per cent had at least
some secondary education.”15 In Guinea, which
has the highest national FGM/C prevalence rate
(99 per cent), this fi nding can also be explained by
the very small proportion of women in the country
with secondary-or-above schooling (5 per cent,
compared with 76 per cent of Guinean women
who have no education).

So it's mostly Nigeria.

I've been in the medical field 30 years. I'm a nurse practitioner. I have a practice specialized in infectious disease. I've read a lot of the research and discussed this issue before. The researchers considered the hazard of circumcision leading to increased unprotected sex. It didn't happen.

I understand that they studied it, but real life works differently from clinical trials. People form their "beliefs" in their teen years, and they look to peers to share information with. How can this study say what Christian school teachers are going to tell 9th graders about condoms and circumcision?
Many of the "educators" over there are teaching kids that the HIV virus is smaller than the pores in latex, so condoms can't work at all, ever, to prevent HIV.
Believing that this study controlled for those kinds of factors requires a tremendous suspension of disbelief.
 
I'm not sure there's any culture in the world where women are men's equals. We still don't get paid the same to do the same job here in the West. (the root of sexism is an interesting topic in and of itself.)

And if you're a child forget about having any absolute rights. Like the right not to have your body altered for a risk that can be reduced by many different ways, if you so choose.

They firmly believe FGM has health benefits. And now that they've finally found health benefits for MGM I'm honestly thinking...who knows? Maybe they're right. Maybe removing the labia and scarifying the vagina makes it hard for the herpes virus to replicate or something there.

Not that it matters, because I'll do pretty much anything to keep my vagina exactly the way it is.

That’s the problem the supporters of this have got. If a man has not chosen circumcision then you will need to provide a really big incentive for him to elect to have it done, or lie to him, in the nicest possible way of course, by presenting half-truths as the whole. You can start a war that way.

Alternatively you can have already done it to him before he could protest, i.e. when he was a child. The parents will be easier to convince. Just show them pictures of children dying of AIDS soon after their child is born. Keep up the propaganda until it’s time for the little one to be taken away for processing – sorry, I mean have the procedure – and you’ll obtain the desired 96% compliance.

But I wonder if in some parallel universe where God told Abraham to circumcise all the girls on the 8th day, if they're now doing these studies in women. The Judeo-Christian influence has undeniably set the stage for this in a multitude of ways.

If parallel universes exist then I’m sure there are all kinds of bizarre stuff being done because authority figures e.g. God, Tribal Elders and Experts decree it to be the right thing to do. There might even be one where some fundamental rights of the individual have been agreed and are not ignored when the going gets tough.

The nerve impulse type research is conflicting from what I remember. The "survey" type research says it's fairly significant.

Didn’t someone post last time about being taught in medical school that on average, circumcised men take longer to reach orgasm? If true that would be a clear indication that the sensation is significantly different after circumcision. But if you’re circumcised as an infant you won’t know any different, so that makes it ok for Skeptigirl. I mean, it’s only a little bit of skin, isn’t it?

I understand that they studied it, but real life works differently from clinical trials. People form their "beliefs" in their teen years, and they look to peers to share information with. How can this study say what Christian school teachers are going to tell 9th graders about condoms and circumcision? Many of the "educators" over there are teaching kids that the HIV virus is smaller than the pores in latex, so condoms can't work at all, ever, to prevent HIV.

I’ve tried this argument and they’re not listening kellyb. Probably because they will be exploiting the same psychological techniques that all groups use who wish to change people’s behaviour.

Believing that this study controlled for those kinds of factors requires a tremendous suspension of disbelief.

No, no, no. What you don’t understand is that the real world and real people’s human rights are not important. What counts is how many people’s lives the model predict they will save. All the uncontrolled factors in the experiment or that not included in the model are unimportant and anyone who brings them up is accused of not wanting or being able to do anything to help anybody, ever, for not being certain of the outcome.

This is turning into the public health version of Bush’s “War on Terror”, where basic human rights that our society has supposedly agreed to support and champion are being forgotten about when they get in the way of what some what to do.

I wonder if occasionally beating children has any long term behavioural health benefits? Along the lines of “spare the rod and ruin the child.” I’m sure there’s a culture out there that does it that could be studied.
 
Last edited:
... if this research is true, it could obviously help in slowing the spread. all children for example could be circumcised at birth.

i'm still dubious though, this study indicates it's the skin aids spreads by, which doesn't seem right, especially when i think about what i've been told about how it spreads(bodily fluids). why is aids less likely to be caught when circumcised? there's no explanation at all. so now of course paranoid parents and maybe even doctors will have kids circumcised because of one study showing a correlation. whoopy! i suppose it can't hurt to be safe, not in the long run anyway.

suppose it could be torn skin and bodily fluids going into the torn skin. i have no idea, lol. still crap evidence though.

oh and religious motives *sigh*. zzzz
I just love posting the same thing over and over. :rolleyes:

There needs to be a high enough prevalence of HIV to warrant recommending all boys everywhere be circumcised. Certainly an individual parent might wish to have their child circumcised for this reason. But a public health recommendation for "the public" needs a higher threshold.

There are specific cells on the inner side of the foreskin HIV actually can enter.
 
My point is that the parents or boys should be given the facts unbiased and allowed to choose for themselves. But you’ve already started the spinning of "The Facts”(TM) with your speech about “The evidence is clear…”

The facts are:

1) Male circumcision has shown ~60% efficacy at preventing males sexually contracting HIV in well run trials lasting 2 years.

2) There is likely to be limited loss of sensitivity after and a small risk of potential complications with the surgery.

3) It is still unknown by how much male circumcision reduces the likelihood of the receptive partner contracting HIV during sex.

4) Circumcision is not a condom replacement. For the best protection a condom still needs to be used during sex. Condoms alone can be >90% effective if used correctly. This effectiveness is dependent on them being available and being used correctly.

Let the parents or boys decide for themselves. Imposing your solutions to their problem smacks of colonialism.

But the evidence is "clear". Are you suggesting health educators lie?

Did anyone here or in any of the research give you the impression they were advocation required circs? Do you think anyone disagrees with this being a voluntary program?


And here I thought I had posted such a thorough and clearly stated post.
 
skeptigirl said:
There needs to be a high enough prevalence of HIV to warrant recommending all boys everywhere be circumcised. Certainly an individual parent might wish to have their child circumcised for this reason. But a public health recommendation for "the public" needs a higher threshold.
Who figures out what the life/death threshold is, though?
At exactly what point do fundamental human rights cease to matter?
Was there some big meeting I missed where the nuts and bolts of exactly what ratio is appropriate for determining what rights fly out the window at what point when however many lives are potentially at steak?

Who gets to decide these things, and who elected them?
 
...

I found it. (thanks to Eos for posting this link in the other thread from a few months ago.)

http://www.unicef.org/publications/files/FGM-C_final_10_October.pdf
From your post : "It is generally observed that women with higher education are less likely to have circumcised daughters than women with lower or no formal education. "

I think you read it wrong. Or I read your post wrong.

You're right that women are not equal in most societies. It's too bad the boys haven't figured out they might get more sex in matriarchal societies if the bonobos are any indication. It's the one primate society females dominate and it also happens to be the one primate society where they really do make love and not war. ;)


.I understand that they studied it, but real life works differently from clinical trials. People form their "beliefs" in their teen years, and they look to peers to share information with. How can this study say what Christian school teachers are going to tell 9th graders about condoms and circumcision?
Many of the "educators" over there are teaching kids that the HIV virus is smaller than the pores in latex, so condoms can't work at all, ever, to prevent HIV.
Believing that this study controlled for those kinds of factors requires a tremendous suspension of disbelief.
"Real life works differently than clinical trials?"

It might surprise you but medical providers and health educators are usually quite well informed and skilled in their jobs. Researchers mostly understand the limits of particular studies. After all it is something every researcher is supposed to put in the conclusion of a research paper.

Your post suggests medical providers are naive, live in bubbles, and set out with a formula to practice what they learned regardless of who they practice on. Perhaps you have your view of providers because of your view of evidence based medicine.

But regarding your other comments, the teachers giving religious based information instead of evidence based information are to be discouraged.
 
Last edited:
Ivor fibbed. He said he was actually evaluating what we were posting. It's your turn again, fls if you have the time/motivation. :D
 
skeptigirl said:
From your post : "It is generally observed that women with higher education are less likely to have circumcised daughters than women with lower or no formal education. "

I think you read it wrong. Or I read your post wrong.

I said "some areas". The finding stuck out to me because I assumed that more education would bring about less FGM every time.

You're right that women are not equal in most societies. It's too bad the boys haven't figured out they might get more sex in matriarchal societies if the bonobos are any indication. It's the one primate society females dominate and it also happens to be the one primate society where they really do make love and not war.
I love bonobos. And elephants. :)

It might surprise you but medical providers and health educators are usually quite well informed and skilled in their jobs.



I am aware of that.

Researchers mostly understand the limits of particular studies.

Right. And I, as a casual evaluator of the research, am allowed to understand the limits of the study, as well.

After all it is something every researcher is supposed to put in the conclusion of a research paper.

I haven't read the study yet. I know fls keeps saying "that behavior wasn't observed" and she's pretty smart, so I'm thinking that's the extent of it.

Am I missing anything?

Your post suggests medical providers are naive, live in bubbles, and set out with a formula to practice what they learned regardless of who they practice on. Perhaps you have your view of providers because of your view of evidence based medicine.

First of all, I'm a big fan EBM. The rest of that's just strawman/ad hom nonsense so I'm not going to respond to it.

But regarding your other comments, the teachers giving religious based information instead of evidence based information are to be discouraged.

I agree.
 
I was trying to be nice, no ad homs intended. But when you post things that are common sense with some admonition health care workers need to.... or the research isn't real life... it's a bit condescending considering the entry level in my field is at least a master's degree. Surely we know that a clinical trial isn't a perfect predictor.

Re the EBM, weren't you against some vaccinations. Maybe I have you mixed up with someone else. Sorry.

But no matter. About the higher education is more likely to practice fgm, I'm confused. I asked you for a link and you posted one saying the opposite, higher education correlated with less fgm.????????

They state that the exception in Nigeria is due to education difference in the groups with the cultural practice of more common fgm. That implies it is something other than education which is the variable being evidenced.

I'm just not convinced fgm is a health practice anywhere. My understanding is it is a "you won't stay a virgin if we don't do it and no man will marry you" practice.
 
Last edited:
I was trying to be nice, no ad homs intended. But when you post things that are common sense with some admonition health care workers need to.... or the research isn't real life... it's a bit condescending considering the entry level in my field is at least a master's degree. Surely we know that a clinical trial isn't a perfect predictor.

Ok.
Ivor and I can see circumcision eventually increasing risky behaviors because of many reasons.
You and fls are saying "But the researchers looked for that, and it didn't happen".
Right?
Ok. We get that part. The circed guts didn't just throw the condoms out the window when told that the circs were 50% effective.

But the counterargument that we're making is that the clinical trial situation won't necessarily represent what goes on once this becomes widespread. There are differences. So saying "It wasn't observed" just doesn't cut it.

I appreciate the information, but it's not entirely relevant.

I'm not being condescending here...it's just my opinion. It's is counter-argument I'm presenting, so don't take it personally.

But no matter. About the higher education is more likely to practice fgm, I'm confused. I asked you for a link and you posted one saying the opposite, higher education correlated with less fgm.????????

Did you read the part about Nigeria?
Where higher education is positively associated with FGM? As a general rule, more education leads to less FGM, but there are exceptions.
 
it has huge positive consequences if true. but some negative things about this study and circumcision in general.

correlation does not mean causation, this i find incredible, all these studies supporting it and no causation? what's up science? how about advancing the testing a little!?

circumcision is incredibly painful and cruel for babies (didn't the UN pass some law about this?) and the babies have no choice in the matter. sadly, there are religious and financial motives (selling foreskins for medical testing) for promoting circumcision.

not saying it's true or not true, but the hole thing is still fraught with questions and obstacles.
 
Last edited:
But the evidence is "clear". Are you suggesting health educators lie?

The evidence is that if you want a reasonable chance of avoiding being infected with HIV and you live in sub-Saharan Africa then you must use a condom if you are engaging in sexual intercourse. Having multiple partners puts both you and them at a higher risk.

Promoting “circumcision is good too” is like having a drink driving campaign which bangs on about not drinking if you’re planning to drive then includes a bit saying that having a drink or two is ok so long as you don’t have an accident.

Therefore I’m suggesting they will use exactly the same methods advertisers’ and the people we give authority to do. The objective is to get the vast majority of young boys circumcised. The propaganda will be tailored to coerce parents to have this done to their child. The success of the campaign will be judged on how many boys have been circumcised. And there will be much rejoicing.

I call it propaganda because it will have to consist of half truths to convince the desired number (96%) of people to comply.

Did anyone here or in any of the research give you the impression they were advocation required circs?

Oh no of course not. They would just like it to happen all by itself, because then they wouldn’t have to wrestle with the idea of being responsible for or supporting a campaign that coerced people into violating an individuals basic human right that they themselves enjoy and exercise every day.

Do you think anyone disagrees with this being a voluntary program?

When this “voluntary” program starts, let us see the information being presented to parents. Do you think it will be more like “the facts” speech you started to give (“condoms aren’t enough, the situation is dire, blah, blah, blah”), or the factually correct list of information I gave, giving unbiased explanations of all the research?

I suppose if it’s done in a clever way then the information that would sway parents away from having their son circumcised will be presented in a more complicated way, such that educated critics can decipher it easy enough, but an adult with barely a primary school education would struggle. Thus the advocates of such a program can argue they are giving the full facts to parents.

And here I thought I had posted such a thorough and clearly stated post.

You have made it clear that you believe the end justifies the means. I disagree.

Infant circumcision is taking something away from the individual that they are not in a position to give consent for. The child is in no immediate danger so it should be left until they are old enough to decide for themselves.
 
Last edited:
For the record...I just made the 96% figure up as a hypothetical. It seems that the WHO/UNAIDS/whoever people are probably doing the math now looking at possible projections. Who knows what they'll actually decide.

I'm still crossing my fingers that they'll decide it's unethical to circumcise newborns and throw the whole deal out the window. Using terms like "circumcision rollout" and doing cost predictions that find that the newborns are cheaper makes it look pretty grim, though.
 
didn't mean to be rude btw, i just find this study so inconclusive and am sick of seeing horrendous correlation equals causation1 claims.
 
Ivor fibbed. He said he was actually evaluating what we were posting. It's your turn again, fls if you have the time/motivation. :D

Ivor has not fibbed, he has come a very long way and is practically sitting right next to you as far as male circumcision goes. My view is slightly different to your own that is all.

If African men wish to use this after being given all the relative information in an unbiased way then I have no problem with it.

But I happen to live in the real world (and I even have a Master Degree for what it’s worth,) so I know that public policy decisions often have unforeseen consequences and humans who feel compelled to get others to act will often not give a unbiased presentation of the facts to them.
 
For the record...I just made the 96% figure up as a hypothetical. It seems that the WHO/UNAIDS/whoever people are probably doing the math now looking at possible projections. Who knows what they'll actually decide.

Ok. I don’t think it’s an unreasonable guesstimate if it is going to be treated as a vaccine-like intervention as it has been referred to in previous studies and would likely to be if performed on infants.

Perhaps they could put a mark on the doors of houses whose boys are to be spared:)

I'm still crossing my fingers that they'll decide it's unethical to circumcise newborns and throw the whole deal out the window. Using terms like "circumcision rollout" and doing cost predictions that find that the newborns are cheaper makes it look pretty grim, though.

Hopefully it’s just they are doing economics first, ethics later. But I too am not confident that the idea of circumcising infants will be abandoned.
 
didn't mean to be rude btw, i just find this study so inconclusive and am sick of seeing horrendous correlation equals causation1 claims.

There’s some evidence that the virus survives better in the moist environment and there are more of the target cells available on an uncircumcised penis. Also, I think that circumcised penis’s are “tougher” and less likely to have small cuts on them. (That’s CUTS you dirty boy).
 
No. Risk communication isn't about lying, but rather simply presenting information in a way that compels one to perform the desired health behavior.

I am directly involved in the public health field within a number of different venues, so I am speaking from my direct experience.

There are many barriers when it comes to risk assessment by individuals. We all know this - we heavily discount future benefit, we are subject to all kinds of rumour and misinformation, we more heavily weigh the unusual or the uncontrollable, etc. Rational risk assessment is meant to represent the idealized situation - how would we decide if we had perfect knowledge. If the 65-year-old oxygen-dependent woman could somehow become part of the 15-year-old girl about to buy her first pack of cigarettes, would it prevent that purchase?

The question is, what you would decide in retrospect? After you see what happens in the future, what would you have decided if you could go back and do it all over again? Information needs to be presented in such a way as to make it easier for the decision you make now to be the same as the decision you would make in retrospect.

If we present information in a way that "compels" a particular action, the only reason for "compelling" that action would be that a rational assessment suggests that that action would be the preferred choice if the individual had perfect knowledge.

I fully recognize that politics can force programs to fall away from the ideal.

If information about meatal stenosis (how often it happens and why it happens) isn't forthcoming, is it a lie?

Yes, that would be considered a lie. Withholding information necessary for informed consent violates the Declaration of Helsinki.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom