Dr de Cock says circumcision reduces HIV risk

Sorry Alan, I didn't find the info. on this last time, just looked at it. Perhaps someone else reading/taking part could point him in the right direction for the info. he wants?

Could you or anyone else reading / taking part (even you Linda:) ) provide me with a sanity check please? Do you think Linda's argument for parental choice is valid? Have I missed something subtle in it? Skeptics are supposed to use logic just a little bit, aren't they?

Some men who were circumcised in infancy do swear that they're really glad it was done to them as a baby...coz having a foreskin sounds yucky or something, and they know they would have just "had to" have done it as an adult for some reason.

But this won't make sense to you for cultural reasons. Your catholicism analogy is accurate, but we don't forbid people from bringing their children up to be religious, you know?
 
I'll try to refind the links on the midwifes thing.

Thanks.

As far as choosing things for your kids 20 years in advance...I sort of get it.

Do you mean you 'get it' in a logical way or in an emotional feel good way?

You are accepting the logical conclusion that there is such a thing as a Catholic child and not just a Child of Catholic parents?

These things do have a way of becoming self-fulfilling prophesies.

I am clearly going insane.

But I found the acceptability studies in question:
http://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140673607603237/fulltext


So that's about one in three men who would not have wanted to have been circumcised as an infant, I guess.

I’ll have a read.
 
i don't give a **** how many correlation experiments there have been. show the virus transmitting, add some controls(!), do some trials on monkeys, rats, mice or whatever. the research should be moving along, instead wallowing over the same type of study that provides no reasons to why circumcision helps in an uncontrolled environment. did circumcision alone prevent aids? there might be other methods without circumcision to prevent aids. some people have vague ideas why it might help, but they're vague and ideas, not evidence. etc etc etc

The trial itself is the evidence. Seriously. I'm not happy about it, but there were controls, and it's just true. The study is nearly flawless. As far as science goes, this was some high quality science.
And the mechanism isn't just a "vague idea." If you know anything about biology you can see that it makes perfect sense.

As far as your idea about animal models and "showing the virus transmitting" or whatever...
I just don't know where to begin. I mean this in the nicest way, but I get the impression that you really don't know very much about science.:o
Not that I'm an expert, but lord have mercy...
Please learn how these things work before criticising the study.
 
Ivor said:
Do you mean you 'get it' in a logical way or in an emotional feel good way?

You are accepting the logical conclusion that there is such a thing as a Catholic child and not just a Child of Catholic parents?

I don't know, Ivor. That's a pretty deeply philosophical and psychological question.

I guess I think we're all children of catholic parents in a way. And we all think we're catholic children. Does that make sense?
So I see Linda's point, and it can't be argued without spinning off into philosophical gobbeldygook.
 
Some men who were circumcised in infancy do swear that they're really glad it was done to them as a baby...coz having a foreskin sounds yucky or something, and they know they would have just "had to" have done it as an adult for some reason.

But this won't make sense to you for cultural reasons. Your catholicism analogy is accurate, but we don't forbid people from bringing their children up to be religious, you know?

I understand it perfectly. Children love their parents. The have no choice in the matter. Even children who have been terribly abused by their parents still want their love. They also tend believe what their parents and other authority figures tell them without question.

This total trust is quite good if little Lucy or John is messing around on the edge of cliff but not so good if their parents want to do things to them that are not so good, such as fill their head with nonsense or abuse them.

The nonsense in the head can be shaken off to a certain extent but physical abuse is often permanent. Having your foreskin removed for a theoretical risk 15-20 years down the line is child abuse. Just because millions of loving parents do it does not make it morally defensible. A boy of 12-15 could make the choice himself couldn’t he? What’s the rush for, just to save a few bucks or is there a more sinister reason? Such as a boy of 12-15 may of actually become accustomed to or even enjoy the feeling of having a foreskin and be more likely to say ‘no’.

I expected a much better argument from someone as smart as Linda:(
 
Male circumcision and HIV/AIDS: challenges and opportunities said:
Less than one in five of people at highest risk for HIV infection have access to effective prevention interventions

So why don't they try addressing that first without performing any circumcisions?

Male circumcision and HIV/AIDS: challenges and opportunities said:
The potential ethical implications of over-reliance on biomedical solutions at the expense of equity, social justice, and human rights missions cannot be dismissed.

So they are planning on exporting some of our values. If the culture is not right then change the culture. Nothing in Africa changes really, does it?

Male circumcision and HIV/AIDS: challenges and opportunities said:
That male circumcision has been shown to be protective against HIV infection presents us with the opportunity to re-invigorate the discussion about gender, socioeconomic inequality, access to care, and stigma, and to develop concrete strategies for addressing these important background factors as implementation of biomedical strategies for HIV prevention progresses.

It re-invigorates us to discuss is coercing people (or even worse their parents) to agree to an irreversible operation when only 1 in 5 have access to the means to properly protect themselves?

Male circumcision and HIV/AIDS: challenges and opportunities said:
...At the same time, there is a need to address the ethics of compromising a child's bodily integrity for an issue that might not affect him for many years to come.

Address that right after you do something about only 1 in 5 having access to the means to protect themselves and before anything is done on the circumcision of infants.
 
The nonsense in the head can be shaken off to a certain extent but physical abuse is often permanent. Having your foreskin removed for a theoretical risk 15-20 years down the line is child abuse. Just because millions of loving parents do it does not make it morally defensible.
So, Ivor, is it your position that all Jews who follow the tradition of the bris are child abusers?

Note: I am not a Jew, I want to understand you position on this with clarity, rather than by guess.

DR
 
Ok.
Ivor and I can see circumcision eventually increasing risky behaviors because of many reasons.
You and fls are saying "But the researchers looked for that, and it didn't happen".
Right?
Ok. We get that part. The circed guts didn't just throw the condoms out the window when told that the circs were 50% effective.

But the counterargument that we're making is that the clinical trial situation won't necessarily represent what goes on once this becomes widespread. There are differences. So saying "It wasn't observed" just doesn't cut it.

I appreciate the information, but it's not entirely relevant.

I'm not being condescending here...it's just my opinion. It's is counter-argument I'm presenting, so don't take it personally.



Did you read the part about Nigeria?
Where higher education is positively associated with FGM? As a general rule, more education leads to less FGM, but there are exceptions.

And my point was you and Ivor and everyone else has considered the problem, will risky behavior increase if.... It wasn't that you see it and we don't. We see it. It was looked for. The results indicate it wasn't significant enough to warrant not recommending circumcisions in countries with high HIV prevalence. You have to go by what the evidence is. If there was any indication of a problem, you could always do further research. But at some point, you have to decide, we now have enough evidence to move forward, (or not if the results had differed).

One of the reasons I am pointing out to you that health care workers have considered all those other implications is you will find that ebm is going to consider a very broad range of issues and understand the research process as well as anyone. We are the experts in this field. Not that anyone can't be well informed. I certainly advocate that. But to think we didn't think of this or consider that is just not a realistic assumption.

It might happen with a single study. That's what peer review is for. It isn't going to happen with 15 years of research on a preventative measure for something as well investigated as one of the biggest pandemics in our lifetime.

-

I edited my above post to add:

They state that the exception in Nigeria is due to education difference in the groups with the cultural practice of more common fgm. That implies it is something other than education which is the variable being evidenced.

I'm just not convinced fgm is a health practice anywhere. My understanding is it is a "you won't stay a virgin if we don't do it and no man will marry you" practice.


Perhaps it was after you saw it.
 
...
correlation does not mean causation, this i find incredible, all these studies supporting it and no causation? what's up science? how about advancing the testing a little!?....
How about a little reading?

HIV gains access to the body by entering specific cells in the inner surface of the foreskin. I believe I have posted this now for the 3rd or 4th time.
 
skeptigirl said:
And my point was you and Ivor and everyone else has considered the problem, will risky behavior increase if.... It wasn't that you see it and we don't. We see it. It was looked for. The results indicate it wasn't significant enough to warrant not recommending circumcisions in countries with high HIV prevalence. You have to go by what the evidence is. If there was any indication of a problem, you could always do further research. But at some point, you have to decide, we now have enough evidence to move forward, (or not if the results had differed).

One of the reasons I am pointing out to you that health care workers have considered all those other implications is you will find that ebm is going to consider a very broad range of issues and understand the research process as well as anyone. We are the experts in this field. Not that anyone can't be well informed. I certainly advocate that. But to think we didn't think of this or consider that is just not a realistic assumption.

The why all the gears in place to circumcise the infants and children?

The behaviors observed in the studies have absolutely nothing to do with them, or the behaviors they will exhibit.
 
Ivor has not fibbed, he has come a very long way and is practically sitting right next to you as far as male circumcision goes. My view is slightly different to your own that is all.

If African men wish to use this after being given all the relative information in an unbiased way then I have no problem with it.

But I happen to live in the real world (and I even have a Master Degree for what it’s worth,) so I know that public policy decisions often have unforeseen consequences and humans who feel compelled to get others to act will often not give a unbiased presentation of the facts to them.
Your post doesn't indicate you are considering what I've posted.

For example no one is suggesting anything but a recommendation to, "use this after being given all the relative information in an unbiased way."

And even with all the concerns you have noted, the risk of HIV-AIDS by far outweighs those concerns.

Have you considered here at all what the consequences are
  • of having 10 million AIDS orphans now living in Sub-Saharan Africa?
  • Of having the people most responsible for putting food on the table for both the young and the old die in numbers greatly disproportionate to the people who relied on them for support?
  • The sadness of seeing the women in a country who cannot support themselves any other way have to choose between the risk of HIV from prostitution or the risk of starvation from having no other options?
  • And of the fact in those countries, they need every single method of reducing the disease burden as they can possibly get?
 
Um, what? I see pointing out how incomparable the procedures are and generally agreeing with you is not relevant then.
Boy, I see the problem but I have no clue how I did it. The quote before my post which you commented on then I then you here was wrong.

Here's the errata:

....
To be blunt, I think the fact that you don't have a foreskin plays a larger role in your thinking on this issue. Imagine that there were research which indicated that amputation of the clitoral hood reduced the risk of HPV transmission by 51-53%. Would you be as quick to support a program of mass FGM for the purpose of reducing occurrence of HPV? Perhaps more importantly, would you personally step forward to undergo such a procedure? Or would you personally prefer to seek alternative means of protection, especially if those had a better rate of return?...

...

It's a tricky question. I tend to go with the cultural norm. Which my double standard doesn't agree with on female genital procedures. Of course in women, the sex police want to cut the clitoris completely out. Better my property hate sex than to share it with anyone else....

Good points, but also.

The two procedures are very different in effect. A more compariable prodecedure for a woman would removing part of the labia, and that is done in the US for cosmetic reasons.

There is no reason to think that the various procedures refered to as female circumcision would have an effect on HIV transmission.

The question and my answer were to the hypothetical suggestion, "if it was your clitoris instead of my penis you wouldn't say that".

Your point is not relevant.

And then your post (the one quoted here) followed.

I can see why you are confused. I had a completely different quote from Ivor preceding my comment in the beginning of the exchange.

Sorry. Best just forget this whole mess.
 
i don't give a **** how many correlation experiments there have been. show the virus transmitting, add some controls(!), do some trials on monkeys, rats, mice or whatever. the research should be moving along, instead wallowing over the same type of study that provides no reasons to why circumcision helps in an uncontrolled environment. did circumcision alone prevent aids? there might be other methods without circumcision to prevent aids. some people have vague ideas why it might help, but they're vague and ideas, not evidence. etc etc etc
Get a grip Al. We are trying to tell you these questions have been thoroughly answered if you would just read the research for the answers instead of imagining they haven't been looked at.

Yes, circ alone makes it harder to get HIV. It doesn't make it impossible to get.

Of course there are other methods to prevent HIV. But they aren't enough.

Condoms and education go a very long way in this fight. Unfortunately the church lady and her kind think condoms are the tool of Satan and made sure the money we send to the fight go heavily toward abstinence education which fails to do anything.

But there is other money and condoms + education is successful, to a point. In the 30 years since the pandemic first emerged along the prostitution/trucking route in Uganda that was responsible for the local occurrences becoming world occurrences, however, condoms and education are not enough.
 
The why all the gears in place to circumcise the infants and children?

The behaviors observed in the studies have absolutely nothing to do with them, or the behaviors they will exhibit.
Because the research is sufficient to support the recommendation, (not that I know which gears you are referring to, but no matter).

"Absolutely nothing" ??? That is not a conclusion which vast numbers of previous studies would support.
 
So why don't they try addressing that first without performing any circumcisions?

So they are planning on exporting some of our values. If the culture is not right then change the culture. Nothing in Africa changes really, does it?

It re-invigorates us to discuss is coercing people (or even worse their parents) to agree to an irreversible operation when only 1 in 5 have access to the means to properly protect themselves?

Address that right after you do something about only 1 in 5 having access to the means to protect themselves and before anything is done on the circumcision of infants.

CDC: Male Circumcision and Risk for HIV Transmission: Implications for the United States
After adjusting for confounding factors in the population-based studies, the relative risk for HIV infection was 44% lower in circumcised men. The strongest association was seen in high-risk men, such as patients at sexually transmitted disease (STD) clinics, for whom the adjusted relative risk was 71% lower for circumcised men.


In an ideal world you would have never had this pandemic in the first place. We can't even educate the population in this country that evolution theory is not in doubt and you would solve the HIV pandemic by adding more resources to addressing education access? Do you not think this is also being addressed? Think if all the resources available were put into other measures then circs wouldn't need to be added to the repertoire? You'd be wrong. To take from kelly's posts, "the world just doesn't work that way".
 
Well, I started off looking at the meatal stenosis issue from kelly's posts. I'm not one to defend a position when the evidence supports otherwise, (about the complication rate, not about the recommendation to circ boys in high HIV-AIDS prevalence areas which has clear support.) The Emed link from kellyb had the following supporting citations. Keep in mind, the Emed article was for meatal stenosis, not circumcision in general.

Incidence of meatal stenosis following neonatal circumcision in a primary care setting; Clin Pediatr (Phila). 2006
The diagnosis was made in 24 of 329 circumcised boys who were Tanner I development and older than 3 years of age (7.29%, 95%CI=4.48-10.10%). Nearly all required meatotomy to resolve their symptoms. All of the boys with meatal stenosis were circumcised neonatally (exact OR=3.54, 95%CI=0.62-infinity). The ratio of circumcised boys to noncircumcised boys in this study provided 80% power to demonstrate a 21.4% difference in the incidence of meatal stenosis between circumcised and noncircumcised Tanner I boys 3 years and older. Meatal stenosis may be the most common complication following neonatal circumcision. The frequency of this complication and the need for surgical correction need to be disclosed as part of the informed consent for neonatal circumcision. A careful meatal examination is indicted in any circumcised boy with abdominal or urinary complaints.

Circumcision for phimosis: a follow-up study; Scand J Urol Nephrol. 1986
It is concluded that circumcision for phimosis in young boys is complicated by meatal stenosis in a certain frequency (13/117) but not loaded with serious complications. There seems to be no reason to fear psychological disturbances due to circumcision.

Both of those articles have pretty small sample sizes. It isn't clear but it looks like the populations are self selected in both cases since that's typical for a small sample and no mention of randomization is made which is normally mentioned in the abstract when it is done. And the CDC data differed so I soldiered on looking for more data.


Risks Associated with Male Circumcision from the CDC
Reported complication rates depend on the type of study (e.g., chart review vs. prospective study), setting (medical vs. nonmedical facility), person operating (traditional vs. medical practitioner), patient age (infant vs. adult), and surgical technique or instrument used. The most common complications are minor bleeding and local infection. In large studies of infant circumcision in the U.S., complications rates range from 0.2 to 2.0% [2]. In the recently completed South African study of adult circumcision by general medical practitioners in their surgical offices, the overall complication rate was 3.8%. The most commonly reported complications were pain (0.8%), followed by swelling or hematoma, bleeding, and problems with appearance (each 0.6%). Damage to the penis (0.3%), infection (0.2%), and delayed wound healing (0.1%) were uncommon. There were no reported deaths or problems with urination [10].

[2]Alanis MC, Lucidi RS. Neonatal circumcision: a review of the world’s oldest and most controversial operation. Obstet Gynecol Surv. 2004 May;59(5):379-95.

[10]Auvert B, Taljaard D, Lagarde E, Sobngwi-Tambekou J, Sitta R, Puren A. Randomized, Controlled Intervention Trial of Male Circumcision for Reduction of HIV Infection Risk: The ANRS 1265 Trial. PLoS Med. 2005 Nov;2(11):e298.

That wasn't sufficient so I looked for the source of the figures and found Report of the Task Force on Circumcision; American Academy of Pediatrics
The exact incidence of postoperative complications is unknown,(50) but large series indicate that the rate is low, approximately 0.2% to 0.6%.(44,45,51,52) The most common complications are local infection and bleeding. Deaths attributable to newborn circumcision are rare; there were no deaths in 500 000 circumcisions in New York City (52) or in 175,000 circumcisions in US Army hospitals.(51) A communication published in 1979 reported one death in the United States due to circumcision in 1973, and the authors’ review of the literature during the previous 25 years documented two previous deaths due to this procedure.(53)

Complications due to local anesthesia are rare and consist mainly of hematomas and local skin necrosis.(41,46-49,54) However, even a small dose of lidocaine can result in blood levels high enough to produce measurable systemic responses in neonates.(55,56) Local anesthesia adds an element of risk and data regarding its use have not been reported in large numbers of cases. Circumferential anesthesia may be hazardous. It would be prudent to
obtain more data from large controlled series before advocating local anesthesia as an integral part of newborn circumcision. When considering circumcision of their infant son, parents should be fully informed of the possible benefits and potential risks of newborn circumcision, both with and without local anesthesia.

But that wasn't full of original data either and the citations didn't offer a lot so I went looking for more. So now I have to admit maybe I was wrong. ;) Circs for HIV prevention benefit might be worthwhile in areas with low HIV-AIDS prevalence after all. And, they should be considered as well to prevent cancer and serious complications from urinary tract infections.

Benefits of newborn circumcision: is Europe ignoring medical evidence? Edgar J Schoen
When properly done, newborn circumcision is a quick, simple procedure with a low complication rate. Morbidity and costs of circumcision are much lower for newborns than they are for older patients.6,7

Moreover, about 70 million circumcised US males currently attest to the lack of effect of circumcision on either emotional health or sexual performance, and no objective studies indicate otherwise. As a matter of fact, evidence indicates that women in Middle America have a sexual preference for circumcised men, mainly from the standpoint of aesthetics and hygiene.33

The multiple benefits of newborn circumcision are additive over a lifetime and include prevention of cancer of the penis, of balanoposthitis, and protection against the effects of phimosis and poor hygiene as well as prevention of UTI and STD, particularly of HIV. Protection against these diseases constitutes a substantial public health advantage and provides a strong argument in favour of instituting universal newborn circumcision in Europe. With AIDS spreading rapidly in developed Western countries in persons who practice heterosexual behaviour as well as in men who practice homosexual behaviour, implementation of universal circumcision beginning with Europe is prudent and timely.

There are scores of additional citations including this very large study, Risks From Circumcision During the First Month of Life Compared With Those for Uncircumcised Boys; Thomas E. Wiswell MC, USA1 and Dietrich W. Geschke MC, USA1; 1 The Medical Research Fellowship, Walter Reed Army Institute of Research, Washington, DC
The records of 136,086 boys born in US Army hospitals from 1980 to 1985 were reviewed for indexed complications related to circumcision status during the first month of life. For 100,157 circumcised boys, there were 193 complications (0.19%). These included 62 local infections, eight cases of bacteremia, 83 incidences of hemorrhage (31 requiring ligature and three requiring transfusion), 25 instances of surgical trauma, and 20 urinary tract infections. There were no deaths or reported losses of the glans or entire penis. By contrast, the complications in the 35,929 uncircumcised infants were all related to urinary tract infections. Of the 88 boys with such infections (0.24%), 32 had concomitant bacteremia, three had meningitis, two had renal failure, and two died. The frequencies of urinary tract infection (P < .0001) and bacteremia (P < .0002) were significantly higher in the uncircumcised boys. Serious complications from routine prepuce removal are rare and relatively minor. Circumcision may be beneficial in reducing the occurrence of urinary tract infections and their associated sequelae.
So while there were 3 deaths possibly (we don't have the information to decide) related to circs in 25 years, there were none resulting from circs and 2 clearly associated with not getting circs in 5 years in the very large study here. And penile cancer is an additional risk not included in the time frame of the study.

You have to wonder why there are so few male physicians writing about the loss of sexual sensation and almost no mention of the complication in the research. With the expected number of men physicians and researchers, it is very curious. I'm beginning to think the evidence for this loss of pleasure is slimmer than one would think given the activism surrounding the issue.



Prepuce presence portends prevalence of potentially perilous periurethral pathogens.This link is to a MetaAnalysis with no abstract, PubMed. I just posted it for the cute name.

And this one was in the bib. of the Shoen article. I didn't look for a link but I couldn't resist:
33. Williamson ML, Williamson PS. Women's preferences for penile circumcision in sexual partners. Journal of Sex Education and Therapy 1988 Fall/Winter;14(2):9-12.

Sorry boys, what can I say.
 
Last edited:
skeptigirl said:
Because the research is sufficient to support the recommendation, (not that I know which gears you are referring to, but no matter).

"Absolutely nothing" ??? That is not a conclusion which vast numbers of previous studies would support.

You know I was referring to the behavior studies, right?
I could probably have been more clear about that.

Well, I started off looking at the meatal stenosis issue from kelly's posts. I'm not one to defend a position when the evidence supports otherwise, (about the complication rate, not about the recommendation to circ boys in high HIV-AIDS prevalence areas which has clear support.) The Emed link from kellyb had the following supporting citations.

I spent all afternoon looking for meatal stenosis figures, as well.
So are you agreeing that it's 10%, or saying that there's not a lot of data out there?


There are scores of additional citations including this very large study
Did they control for prematurity?
I know I've run across several older "being intact makes babies die of bacterial infections" type studies before, and the intact kids were intact because they were born prematurely. Which obviously skews the findings.

And this one was in the bib. of the Shoen article. I didn't look for a link but I couldn't resist:
33. Williamson ML, Williamson PS. Women's preferences for penile circumcision in sexual partners. Journal of Sex Education and Therapy 1988 Fall/Winter;14(2):9-12.

Sorry boys, what can I say.

That is breathtakingly tacky, skeptigirl.
But if you think it's cute then whatever.
 
Last edited:
So, Ivor, is it your position that all Jews who follow the tradition of the bris are child abusers?

Note: I am not a Jew, I want to understand you position on this with clarity, rather than by guess.

DR

IMO they have committed an act of child abuse. I am not saying or believe at all that the vast majority of Jewish (or any other ethnic group I know of) parents continually abuse their children on a regular basis. I would put it in a similar league to the parent who looses it and goes overboard with a physical reprimand. I find it easier to understand the motivation of parents who loose it with their kids more than I understand the thought process of the Jewish parents’ (living in the west) ritualistic behaviour.

I am not arguing they are are unfit to be parents or anything along those lines.

Have I made myself clear?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom