Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

All good points. Well done.:D

I have lots of practice.

Actually, higher education is positively correlated with HIV incidence.

Education directed at promoting safe sex measures leads to decreased HIV incidence, though. You are referring to an association which is clearly a confounder and not direct.

Assuming all other factors stay constant. That's a really big assumption.

It was an assumption based on the actual data. I would also like to point out that it was a very generous assumption. It is more likely that regular condom use will not be maintained at the higher levels once the study interventions have stopped.

It would depend on the risks associated with and the effectiveness of the vaccine. They are some diseases that can be vaccinated against that the risks of the vaccines are considered high enough to stop them being used for the general population. Other vaccines are considered not to have a high enough efficacy to make them cost effective. Yet others only work for a limited time period.

However, on the whole I support vaccination.

:) I know you would probably support vaccination. Parents make a lot of choices for their children, hopefully in their child's best interest. Some of them are permanent. So I don't think we should assume that they can't do the same in this situation, although I do realize that this is considered a particularly sensitive choice.

Is that what you think I'm advocating? I have two main concerns with what the research will lead to:

1) Blanket male circumcision for boys who are too young to make an informed choice.

But their advocates will be making an informed choice.

2) Over a longer term than the studies to date and in real life, i.e. men who are not part of an experimental group with an uncertain outcome, behavioural changes occur that compensate for the increased protection circumcision provides.

I freely admit that (1) is my bias. You appear to be saying studying (2) is "dicking around". I think it is a real and significant risk.

You can always claim you need more information and more study. However, the information we already have on this issue is consistent and direct. Under any other circumstances, it would be considered sufficient to act upon.

Linda
 
Because the intervention comes with a cost; one, it might be noted, that will not be borne by the proponents of an envisioned mass-circumcision program in sub-Saharan Africa. Thus, there is a cost-benefit analysis to be made, and if this analysis is to be honest, it must take into account the fact that consistent use of condoms provides better protection (and for both parties involved) than circumcision alone.

The cost will be borne by those who acheive the benefit. And cost-benefit analyses should be based on effectiveness (what happens in the real-world) instead of efficacy (what happens under idealized situations). What happens in the real world, is that regular condom users still get HIV (the risk is reduced by about 85 percent). Yes, theoretically the risk reduction could be 99 percent, but does that mean we should be blind as to what really happens? And also what happens in the real world, is that even with a concerted effort at education into safe sex and the provision of free condoms, less than half of the men become regular users of condoms.

Yes, I acknowledge that the prophylactic effects are cumulative, but not without the equation undergoing some changes. Consistent condom use is at least 87% effective in reducing the risk of HIV transmission, and more likely 99% or more. So imagine two subjects; #1 is uncircumcised, #2 is circumcised. Assuming consistent use of condoms, subject #1 enjoys 87-99% protection from HIV infection. Given that the effect of circumcision is moot unless and until the HIV manages to bypass the condoms, subject #2 enjoys 93.5%-99.5% protection. In the overall equation, then, given the consistent use of condoms, the beneficial effect of circumcision drops from the touted 51-53% to at most ~7% and more likely less than 0.5%. Those are markedly less impressive numbers.

I agree that if intensive education programs and free condoms led to 100 percent of men becoming regular users of condoms that the incremental benefit from circumcision would be about 7 percent. However, since the evidence shows that intensive education programs and free condoms leads to, at best, small increases in the number of men becoming regular users of condoms (in the studies under consideration, in one there was no change from a baseline of about 20 percent, and in the other there was an increase from 20 to 40 percent), the incremental benefit from circumcision is more like 40 percent.

To be blunt, I think the fact that you don't have a foreskin plays a larger role in your thinking on this issue.

I definitely think that not having a foreskin makes it more difficult to assess the situation, just like not being an African woman living in poverty, with little power, watching my brother and sister and two of their children die from AIDS makes it more difficult to place it in perspective. Which is why I think that all I can do is try to objectively evaluate the science, which includes the results of the surveys as to satisfaction and acceptability.

Imagine that there were research which indicated that amputation of the clitoral hood reduced the risk of HPV transmission by 51-53%. Would you be as quick to support a program of mass FGM for the purpose of reducing occurrence of HPV? Perhaps more importantly, would you personally step forward to undergo such a procedure? Or would you personally prefer to seek alternative means of protection, especially if those had a better rate of return?

That doesn't really help me. One of the major factors that helps me overcome my distaste (wrt a mass circumcision program in Africa) is that we are talking about a universally terminal, incurable disease, with slow progress in the area of finding effective interventions. HPV is not and the serious sequelae can be easily detected and eliminated, meaning that efforts directed in other directions will be more fruitful. Plus, a vaccine is now available which should also be effective.

Moreover, the controversy regarding this issue does not concern the findings of the studies themselves; it concerns how those findings should inform policy regarding aid to Africa. We have finite resources to apply to attempting to limit, and hopefully reduce, the incidence of HIV/AIDS in Africa. Even taking it as read that the findings of these studies are correct, reducing the transmission rate of HIV will at best slow the spread of HIV/AIDS, not halt it. It is a legitimate question to ask whether the resources necessary to responsibly implement a program of mass MGM in sub-Saharan Africa ("responsibly" in this context meaning that it does not cause greater damage to public health as a result of non-HIV/AIDS-related complications and side-effects than the benefits derived from slowing the spread of HIV/AIDS) might not be better spent otherwise.

Exactly.

It is also a legitimate question to wonder whether such a program would provide full disclosure to its prospective subjects (or "clients," if you prefer) regarding the benefits and drawbacks to undergoing such a procedure: Will it be sufficiently emphasized that the procedure provides an extremely limited degree of protection? (Would you play Russian roulette with three chambers loaded?) Will the subjects be fully informed beforehand as to the drawbacks of not having a foreskin?

I really don't know. Politics is a separate issue from the science.

Not a very good analogy. Male genital mutilation permanently affects the quality of life of the subject to an extent that nobody would accept from a vaccine, especially not one that was at most 53% effective. If someone came out with a vaccine against HIV next year, which was effective 53% of the time, and gave the subject a mild but incurable permanent cough, would any governmental agency approve it? Would we fault anyone who refused to take it, or inflict it on their kids, instead preferring to exercise caution regarding exposure and hope that somebody might come up with something without permanent side-effects a few years down the road?

It wasn't meant to be a good analogy, just a recognition that parents already act as advocates for their children.

It's hard to know what to recommend. In order to have an effect now, adult and teenage men should be circumcized. But if someone is going to end up circumcized, anyway, it is easier to do it as a neonate.

Linda
 
fls said:
But their advocates will be making an informed choice.

I really don't know. Politics is a separate issue from the science.

I dunno. What you're calling politics is actually an aspect of the science of public health. Communications. It's science but it's not biology.
If the UNAIDS/WHO decides they need, say, 96% of the male newborns being born in hospitals circumcised in order to decrease HIV transmission by whatever percent by whatever year, then the information being presented to mothers and fathers will be designed to achieve that 96% compliance rate. At least, that's how it generally goes with every other aspect of public health, and I'm not seeing any reason why circumcision would be any different. I hope I'm wrong, though. Maybe because of the controversial nature of the issue it will be treated differently.

Anyway...this looks like good news for Africa:
http://www.niaid.nih.gov/dmid/stds/herpevac/
http://clinicaltrials-nccs.nlm.nih.gov/ct/show/NCT00057330?order=113

And here's the outcome of what I'm pretty sure was the phase II.
http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/CI.../35035.web.pdf?erFrom=546823536537764229Guest

Since herpes is such a huge part of HIV transmission, this should have a really positive impact.
Of course, it'll probably be quite a while before that impact would begin to show up, but the same is true for circumcising babies.
 
So there should be solid evidence from the sexually-active Jewish community. Is the AIDS rate lower in Jews practicing non-safe sex?
Lower than what?

This is a straw comparison because you are ignoring the other variables.
 
I do not understand why it is more responsible to withhold an intervention which now has overwhelmingly demonstrated, in real world situations, that it reduces the acquisition of HIV by more than half.

Except that, as demonstrated repeatedly in the previous thread on this subject, it doesn't.

It is claimed, but not fully proven, that it may decrease female to male transmission of HIV, by up to 50%. FtM vaginal intercourse has the lowest transmissibility rate of any form of intercourse, at .0005. It has no effect at all on Male to Female HIV transmission, .001. The study did not investigate anal intercourse, FtM .00065 and MtF .005, which is commonly practices but not as readily admitted to due to social stimgas. In both studies, circumcision was paired with substantial safe-sex education. So the chances of it substantially reducing HIV transmission on it's own is not only not proven, but it is very likely that it will be counterproductive by providing a sense of false security. It's a panacea that will do nothing to stem the steadily increasing rate of HIV infection and AIDS.

The only way to substantially reduce the AIDS epidemic in Africa is precisely the same way it was greatly reduced in the US homosexual population during the '90s: safe-sex education and condom use.
 
Last time I read the UNAIDS report they stated they could use another 8billion condoms. How much will mass hygienic circumcisions cost?

IMO The main reason for a boy/man who is not going to be circumcised for religious reasons to opt for this is to have unprotected sex. The exact opposite of what is required until a high efficacy (i.e. similar to that of using a condom correctly) vaccine is developed.

http://www.unaids.org/en/HIV_data/2006GlobalReport/default.asp

This evidence always riles a few people. Keep in mind a couple things with any recommendation to use circumcision as a weapon in the HIV battle.

Most of the riled people are not thinking about cultures and circumstances of the other country. For example, the conservative Christian moral police in this country have pushed their proven ineffective abstinence only campaign on to every other culture in the world including HIV prevention programs in Africa where the culture and circumstances are completely different than in the US.

So, in the US and other Western countries circumcision is not likely to have a significant impact on HIV prevention. But in Africa, given the completely different circumstances, circumcision has been shown in prospective trials to lower the rate of HIV infections. Three trials have now been completed with the same results. In addition, cells in the foreskin have been identified as the portal of entry for the HI virus.

Circumcision varied, not necessarily by religion so much as by tribal culture. It's a cheap surgery. It is very cost effective in areas of the world where HIV is still spreading via sexual intercourse despite other measures. No one is advocating circumcision in lieu of condoms. There was some concern about increasing risky sex if this is promoted. But the prospective trials have shown circumcision lowers the HIV infection rate. And that's hard to argue against.

Of course it would be helpful if common sense and less religion returned to our government and they took the earmarking of funds for proven ineffective abstinence only campaigns out of the money we donate to the world HIV prevention funds. The earmarking and restrictions on money donated by the USA to the global AIDS fund resulted in the loss of some condom campaigns in Uganda and the rate of HIV went up accordingly.

It is pretty stupid not to be funding both the condoms and the circumcisions. Our problem or not, HIV-AIDS has led to an increase in worldwide tuberculosis, and economic & government instability in Africa, and that affects us all eventually.

[mumbles] Stupid head in the sand bigoted moral police. Makes you want to send their kids over there to see how well they do in those circumstances.[/mumbles]
 
...

The only way to substantially reduce the AIDS epidemic in Africa is precisely the same way it was greatly reduced in the US homosexual population during the '90s: safe-sex education and condom use.
The "only" way? Are you claiming to have evidence which refutes the findings in the three prospective circumcision trials?
 
As I recall, this whole issue came to light because of the observed differences between Moslem and Christian villages in those areas of Africa where both populations are at risk from AIDS....
It's worth reminding people that there are other beliefs in the world besides those that revolve around the Bible. (Not saying you meant to imply there wasn't.)

The different rates were indeed noted first, between tribes which had different circumcision practices. Anecdotal evidence has its place.
 
...

Although I guess it could be that the circumcised men's urge for sex increased while they were waiting for their penises to heal and so started using condoms to protect their wounded member and got used to wearing one.
Interesting hypothesis. All the variables one could possibly look at were. There was a lot of resistance to this research outcome.

In the first year after the circumcisions, those who had it had less sex then rates evened out. So number of protected and unsafe sexual encounters was calculated in the results. That's how we know safer sex practices resulted in both the circumcised group and in the controls.

But you know, sometimes boys just go with the decisions of that little head over the big head. That means circumcision is a tool we should use in some countries for everyone's sake.

In areas with high poverty rates, women's economic circumstances mean they often have no choice. That's why I am angry over the moral police who think condoms and abstinence are all people need. And the creeps who think abstinence is the only thing are especially loathsome. Most of them have never been out of their little Western bubble and they think they know what other people need. It's a shame.
 
... In any case, I'll bet anything you like condom use is safer,
Well duh!

but I think it's irresponsible to offer what may be an exaggerated lifeline.
Once again, those personal beliefs interfere with assessment of the actual evidence.

Encouraging condom use would seem to be a more responsible attutude.
Because?

Are you only allowed one intervention measure per person?
 
...
Not quite. There's a difference between being a volunteer in a medical trial and have a procedure presented to you as effective, especially as the procedure in question is a preventative measure - but isn’t really, since you still have to do all the same stuff you did before!
I believe IIRC that in the first study the study group were men seeking circumcision for other reasons. They then split the group just requesting the control group wait before the procedure. But I didn't go back and review the study so don't quote me.

...My only bias toward what anybody does with their body is that they are allowed to make an informed choice. In the discussion session they were mentioning 100% uptake and performing the circumcision before the boys were sexually active, which could be a very young age in sub-Saharan Africa.
It's a tricky question. I tend to go with the cultural norm. Which my double standard doesn't agree with on female genital procedures. Of course in women, the sex police want to cut the clitoris completely out. Better my property hate sex than to share it with anyone else.

What I wonder is how can guys be so certain circumcision alters sexual pleasure that much? Even an adult comparing before and after is making a pretty subjective and with all sorts of intervening variables assessment.

I never heard a circumcised man complain about this issue until reading it in these forums. The men I know certainly didn't act less responsive or complain. Just like you men want us to be a certain way, sorry but I prefer the clean cut version. It's a girl thing, what can I say? Well, maybe it's a cultural thing.

Given the nature of the HIV pandemic, I think a little decrease in sexual pleasure is a small price to pay to live past 30. Keep in mind, promoting circumcision is only of value in some locations where HIV is rampant. Circumcision is not going to be added to the recommendations your family pediatrician gives you in a Western country in the foreseeable future.

...I think promoting circumcision for HIV prevention has huge potential to backfire. As it looks like they will be doing this in the near future, I hope I'm wrong.
How do you picture this "backfiring" occurring?
 
Last edited:
Has anyone read this yet?
http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140673607603237/fulltext

I really hope this isn't the mentality that implements whatever happens next.
I think the whole cost/benefit thing on neonatal circumcisions is pseudoscientific and morally repulsive.
from the Lancet editorial
The results of the clinical trials present the opportunity to re-examine national and professional policies on infant circumcision. Neonatal circumcision is considerably safer and substantially less expensive than adolescent or adult circumcisions.14,16,33–38 If male circumcision proves effective and is only rolled out to neonates, it would take at least a generation before a population-level effect occurs. An adult intervention raises important questions regarding the capabilities of existing health systems, increased complexity of the procedure, higher complication rates, and greater expense. Managing complications and the associated costs in resource-poor settings also raises concerns. At the same time, there is a need to address the ethics of compromising a child's bodily integrity for an issue that might not affect him for many years to come.

Is that what you were referring to as morally repulsive? (by the way, registration to read the whole article is free)

Is it moral to not take whatever actions are possible to prevent a child acquiring HIV?

Is is moral to not take a country's resources into consideration when making public health policy?

Is it your moral judgment that the act of circumcising an infant is worse than any HIV infection which is expected to result if you don't circumcise?

Is it your moral judgment that the mother of a female infant in a country where poverty means your daughter has a high likelihood of contracting HIV because economic circumstances will force her to choose between having sex or not surviving, has no right to ask the society to circumcise the male infants in order to decrease the risk of her daughter?

If you had a daughter and a son in those circumstances, what would your moral choice be? Spare the male child's loss of sexual sensitivity even though you are increasing his risk of HIV? Spare the male child's loss of sexual sensitivity even though you are increasing the risk of all females acquiring HIV (in other words as a societal decision rather than an individual decision)?
 
...I have two main concerns with what the research will lead to:

1) Blanket male circumcision for boys who are too young to make an informed choice.

2) Over a longer term than the studies to date and in real life, i.e. men who are not part of an experimental group with an uncertain outcome, behavioural changes occur that compensate for the increased protection circumcision provides.

I freely admit that (1) is my bias. You appear to be saying studying (2) is "dicking around". I think it is a real and significant risk.
(2) is dicking around. This research has now been going on almost a decade.

(1) is a very narrow criteria to be evaluating such an enormous public health issue over.
 
Because the intervention comes with a cost; one, it might be noted, that will not be borne by the proponents of an envisioned mass-circumcision program in sub-Saharan Africa. Thus, there is a cost-benefit analysis to be made, and if this analysis is to be honest, it must take into account the fact that consistent use of condoms provides better protection (and for both parties involved) than circumcision alone.
Not in the real world. The research results refute your claim. You are naive to think the "cost" to the individual is only the circumcision. The "cost" analysis includes the results of not circumcising which in this case are enormous. Read anything lately about the devastation of the HIV pandemic on the outside of your bubble?

...To be blunt, I think the fact that you don't have a foreskin plays a larger role in your thinking on this issue. Imagine that there were research which indicated that amputation of the clitoral hood reduced the risk of HPV transmission by 51-53%. Would you be as quick to support a program of mass FGM for the purpose of reducing occurrence of HPV?
Are we saying cut off the head of your penis? Or are you talking about removing some skin surrounding the clitoris, leaving the clitoris functioning but a little less sensitive? And, last I checked, HPV wasn't quite as devastating of a pandemic as HIV-AIDS is.

.. It is a legitimate question to ask whether the resources necessary to responsibly implement a program of mass MGM in sub-Saharan Africa ("responsibly" in this context meaning that it does not cause greater damage to public health as a result of non-HIV/AIDS-related complications and side-effects than the benefits derived from slowing the spread of HIV/AIDS) might not be better spent otherwise. It is also a legitimate question to wonder whether such a program would provide full disclosure to its prospective subjects (or "clients," if you prefer) regarding the benefits and drawbacks to undergoing such a procedure: Will it be sufficiently emphasized that the procedure provides an extremely limited degree of protection? (Would you play Russian roulette with three chambers loaded?) Will the subjects be fully informed beforehand as to the drawbacks of not having a foreskin?
After a decade of research, these things have all been thoroughly considered. Just because you haven't investigated all these issues, doesn't mean researchers and public health policy makers haven't.

If you are really interested, please join those of us trying to get the influence of the religious police in the US to get their grubby little paws out of the HIV prevention policy legislation. Let scientific research guide the decisions. Believe it or not, science and public health fields both include consideration of all the societal mores and related issues in the research and decision making. You can't make public health policy without such input. The difference is public health officials and scientists are taking the societal mores of the populations involved into account, rather than pandering to the mores of the Dobsons, Falwells, and Robertsons who donated campaign money and got their congregations out to vote.

.. Not a very good analogy. Male genital mutilation permanently affects the quality of life of the subject to an extent that nobody would accept from a vaccine, especially not one that was at most 53% effective. If someone came out with a vaccine against HIV next year, which was effective 53% of the time, and gave the subject a mild but incurable permanent cough, would any governmental agency approve it? Would we fault anyone who refused to take it, or inflict it on their kids, instead preferring to exercise caution regarding exposure and hope that somebody might come up with something without permanent side-effects a few years down the road?
Re your scenario with the cough side effect, if the prevalence of HIV was approaching 30% in a community, I'd buy stock in some cough syrup.
 
Last edited:
WHO 2006 World HIV-AIDS Report, summary
Civil society reports indicate that stigma and discrimination remain pervasive. Half of all reporting countries said that they have laws and policies that interfere with the accessibility and effectiveness of HIV prevention and care.
I forgot about the proven effective needle exchange programs that are outlawed everywhere by the moral police (not confined to religionists in this case) despite very good evidence the programs in no way increase IV drug use.

Impact of HIV, in depth, WHO report, 2006

And just a few notes to illustrate why you aren't talking Kansas here.

Global facts and figures

6% of all adults in Sub-Saharan Africa have HIV. In North America and Western Central Europe it is 0.5%

Sub-Saharan Africa has:

64% of all HIV infections
59% of whom are women
over 2 million children under 15 have HIV

However, in Zimbabwe, where 1.7 million people are living with HIV, data have shown a decline in HIV prevalence which is currently estimated at 20.1%, down from 22.1% in 2003. This decline is twofold; studies have shown both a substantial increase in condom use since the early 1990’s and that more young people have been delaying their sexual début and reducing the number of casual sexual partners; however, a significant factor in the decline is attributed to high-mortality rates.

...at the end of 2005. Botswana’s national HIV prevalence stood at 24.1%, Namibia’s was at 19.6% and Swaziland’s at 33.4%. In Swaziland, HIV prevalence among pregnant women attending antenatal clinics rose from 4% in 1992 to 43% in 2004. [The life expectancy is now down to 30 in Swaziland because of HIV]

South Africa’s epidemic is one of the worst in the world with an estimated 5.5 million people (18.8% of adults) living with HIV in 2005. Almost one in three pregnant women attending public antenatal clinics were living with HIV in 2004 and trends show a gradual increase in HIV prevalence. There has been significant scale-up on the treatment front – around 190,000 people were receiving therapy by the end of 2005 – however this still only represents less than 20% of those in need.

In Mozambique, national adult HIV prevalence is estimated at 16.1% and 1.8 million people were living with HIV in 2005. The virus is spreading fastest in provinces linked by major transport routes to Malawi, South Africa and Zimbabwe.
I think if you consider 35% of all adults in your country have HIV, circumcision of infants as a moral outrage seems pretty naive. Since a lot of them will of course be orphaned, maybe some of you would like to adopt a few to keep that little foreskin intact for them?

Of course "a substantial increase in condom use since the early 1990’s and [] more young people [] delaying their sexual début and reducing the number of casual sexual partners" in Zimbabwe resulted in the HIV prevalence decreasing from 22% to 20%; That is except for the "significant factor in the decline [that was] attributed to high-mortality rates."

Exporting Ineffective Policy: The Globalization of American Abstinence-Only-Until-Marriage Programs
 
Last edited:
Is that what you were referring to as morally repulsive? (by the way, registration to read the whole article is free)

Actually, the part you quoted was sort of the redemptive hope from my perspective.

Is it moral to not take whatever actions are possible to prevent a child acquiring HIV?

No, it's not. If taking "whatever actions are possible" were automatically ethical we could do much more drastic things that would be completely effective. Like total penile amputation. That would be 100% effective at preventing both female to male and male to female transmission.
But that's obviously unethical.
And I mentioned this in the other thread (and I'll re-find a link of anyone wants) but some kinds of FGM have proven effective for reducing HIV acquisition in females.

So is it ethical not to further pursue that? Set up the giant RTCs to verify it?

Why not?

Is is moral to not take a country's resources into consideration when making public health policy?

You do realise, don't you, that in theory we could just strap men down and do it to them without adequate pain relief, right? And shave off quite a bit of the price that way?

Is it your moral judgment that the act of circumcising an infant is worse than any HIV infection which is expected to result if you don't circumcise?

As bad as I hate circumcision, HIV is definitely worse. And I'm not saying circumcision shouldn't be utilised. It should. I don't like it, but I "get it". I have enough of an understanding of what's going on over there (starving grandmas raising 14 starving grandkids since moms and dads died, etc.) to understand that.

But on babies? There has to be some other way.
There has to be a way to allow people of reproductive age to decide for themselves.

Is it your moral judgment that the mother of a female infant in a country where poverty means your daughter has a high likelihood of contracting HIV because economic circumstances will force her to choose between having sex or not surviving, has no right to ask the society to circumcise the male infants in order to decrease the risk of her daughter?
I don't know how to answer that. Jesus. I can't hardly consider the question without being awestruck with the horror of the fact that it's like that.


If you had a daughter and a son in those circumstances, what would your moral choice be? Spare the male child's loss of sexual sensitivity even though you are increasing his risk of HIV? Spare the male child's loss of sexual sensitivity even though you are increasing the risk of all females acquiring HIV (in other words as a societal decision rather than an individual decision)?

I honestly don't think I have a right to even assume what I'd want or do. Sitting here in the US, I'd like to think I'd enforce the importance of condom use and other responsible behaviors with such regularity and passion that my son would just wear condoms religiously.
But I can't know one way or another because I'm here and not there.
 
Last edited:
Are you seriously equating penile amputation and clitoral removal with circumcision?

I have no issue weighing risk/cost of acting and benefit/cost of not acting. I am, however, pointing out the narrowness of looking at circumcision as if it were as bad as removing a clitoris or a penis. I'm trying to get a little better perspective into the discussion. The value of an intact foreskin is nice to have the luxury of consideration in a Western society. It's insane to think it is really a critical sacrifice in a country where HIV prevalence is 10-30%.

...I honestly don't think I have a right to even assume what I'd want or do. Sitting here in the US, I'd like to think I'd enforce the importance of condom use and other responsible behaviors with such regularity and passion that my son would just wear condoms religiously.
But I can't know one way or another because I'm here and not there.
Well we do send HIV prevention money to the global fund. If you get a chance, do consider giving thought to any action you can take that might help remove the moral restrictions we send along with the money. I'd love for people to not be making decisions for other people in circumstances we can't easily imagine if we haven't been there.
 
It's a tricky question. I tend to go with the cultural norm. Which my double standard doesn't agree with on female genital procedures. Of course in women, the sex police want to cut the clitoris completely out. Better my property hate sex than to share it with anyone else.

I think you might be grossly misinformed on the reality of FGM in Africa.

Type 1 is the most common. And it's the WOMEN who perform and perpetuate it just as much as the men. Because it is their cultural tradition, and it's believed to have health benefits.


What I wonder is how can guys be so certain circumcision alters sexual pleasure that much? Even an adult comparing before and after is making a pretty subjective and with all sorts of intervening variables assessment.

Well, that's what science says.
I never heard a circumcised man complain about this issue until reading it in these forums. The men I know certainly didn't act less responsive or complain. Just like you men want us to be a certain way, sorry but I prefer the clean cut version. It's a girl thing, what can I say? Well, maybe it's a cultural thing.

Interesting sidenote...
In some areas of Africa, it is the highly educated women who are the most likely to take their daughters in for FGM procedures. I think I've read somewhere that men over there prefer "clean cut" women, as well.



How do you picture this "backfiring" occurring?

Have you ever heard of dangerous myths? Circumcision is already being referred to as an "invisible condom".
 
skeptigirl said:
Are you seriously equating penile amputation and clitoral removal with circumcision?

Where did you get that from?

I have no issue weighing risk/cost of acting and benefit/cost of not acting.
Neither do I.

I am, however, pointing out the narrowness of looking at circumcision as if it were as bad as removing a clitoris or a penis.

No, you're not pointing that out because I look at different forms of sexual mutilation on the same scale that the WHO and UNICEF does. So you're not pointing out anything. There are several grades. Not all forms of sexual mutilation are created equal.

I'm trying to get a little better perspective into the discussion. The value of an intact foreskin is nice to have the luxury of consideration in a Western society. It's insane to think it is really a critical sacrifice in a country where HIV prevalence is 10-30%.

I have a feeling that kind of value judgement would be different for different individuals depending on their different personalities and circumstances.

I'd love for people to not be making decisions for other people in circumstances we can't easily imagine if we haven't been there.
Agreed.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom