All good points. Well done.![]()
I have lots of practice.
Actually, higher education is positively correlated with HIV incidence.
Education directed at promoting safe sex measures leads to decreased HIV incidence, though. You are referring to an association which is clearly a confounder and not direct.
Assuming all other factors stay constant. That's a really big assumption.
It was an assumption based on the actual data. I would also like to point out that it was a very generous assumption. It is more likely that regular condom use will not be maintained at the higher levels once the study interventions have stopped.
It would depend on the risks associated with and the effectiveness of the vaccine. They are some diseases that can be vaccinated against that the risks of the vaccines are considered high enough to stop them being used for the general population. Other vaccines are considered not to have a high enough efficacy to make them cost effective. Yet others only work for a limited time period.
However, on the whole I support vaccination.
Is that what you think I'm advocating? I have two main concerns with what the research will lead to:
1) Blanket male circumcision for boys who are too young to make an informed choice.
But their advocates will be making an informed choice.
2) Over a longer term than the studies to date and in real life, i.e. men who are not part of an experimental group with an uncertain outcome, behavioural changes occur that compensate for the increased protection circumcision provides.
I freely admit that (1) is my bias. You appear to be saying studying (2) is "dicking around". I think it is a real and significant risk.
You can always claim you need more information and more study. However, the information we already have on this issue is consistent and direct. Under any other circumstances, it would be considered sufficient to act upon.
Linda